What would a Silmarillion game be like?

Pay to win tower defense

Extremely boring. Just like the source.

>>322324070
undertale

A Telltale choose your own adventure book where the choices don't matter.

>>322324070
A moba

it would either be very chaotic, very boring or very dumbed down
the silmarillion isn't a 'story', the only things to draw from are the ideas written in it, taken from poems or whatnot
but weaving together a game narrative would be difficult if not impossible and they'd have to make drastic changes, or it would be a game that played out like an episodic fever dream of insane shit happening, with bits of exposition telling you what you're even doing smiting the gates of angband or why you're talking to your sword after killing a dragon
doing all that stuff in regular game play would take waaay too long, kind of like reading this post

anyway, all things considered i wouldn't really mind another game like shadow of mordor that is informed by the lore while doing new things, but not taking (too many) great liberties, and honestly it would be the best we'd get besides some butchered Middle Earth tv series

Well there is Sil, which is a very good roguelike.

>>322324264
>where the choices don't matter.
so just like every other telltale game

Dark Souls 2.
A bunch of badly written, convoluted lore that only makes sense and connects if you read really far into it.

>>322326290
>Dark Souls 2.
>A bunch of badly written, convoluted lore that only makes even less sense of you read really far into it.
Fixed