[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Click for more| Home]

Is bat the most liked because of her dominant personality?

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 144
Thread images: 33

File: shinobu67.png (392KB, 1600x1114px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
shinobu67.png
392KB, 1600x1114px
Is bat the most liked because of her dominant personality?
>>
>>117259141
No.
>>
I like her because she's got the best scenes, the best seiyuu, the best personality, the best everything. Bat is love.
>>
It's because she's a loli for underages.
>>
>>117259201
>best seiyuu
I can agree with you on that one, although I think Ryougi is Sakamoto's best role.
>>
File: 1357262190839.jpg (99KB, 758x590px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1357262190839.jpg
99KB, 758x590px
It's because she's a loli, an ojou-sama, and everything in between.
She does have a fun personality though.
>>
>>117259201
>best personality

No.
>>
File: 1416429520619.png (1003KB, 684x897px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1416429520619.png
1003KB, 684x897px
>>117259201
Pretty much this
>>
File: bscap0057.jpg (27KB, 288x267px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
bscap0057.jpg
27KB, 288x267px
>>117259267
>loli for underages
>>
>>117259141

They show you outright that, even when she hadn't realized yet, her bond to Arararagi was so important to her that the shock of losing it was enough to send her into a depression spiral that would DESTROY THE FUCKIN WORLD. Literal endtimes of humanity bad end.

For a being like they play her up to be like the concept of love as a bond is several orders of magnitude more hardcore than anyone short-lived like humans.
>>
File: 1372173343828.jpg (20KB, 158x158px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1372173343828.jpg
20KB, 158x158px
>>117259141
>bat
>>
>best liked because of her dominant personality

Doubtful, /a/ are just lolicons. Her having decent writing is secondary
>>
>>117259445
That would be truth if she were the only loli in the show
>>
File: 1416502242158.jpg (900KB, 2421x3286px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1416502242158.jpg
900KB, 2421x3286px
>>117259385
>leaving the old thread before that lovely anon posted the full scan
>>
File: 1385137249716.jpg (312KB, 938x1364px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1385137249716.jpg
312KB, 938x1364px
>>117259141
She's perfect in all of her forms. I love her personality and her body.
>>
>>117259445
Dom lolis are my fetish. But then so are tomboys.
>>
>>117259267
>for udnerages
>loli
Doesn't compute.
>>
>>117259481
It is still truth, regardless of how many lolis there are. It just means people tier their lolis based on other non-physical aspects.

>>117259580
Good to know, man.
>>
>>117259141
She's the most liked because the japs and /a/ have shit taste.
>>
File: 1412995243542.jpg (66KB, 548x470px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1412995243542.jpg
66KB, 548x470px
>>117259141
>because of her dominant personality?
yes
>>
File: we334.jpg (32KB, 640x360px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
we334.jpg
32KB, 640x360px
>>117259684
>zing
>>
>>117259661
But then it means it's not because it is a loli but becase those other aspects, if it was because of that there wouldn't be a difference between Batfags and Snailfags
>>
>>117259684
I bet you're gonna say next that Kanbaru is among the better Monogatari girls.
>>
>>117259791
No. I mean, they're all great. But Kanbaru is towards the bottom of my list.
>>
>>117259141
She isn't the most liked though.
>>
>>117259141
It's because she has the body of an eight year old but it is okay because she is actually a thousand year old vampire :^)
>>
It's actually the opposite. She's the most submissive. Shinobu does anything Araragi wants and doesn't attack him like most of the other girls do. In fact, she is always waiting in his shadow for him to call her.
>>
File: 1410921819819.gif (2MB, 960x540px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1410921819819.gif
2MB, 960x540px
It's actually because of dat ass
>>
>>117259865
The biggest ass popularity poll says you're wrong.
It went like (in order):

Shinobu
Senjougahara
Mayoi
Tsubasa
Nadeko
Tsukihi = Kanbaru
Karen
>>
>>117259890
This

