[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Click for more| Home]

Best battle shounen manga

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 104
Thread images: 30

File: MelchseesNova.jpg (92KB, 693x799px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
MelchseesNova.jpg
92KB, 693x799px
Best battle shounen manga
>>
File: 1398403084067.png (1MB, 1703x1200px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1398403084067.png
1MB, 1703x1200px
>>111058312
>>
Psyren was disgustingly underrated.
>MC has powers of complete destruction and oblivion
>Big bad has the powers of life and growth.

There was so much potential...
>>
>>111058806
Ideas were great, execution and art was not. Later half went to complete shit regarding the plot.
>>
That's not Nanatsu no Taizai.
>>
>>111058806
Squandered potential, especially near the end...
>>
>>111058565
This is Battle shounen? I thought it was Vinland Saga-style seinen
>>
>>111058944
It's not really squandered when the guy was forced to end it. Frankly I'm surprised it ended so well. It was hell watching those jump rankings every week.
>>
>>111058905
>>111058944
yeah, it was obviously rushed because it didn't sell that well
>>
>>111058981
Well that sucks, I really liked it up until near the end. Makes sense why it felt so rushed now.
>>
>>111058953
That's pretty much battle shonen. It's just marketed as seinen because there's a lot more gore and random fucking. The themes are pretty much no different than battle shonen.

>Muh weight = Muh NAKAMA
>Muh trance = Muh ZONE

It just puts a pseudo realistic spin on it. It's very different from Vinland Saga which is more akin to Historie.

Ravages of Time is probably the biggest mix of shonen/seinen shit, but it pretty much has everything but fan service. Just look at Lu Bu vs Zhang Lei & Guo Ang. It's like a fucking Bleach fight except instead of special moves and paragraphs of exposition they replace it with choreography and cheeky one liners trying to get in their opponent's head.
>>
>>111058312
>>111058981

atleast MC got best girl right?
>>
>>111058981
He was forced to end it because it didn't sell or do well on rankings. Even ignoring the rushing the art style in Psyren screamed deviantart/pixiv and made it hard for the majority to get into.

Do you think Psyren would have been rushed/axed if it was say, drawn by one of Lim Dal Young's artists? Not a chance.
>>
>>111059418
The art in Psyren is average. It was perfectly normal for a shonen jump manga
>>
>>111059507
Agreed.
>>
File: 594566.jpg (125KB, 800x1240px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
594566.jpg
125KB, 800x1240px
>>
File: 065.png (659KB, 688x1024px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
065.png
659KB, 688x1024px
>>
>>111059507
>>111059625
>average

That's exactly the point anons. How long do you think average series last in WSJ?
>>
>>111059774
You're competing with whatever crap the other mangaka can manage in just a week. Go make the argument for monthly mags. That's just stupid.
>>
>>111059720
Only correct answer.
Kiyomaro is probably has the best protagonist character development in shonen.
>>
>>111059774
> How long do you think average series last in WSJ?
10+ years
>>
Like many have said, there was loads of potential, and the author did a lot of things right. I think the author dropped the ball a lot earlier than the forced end though. He could have made much more out of those time hopping antics. He could have gone full "Back To The Future 2" with the plot, but he didn't.. He could have used this so the heroes would staked the cards in their favor, so they'd have a chance to battle an overwhelming enemy, but it somehow just went the usual powerlevel route and it became even worse when the future antics with the grownup kids was determined as "divergent future path that can't be corrected for the people living in it". Felt unsatisfactory and the author could have easily made up some different mechanic.

Also many of the secondary cast were plain uninteresting. That beefy dude for example, who had a best friend who became a superzombie, never got interesting to begin with. Same for the scaredy cat dude. I never really thought "fuck yeah, a chapter about them!".

