Doom: Going down. No question, better than any AAA shit released this year
1) Axiom Verge
2) Rocket League
3) Warhammer End Times
4) Witcher 3
5) Shadowrun: Hong Kong
Worst GOTY: Fallout 4
all memes aside, i really liked fallout 4, the story was great
i mean bloodborne was cool and all...
but i just liked fallout 4 better
Because not everyone enjoys revolutionary things. Some people like to stay in their comfort zone , pick one game and develop more in it ( like did witcher 3 ) . It's the same reason why phantom pain while being sucesfull didnt grab some of the old audience , going full open world killed the game for people.
Well there was that and the game was launched half finished with the promise of more content later which you really cant trust any developer even Nintendo to keep their promise with. Also it's on a console that numbers wise less people own than the competition.