She has this gap moe between her personality and her actual actions that is just perfect
>>
>>117259897
I liked her actually child looking tummy curve more.
>>
File: shinobu nadeko.jpg (81KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
shinobu nadeko.jpg
81KB, 1280x720px
More like she's the main character of the show. Senjougahara is simply a love interest for protag while Shinobu is the main character to the protag. The second best girl is of course Nakedo Snake. Even the show acknowledged it.
>>
>>117259925
>Nadeko over Kanbaru/Karen
Sasuga Proxy-san
>>
>>117259925
>Tsukihi = Kanbaru
Jesus christ
>>
>>117260043
>Main character of the show
I'm pretty sure she's gotten the least screen time of all the semen demons in this show.
>>
>>117259925
Jesus Christ what a fucking shit taste.
I bet by the time Nise aired Karen was like #1.
It's sad people don't have any fucking memory.
>>
>>117259776
Remove the Loli from anyone in the show and they'd lose fans. It's because they're a loli with good writing, if it wasn't about the loli then they'd say "I like Kiss-shot more"
>>
File: PTHFTHETE.jpg (27KB, 371x386px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
PTHFTHETE.jpg
27KB, 371x386px
>>117259684
>>
>>117259925
Is this an /a/ poll? Because I remember one months ago where Senjougahara was first and Shinobu wasn't even second. I remember it because it surprised me (lolis scored low).
>>
>>117260088
? Screen time would probably be
Shinobu>Tsubasa>Mayoi>Senjougahara>Kanbaru>Nadeko>Karen>Tsukihi

Especially if you include Kizu.
>>
I used to be a snake fag

Then they gave me the Bee
>>
>>117260199
Completely wrong.
>>
>>117260145
>Implying they don't
That's just semantic, it's the name she's given through most of the show, they do say she's best in every form
>>
>>117260288
And also Kizu
>>
>>117260283
But it isn't. Bakemonogatari is only one part of the story. Shinobu features prominently in every other arc and even has her own novel (Kizu). Tsubasa has 3 arcs and has a major part in Kizu. Mayoi is in nearly every arc giving Araragi advice. Senjougahara is a side character after bake but does feature prominently in it. After that it's just a question of who got less screentime.
>>
>>117260288
They obviously don't like Kiss-shot more or else you'd see more people posting Kiss-shot and not Shinobu.

The entire point is that her being a loli is big part of her appeal. It's even in the novels when Araragi comes to the conclusion that the neck/collarbone area is the most dangerous part of a loli.

She would have less fans if she wasn't a loli
>>
>>117260500
The only difference between Kiss-Shot and Shinobu is not body type. Kiss-Shot had a very different personality.
>>
File: A7C.jpg (108KB, 650x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
A7C.jpg
108KB, 650x920px
>>117260500
>They obviously don't like Kiss-shot more or else you'd see more people posting Kiss-shot and not Shinobu.
>Implying there's a difference
>>
>>117259397
It's okay to sexually fantasize, since she is like, 1,000 years old.
>>
>>117260569
What about Kiss-shot from the later novel then? She's Shinobu except Kiss-shot sized.
While my stance has always been Kiss-shot and Shinobu were two different entities until Owari, my point still stands. While Kiss-shot is not Shinobu, Shinobu is still Kiss-shot, the personality traits she kept from those days are still a big part of her current personality.

I'm not saying you can't like Shinobu without being a lolicon, but saying "Her being a loli has only a minor impact on why people like her" and things along those lines is just ignoring the fact that her being a loli is a big part of her appeal.

If being a loli wasn't such a big deal then Yotsugi would have no fans
>>
>>117260774
Yotsugi has fans?
>>
>>117260774
But she practically has no fans

At least in comparison with Mayoi or Shinobu
>>
>>117260602
There is totally a difference, Kiss-shot is Kiss-shot, Shinobu is Kiss-shot plus Araragi.