Overall I liked the early series and lots of things done right, but ultimately, I think the fact that the writing lost steam because the author didn't realize its potential, was what lead up to the cancellation, after which it was a vicious circle and the author then just chose an ultra generic one way fast lane to finish it up in a timely manner.
>>
>>111058565
>shit quality battle scenes
No.
>>
>>111059774
you are right. if it was bad and filled with cliches it would have gone forever
>>
>>111059909
>Naruto
>Bleach
>One Piece
I see where this is going.
>>
>>111059928
not that I disagree with you but fuck you I loved the scaredy cat dude
>>
>>111060056
Do you mean Kabuto?

That was the best character in the manga, don't know what the fuck is that guy smoking.
>>
File: 15.jpg (47KB, 640x480px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
15.jpg
47KB, 640x480px
The Law of Ueki

The anime supposedly more or less exactly like the manga.
>>
>>111059928
>Also many of the secondary cast were plain uninteresting. That beefy dude for example, who had a best friend who became a superzombie, never got interesting to begin with. Same for the scaredy cat dude. I never really thought "fuck yeah, a chapter about them!".

Because they got relevant around the time the manga was getting axed. You can't exactly develop your secondary cast when you have 20 chapters til the end and your main plot line is in the middle of nowhere.
>>
>>111060153
I still have no idea what the author was thinking with Yandere Amamiya.
>>
>>111060153
The catch is though, maybe if the author had managed to make his secondary cast interesting from the beginning, then it wouldn't have been in danger of cancellation to begin with. He managed with the mc couple, so it's not af he's incapable of doing it. What I'm trying to say is that the author had a phenomenal setup, but didn't have the storytelling skill to make the most out of it. By the time the cancellation became apparent, he had already let many plot- and character-related chances pass. That's just my general feeling on this.
>>
>>111060215
I actually liked her.

Instead of having a female lead have a mental breakdown somewhere in the middle of nowhere and become a "damsel in distress", she becomes a bad-ass killing machine.
>>
>>111060492
>Instead of
That's my problem. The thinking in the first place was stupid.
>>
>>111059954
You'd prefer paragraphs of flat out talking after calling out your special move as opposed to actual choreography with monologues describing their instinctive thoughts?

I didn't know people with shit taste could be so confident in themselves.
>>
File: image.jpg (211KB, 600x848px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
image.jpg
211KB, 600x848px
>>111058312
>>
>>111061201
Nakama.
>>
>>111059803
No it isn't, stop crying just because you can't address the point. Successful series in Jump last because their art isn't randumb deviant art designs all bundled up together.

Go take your /fa/ taste elsewhere.

>>111059909
Which speaks volumes of how shitty Psyren is when it can't even manage that.
>>
>>111061281
>Which speaks volumes of how good Psyren is when it can't even manage that.
Fixed
>>
File: Houshin_Covers.jpg (2MB, 3500x2490px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Houshin_Covers.jpg
2MB, 3500x2490px
I enjoyed Houshin Engi a lot, back when I first read it. Bonus points for suitably grandiose ending.
>>
>>111060153
If your main cast can't even carry the series until your secondary cast gets developed you deserved the axe one way or another.

The thread's psyrenfags are almost as clueless as those who believed Double Arts could get away with it's shitty drawings and boring MCs on premise and choreography alone.

>hurr durr I enjoy 1-2 aspects of a series
>hurr durr I don't care about anything else and can overlook it
>hurr durr everyone should b lik me!

The closest series to having ridiculously clashing character designs and still be successful is HxH, and that series wouldn't even survive if it started at the same time as Psyren instead of 1998.
>>
>>111058941
This so much.
>>
>>111061356
Tip your fedora harder.
>>
>>111058312
started out as a gantz clone, ended as a generic shounen
>>
>>111061435
>gantz clone
What? It the same generic shounen theme of whisked off into a different world from the beginning.
>>
File: K12[1].png (693KB, 1024x479px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
K12[1].png
693KB, 1024x479px
>>111061406
>The closest series to having ridiculously clashing character designs and still be successful is HxH
Nigga are you fucking retarded?

