[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Click for more| Home]

3x3 Rate and fucking hate

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 143
Thread images: 47

File: 3x3 sep.jpg (269KB, 920x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3 sep.jpg
269KB, 920x920px
3x3

Rate and fucking hate
>>
File: 3x3 related.jpg (1MB, 1900x2000px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3 related.jpg
1MB, 1900x2000px
>>113373463
6/6 +Madoka, Jinrui, Baccano, TTGL, Kaiji
>>
File: 3x3.jpg (983KB, 2920x1020px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3.jpg
983KB, 2920x1020px
>>113373463
4/8
>>
File: 3x3.png (1MB, 920x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3.png
1MB, 920x920px
>>113373463
4/6
>>
>>113373683

>independent

We hipster now?
>>
>>113374204
>now
>>
>>113374385

>then
>forever
>>
>>113373463
7/7
>>113373662
hey
5/5 tv
2/2 manga, was thinking of reading The Lucifer and Biscuit Hammer soon.
5/5 char
>>113373878
7/7
Watching Birdy now, it's pretty fun. Great OST. Also good taste.

I see an increase in Penguindrum
>>
>>113373463
5/6
>>113373662
6/7 anime
>>113373878
3/3
>>113375372
5/5

I want to change mine so bad. Might just swap the pics for newer ones.
>>
These threads always turn into pissing contents of who has the most diverse and refined taste.

And if you like TTGL, KLK, SnK, Bleach, Naruto, One Piece etc etc.
Well, then you're bad at anime.
>>
File: 3x3.jpg (746KB, 920x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3.jpg
746KB, 920x920px
>>113373463
4/4

>>113373878
3/3

>>113375372
3/3
>>
>>113375562
>These threads always turn into pissing contents of who has the most diverse and refined taste.
What? No it doesn't. I think that's just how you feel about it. We just post our 3x3's and rate others. Nothing more. Nothing less. It's quite comfy.
>>
>>113373463

8/9

>>113373662

9/9

>>113373683

6/9

Only because I haven't seen that much retro anime compared to modern stuff.

>>113373878

7/9

>>113375372

7/9

I need to update this to include OVAs, short anime and characters. I might just leave it as it is though.
>>
>>113375749
Is retro really the right term to use? I guess you could call Astro Boy (2003) retro because it is in a style from a by gone age in modern times.
>>
File: favorites.jpg (250KB, 920x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
favorites.jpg
250KB, 920x920px
>>
File: mosaictv28.jpg (210KB, 920x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
mosaictv28.jpg
210KB, 920x920px
>>113376555
Even if your powerlevel is low, picking Nazo no Kanojo X shows you have potential. 8/9 overall.
>>
File: 3x3_Animu.jpg (2MB, 1200x1200px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3_Animu.jpg
2MB, 1200x1200px
>>113373463
6/9
>>113373662
6/9 TV
6/6 Mango
5/9 Mova
>>113373683
2/7
>>113373878
5/7 whats top right?
>>113375372
6/8
>>113375498
3/8
>>113375679
5/6
>>113375749
3/3
It's still liked/seen not recognized/9 or however you rate
>>
>no new friends with great taste
I won't post until I'm ready.
>>
>>113377036
That's okay since your taste is utter shit. Please don't change your names that often, otherwise it's hard to filter you out.
>>
>>113377222
Don't worry. I'm going to start posting anonymously in these threads so it's more difficult for people to identify me.

Also I have the objectively best taste. I bet your 3x3 has lain, haibane, kino no tabi, mushishi, and aria. Don't lie.
>>
>>113375498
Changed some pics and took out KnK and Mushishi. Feels fresh.
I spent more time that I should have with the composition of the entire thing. Although the YYS pick throws it all off. I just can't find a good one to go with the rest.

