[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Click for more| Home]

How would you rank the more popular shounen manga, on-going or

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 128
Thread images: 10

File: shounen.jpg (67KB, 540x351px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
shounen.jpg
67KB, 540x351px
How would you rank the more popular shounen manga, on-going or not? Here's a list you can either agree with or shit all over: Jojo (Part 7 + 4 + 2 power trinity) >HxH > One Piece = FMA > One Punch Man > Magi > Naruto = Bleach > Fairy Tail
>>
>>118693460
FMA >Jojo >OPM>HxH >Naruto= OP>Magi>Bleach>Fairy Tail
>>
>>118693460
>GOAT
FMA
>Good
One punch Man
Huntex Hunter
Jojojo
>Ok
Naruto
One Piece
Magi
>Shit
Bleach
Fairy Tail.
>>
I dont recall Ichigo calling out the names of his attacks. I dont even recall if he said bankai like all the cool kids.
>>
>>>118693675
>Getsuga Tenshō x100
>>
>>118693591
>>118693639
FMA is not better than HxH.
>>
Reasony why characters yell their attack names:

>In-Universe-Reason
>It's the chant that causes the attack

>Real life reason
>Marketing and merchandise
>>
>>118694569
I dont know why it bothers people. What should bother them is when a character takes 1-2 pages to explain their power while their opponent just stands there
>>
why is everyone forgetting Katekyo Hitman Reborn.
Zero point break through was one of the best anime moves ever
>>
File: 1388797545757572.jpg (115KB, 800x575px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1388797545757572.jpg
115KB, 800x575px
>>118693460
>Part 7
>Shounen
I agree with part 4.
>>
>>118694691
>1-2 pages to explain their power while their opponent just stands there
Or half the chapter.

Bleach.
>>
>>118693460
One punch man is Seinen, why is so fucking hard to understand demograpichs??

(not that being seinen actually matters, but still)
>>
>>118694747
>why is everyone forgetting Katekyo Hitman Reborn.
It's so forgettable that it's not even worth mentioning.
>>
HxH>Jojo>One Piece>FMA>Magi>Fairy Tail>Bleach>Naruto.
>>
Berserk>All
>>
DB > DBZ > all other weeb shit
>>
>>118693460
Dragon Ball
HOkuto No Ken
One Piece
Yu Yu Hakusho-Kenshin-FMA-Eyeshield 21-Slam Dunk-CAptain Tsubasa-Shaman King-MEdaka Box
OPM-Naruto-Saint Seiya-Ippo-Death Note
Jojo-Nanatsu No Taizai
shit
Bleach
HunterxHunter
Fairy Tail
Reborn
>>
>>118697573
Shounen.
>>
>>118693460
>OPM
>Shounen

No
>>
>>118693460
Early on in the manga at least Naruto characters thought the name but did not say it. However kids in nippon are either used to or actually like characters to say the names out loud so they changed it in the anime.
Actually this is true for most fighting Shonen.
>>
JoJo > One Punchman > HxH > FMA > Bleach > OP > Magi > Naruto > Fairy Tail

If you disagree, you have shit taste.
>>
>>118698306
Bleach does not deserve to be just behind Fullmetal Alchemist. It belongs right next to Nurutu and Fairy Shit.
>>
>>118698372
B-but Kubo?
>>
>>118698396
Kubo is a lazy hack when it comes to writing and everybody should already be aware of this, regardless of whether they enjoy Bleach or not.
>>
>>118698464
>lazy hack

Isn't that the reason why we love Kubo?
>>
>>118698513
Yes it is, thats why Bleach will never, no matter what happens in it, be worse that FT.
>>
>>118693460
One Piece > Hunter x Hunter

the rest is irrelevant
>>
>>118698513
>we
>>
>>118698306
hate to break it to you but anyone who puts Bleach or JoJo in front of OP is pretty bottom of the barrel when it comes to taste
>>
>>118698562
>Implying /a/ isn't a single person with a multiple personality disorder
>>
>>118698536
But Mashima is no different. Kishimoto was no different. I have no fucking clue why people like Kubo more when they all suffer from shitty writing. Kubo's "trolling" is what would be an asspull in any other series. He is dragging this crap on and puts 0 effort into it because he knows you idiots will gobble up whatever he shits out.
>>
>>118693639
FMA is the most overrated shit on this planet
>>
>>118698585
>that's what OPtards actually believe
>>
>>118698585
Dude, OP stopped being good after Vivi/desert arc.

