I think we can all agree on this

>>25045564
>Ethan in God Tier
>Hilbert and Hilda in Mid Tier

No. Ethan's redesign really pulls him down. And Hilbert and Hilbert should be high.

File: 1432379842395.gif (1MB, 400x300px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 400x300px

>>25045564
>no Brendan or May
>Calem, Orlando and Anna that high
>Hilda and Hilbert that low

>ORAS characters in high tier
stopped looking at the chart there

>>25045564
Rank from best to worst:
Rosa
Hilda
Serena
Dawn
Leaf
May
Lyra
Kris

Don't really got an opinion for the males.

>>25045564
>Lyra that low
>Colorblind girl from Crystal that high

>>25045564
yeah white 2s fucking hair coming out of his hat is fucking dumb

>>25045597
>>25045591
it's a normalized distribution, so I had to cut some characters from high tier and tried to only put legitimately bad designs in the lower tiers

maybe I could add a couple intermediate tiers on both sides, but then all the tiers would be thinned out

File: protag.png (696KB, 1124x1612px) Image search: [Google]

696KB, 1124x1612px

>>25045564
fixed, family :>

>>25045731
>oras brendan still in High tier
shit taste tbqh familia

>>25045564
>leaf and hilda anything but god tier

>>25045731
Brendan aside, spot on

File: trainers.png (506KB, 900x1600px) Image search: [Google]

506KB, 900x1600px

>opinions

>>25045731
I would put Lucas in low tier in any form. He's just unlikable.
Both Dawns are objectively god tier.
Kris and Leaf are boring.
>>25045743
>not liking the cutest boy
fuck you

What's wrong with ORAS Brendan

File: b2.gif (1MB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 500x281px

>>25045780
nothing, he's perfect

>>25045776
>cutest boy
well, he certainly looks like a faggot, so I guess that works for you

>>25045564
Not
>>25045564
Even
>>25045564
Close

>>25045564
>using remake red/brendan/ethan while using D/P lucas

At least have some consistency

>>25045564
>I think we can all agree on this
We can't agree on anything.

>>25045564
>Lucas not at least high

>>25045893
he'd still be low-tier, maybe even lower

File: 439802361.png (198KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

198KB, 500x500px

Lyra is a cutie.~

>>25045857
it's ironic that you think that's an insult

File: fixed.png (697KB, 1124x1612px) Image search: [Google]

697KB, 1124x1612px

>>25045731

File: lyra no hat.png (365KB, 550x650px) Image search: [Google]

365KB, 550x650px

>>25045564

No can't do

i agree with like 66%

I don't know any of these sad fan made, head-canon names to understand what people are bitching about.

File: 67083e440d56280c10d09d3d6fe0ebd3.jpg (57KB, 620x780px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 620x780px

Someone explain the unanimous hate for Kyouhei.

He's cute in a no-homo way. Only male character I've played as in ages. Has a neat and unique outfit too. Big hair is nice too.

Calem shouldn't be above anyone, what a bore.

>>25046082
If you got rid of either the hair or the leggings it would be fine. The stupidity of those two things combined is greater than the sum of its parts

>>25046082

>jap names

But yeah, I agree with you to some extent. Hating any MC at all, you might like some more than others but no one is really that bad.

I could make a point about his clothing style, but Rosa also dresses funny.

>>25045564
>lucas low tier not high tier
>calem mid tier not shit tier

calem is literally fuck boi impersonated

>>25046120
Lucas is offensively bland

Calem is bland but at least he has cool boots, and you can customize him

File: fixed your shit nigga.png (434KB, 900x1600px) Image search: [Google]

434KB, 900x1600px

You all seem to have made several mistakes in your charts, the most egregious of which is putting anyone on the same tier as or above The One True Waifu.

File: realtierfaggots.jpg (335KB, 993x1189px) Image search: [Google]

335KB, 993x1189px

this is the real faggots

>>25046336
Switch Hilda and Brendan up one each and you are my man

File: b4bb227a71fc43febbc4e5e756e73d66.jpg (71KB, 600x800px) Image search: [Google]

71KB, 600x800px

>>25046105
>leggings

I'm tired of this misconception. He wears a full wetsuit, like how Rosa wears a bikini underneath.