>>113377338
>I bet your 3x3 has lain, haibane, kino no tabi, mushishi, and aria. Don't lie.
>this is a sign of bad taste
Used by many, but bad by no means whatsoever.
>>
File: 3x3s.jpg (768KB, 1977x1001px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3s.jpg
768KB, 1977x1001px
>>113373662
Manga: 4.5/9
>>
>>113373463
4/4
>>113375372
3/4
>>113375679
5/6
>>
>>113377518
6/6
Still like you a lot for Yuyushiki.
I should watch Tamayura sometime.
>>113377025
6/6
>>113376943
8/8
>>113376555
4.5/7 Urabe a best
>>113375749
4/4
>>113375679
3/6
>>
File: 3x3.jpg (367KB, 920x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3.jpg
367KB, 920x920px
Most people in these threads have fairly good taste.
>>
>>113375562
>These threads always turn into pissing contents of who has the most diverse and refined taste.

>And if you like TTGL, KLK, SnK, Bleach, Naruto, One Piece etc etc.
Well, then you're bad at anime.

Lel what a faggot
>>
File: ultimate 3x3++.jpg (2MB, 1590x1587px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
ultimate 3x3++.jpg
2MB, 1590x1587px
>>113373463
-1 Here and There whatever
-1 Juirui
7/9

>>113373662
-1Juirui
-1 Fate/Zero
6/8 anime

-1 Lucifer & Biscuit
-0.5 Musashi
7.5/9

>>113373683
5/5 anime
-1 Gunbuster
4/5 ova/movie

>>113373878
8/8

>>113375372
7/7

>>113375498
-1 KnK movies
7/8 (I swear I've seen the mid right but I can't remember it)

>>113375679
-1 Soul Eater
-0.5 CG
7.5/8+1

>>113375749
3/3 manga
-1 Nodame
7/8 anime

>>113376555
-1 Mysterious Girl X
8/9

>>113376943
-1 Kaiba
7/8

>>113377025
-0.5 Symphogear
8.5/9

>>113377338
Stop being a faggot who wants people to notice your shit taste.

>>113377724
4/4 manga
I'll read your one shot one day

>>113377910
9/9

>>113378056
8/8

>>113375562
It just means they haven't watched a lot.
>>
File: Plebeius Maximus.png (768KB, 1318x854px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Plebeius Maximus.png
768KB, 1318x854px
>>113377910
6/7 I like it
>>113377518
3/3 old one was better
>>113377025
6.5/7, yo
>>113376943
5.5/6
>>113375679
5/5
>>113375372
8/8 hey anon
>>113373878
7/7
>>113373662
9/9 anime, haven't seen you in a while
>>113373463
8/8, haven't seen now & then
>>
>>113378564
>haven't seen now & then
It's shit.
Don't bother.

''Force'' suffering for the sake of suffering with nothing to be learned from the experience other then suffering is painful.
>>
File: 1394832059315.jpg (28KB, 467x413px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1394832059315.jpg
28KB, 467x413px
>>113378564
>this taste
You've won my heart.
>>
>>113378352
5/5 Mango
4/6 Mov
>>113378564
8/9 yo
>haven't seen now & then
It's good watch it. A lot of suffering, a faggot MC and Sara.
>>
File: mosaic3.jpg (221KB, 920x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
mosaic3.jpg
221KB, 920x920px
>>113375679
3/4
I might pick up the Soul Eater anime just to say I did, but I hear the ending was shit. Should I just read the manga instead?
>>113376555
7/7
>>113377910
6.5/8
>>
File: Desktop1.jpg (3MB, 3584x2688px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Desktop1.jpg
3MB, 3584x2688px
I dont belong here
>>
>>113379665
>just to say I did
Why? Are people in your life offended if you tell them you're not interested in SE?

>>113379700
5.5/7 rate others anon
>>
>>113378564
what's the name of the one in the middle?
>>
>>113379700
5/6, nah you ight
>>
>>113379700
top kek
>>
>>113378352
>-1 Gunbuster
Why?
>>
>>113379814
Mushishi
>>
>>113373683
>Yoji Kuri

Oh come on, I could even suspend my disbelief for stuff like Horus, but this is pretty much veering into "hipster parody" territory. If I had to make a /lit/ chart analogue, it would have something like Moll Flanders, Omoo, and "The Tale of the Husband and the Parrot" on it.
>>
>>113373683
You will source your independents for me right now. I'm far too important to take each panel to google.
>>
>>113378056
You had me at Sketchbook.
>>
>>113379920
Boring and shit in every way, wasted potential, only liked because it's an OVA and nothing else.
The only thing good is that time lapse episode where you see that everything changed and it sucks that everyone moved on in life.

