Why do so few anime know how to handle emotional and dramatic

yeah you would neo-/a/

I think its because Japanese are (generally) reserved, awkward people.

Most anime can't into subtlety and semi-realistic characterisation when needed. It's likely a consequence of the target audience being somewhat emotionally stunted and Japan's general attitude towards open emotion.

Most attempts at drama feel melodramatic at best and outright hamfisted at worst as a result.

File: 1410464861918.jpg (213KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

213KB, 1920x1080px

In my opinion K-On was easily the best in that regard.

>>121141130
I guess it depends on whether you think right and accurate are the same things. Not everyone would agree that TV shows and movies (or theater, or whatever) should reflect emotion and drama in a realistic way. It obviously needs to be in some way relatable but for the most part I think people expect it to be a little different, a little separated, and probably more dramatic. Some people will think that's perfect, some people won't be happy unless "drama" is just like the real world.

What's twisted is when people start to express their emotions in real life like they've seen modeled in drama.

Pic unrelated I guess.

File: azu_nyan.gif (918KB, 499x250px) Image search: [Google]

918KB, 499x250px

>>121142343

>>121142848
Realistic drama is shit. Melodrama is best.

West sucks for abandoning melodrama.
Melodrama is basically portraying events in such a fashion that they apply to the emotions of the viewer in a strongest way possible. If you abandon this sort of approach, there is no point in doing fiction at all.

When people tell me that Madoka is melodramatic, I take that as a COMPLIMENT

File: 1386617027949.jpg (213KB, 1200x848px) Image search: [Google]

213KB, 1200x848px

>>121142877
>you'll never put a bullet in your best friend's head

>>121141130
Pic is related

>>121142966
killing friends in madoka is like killing friends in a videogame because there's going to be a next round and nobody really fucking cares or has any hard feelings about it

File: [Salender-Raws] Evangelion - The End of Evangelion (DVD 1004x574 x264 AC3 5.1).mkv_snapshot_01.02.48_[2015.02.09_16.57.00].jpg (45KB, 1004x574px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 1004x574px

Evangelion is the only series that got it right.

>>121141130
Pic not related I presume.

>>121143019
This

File: brilliant.jpg (100KB, 1066x600px) Image search: [Google]

100KB, 1066x600px

>>121142937
>Melodrama is best

>>121142966
little known fact: she missed and time-jumped immediately so that she wouldn't die of embarassment

>>121141130
>Pic
>Muh shock value
>muh mammy
>muh devil
>muh devil did nothing wrong
>muh pinku
Fanbase a shit, series a shit, homu a shit, Madoka a smug pink bitch.

File: 1396596427945.jpg (171KB, 700x992px) Image search: [Google]

171KB, 700x992px

>>121143072

File: 1419658983650.png (125KB, 620x531px) Image search: [Google]

125KB, 620x531px

>>121143103

>>121143104
put it in your mouth and pull the trigger you useless character

File: 1366730585019.gif (678KB, 640x276px) Image search: [Google]

678KB, 640x276px

>>121143022

>>121142937
But Madoka is melodrama done wrong. Onii-sama does it right.

File: 1399407874287.jpg (579KB, 820x1125px) Image search: [Google]

579KB, 820x1125px

>>121143165

File: 1400960950337.jpg (177KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

177KB, 1280x720px

>>121143222

>>121143230
Who homu here?

>>121143165
Wouldn't do much against a Magical Girl, you stupid fuck.

>>121143103
My my, you're so edgy, /a/non. Here, take your shot.

>>121143019
>mercy killing someone
>not a mental strain itself

Homura did right by grabbing onto every last glimmer of hope. If she didn't and thought that, she'd have quickly lost hope and lost any reason to keep going back, because she wouldn't try hard each time. She'd lose spirit, and hope, and would turn into a witch.

Your argument has just been destroyed, pulverized, annihilated.

File: 1395998599546.jpg (188KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

188KB, 600x600px

>>121143291

>>121143327
>Homura did right by grabbing onto every last glimmer of hope. If she didn't and thought that, she'd have quickly lost hope and lost any reason to keep going back, because she wouldn't try hard each time. She'd lose spirit, and hope, and would turn into a witch.
You say all that like it's a bad thing, then the series would be over and anime would be saved from rabid retarded fans.

>>121143327
You know, that scene is great and it wrecks me emotionally, and I would never remove it but even I agree that Homura didn't have to kill her since she was going to turn back time anyway

>>121143291
I homu here.
It's fucking Christmas that I'm using my trip outside normal Madoka threads, although with a bit of effor we can make this Madoka thread yet

>>121143423
>although with a bit of effor we can make this Madoka thread yet
The rabid retarded anime fans I'm talking about.

>>121143423
No, Homu a shit.

File: 1416711703600.jpg (199KB, 800x563px) Image search: [Google]

199KB, 800x563px

>>121143327
>>mercy killing someone
>>not a mental strain itself

when you can groundhog day the entire universe to your heart's content, no action consequences have ANY weight whatsoever because you can
A. redo literally anything you did that has results you didn't like
B. nobody will remember anything you did, so they'll never hold it against you

File: haibane renmei.jpg (1MB, 1280x1024px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1280x1024px

>>121142017
>subtlety and semi-realistic characterisation
A master of this coming through.

>>121143474
the groundhog day cliche is getting a bit old, also it allows the creator tons of room to fuck up and redo which in my opinion makes them lazy.

>>121143423
>not wanting to grant your best friend's last wish
>refusing to give in to emotions, which are pretty much the only thing that still makes you human

You truly are the worst tripfag I've ever seen.