From a personality stand point only, while Shinobu is Kiss-shot, it doesn't work in reverse since Kiss-shot hadn't met Araragi and got influenced by him

Ignoring the future Kiss-shot from one of the books where Gaen splits Araragi and Shinobu apart to make her Kiss-shot with Shinobu's personality
>>
>>117260862
Of course she has, I said with a posed look
>>
>>117259141
Perhaps.
>>
>>117260862
>>117260895

They're there but I feel they're just paying lip service to the fact she's the third loli in a loli trio. The fact she even has 1 fan with so little personality is surprising
>>
>>117260189
>where Senjougahara was first
But that would mean /a/ has good taste, impossible.
>>
File: 1346037431967.png (564KB, 900x506px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1346037431967.png
564KB, 900x506px
>>117260902
What exactly is a "posed look"?
>>
>>117260942
Tell that to Reifags and see what happens
>>
>>117260897
Even when there's character development it's still the same character

And she has most of her character traits in all of her forms (remember the guy she turned before Araragi)
>>
File: maxresdefault.jpg (63KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
maxresdefault.jpg
63KB, 1280x720px
>>117260978
I wonder about that myself
But we'll always have "yaaay peace peace"
>>
>>117259925
I bet Tsukihi would be more popular if they expanded on her character more. She didn't even play that big of a role in her own fucking arc.
>>
>>117260043
I think bat is best girl, but your entire opinion is still invalidated by you liking snake in any way.
>>
>>117261087
Tsukihi is a pretty fun character in the LNs, the anime adaptation had a lot of random chats between her and Araragi cut off
>>
>>117259481
She is the only loli in the show. Snail left after the oddity police was after her.
>>
>>117261281
>oddity police

kill yourself
>>
>>117260979
You're confusing no personality with a non-expressive one.
>>
>>117261071
If this were a normal series I'd agree but we know Oddities are influenced by the perception people put on them. Oshino says as much and Yozuru insists on calling her Former-Heart-Under-Blade.

If Shinobu's loli form wasn' t explicitly influenced by Araragi and Oshino treating her like a child then I would be like. "Yeah man, I agree" but Shinobu/Kiss-shot is the only case where I'm pedantic enough to be like. "There is an academic difference between these characters where you need to treat Kizu-Kiss-shot as a separate character from Shinobu Oshino"

>>117260979
Hey Rei has personality...I mean she did uh...that thing where uh...ummm...at least she's not Asuka?
>>
>>117259141
no, its because she is helmet hair moe and bandaid.
>>
>>117260189
>>117260103
>>117260078
>>117260072
This was a japanese poll, and no chance for proxy.
It's also infinitely better taste than what /a/ polls could ever shit out.
>>
>>117261281
The only one left, that doesn't means that for more than half of the series there wasn't any other lolis

>>117261389
Then what can you say about Tsukimonogatari?
>>
>>117261389
But if you treat them as a separate character then the whole bathing scene in Nise becomes void of any meaning.

I've had this discussion with another anon a while back and it boiled down to Shinobu acts childish because she's just messing around but when things get serious she isn't afraid to go full kiss-shot personality even having a loli body.

I think the main diference between Shinobu and Kiss-shot is her more...regal appearance
>>
>>117261389
>You need to treat Kizu-Kiss-shot as a separate character from Shinobu Oshino
Still doesn't means it's a different character

It's just circumstances surrounding her character, but as a character (taking away oddities, Araragi and vampirism) she's basically the same
>>
>>117259201
I would disagree with you on best personality.
>pic related
>>
File: 12362375.png (494KB, 783x624px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
12362375.png
494KB, 783x624px
>>117259925
Kanbaru stuck with the no screentime duo.
Nadeko not last place.

Goddammit /a/.
>>
File: Oddity Police.png (1MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Oddity Police.png
1MB, 1280x720px
>>117261344
Read the filename.
>>
I want to force bat to wear panties
>>
>>117261568
I'm about 90% sure unless you've said "When things get serious she goes back to Kiss-shot" to multiple anon then we've already had this conversation.

>>117261564
Nothing so far, haven't seen/read it. I doubt all the non-personality she's had in her current appearances is going to really expand into some magnificently three-dimensional character like Mayoi or Shinobu.