That was every well done.
And the ending being actually good.

However, everything else is shit.
Coach is a bunch of uselessness, even if his character is awesome.
Jung Freud Skinner (insert famous psychology guy) was complete irrelevant.
The other girl as well and her I LOVE COOOAAACHHH AAAAAHHHH was fucking stupid and annoying and seemed like adding more drama bullshit than giving her character depth or purpose.

It's just wasted potential but given a pass because ''as an OVA and for its time, it's good'' which isn't a valid excuse for it being meh overall.
And breast doesn't make it good.
>>
What's the show on the middle left here
>>113377518

It's the same one on the middle bottom row here
>>113376943
>>
>>113380553
Isamu Hirabayashi - 663114
Yoji Kuri - Human Zoo
Mirai Mizue - Modern No.2
Kihachiro Kawamoto - Briar-Rose, or the Sleeping Beauty
Koji Yamamura - Atama Yama
Kei Oyama - Hand Soap
Tsuji Naoyuki - Trilogy About Clouds
Hiroshi Harada - Midori - Shoujo Tsubaki
Atsushi Wada - The Great Rabbit
>>
>>113381639
Based anon. Thank you.
>>
>>113380443
Too tired to argue, I just post what I enjoy. Make of it what you will. If I wanted to impress posters in this thread I'd likely be better off going for things people who visit these threads might have seen.
>>
>you will never be as cool as bear
Kill me now
>>
>>113381639
.baseD anon .thanK you
>>
>>113373463
5/7
>>113373662
5/6
>>113373878
5/5
>>113375372
5/6
>>113375498
4/7
>>113375679
6/7
>>113376555
8/9
>>113377910
7/8
>>113378056
4/5
>>113379665
7/7
>>113379700
7/9 not bad for pleb tastes

Alright /a/ tear me apart.
>>
File: 3x3.jpg (868KB, 1832x1812px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3.jpg
868KB, 1832x1812px
>>113383293
...For forgetting to post my image.
>>
>All that Aria in the 3x3's

How does it feel being hipster, overrating such a bland and boring show?
>>
>>113383293
Nice 3x3
>>
>>113383351
It makes them feel smart
>>
>>113383348
-Baccano
-Fate
-Haruhi
+/- LotGH
+/- Madoka
+Eva
+FLCL
+CB
++TTGL

breddy good. Mine.
>>
File: 3x3am.jpg (696KB, 1840x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3am.jpg
696KB, 1840x920px
>>113383513
Forgot mine, too ((((????)))
>>
>>113383486
How could you feel smart watching Aria? The whole point is to switch off completely.
>>
>>113383513
>>113383592
Wait I thought you liked Haruhi
>>
>>113383702
I do like Haruhi.
>>
>>113383635
He probably means "look" smart.

People overrate that bland and boring crap because it makes them look smart/cultured, it is a hipster's masterpiece.

Everyone with Aria in their 3x3 is a hipster.
>>
>>113383733
>-Haruhi
Explain
>>
>>113383348
7/8

I absolutely do not understand the appeal of the Fate series. I know, I know, I'm in the minority, I haven't felt this weird since I watched and hated The Dark Night Rises.
>>
>>113383781
My 'like' continuum is vast, and I don't like it enough to meet the standards I have for dealing out +'s
>>
>>113379700
4/5 but you are not alright becouse one of them is NGNL
>>
>>113383891
Not him but NGNL isn't on there
>>
>>113383348
4/6
I watched the first ep of NGE so far, still need to watch the rest. I also got TTGL on hold.
>>113383351
It's my favorite anime and 2nd favorite series in general.
>>113379700
3/7 could be better
>>113378564
yo 8/8
>>113378352
3/3 mango
1/1 vn
4/4 tv
2/3 movie
>>113378056
5/5
Initial D, Hidamari, Kaiji, and Aria.
I like it.
>>113383891
That anon doesn't have NGNL on their 3x3.
>>
>>113383936
NGNL has a monopoly on high saturation.
>>
>>113383804
I want to give a highly articulated reason why Fate is great and your tastes are shit but I can't because in the end it would accomplish nothing but make me look like a buttmad autist.
>>
>>113383804

I don't like the Fate series that much either outside of a few things like Carnival Phantasm and characters.

