>the eventual shinno remakes will be like OR/AS, devoid of content and inferior to platinum
>mfw the amount of people that started with gen IV is actually pretty big already
Mfw it's true
>taking the risk of making Sinnoh remakes at all
Come'on Anon you can do better than that
My cousin's first Pokemon game was Diamond; he's halfway through Grade 12 now
That's not what I'm trying to convey
To you it seems like a risk allowing GF to remake the Sinnoh games, because they might fuck it up and ruin something that you hold dear
From the standpoint of GF there is no risk, its free money because fans will definitely buy it. Its a smart investment because the dev time is shorter and the sales are just as high as other mainline games.
as someone who likes emerald the best, fuck no it's not
platinum is probably the best pokemon, while it's single player was slightly worse than emerald's and B2/W2, it's online metagame was the best
OR/AS single player is worse than platinum and it's metagame as well
I wouldn't even care honestly, unless they actually revamp mechanics in a great way for gen 7. Only reason I'm even that disappointed in ORAS is because I was dying to basically play Emerald with phys/special split. But if gen 4 remakes are shit then I am entirely content just playing Platinum.
You don't know that
It's their first time on 3DS hardware
ORAS was made immediately after X and Y they didn't have enough time to improve they just made Hoenn
Skipping a year just makes things better
>No Poffin Making
You don't know that. Pokéblocks weren't removed entirely
and that game you had to play to make them was shit anyways
>No Amity Square
>No underground mining
>No Sinnoh Battle Frontier
It wasn't even that good.
Highly doubt it. I'm 99% sure that's staying in gen VI.
>implying that's a bad thing
>New formed yippee
Literally everyone needs to shut the hell up. Remakes are not bad, and after gen VII, or even as soon as Z is released, you fucks will be praising Gen VI and saying OR/AS was better then HG/SS, because it's how you contrarian faggots work. You did it with both HG/SS and you did it with Gen V in its entirety. Kill yourselves.
I just want a Platinum remake, is that too much to ask for?
>no third game elements
You get a Johto starter in Emerald for completing the Hoenn dex. You also get that in OR/AS. You don't get that in R/S.
>Pokéathalon takes effort
No it doesn't. It's pretty much free stuff that is normally in limited quantity.
>Customizable safari zone
Yeah, that you have to wait months to see the effects for.
>no game corner instead of "interesting mini-game"
You mean that retarded copy of minesweeper? No. I'd rather have no game corner than a neutered one that is impossible to get anything from.
>added new routes
Who the fuck cares? It's two boring routes.
Kek. You are blind as a bat. And literally all the "gimped" parts of OR/AS we're taking out the tedious stuff that were a roadblock until you got insanely lucky.
>harder gym leaders
You're forgetting this is a game marketed towards children, and isn't meant to be overly difficult. Plus the only reason HG/SS gym leaders were hard is because the broken leveling curve.
Who gives two fucks?
>copy pasta'd a better thing than the battle maison
Kek. You have better things to do in post game. Like get almost any legendary you want. And you don't have the roadblock of 8 more gyms and someone who's got almost level 100 mons on their team.
TL;DR: HG/SS is not actually better than OR/AS, you fucks are just delusional.
You're not really countering the argument. Even if you don't care about stuff like the Pokewalker and the extra routes and the generally more robust postgame content, it doesn't mean it wasn't there, nor that others didn't enjoy it, nor that ORAS didn't lack those things.
Hot damn, this is some class A shilling.
Point 1: that's such a fucking trite, minuscule detail. You're really digging.
2: you have to actually look at the screen to play pokeathlon. It's like a bunch of Wario Ware games, and it was fun as hell and really accessible to play with friends.
3: only for the rarest Pokemon (this was back during a time when certain Pokemon were actually hard to find and not present on Route 3 like in XY)
>retarded copy of minesweeper
Confirmed for never having played Voltorb Flip. Shame, because it was a fun game that actually involved puzzle mechanics and you could there and listen to the great HGSS game corner theme.
5: people who like exploring routes care. Which should be just about everyone. God, you're really defending a lack of new content, huh? That's like saying who cares about the Sevii Islands (don't say this). Also, the routes had Crasher Wake, the best gym leader, as well as the Onix and Cloyster trainers.
6: you're a fucking idiot. Go back and walk through GSC's Viridian Forest.
8: I do. Going for late night runs with my Jirachi and getting expensive items to sell was a blast. I have to ask you at this point, what part of Pokemon do you even like?
9: so I hear you like to do easy things like catch Pokemon, and not things that actually take effort, like beating a Frontier Brain.
TLDR you're riddled with delusion you shill