If it does, I will be the first to admit I was wrong and will praise NisiO for his excellent writing. However until that point, I can only go on what I've seen of her personality which is basically. "I can't keep it on straight and I'm a smarmy person who thinks your muscles look edible"
>>
File: 1393100089148.jpg (192KB, 631x850px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1393100089148.jpg
192KB, 631x850px
I would literally fuck Shinobu in all her forms until her vampire pussy went numb and my dick fell off.
>>
>>117261728
>(taking away oddities, Araragi and vampirism)

The three most important things to her character. Like I said, if this was any other character, I would be fine but having "This character is explicitly shaped by our perceptions of her" makes this shit quantum.
>>
>>117261840
It's not /a/. It's the nips.
>>
File: 12236576.png (585KB, 843x694px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
12236576.png
585KB, 843x694px
>>117262687
Ah that explains it.

There is no accounting for nip taste.
>>
At least we can all agree on the very true factual fact that cat is incontrovertibly absolute shit.
>>
>>117262984
Nips like feminine and frail, cute girls, while not so much sporty or a bit masculine girls.
Nothing new, and I'm more partial to their taste compared to /a/'s.
>>
File: 1415605751582.jpg (221KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1415605751582.jpg
221KB, 1280x720px
>>117263126
What about snake then?

I don't care if you like moe-blobs, she's still a shit.
>>
I like cat the most for her catiness
>>
>>117263077
No we can't.
>>
>>117263247
Sorry, I forgot to jump on the bandwago. I like her.
>>
>>117263544
Yes we can.
>>
>>117263247
>snake
>shit
but that's wrong
she's not a shit character, she's just ignorant of evil/malice
if you don't like her that's one thing, but that doesn't make her shit
>>
>>117262060
I'm not saying those factors don't affect her character I'm saying that its base personality and traits stays the almost same trough the series so besides eventualities from the plot she's the same
>>
>>117263802
Snake is shit though
She was cool but just jumped straight into crazy mode.

She's just eye candy.
>>
>>117262060
>the extra fluff makes her character and not the way she acts
you're a moron
>>
>>117263910
>shes just eye candy
yes, for a reason
if she didn't come off as "just eye candy" then her whole character arc would be retarded
>>
File: 077.jpg (438KB, 1329x2079px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
077.jpg
438KB, 1329x2079px
Important question time
Is Kiss-shot the most powerful vampire in Anime?
>>
>>117264002
Depends on what kind of strength we're talking about and also what kind of vampire
>>
>>117264002

Yes, if we measure power by boners induced
>>
>>117264002
No thats Alucard from Hellsing but thats another shitpost for another time
>>
>>117264069
>alucard
>anywhere near strongest
look at this pleb and laugh
>>
>>117264069
Dude
Alucard was gay as fuck
>>
>>117264112
>>117264190
>another shitpost for another time
>>
>>117263864
That's exactly what makes her a shit. I'm not talking about how well written her character is but her personality.
>>
>>117264911
Her personality is either damn erotic, or plain entertaining.
I like her.
>>
File: 1416459938515.jpg (247KB, 800x800px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1416459938515.jpg
247KB, 800x800px
>>117259876
>>117260654
>1,000 years old.
She's only 600 years old.
>>
shinobu is the saber of monogatari
>>
>>117266092
Blonde?
>>
File: 1405812271043.jpg (217KB, 1053x1070px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1405812271043.jpg
217KB, 1053x1070px
>>117266125
>not knowing the characters name
>>
>>117266301
Wait, what?
>>
>>117266301
That's not what he was implying.
>>
File: 7pt01r31_500.gif (696KB, 500x281px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
7pt01r31_500.gif
696KB, 500x281px
>>117264002
The awesome part of that scene is that she can choose how she looks, so it's like a method to outer how devastated she was

Why is Nisio so awesome and Kiss-shot such a best girl?
>>
>>117266939
Please don't post tumblr gifs on /a/.
>>
>>117267091
Sorry for not having a gif/webm for every single scene she's in
>>
>>117267157
Why are you apologising for that? Just don't post tumblr gifs.
>>
>>117266301
She was just mentioning one of the connections between the two.
>>
>>117267217
Why? this one is not specially bad quality or full with stupid artifacts and illustrates my point
>>
Nope, in fact at least half of the dumbasses here haven't even read Kizu. They like her because shes a legal loli with an OP powerlevel and a haughty personality.
>>
>>117267335
It has way too few frames and is left feeling motionless and disjointed.
>>
>>117267380
It doesn't matter, she's the best through the series, Kizu is just the confirmation
>>
>>117267335
The framerate and resolution are both subpar.
>>
>>117267546
>>117267609
I chose it because the stills focus on her clothes which is what I was talking about in my post