Even in official art, look at the sleeves, undershirt, and "leggings". It's all a single black and teal garment.

>>25046112
He's the only one I do this with, really. I don't know a name more annoyingly lame than "Nate".

>>25045731
What the fuck is the difference between platinum and D/P Lucas?

>>25045776
>cute
I think you meant hot
Hoennshipping is best ship

>dawn
>wearing no pants despite living in an obviously temperate region with seemingly perpetual early spring
>god tier
She's pure trash sorry

File: W5ocbTK.gif (976KB, 450x338px) Image search: [Google]

976KB, 450x338px

>>25045564
I disagree with literally every position

>>25047152
Agreed

File: trainer tier.png (697KB, 1124x1612px) Image search: [Google]

697KB, 1124x1612px

>>25045564

>>25046417
>even putting Red in a low tier

Kys

>>25045615
Rosa>dawn>Serena>Hilda>may>lyra>kris>leaf
Fixed that for you

>>25045731
>low tier Rosa
>low tier taste

I don't know what people see in Hilda, most bland and unorginal fem protag desing so far.

>>25048613
I don't know what people see in Rosa, most idiotic design so far as well as horribly overhyped and overrated.

File: CZAj7hjWEAE_Da7.png (462KB, 600x400px) Image search: [Google]

462KB, 600x400px

nATE AND rOSA aRe cUteeeeeee, the rest is shit

>>25045564
Most agree but:

>>25045591
/thread
No matter if BW was bad, Hilda1/Hilbert1 was great designs.

>the customisable protags anywhere but god tier

Sure the base design is shit, nut you are all idiots if you think customisation doesn't fix them and make them literally better than everything else.

File: 1453238712705.jpg (43KB, 397x395px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 397x395px

>>25048903
This.

>>25048613
The only bad thing about Hilda's design is the pocket things on her shorts, but otherwise she's one of the few protagonists who don't look like they got dressed in the dark.

>>25048903
The male clothing options sucked.

>>25046835
Nate is pretty good imho when you consider entire "Resonate" thing going for Rosa's and Nate's names. Which goes along with entire Harmonia theme.
Makes more sense than Hilda and Hilbert anyway.

>>25048920
Some options that are mostly shit still beat no options at all. I actually liked my Gen 6 character, where I find most of the other male protags to be awful.

File: 1453340372908.png (695KB, 924x1612px) Image search: [Google]

695KB, 924x1612px

There. Much better.

Hilbert da qtest

File: Mainline protagonists.png (738KB, 908x2008px) Image search: [Google]

738KB, 908x2008px

My reasoning mainly takes into account clothing, bags and hairstyle.

>>25049314
>OR/AS Brendan low tier
>Kris shit tier
Y tho? Everything else is in the correct place tho.

>>25049329
I don't like Kris' hair and cap thing. The rest of the desgin is pretty messy overall.

Same goes for OR/AS Brendan's shoes (plus apparent lack of socks), and the added amount of white on his bag. Also, the hat isn't as spiky anymore.
I can at least understand it being thematically correct for a region like Hoenn, but it doesn't make me like the design.

>>25049366
>missing socks
I've had socks that don't go up to my ankles and aren't visible when wearing my shoes. Same argument can't be said for May considering she is wearing practically boots.

File: blackwhitebestgames.png (829KB, 762x1612px) Image search: [Google]

829KB, 762x1612px

Everyone has their own opinions, except mine's right.

>>25049366
The oras brendan is one of the more realistic outfits. The only complaint is the hat which is off with the runner, bikers /out/fit/

File: 1307043278041.png (72KB, 460x430px) Image search: [Google]

72KB, 460x430px

>>25049477
>Hilbert in god tier
this is the only correct position for the trainer with the least retarded clothing

>>25049488
>mays under armor has frills
JUST

File: 4ffc2a0cF6gUSt9m.png (338KB, 600x510px) Image search: [Google]

338KB, 600x510px

Whenone thinks about it Nate's outfit would make more sense in Hoenn where Dive is more in use than in Unova.