Christopher Nolan can go fuck himself too.

Are you me?
>>
>>113383804
The entire fate series, I might go so far to say anything Nasu has made, other than maybe Tsukihime because I liked the atmosphere, is shit.

TDKR being meh with a few okay parts is a good analogy of the entire thing nasu has made imo.

>>113384783
Nolan isn't bad, he's just shit when he has minimal control.
The prestige was shit.
The second batman was chill and so was inception.
The guy is just devoid of anything related to anything he can't control.
>>
File: anime 3x3.jpg (388KB, 920x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
anime 3x3.jpg
388KB, 920x920px
>>113379665
2/2
+Eva and Yu Yu Hakusho

>>113383348
4/6
+TTGL, Madoka, FLCL, and NGE
-Haruhi and Bebop
I hated Haruhi.
>>
>>113385376
>>113383348
>>113379700
0/10 watch more anime before posting.
>>
>>113386985
Big name shows are big name for a reason. If if I had seen over 1000 anime I'd probably still have mostly mainstream shows in my favorites.
>>
>>113387049
>If if I had seen over 1000 anime I'd probably still have mostly mainstream shows in my favorites.
But that's inaccurate anon. If you've watched at least 200 I can guarantee that at least 70% of your favorite shows would change.
>>
>>113387049
It's not possible to watch 1000 series and end up with Haruhi/AoT/Angel beats in your top 0.1%
>>
>>113387207
Do you have a single fact to back that up?
>>
>>113387334
Ask anyone on here who has seen at least 200 shows if they'd even consider having AoT, Sakurasou, or Angel Beats in your 3x3.
>>
>>113387458
in their 3x3*
>>
File: 3x3.jpg (670KB, 1497x1497px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3.jpg
670KB, 1497x1497px
>>113386888
4/6
>>113385376
4/8
>>113379665
7/9
>>113378564
9/9
>>
>>113387458
I have and I would, if I was a faggot who went around bragging about my taste to anonymous basement dwellers on the Internet.
>>
>>113387754
I'm not even bashing on anyone's taste here. It clearly just proves how much little you've experienced in the anime medium if you're not even willing to watch more than 100 shows.
>>
>>113382572
Don't get me wrong, I like a lot of stuff that would be considered "artsy" myself. But 3x3s are supposedly a person's favorites rather than just "I enjoyed them."

If I had to make another analogy, this time to movies, it's like seeing someone put "The Great Train Robbery" on their all-time top ten list. There's a good chance that person is out there, but even so it's hard to believe.
>>
File: threebythreea.png (538KB, 599x485px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
threebythreea.png
538KB, 599x485px
>>113385376
4/4
>>113383592
3/3
>>113383348
4/4
>>113379665
4/4
>>
>>113387049
Well I have seen 1000+ anime (>>113383592), and I actually do have some big name titles in my 3x3. So you're right.
>>
>>113388177
i'm trying to rate people more, but I still haven't seen/read enough yet
>>
>>113388009
http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Battlechili1
>>
File: 100percentlegit3x3.jpg (242KB, 920x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
100percentlegit3x3.jpg
242KB, 920x920px
>>
>>113387682
>4/8
Its Blue Submarine No. 6 isn't it? The one that you haven't seen I mean.
>>
>>113388435
reddit/9
>>
File: 3x3.jpg (237KB, 920x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3.jpg
237KB, 920x920px
>>113385376
6/8