This were the main characters of Naruto. They're supposed to be stealthy ninjas, spies, assassins, saboteurs.
>>
Alive! The final Evolution
>>
>>111059774
Look at Reborn
>>
>>111061406
Your argument falls flat when there are ongoing series that are utter fucking shit. Psyren and Double Arts were at least decent.
>>
File: SunaovsKazuya.jpg (400KB, 1456x1061px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
SunaovsKazuya.jpg
400KB, 1456x1061px
Surprisingly good art and battles from an H artist.
>>
>>111061525
>They're supposed to be stealthy ninjas, spies, assassins, saboteurs.

Except they're not. They're "ninjas" in name only.
>>
>>111064533
That's what I said. Learn to read.
>>
>>111066488
That's obviously not what you said. Learn some reading comprehension.
>>
>>111061395
Is anime good or should I start with manga? I remember watching some episodes years ago in tv.
>>
>>111062164
Point. But it's part of the old guard of manga. Manga stories survive on vampire rules; the older and more ancient it is, the more powerful it becomes and the harder it is to die.
>>
File: Astral_Space.png (277KB, 915x809px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Astral_Space.png
277KB, 915x809px
>>111058312

Psyren was so fucking cool
>>
>>111060128
Man. I remember this. Really loved it. Had a bit of a crush on Rinko, although that's faded already.

I'm enjoying Anagle Mole too, though it's a shame that translated chapters come so infrequently.
>>
>>111067412
Avoid the anime. It's all round shitty. Plot diverges from the manga to do it's own thing and the anime came out when doing studios were still in the transition from traditional to digital animation, so you get shit cgi and cheap looking coloring.

In short, the manga is the way to go.
>>
>>111059418

Psyren wouldn't have ended if the author was friends with Oda just like Toriko's was.

Psyren's art was miles better than Toriko's, which only broke even due heavy nepotism.
>>
>>111059928

Time travel shenanigans are a common newbie mangaka trap that can fuck you up really fast, just look at Reborn's future arc, that thing alone lasted more than the entire manga before it, the author was forced to end it because the ranks were dropping like limp dicks.
>>
File: dark amamiya.jpg (75KB, 418x300px)
dark amamiya.jpg
75KB, 418x300px
I liked the artists art style. Pity his writing wasn't quite up to par with it.
>>
>>111059928
>Same for the scaredy cat dude. I never really thought "fuck yeah, a chapter about them!".

Come on, he got a fucking Stand at the end of the series, that thing was cool as hell.
>>
>>111068028
Someone must have liked him already considering how long it managed to go for, despite being in the bottom 3 consistently.
>>
Did Psyren's author ever start another work?
>>
>>111068230
He just published a oneshot recently I believe.
>>
File: touch amamiya.jpg (23KB, 333x309px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
touch amamiya.jpg
23KB, 333x309px
>>111068090
Yes, unless the whole series premise is based around it, authors should stay away from it. Using time travel as a side arc gimmick is a surefire way to fuck things up, since after a short while readers will get the feeling that this is a divergence from the actual plot that should be happening.

The Psyren author had the opportunity to go all out with the time travel thing, since it was at the core of the series, but somehow he managed to sideline the fun concept of "adjust the past->crazy side effects happen in the future" and turn it into a pretty generic "defeat 10 strong dudes and all is well" type of story. Also didn't help that the whole future arc was rendered inconsequential, since it was a "diverging timeline". Bad story decisions all around.