Not to mention OP is repetitive. I can't tolerate 'muh nakama' any longer.
>>
>>118698631
Its because he Kuboed us the first time with Aizen. Every other Kubo Moment after that was inferior, but that doesnt matter, because the thing that makes Bleach Bleach isnt Ichigo, but Aizen. Fairy Tail simply has nothing of course i like the fanservice of it that can compare with him. No Enemy or Good Guy is as famous and actually good written as him. (Yes i really believe that Aizen was good written overall.)
>>
>>118698639
FMA isn't overrated. It is objectively an 8/10. Only the minority that scream 10/10 or 'it is a masterpiece' are just retarded.
>>
>>118695076


>My bankai does this and this! Too bad for you that you're not deaf.
>Enemy makes sure he can't hear anymore.
>Captain jobs to enemy who is now immune to bankai effect.
>"IMPOSSIBLE! How could this be!?"


Fuck this shit, seriously.
>>
I can only say that Fairy Tail is the worst.
>>
-God Tier-

Jojo Part 7

Great Tier

HxH
One Punch Man
FMA

Nostalgia Tier

Yu Yu Hakasho
Hokuto no Ken
Dragon Ball

Ok Tier

Naruto
One Piece

Early Naruto deserves more credit for being a genre definer next to DBZ. People who say otherwise just want to be special snowflakes.
>>
>>118698778
Watch out for FT defenders, they will say
>B-BUT MUH FANSERVICE
>>
Ichigo rarely names his attacks, he's got a dozen variations of the Getsuga and in recent times has only mentioned Getsuga Jyuujishou. Try harder.
>>
>>118700328
Why would you defend Bleach, ever?
>>
>>118698854
>Naruto
>being a genre definer

Not trying to contradict you here, but could you expand a bit on that?
>>
>>118694747
BECUASE NOTHING HAPPENED AT THE END
ABSOLUTELY NOTHING
>>
>>118698306
>Bleach >something
NOPE
>>
>>118693460
JoJo>OPM>FMA>rest of them=shit>fairy tail
>>
>>118700748
It helped set everyone's expectations of what you'll find in shounen/battle manga/anime nowadays.

Not him btw.
>>
File: 1417467819759.png (1MB, 779x1210px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1417467819759.png
1MB, 779x1210px
>>118693460
>JoJo
My nigga
>>
>>118693460
>Part of popculture
Jojo
DB
>Literally cancer
Naruto
>It's all the same shit
Everything else
>>
>>118701063
Tell that to everyone living in moonland.
>>
>>118701063
-tips fedora-
>>
>>118693460
1. JoJo
all others need not apply
>>
Reminder that OP means battle manga which is why OPM applies, rather than shounen which is a demographic.
>>
>>118701063

>part of popculture
>jojo

Literally what
>>
>>118701130
M'lady
>>
File: Rurouni Kenshin.jpg (619KB, 2056x1500px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Rurouni Kenshin.jpg
619KB, 2056x1500px
>>118693460
Rurouni Kenshin > JoJo > FMA > YuYu Hakusho > Bleach > One Piece > HxH > Naruto > Fairy Tail > Soul Eater
>>
>>118701130
JoJo is mediocre enemy of the day shit, sorry
>>
>>118693460
>name of my move

whats that?
>>
>>118698685
>Dude, OP stopped being good after Vivi/desert arc.
a very hot minority opinion you got there m8
>>
>>118701277
Nah, you just dont get how deep it actually is.

Now excuse me while I go wash my fedora.
>>
>>118701264
>Bleach > One Piece
this is how you detect shit taste
>>
>>118701304
>Serious punch!
>>
>>118698854
>Naruto
>genre definer
Everything that Naruto did was done before, and better
>>
>OPM mentioned so many times
what's so good about it? I thought it's just a shounen parody
>>
>>118698854
>One Piece in the same tier as Naruto
Confirmed never read One Piece.
>>
It is an anime it is not supposed to be realistic
>>
I don't understand how Jojo can be consistently ranked so high. It's entertaining as fuck but it draws absolutely no emotional response from me at all unlike pretty much everything else on that list. I'd put it high up but not over FMA, HxH and One Piece.
>>
>>118701691

Before 1998 you had mangas of the 80's. Such as Fist of the North Star which inspired Jojo etc... even earlier you had Doraemon and Astro Boy.

In the west anime/manga was still unknown to the majority of western fans besides for hardcore oldfags. Until Dragon Ball Z began showing on a regular basis on western tv channels (CN/Toonami in 1998). DBZ served as the gateway to introduce a majority of younger viewers to the shonen archtype (not all but still alot).