>>113386888
4/4

>>113387682
6/6

>>113388177
6/6
>>
>>113388435
7/8
Didn't like Code Geass and never watched Clannad
>>
File: 3x3full.jpg (1MB, 1830x2028px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3full.jpg
1MB, 1830x2028px
>>113373463
5/6
>>113373662
4/4 anime
>>113373878
6/6
>>113375372
5/5
>>113377025
5/5
>>113377910
3/4
>>113378564
5.5/7
>>113386888
4/4
>>113388435
4/7
>>113388612
4/4
>>
>>113388435
6/7

Code Geass is pretty bad.
>>
>>113387682
8/8
>>113388177
4/4
>>113388612
3/3
>>113389092
3/3
>>
>>113388453
No its Eureka 7
>>
File: 9x9.jpg (1MB, 940x940px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
9x9.jpg
1MB, 940x940px
Mock me all you want, this stuff is the only thing that brings joy to my life.
>>
>>113388406
http://myanimelist.net/profile/mrrunningbear
>>
>>113386985
Not everyone can be a no life faggot and watch +1000 shitty anime so that they can impress other no life faggots on the internet by claiming that they've seen some obscure piece of shit.
>>
>>113386985
If you're gonna rate actually rate and don't shitpost
>>
>>113390619
I need to watch more.
>SEL
>2/10
I mean it wasn't the most enjoyable thing to watch but did you really think it was that bad?
>>
File: 4x3x3_All_01.jpg (2MB, 1800x2000px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
4x3x3_All_01.jpg
2MB, 1800x2000px
>>113390572
I'm sorry anon.

>>113388612
1/1 - Macross
Prince Tutu is tainted for me. Was the favorite anime of an ex. I've seen at least the first episodes (dubbed, not my decision).

>>113388435
3/6
Like: NGE, Kill la Kill, Hellsing
Dislike: Geass, TTGL, SnK (only series I've ever dropped after getting more than 75 percent of the way through)

>>113388177
6/6 - Overall
Like: Conan (Fantastic series. I'm finishing it up now; I'll probably add it to my 3x3, replacing NGE.), Kaiba, Lupin, Mononoke, Kill la Kill (Watched the OVA today, it was OK. I really only like Ragyo.), Devilman.

>>113386888
2/3
Like: Aoi Bungaku (watched the No Longer Human adaption this weekend due to my copy of the novel not coming in in time for the weekend. I wanted to read it first.), Mononoke
Dislike: F/Z

>>113385376
3/6 - Toonami-core
Like: Big O (need to actually sit down and watch it, but I ;loved it when I was a kid), Casshern Sins, Eureka
Dislike: TTGL, SnK, FMA

>>113385027
>The entire fate series... is shit.
I like you.
>>
File: Deal with it nerds.jpg (315KB, 920x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Deal with it nerds.jpg
315KB, 920x920px
>>
File: 3x3 Pleb taste.png (942KB, 1068x1054px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3 Pleb taste.png
942KB, 1068x1054px
>>113375679
>>113388435
I like that you like what you like.

Still haven't fixed the aspect ratio.
>>
File: 12434364564686798.jpg (133KB, 627x470px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
12434364564686798.jpg
133KB, 627x470px
My VN 3x3.
>>
>>113392023
Real gay/10
>>
>>113392087
Nothing gay about the greatest love story ever told. Komine is best boy.
>>
File: Anime OP 3x3.png (1MB, 920x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Anime OP 3x3.png
1MB, 920x920px
>>113388612
8/8 that's some great taste
>>113392023
checked vndb
>High Amounts of Rape
sounds fun
>>113391376
6/6
>>113391361
5/5
>>113391294
3/3 I think I should pick up Takarajima
>>113390572
you're cute anon
>>113389092
3/3 anime
>>113388435
the greatest ever
>>113388177
3/3
>>113387682
8/8 nice
>>113386888
6/6 hey
>>113385376
3/4
>>
File: 1373348743678.png (200KB, 453x304px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1373348743678.png
200KB, 453x304px
>All this Hidamari love
>>
>>113391361
4/4
>>113391376
7/7
>>113392995
8/8
>>
>>113392995
>I think I should pick up Takarajima
You won't regret it.
>>
File: 1374366006628.jpg (382KB, 1116x1944px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1374366006628.jpg
382KB, 1116x1944px
>>113392995
Its not rape if its pure love! Honestly this VN is so much fun. Wildest ride I have ever been on. Damn fun things are fun. Anime when?
>>
>>113390572
Why do you have the same show listed 9 times?
>>
>>113394255
Picked up
>>
>>113394521
Hi there!

