Is this the end for her career?
>You switch places with your friend during sex and surprise the girl through the window
>You switch places with your friend during sex and surprise the girl through the window AND THAT'S FUCKING RAPE
It's her own joke because she added her own unique funny sense of comedy
You could argue that for the show clips (which is still debatable, usually comedians write a lot of their shows material like Louis and Jefferies did) but not the standup peformances.
She explained the patrice joke on opie and jim at some point recently and everyone pretty much agreed that sex act jokes were pretty much open ground and many people had almost definitely done a version of the gorilla mask joke well before he did and will keep doing it long after, at worst its kinda hacky but not like Mencia level
Ok calm down. Are we really calling explaining a sexual position/scenario a joke that someone can 'own'? If I made some stupid joke about being kicked out of the Mormon church because we had very different ideas of "missionary work", does that mean I can then call anyone a joke thief who dares to use or explain what missionary sex is? Oneil didnt invent sex, what the fuck. he can explain what donkey punching is on the stage and so can you. you arent stealing shit
that being said she absolutely ruined the delivery and is an awful performer
old generic topics that every comic has riffed on at some point in their career, jokes about being a prostitute or drunk lady holding up a finger while she finishes her drink are hardly new territory for comics and most can do a funny riff that till probably be remarkably similar to the thousands of funny riff's others have done in the past. Granted its usually early in your career or when facing a new audience out of your usual demographic so you use "safe" generic jokes to win them over, that you do bits like these and not on your HBO hour-long special
This entire thread is so cringe worthy, not even a fan of Amy either.
How would a joke that no one even remembers ruin her career? Remove that joke from her history and she is just as popular. She is not "known" for that joke, it is irrelevant. If she stole it, who cares? Its not like that one joke is why shes popular.
This place is autistic. Also, Patrice Oneal is garbage /b/ MRA tier humor
She can get away with literally everything, because her uncle is a senator
Like a real life version of that episode in Always sunny where Frank pays off hundreds of people to pretend to laugh at Dee's jokes
I was indifferent about her, never laughed from her "jokes" I don't even care if steal them but what make me hate her is how she got triggered by a joke tweet which joke is what she is selling "ya I am fat cunt huhu"
Get real you unfunny pig
I can only imagine the neckbeards in this thread irl
>normie girl: hehe amy schumer is so funny
>neckbeard: SHES A THIEF!!!!!! SHE STOLE A JOKE!!!!
>neckbeard: REMEMBER THAT JOKE ABOUT HER BEING IN THE WINDOW AND ITS LIKE RAPE
girl: uhh, no, no really, haha her show is so funny thou-
>neckbeard: IT WAS A STOLEN JOKE. SHE USED THE SAME CONCEPT FOR A JOKE THAT SOMEONE ELSE DID. WE MUST MAKE THIS GO VIRAL. JOE ROGAN IS SO ALPHA I LIKE REAL COMICS LIKE BILL BURR AND DOUG STANHOPE
this is what the jews in charge are telling her to say. She fucked the right ones, thats why she has fucking become a household name in the past year. She has been around for a long time, so has her tv show. Nothing has changed with her or her 'comedy' but all of a sudden she is everywhere in the news, tv shows, movies, then she decides to start spouting feminist shit once she gets in the limelight. Coincidence?
why does everyone on reddit talk the same...spelling wise and opinionated
fucking autismo niggers jesus...
Holy hell, her delivery is SO BAD. The original jokes flow so perfectly, then she delivers the same material and somehow it seems so forced and unfunny. I guess because it isn't really hers.
>So the guy goes outside and waves BUT THATS NOT FUNNY CUS ITS RAPE THO
Great comedy chops.
That they were old jokes back when Patrice did them and they probably did the same jokes 20 years ago, sex act jokes are open ground and everyone has done them at some point for an easy laugh https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TRyOvIya_Dk
they only referenced the Patrice ones because they all have to personal connection to him and the female ones are even more generic and overused by everyone that its not really worth even talking about.
Conversation I've actually had:
>normie girl: Trainwreck was kind of funny I guess. I hadn't heard of her before.