A real shame, early on when the mystery was still in place it was full of suspense. Then after the big reveal he had time travel to play with, but he faltered.
>>
>>111067970
Thanks.
>>
>>111068149
It turned into one of those series that are bottom 5 floaters, always hovering on the edge. It got lucky that there always were enough worse series around, so those would get canceled instead.
>>
File: 1204593601790.jpg (79KB, 500x700px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1204593601790.jpg
79KB, 500x700px
>>111068394
BTW don't get scared away by the funky designs. You get used to the big shoes and gloves in no time.
>>
Those threads we used to have every time a new issue would come out were so much fun.
I know it's technically a seinen, but come on. It's basically a battle shounen.
>>
>>111058312
Seems like Dio Brando has got a new body
>>
>>111064028
Tsugumomo's author doesn't do hentai. I wish he did though.
>>
>>111069452
You dont know Tusgumomo started out as hentai?
>>
>>111069536
In a oneshot or something?
>>
>>111068688
>>111064028
Those are seinen/
>>
>Cancelled
>Best shonen
>>
It's Gash Bell.
>>
>>111070038
I'm gonna start posting best shonen series.
>>
Shonen where you cry every chapter
>>
Noble Sacrifices
>>
Extremely comedic
>>
Like really really funny
>>
>>111058312
I never finished Psyren but why are his nipples glowing
>>
This guy for example provided many laughs.
>>
3 part story inc
>>
>>111070412
He's the fairy of the woods
>>
>>111070412
Stop
>>
>>111070412
>>111070367
>>111070330
>>111070284
>>111070236
>>111070191
>>111070148
do you not know what the word 'one' means? if you want to dump a bunch of gash bell pages, go make a gash bell thread.
>>
>>111070454
The best faces

>>111070471
I can't now, I need to finish what I started.
>>
>>111070486
wait i thought this was a one page thread. i'm an idiot. you're still dumb for dumping tons of pages.
>>
>>111070486
Where is the word one mentioned?
Where is there someone saying that we have to only post 1 pic?

Do you think this is a one page thread?
>>
>>111070534
No it's just you m8.
You lose all form of credibility by acting all though in the wrong context you tool.
>>
File: UlGgtdR.gif (3MB, 424x240px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
UlGgtdR.gif
3MB, 424x240px
>>111070343
Mikisugi's little brother.
>>
Great fight scenes
>>
>>111058312
God damn you Aikuro, god damn you and your glowing mennipple.
>>
>>111059928
Well he fucked up on the power creep.
>timeline x kids from the past are now so uber that they rape the star dudes like it is nothing
>timeline y kids are fooder tier at best
>despite drastic changes of timeline events of that one dudes friend remain untouched
>suddenly everything is the master plan of evil space meteor
>>
File: AIKI_v01_038.jpg (113KB, 728x1145px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
AIKI_v01_038.jpg
113KB, 728x1145px
Battle Shounen huh
>>
>>111074666
Fucking old men, running the world.
>>
>>111072349
surprisingly hot manga. I remember when that french girl came into the story and he sorta raped her? And the day after she's like "DO YOU KNOW HOW MANY TIMES YOUR MASTER CAME INSIDE ME LAST NIGHT?!
my dick went cray.
>>
File: [MedakaBox]-ch40-01.png (197KB, 800x1200px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
[MedakaBox]-ch40-01.png
197KB, 800x1200px
>>
>>111061201
i can't wait to see the other version
>>
NOT EVEN
A SINGLE
KISS
BETWEEN THE MAIN COUPLE
>>
>>111058312
Was it even a battle shounen, MC never used his powers until the last few chapters since they always went out of control.

Probably why it was so enjoyable (first half of course). Most battle shounens are alright in the beginning though before they are forced to end or continue it.
>>
>>111070505
after reading through the first volume, i realized that it reminded me an awful lot on the setting in beelzebub. so who took from who?
>>
>>111061129
This Anon gets it, it was almost Manhua tier.Seriously go read Feng Shen Ji at least for the art. The latter parts are ridiculous with the manhua wall of text.
Thread posts: 104
Thread images: 30


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]
Please support this website by donating Bitcoins to 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
If a post contains copyrighted or illegal content, please click on that post's [Report] button and fill out a post removal request
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows an archive of their content. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.