>>25049477
>Lucas in shit tier
Sorry, your opinions are wrong.
Am I the only one who things that DP Lucas is the best designed male protag?

>>25049869
Pt Lucas looks like me, so he instantly gets up to God tier for good fashion. I mean, what the issue? He dresses well!

>>25049869
he's so boring that I've actually abandoned DPPt playthroughs where I chose him just so I could switch back to Dawn

>>25049869
Maybe not best designed but definitely a very good one.

Better than Dawn anyway.

>>25049925
His clothes are okay, but that hat is retarded.

File: best designed.png (2MB, 2000x2220px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2000x2220px

Get on my level.

File: 9d1fef2010f3fb28dbbe9868bec97936.jpg (60KB, 400x500px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 400x500px

Lyra is the best.

>>25050688
I'm amazed someone else did save this pic.

File: 20831251.jpg (57KB, 512x512px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 512x512px

>>25050704
I save a lot of Lyra pictures.

>>25046417
great taste, anon.

>>25050083
I wear a flat cap!

>>25049477
I'd make an arguement but OR/AS May is in god tier so I'm pinned.

>>25049535
>not liking the frills
Faggot

>>25050688
I was about to say the same thing before I noticed your post. Some people just can't appreciate glorious overalls.

>>25045564
>Serena and Hilda in mid tier
What the fuck kind of shit taste is this? Also I feel as if ORAS Brendan and Hilbert should swap places, Leaf should be in high tier, and get rid of shit tier and put Lyra in low.

>>25046268
Only right answer

>>25051190
>overalls
>thighhighs
>zetta ryouki
>best hat
best girl

>>25045564
yes

>>25048990
Move rosa up one and d/p lucas down one and you're good

File: 1453338862004.png (852KB, 900x2028px) Image search: [Google]

852KB, 900x2028px

>no one has posted the correct tiers yet

Facts inbound:

This isn't a CUTE AND QUIRKY XDD fashion show. These are people who train animals to fight that spend months at a time outdoors on foot.

These tiers are based in part by how well they look the part of a trainer (boots, backpack, not tutus and tights, hiking/outdoor gear) and how aesthetic the art is overall.

For example, I might have put RS Brendan up higher but the official art makes him look like a jackass, despite looking like he's ready for questing and battle. Emerald Brendan on the other hand has basically the same clothes, but overall is far more aesthetic.

Also, why the fuck is FRLG Red wearing pink clothes? The fuck? Always hated that.

you can't

>>25051726
>Emerald May and Brendan above R/S and OR/AS May and Brendan
Emerald designs were shit tbqh. And OR/AS designs were amazing.

>>25051726
autism/10

File: 1445240208068.gif (2MB, 360x270px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 360x270px

>>25051991
>OR/AS designs were amazing
You had me going for a sec.

>>25052007
This entire thread is autism, I just didn't want it to devolve into a b8 battle and explain why I placed certain protags.

>>25051726
>boots, backpack, not tutus and tights, hiking/outdoor gear
>Hilda in high
She'll freeze. Or be raped. Or both. She's dressed terribly for adventure.

File: 94d28b065014c54d3abee1ccf7642bcb.jpg (82KB, 736x490px) Image search: [Google]

82KB, 736x490px

>>25052228
I was thinking that, but it depends on the time of year I'd say.

>>25052008
Besides Brendan's main artwork which looks kind of goofy, the ORAS characters and their in-game models are some of the best in the series

File: silent rage.jpg (25KB, 506x474px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 506x474px

>>25052684
is it fucking opposite day or something

File: bd.gif (815KB, 245x141px) Image search: [Google]

815KB, 245x141px

>>25052702
you must be dumb, cause they're both cute

>>25052714
awful N64 moeshit garbage

>>25052719
>N64

Not even that anon, but were you alive when the N64 or even PS1 were relevant? You have no idea how bad early 3D was if you consider that N64 tier.

none of those are appropriate adjectives, you should try to form more coherent ideas

>>25052736
Regardless, have you seen other 3DS games? ORAS/XY looks like fucking garbage.