2000 and onwards Naruto/One Piece began to reach the states and exploded in popularity. Arguably there were more Naruto fags than One Piece fags at this point in time. Mostly cementing young anime fags perception of a battle series with world building elements that wasn't Dragon Ball/Gundam.

You can argue Gundam was better at World building before Naruto.

I swear if it wasn't for retarded monkey aliens doing asspulls on a regular basis and adhd ninjas 3/4 of you anime fags wouldn't even be here let alone know about the genre.
>>
why is OP so fucking over rated ?
>>
OP=Bleach=fairy tail=Naruto=trash tier
>>
what is up with you faggots and jojo? like Jesus Christ it's the gayest shit in existence.
Best ranking
FMAB>HunterxHunter>Opm>FMA>Bleach>One piece>Fairy Tail>JoJo>Magi>maruto
>>
>>118694465
I would agree if the mangaka wasn't such a lazy fuck and started to produce some shit.
>>
>>118703299
adult swim/toonami served as better gateways imo
>>
>>118704522
He has given us 32 volumes + 8 chapters of god tier shonen.
>>
>>118704483
>Bleach anything bottom trash
No anon, you have shit taste.
>>
>>118704602
he is lazy if you compare him to naruto or one piece but at least hxh isnt becoming a 1 shit chap/ a week like naruto
>>
>>118704625
I'm not disagreeing that bleach is objectively trash,but so is everything below it and i simply find bleach to be the best of the trash
>>
>>118693460
>tgat pic
At least Naruto has an excuse seeing as they're all wizards and invoking the spell with a name is part of the process. Do the others have excuses? I imagine Fairy Tale might, too, for the same reason.
>>
>>118698585
>Bleach in front of OP is pretty bottom of the barrel when it comes to taste
>JOJO in front of OP is pretty bottom of the barrel when it comes to taste
Your opinion instantly became irrelevant.
>>
>Elder God tier
Fist of the North Star

>The rest tier
The rest
>>
Where would you rank My Hero Academia?
>>
Nardo won a couple points for making best girl win.
>>
>>118693639
>One punch Man
>Shonen
>>
File: 1419230298154.jpg (170KB, 530x704px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1419230298154.jpg
170KB, 530x704px
We all know who's in the top, even though hes a giant faggot.
>>
>>118704714
>1 shit chap/ a week like naruto
>HxH manga
>#1 example of QUALITY manga art
>I'm probably mad because my husbando Madara was a pawn
Haha. Okay.
>>
>>118694569
You don't need to chant martial art attacks
>>
>>118697651
>Kenshin lower than one piece
Thats just balls
>>
File: faggot OP.jpg (34KB, 600x611px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
faggot OP.jpg
34KB, 600x611px
>>118693460
>One Piece = FMA
>Naruto = Bleach
Only a /v/ meme is retarded enough to reply to this
>>
>>118700944
Hokuto no Ken did that you underage faggot
>>
>>118707401
Notice how I said helped, not "single-handedly" or some shit.
>>
>>118707529
Naruto didn't even put a nail for defining the genre
>>
>>118707378
Bleach = Naruto is accorate enough.
>>
I think Magi is really good. The Alma Toran arc was fucking shit though.

Hopefully Ohtaka delivers with Kou civil war arc.
>>
>>118693639
This.
>>
>>118707742
Magi is shit now.
>>
>>118698639
It isn't, shounen as a genre is very clichéd. FMA does all the regular tropes well, has good pacing, fights, diverse cast, avoids the power creep and doesn't overstay it's welcome. It's more than what can be said of pretty much every other shounen.
>>
>>118708354
No the edgebros arc was great and we're getting a fucking civil war arc man!
>>
>Tfw One Piece stopped being good after Impel Down, Oda is about to die and it will never git gud again.
>>
>>118698631
Like >>118698730 said, /a/ is dere for Aizen. He has so many ridiculous asspuls they should never have been let past the editor in the first place, but he's a terrible entertaining character.
>>
>>118693460
Jojo > Magi = HxH > One Piece > Naruto = Toriko > Bleach > Fairy Tail
>>
>>118703299

I couldn't believe it when Dragonball started showing on national TV, I grew up watching it on the local Japanese TV station. Most of my other exposure was VHS at the local Japanese rental store.