You seem to have made a bit of a mistake in your post. Luckily, the users of 4chan are always willing to help you clear this problem right up! You appear to have used a tripcode when posting, but your identity has nothing at all to do with the conversation! Whoops! You should always remember to stop using your tripcode when the thread it was used for is gone, unless another one is started! Posting with a tripcode when it isn't necessary is poor form. You should always try to post anonymously, unless your identity is absolutely vital to the post that you're making!

Now, there's no need to thank me - I'm just doing my bit to help you get used to the anonymous image-board culture!
>>
File: 1378066200370.png (20KB, 491x49px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1378066200370.png
20KB, 491x49px
>>113394717
Have fun anon. Also the worse you are, the better the h-scenes and end will be. Being nice will only hurt you in the end. I was actually heart broken at these ends. ;_; Play Komine last. Thank me later. The ride never ends.
>>
>>113394741
top kek. Dream on, loser.
>>
File: 1409764963616.png (15KB, 400x400px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1409764963616.png
15KB, 400x400px
>>113395668
>Tripfag
>Calling anybody a loser
>>
>>113396010
>>113394741
All these new fags not knowing what a tripcode is.
>>
>>113388435
5/8
I think TTGL, Madoka, Geass and Evangelion are fine
Didn't really care for SnK, Hellsing, Clannad or Kill la Kill
>>
>>113396623
>5/8
*4/8
>>
>>113396484
You sure told me friend.
>>
>>113391294
I'm confuse
You rated >>113388177 but what you said after is like it's from another one
>>
>>113388158
The point of the statement "I just post what I enjoy" was that the shows are there because they were enjoyed, not for some other reason, and what are favorites besides shows you have enjoyed the most? I don't know why you would assume thast I would mean they were not favorites because I said I enjoy the shows on my 3x3. Most people enjoy their favorite things.
>>
>>113397580
I was drawing a distinction between enjoying something, and enjoying something so much you would call it a favorite, which is a superlative designation and a completely different matter.

As in, I'm not surprised that someone enjoys Yoji Kuri, etc., but that someone chose to put him in a 3x3. Well, it's not Yoji Kuri in particular, since everyone has preferences a lot of others don't understand, but overall a lot of your 3x3 entries just puzzle me in this way because those are choices over every other short/anime that person has watched. I know I've thrown tons of analogies around, but take Koji Yamamura. This feeling is like seeing someone put Suisei or Japanese-English Pictionary on a 3x3 over Mt. Head or Country Doctor. I just have to ask how. Or take "The Great Train Robbery"--it's obviously cultural, artistically, historically significant, and there's enjoyment value to be had, but I would be baffled at anyone who would say that he didn't just enjoy it but would place it on the list of his favorite movies ever.

To conclude, I guess the moral is other people's tastes just can't be understood.
>>
>>113399015
>This feeling is like seeing someone put Suisei or Japanese-English Pictionary on a 3x3 over Mt. Head or Country Doctor.

I do understand what you are referring to, I think it sometimes when I see other peoples 3x3 selections. If that is the way you feel however I can't say I have intentionally gone out of my way to select shows such that this effect might be achieved. They are all there for various combinations of reason and might have been enjoyed in different ways but still they are what I would at least call favorites. There are probably other things I could easily swap in but I am pretty happy with it.
>>
>>113396872
My bad, >>113388177 was meant for >>113383592
>>
File: mosaic5.jpg (221KB, 920x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
mosaic5.jpg
221KB, 920x920px
>>113373878
3/4