>me: I think her humor gets old really fast. "I'm a slut and I'm really sad"
>normie girl: That's what hooking up does to people. We've all done it and regret it.
>me: You think it's more of a warning than a celebration?
>normie girl: Hooking up is dumb and making fun of it is dumb. I don't think I'd see another one of her movies.
It turns out even sluts don't like being sluts. They know no one wins.
Also, one of the guys is an imaginary construct created by the main character for his novel. He cucks himself.
So you're saying Amy Schumer tells generic, overused jokes is thus a hack? I agree.
The difference being, of course, the rapid rise of her career from absolutely nowhere, and the fact that those comedians who tell hacky material go on to tell better jokes. She is stuck there. You disingenuous cunt.
Its not the question that was asked and since shes become a big star recently and she's a longtime friend of the show I'm sure they didn't want to burn bridges but if I had to guess I bet if the question was "is it hacky to use these old jokes" they would have said yes. Though to play devils advocate that's only three jokes of a set that was probably an hour and a half cut down to an hour for HBO and not seeing it myself for all I know it could be 95% funny and original material with 5% hacky generic shit to win over middle America and the "two broke girls" demographic
She was pretty funny on Last comic standing in 07 and on that weird reality parody show with Michel Ian Black in like 09 but I would agree she's become a lazy self important hack in the last 4 or so years
I can only speak for people I've talked to. The irony of the premise of Trainwreck is that in a less pronounced way it's a very common feeling among women in their mid twenties to mid thirties. At some point even the most "progressive", sex positive, feminist shill women want to settle down with a decent guy, and the worse their reputation the harder it is for them to find that. The biggest SJW I know is married.
Schumer's character would find it near impossible to find a decent guy IRL and normie women know this.
I'd say such obvious bait is useless but people have been biting pretty hard in this thread.
Not even a fan but
>first joke, ok that's a little strange but it's not unheard of for comedians to come up with the same bits
>sex jokes stuff: literally urban dictionary entries which have been around since 2000, who gives a fuck
>the food slapper bit on her show, she has writers like every comedian, I doubt she personally writes 10 percent of the bits on that show
Verdict: she's just a hack, not a joke thief
Her movie made nearly $140 million and she was on stage with JLaw coming out of something close to total obscurity. I'd say it was more than a fair trade. How long she can ride it out is yet to be seen.
You're implying Schumer has written a good joke.
she would probably just bullshit and say it was a tribute to classic comedians of yesteryear...and equalize it to remakes like Ghostbusters, something that puts a quirky feminist spin on it :^)
Every "joke" she's ever told had probably been arrived at independently by thousands of people before her, because she's an utter mediocrity who's only famous thanks to a perfect storm of tokenism and nepotism.
I remembering hearing that bit about knocking on the window more than a decade ago from some drunk old cunt in a pub who claimed to have actually done it to a black prostitute in Ibiza. That's the level of creativity she's working with.
>no point in stating an opinion or having a discussion if people disagree with out
>public opinion is absolute and makes discussion pointless
If you think she's a funny comedienne, great, knock yourself out.
The question then is "why are you here bothering to talk about it if you think that?"
>This entire thread is so cringe worthy
It's okay to talk about the same premises. It's okay to talk about sex acts without attributing others, since they're mostly of unknown origin, as long as you put your own spin on it. When it comes to Amy Schumer, though, she talks about multiple sex acts from the same Patrice set. It's like she watched Patrice, wrote the acts down, and changed one of the punchlines slightly.
The video also contains a joke directly ripped off from Wendy Liebman, as well as premises from things she's written that are also direct rip offs. She's not Mencia bad, but she's at least Dane Cook, no respect for the craft tier.
>guys like Jim Jefferies and Andrew Maxwell dont have jokes based on the subject matter
>he hasn't done anything in years
>>he hasn't done anything in years
Comedy is hard when you have to come up with shit by yourself.
Stealing jokes was easy before the internet. Now, not so much. It's a good thing his carried is dead.