As an oldfag I can tell you that there was nothing special about that time. There was almost nothing available and most of it was post-apocalyptic/cyberpunk. Even the more school yard stuff tended to be martial arts or fantasy/sci-fi. It wasn't until the mid-90s or so that we started getting more variety.
>>
>>118693460
Bump
>>
>>118693460
>Like the JoJo anime
>try part 4 of the manga
Lose interest 2/3 of the way through because it's repetitive and boring
Why do people guzzle Araki's semen like it's the wine of the gods?
>>
File: 670985463598765.jpg (24KB, 193x276px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
670985463598765.jpg
24KB, 193x276px
>>118693460
>Shounen
>JoJo

This thread is the biggest bait.
Also JoJo is for fujoshits what the fuck are you smoking?
>>
>>118693639
I would put One Piece between ok and good, but I agree with everything else.
>>
Best taste in here:
HnK>Jojo>>>>>>Bleach>HxH>YuYu>DB>OP>Naruto>Magi>FMA>FT>
>>
>>118693675
He always call his attacks, but he only have one.
>>
>>118708738
>Bleach>HxH
>YuYu>DB
Shit taste
>>
>>118698306
>Bleach > OP

Every thing else is debatable, but this is just an absurd.
>>
>>118709656
Meant to reply to this
>>118709616
>>
>>118707257
He is based man anon, he is living the dream

I hope he releases some chapters next year.
>>
Why the fuck people like JoJo so much? I'm in the Italian JoJo part and I think it is a 7/10 max. Part 1 was shit, part 2 was ok, part 3 was good, part 4 was good, part 5 is ok so far.

Unless part 7 really is that mind blowing, I would never rank it above One punch man, HxH, FMA or even One piece.
>>
>>118709818
Same. I never got the love for this series.
>>
>>118708738
Put JoJo under Magi and HxH then its good.
>>
>>118709818
Oh, and the art is bad, get over it.
>>
>>118697651
Dbz on top
HxH below bleach CAptain Tsubasa, shaman king, eyeshield 21 and NNT

OP above kenshin, FMA, OPM

What will yo do with such shit taste anon
>>
>>118709818
I think the reason people like JoJo is because it's got a unique in universe power, looks stylish, has truly GOAT fights throughout and benefits from having a lot of (relatively) well written and developed characters due to the cast resetting for each part. I certainly think it's better than FMA/OPM/HxH/OP but in different ways. You could argue that the others do one aspect of shounen fighting manga better than the same in JJBA but I think JJBA does them all well enough such that the cumulative effect is that it's better than most of it's competition.

It's not perfect by any means though. But Part 7 really is that mind blowing.

All this said, it isn't nearly as good as Fist of the North Star.
>>
>>118709818
It's called taste.
Which you don't have.
>>
>>118697651
>DB and HnK above everything else
>OP above yu yu hakusho
>OPM in the same tier as Naruto and los caballeros del zodiaco


Damn, look at that shit taste
>>
Great Tier:
HxH
FMA
JoJo
OPM

Good Tier
Magi
One Piece

Ok Tier
Bleach
DBZ

Shit Tier
Naruto
Fairy Tail
>>
>>118710079
So, I won't see the light after part 7?
>>
>>118710067
>it isn't nearly as good as Fist of the North Star.

Damn it anon, I was agreeing with everything you said, but you fucked it all up.
>>
>>118710129
>Bleach and DBZ above Naruto
Explain
>>
>>118697651
You are 14 right otherwise just stop reading manga.
.
>>
File: 5604564.png (270KB, 680x467px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
5604564.png
270KB, 680x467px
>>
>>118693460
HxH=FMA>OPM>Jojo(still have to read from part 5)>OP>Magi>Bleach>>Naruto(till Pein)>FT
>>
>>118710226
Bleach and DBZ are silly and formulaic, but unlike Naruto, both of them have intact plots and there has yet to be a villain that has been literally defeated by the power of friendship.
>>
>>118710210
Search your feelings, you know it to be true. Fist of the North Star will be the eternal GOAT shounen fighting manga.

Best character development, excellent power set, best story for the majority of it, best manly tears moments, iconic artwork, great fights. The fight between Fuudo and Raoh (or Rei and Yuda, or Shuu and Souther) instills more emotion than most other shounen manga do in there entire run.

It also has it's own problems but you cannot deny that Buronson is an excellent writer when he isn't made to continue his shit on longer than he intended it to go.
Thread posts: 128
Thread images: 10


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]
Please support this website by donating Bitcoins to 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
If a post contains copyrighted or illegal content, please click on that post's [Report] button and fill out a post removal request
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows an archive of their content. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.