>no Brendan or May
>Calem, Orlando and Anna that high
>Hilda and Hilbert that low
it's a normalized distribution, so I had to cut some characters from high tier and tried to only put legitimately bad designs in the lower tiers
maybe I could add a couple intermediate tiers on both sides, but then all the tiers would be thinned out
Someone explain the unanimous hate for Kyouhei.
He's cute in a no-homo way. Only male character I've played as in ages. Has a neat and unique outfit too. Big hair is nice too.
Calem shouldn't be above anyone, what a bore.
But yeah, I agree with you to some extent. Hating any MC at all, you might like some more than others but no one is really that bad.
I could make a point about his clothing style, but Rosa also dresses funny.
You all seem to have made several mistakes in your charts, the most egregious of which is putting anyone on the same tier as or above The One True Waifu.
I'm tired of this misconception. He wears a full wetsuit, like how Rosa wears a bikini underneath.
Even in official art, look at the sleeves, undershirt, and "leggings". It's all a single black and teal garment.
He's the only one I do this with, really.
I don't know a name more annoyingly lame than "Nate".
nATE AND rOSA aRe cUteeeeeee, the rest is shit
>the customisable protags anywhere but god tier
Sure the base design is shit, nut you are all idiots if you think customisation doesn't fix them and make them literally better than everything else.
Nate is pretty good imho when you consider entire "Resonate" thing going for Rosa's and Nate's names. Which goes along with entire Harmonia theme.
Makes more sense than Hilda and Hilbert anyway.
My reasoning mainly takes into account clothing, bags and hairstyle.
I don't like Kris' hair and cap thing. The rest of the desgin is pretty messy overall.
Same goes for OR/AS Brendan's shoes (plus apparent lack of socks), and the added amount of white on his bag. Also, the hat isn't as spiky anymore.
I can at least understand it being thematically correct for a region like Hoenn, but it doesn't make me like the design.
I've had socks that don't go up to my ankles and aren't visible when wearing my shoes. Same argument can't be said for May considering she is wearing practically boots.
Everyone has their own opinions, except mine's right.
>Hilbert in god tier
this is the only correct position for the trainer with the least retarded clothing
Whenone thinks about it Nate's outfit would make more sense in Hoenn where Dive is more in use than in Unova.
>Serena and Hilda in mid tier
What the fuck kind of shit taste is this? Also I feel as if ORAS Brendan and Hilbert should swap places, Leaf should be in high tier, and get rid of shit tier and put Lyra in low.
>no one has posted the correct tiers yet
This isn't a CUTE AND QUIRKY XDD fashion show. These are people who train animals to fight that spend months at a time outdoors on foot.
These tiers are based in part by how well they look the part of a trainer (boots, backpack, not tutus and tights, hiking/outdoor gear) and how aesthetic the art is overall.
For example, I might have put RS Brendan up higher but the official art makes him look like a jackass, despite looking like he's ready for questing and battle. Emerald Brendan on the other hand has basically the same clothes, but overall is far more aesthetic.
Also, why the fuck is FRLG Red wearing pink clothes? The fuck? Always hated that.
>OR/AS designs were amazing
You had me going for a sec.
I was thinking that, but it depends on the time of year I'd say.