>>113377025
5/6

>>113377910
3/4

>>113385376
5/7

>>113388612
5/6
>>
File: 3x3.jpg (363KB, 920x920px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3.jpg
363KB, 920x920px
>>
>>
>>113392995
8/9
>>
>>113401029
Why did you post my 3x3
>>
>>113401575
Because
>>
>>113399015
I was considering putting Noburo Ofuji's 1952 film Kujira on there and possibly Kenzo Masaoka's Sakura, I assume those choices would have been similarly puzzling for you in the same fashion? Though I am not sure what you would think the motive behind making such choices would be if they were made disingenuously because the result is that many posters just outright do not rate it.
>>
File: 3x3.png (763KB, 600x600px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3x3.png
763KB, 600x600px
>>
>>113402917
Well, I just don't understand how certain choices could actually rise above mere appreciation to "favorite" status. Saying something is one of your favorites is a strong assertion. Horus, for example, I wouldn't think it particularly inaccurate to compare it to works like The Jazz Singer or Pamela that are recognized primarily for their historical importance. Sure, people enjoy them, but how many people do you see saying Jazz Singer or Pamela is one of their favorite works? Or maybe, given the director, my previous mention of picking Omoo when the same author wrote Moby-Dick could apply too.

On the other hand, Yoji Kuri shorts are mostly experimentation from the early days of animation, and here my diffficulty is mostly in imagining what qualities could make these kinds of shorts rise to superlative status. People tend to put Tsumiki no Ie over Iblard Jikan or 1001 Nights on 3x3s for a reason. In the same way, I find it hard to imagine how someone could pick something from Yoji Kuri over everything else that is out there. It feels like picking "A Trip to the Moon" when The General or Metropolis is out there.
>>
>>113404229
I'm not quite sure how the 1960s qualify as the early days of animation given that there had been works being produced in Japan since the 1910s. A better parallel to draw surely would have been a silent animation by someone like Yasuji Murata in the 1920s. I just see it as experimental animation rather than early. Early in terms of the development of the anime industry maybe but not so much in terms of the development of the Japanese animation industry.
>>
>>113404841
>I'm not quite sure how the 1960s qualify as the early days of animation

In the same way that the 17th and 18th centuries count as the "early days" of the novel even if there were many proto-novels and prose narratives that date to the Roman era. You can't really consider animation before Disney, or anime before Tezuka, comparable to what most people think of as animation today.
>>
>>
>>113405189
Disney was making animation in the 1920s so I am not really sure what you mean by that. With regards to tezuka however that is why I made a distinction between the anime industry and Japanese animation. Independent japanese animation really is for the most part something quite separate from anime. The point anyway is that Japanese animation did not start in the 1960s and it had 40 or so years of history prior to that.
>>
>>113406614
>Independent japanese animation really is for the most part something quite separate from anime. The point anyway is that Japanese animation did not start in the 1960s and it had 40 or so years of history prior to that.

That's true, but shorts like Tsumiki no Ie or Glassy Ocean also don't have much in common with mainstream TV/OVA anime of their period, and we call them "anime" anyways. So I don't see an issue in considering 1960s anime "early" even if we're talking about independent shorts. Tezuka, and the emergence of an anime industry, is a good dividing line for that kind of qualification, especially since the number of works produced only really picks up from the 60s. Each decade afterward easily dwarfs the amount of content produced in those first 40 years.
>>
>>113377910
Your post just helped me decide my to 6 anime of all time.
>>
>>113407170
I believe the exception was based in referring to the 1960s as early in the history of animation but I think unless I am mistaken it is quite clear you meant anime rather than animation in general so that is quite agreeable. I am aware that independent animation is often referred to as anime but I think that is the result of a combination of factors such as general semantic laziness and most fans of anime only dabbling in the more well known shorts. I think in terms of both creative content and their commercial realities there is a real distinction between the two even without the semantic one always being made. There are of course though some works that blur those lines.
Thread posts: 143
Thread images: 47


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]
Please support this website by donating Bitcoins to 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
If a post contains copyrighted or illegal content, please click on that post's [Report] button and fill out a post removal request
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows an archive of their content. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.