And tumblr or not most gif have fucked up resolutions
>>
>>117267717
You could have just posted a screenshot.
>>
>>117267756
But then I would have to crop and paste the different shots
>>
>>117267829
There's no need for that.
>>
>>117267858
No but it helps to portrait the statement I'm making
>>
>>117267957
Not to any notable effect. At any rate, I think some English lessons would help you "portrait" your point to a greater degree.
>>
File: 1404237782243.gif (2MB, 600x338px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1404237782243.gif
2MB, 600x338px
the terrorists win this time
>>
>>117268060
No but then again, most of the times that's the reason why anyone posts images

And my English is not relevant to the post we are talking about
>>
>>117268283
>No but then again, most of the times that's the reason why anyone posts images
Are you comparing using multiple images of the exact same scene to using any image at all?

>And my English is not relevant to the post we are talking about
It's relevant to the part where I have to experience your English when I read your posts. It makes said experience tiring.
>>
>>117259141
I like her because there's nothing she wont talk to araragi about. The rest of them are teenagers, and thus talk in metaphors, or are constantly on guard. She talks like a woman. Adult body shinobu = best monogatari.
>>
>>117259537
Those scanlines though.
>>
>>117268415
First of all I'm talking about different takes and angles

And I'm not comparing anything, I'm merely saying that posting images is mostly to illustrate a point
>>
>>117267217
Do you see his posts? That's what you get for being friendly with tumblr-scum!

>>117267335
Please kill yourself.
>>
>>117260774
You're joking right?

Saying loli has anything to do with Shinobu and Mayoi's characters is doing a huge disservice to their role in the story. They're arguably the two most significant non-protagonists, one being the cause of the entire story and the protagonist's entire reason for living, and the other being the protagonist's main source of emotional support.
>>
>>117266939
What small bat jealous of the head pat big bat was given?
>>
>>117259141
It's because she is a vampire loli and also due to the personality she has that is shaped by the fact she's a vampire loli.

>Power which is attractive, all kinds of moe from gap moe to moe death, eternal unchanging body, is sex incarnated, lewd yet pure, master/servant, dominating/dominated, and the fact they can be both childish and mature.
My repost why vampire loli is the best, and all that applies to Shinobu.

>I think it's mainly about the contrast.
>Looking like a little girl, which suggests weakness, yet possessing great power.
>Carrying a lewd adult mind within a pure, untainted body.
>Master and Servant at the same time.
>Monster, but also cute with cute behavior.
Some other points an anon made that I agree with.
>>
>>117269066
Let me rephrase: Saying loli is very significant at all to Shinobu and Mayoi's popularity is doing a huge disservice to their writing as characters, as well as their role in the story.
>>
File: 1410929986867.gif (968KB, 500x281px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1410929986867.gif
968KB, 500x281px
>>117269136
I don't think so, she probably gets her head patted everyday
>>
>>117267380
Honestly, people are going to be so disappointed
when Kizu finally comes out, because people keep upholding it as some kind of holy grail.

Kissshot isn't even awake for most of it.
>>
>>117261080
ye-aay
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H8XWRxN8ZsQ
>>
Its because she's like a 11 years old girl
>>
>>117259791
You can't hide your shit taste just by being condescending.
>>
>>117259925
And the funny thing is that that poll had a seperate kisshot, so shinobu should have won by even more
>>
>>117269461
but the scenes where she is awake are the best. And we get to see her in several different ages, even one with short hair.
>>
File: 1354243325.png (1MB, 1278x718px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1354243325.png
1MB, 1278x718px
>>117259791
>>117259862
Fuck both of you
Thread posts: 144
Thread images: 33


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]
Please support this website by donating Bitcoins to 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
If a post contains copyrighted or illegal content, please click on that post's [Report] button and fill out a post removal request
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows an archive of their content. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.