This is quite inspiring, you know the Native Americans would honor every buffalo they killed by making use of every part of the animal, I'm glad to see Amy Schumer respecting that tradition by using an entire cow for her leather outfit.
Let's put a female spin on jokes
> Guy comes home at night
> slips into bed in the dark
> gets frisky with his wife, seks ensues
> next morning guy goes to kitchen
> his wife is already there
> Honey, my mother stayed the night, the couch is no god for her back, so i let her sleep in our bed
> THAT WAS RAPE!
I don't get why Joe Rogan thinks he's (direct quote) "the mouthpiece of the comic community".
His standup is worse than Bob Saget, Mencia, and Amy Shumer combined. He's not funny at all, whereas Shumer and Mencia may not be good but actually have fans and succesful careers in comedy.
Patrice would fucking destroy her if he was alive right now.
Can we atleast share this video to Opie and Jim? I'm sure they would do something.
anthonywould probably do the most.
When you come straight out of the boonies and got tickets to see the show and she comes on stage and all you want to do is fuck 16 year olds in your dressing room but you just got to sit there and endure
look at her fuckin face its like made of plastic or some shit
That's not even the shit she says that Houdini is, not even the same description you fucking nigger. Dd you even bother to finish the video or did you switch it of the moment you heard the word Houdini?
holy fuck are you retarded
>definition added 2007
>3 years after patrice oneal made the joke
THEY STOLE IT FROM URBA N DICITIONARY GUYS xD
"a houdini can also refer to a sex act where a male, who is fucking a chick doggy style in front of a first floor window, quickly pulls out, and his friend jumps in to continue banging her. the first man then proceeds to run naked and dance in front of his bitch outside the window. magic, eh? "
Learn how to fucking read.
>definition added 2007
>3 years after patrice oneal made the joke
THEY STOLE IT FROM URBA N DICITIONARY GUYS xD
>In 2015, Minority Leader Harry Reid, who is retiring after the 2016 elections, endorsed Schumer to succeed him as Leader.
>Schumer was born in Brooklyn, the son of Selma (née Rosen) and Abraham Schumer. His family is Jewish, and he is related to comedienne Amy Schumer.
I'm pretty sure the only reason she is famous is because of her powerful uncle, who is one of the leaders of Congress
>mfw this one guy keeps linking to reddit
>the top rated comment is "do you even audio level bro?"
>this is the top rated comment by 1,610 people
Holy fuck I honestly keep forgetting how cringey and autistic these people are.
>"the mouthpiece of the comic community"
Friendo, Rogan is a fight commentator and sitcom actor therefore instead of actually being a decent standup he knows on some level that he is really only a commentator about standup.
Just my perspective on a guy also known for his ... podcast, about comedy and fighting. ;)
come to the gym with me anon, i'll spot ur bench ;)
anyway how is this person even popular? she's terrible
or is it like one of those things where his rich dad pays people to say that she's good and empowered, so everyone just sort of goes along with it because they don't want to be that stick in the mud who says otherwise
> guy to girl after sex:"If i'd known you're still a virgin i would have taken more time".
> girl:" If i'd know you have mire time, i would've pulled my pantyhose down first"
That's the one that should slide, to be honest. Lame she used the same jokes as him w/ different names, but jokey sex acts like that are told by literally everybody without needing to be a comedian.
That said he told them better.
her delivery is actually the worst possible
you would find the jokes more funny by reading them from a piece of paper
you would find the jokes more funny by putting them into microsoft sam and having it read them for you
she's basically a black hole of humor
I don't know where you live, but I knew those jokes when I was a kid.
That said, Schumer said he didn't know the joke, but patrice talks about it in his Television appearance talking about radio censorship.
Schumer would have seen this, no doubt in my heart what so ever.
>It's fucked up she stole the patrice bit and the first joke in the vid, but that video is stretching it with the throwaway line in the movie, and the poster. Women dressing their man shitty on purpose isn't some original premise, and the "hold on I'm drinking" pose has been around since like the 20's. I'm all for calling her out on joke stealing, but the video loses credibility by stretching shit too much.