>>64702229 m8 it's all a gamble when u think of it, what kind of god would judge you based on what religion you placed your bets on? why not judge us based on good/bad and if he wanted us to have free will he wouldn't have put prophets on earth and gave them laws and shoehorned politics to write down for everyone to obey, he would've left us alone.
Because we would rather talk to a priest who has spent his life training, and learning scripture rather than some fucking bloke they bump into like huns do.
Dated a girl who was a Presbyterian. She invited me to her "service" with her family. Mass or whatever the fuck the Presbyterian alternative is called took nearly 2hrs rather than the usual Catholic 45mins, there was far too much singing and the arsehole minister decided to point me out at the start to welcome the "Catholic" to their service so I had all eyes on me when I would fumble, or sit and stand at the wrong parts.
THEN we had to go back later that night for fucking movies night and a communal gathering.
Fuck all that noise. Being a catholic is about going to mass twice a year, Easter and Xmas just to renew your Catholocism
>>64702205 Yes, most of the parish seemed to rub their sins in the Priests face, like the cuckolding adultress, the rich guy pissing on everything,the church burning etc.. The person with the most faith was the woman visiting from France who lost her husband. I may need to watch this again. I think it is worth watching.
>b-buh what about the other religions that don't have a huge impact on our cultural identity?!
The whole "he did it too!" thing doesn't work past the age of 5, yaknow. Also, it'd make more of an impact if you answered your own question rather than implying that by having the question, you have a point.
>>64702951 Yes, the Catholics get a bad rap because some sodomites caused a lot of problems, but there are issues in every religion. I think Calvary addresses this with people wanting to blame current priests for the sins of a few.
>>64703024 many of them either turned a blind eye or even covered it up, no one in ireland trusts the catholic church as much as they used to i rarely meet people who openly say they're christian or that they go to church.
it's quite understandable from that guys perspective that he hates the priests much like how /pol/ hates muslims for their high rate of crime.
>>64703358 you can always ignore the organised religions and study the bible and pray in the privacy of your own home. Jesus even says its better that way: "But when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father, who is unseen. Then your Father, who sees what is done in secret, will reward you."
>>64702446 You just explained in your post quite literally why Catholicism is a farce. There's no emphasis on living a pious day to day life. No emphasis on on being part of a community where the other members can serve to keep each in other in line.
Yes, the song & dance is to attract nonbelievers and create a fun atmosphere for churchgoers to stay. If you listen through the sermon though, then you realize that there's actual messages and life lessons be given.
I'm not even a believer. I just think Catholics, despite their stance on certain issues, are the bigger degenerates.
>>64703024 In my country the catholics get a bad wrap because of the greediness, pushing retrograde ideals and overall power hunger of their church and how the supposed secularism is a joke, having several "deals" that heavily benefit the church in detriment of non catholic people.
But hey, that's just my view on it I guess. I can only imagine Ireland is similar.
>>64703616 Catholicism is a deep tradition that contains elements that pre-date Christianity as a whole. It's a codified ancestral memory. Protestantism of all kinds is a cult for Americans and englishmen that demands varying degrees of tacky commitments ranging from the benign and boring (movie nights) to the outright crazy (snake handling and shit). Protestantism is literally either for crazy people or idiots.
>>64701363 The first two times I thought the ending where the priest was killed was kinda forced. Most people who saw the film didn't really understand why the priest even decided to stay at his home and then go to the beach. But I think that's kinda the point. The priest is obviously supposed to be a Jesus figure. Christians still don't know exactly why Jesus had to let himself die to forgive our sins. There's theories about it, but no one can claim to know for sure. So I think that's what the film was getting at.
>>64702059 >John 20: > 21Again Jesus said, “Peace be with you! As the Father has sent me, I am sending you.” 22And with that he breathed on them and said, “Receive the Holy Spirit. 23If you forgive anyone’s sins, their sins are forgiven; if you do not forgive them, they are not forgiven.”
Jesus was the first one to decide that disciples/priests were needed to forgive sins.
I don't think it was (or was meant to be) either for or against Catholicism. I should go back and watch it though, because I find myself struggling to find something to say about it other than that it was great.
>>64702059 It's not just Catholics. It was pretty much every Christian from apostolic times to the 1500s when Protestants decided that confession wasn't needed. Catholics and Orthodox (who make up about 70% of Christians today) believe in confession.
Christianity isn't just the Bible, you also have to pay attention to the church fathers and the ecumenical councils that came afterwards. Scripture is extremely important, but it's only a part of a greater tradition going back to the apostles.
>>64704667 I like how a catholic apologist is calling protestantism more batshit when you guys pray to like 9000 saints and icons, perform retarded rituals: starting infanthood throughout adult life, are literally taught to believe you're eating the body and drinking the blood of christ, and invest undue power and influence into men wearing black and white robes (whom have a propensity to pedophilia).
There are batshit sects in protestantism but I'd rather be in one of the moderate ones than be apart of catholicsm.
>>64706757 Atheists can't appreciate anything spiritual... Or at least they can't correctly interpret any art that has spiritual or philosophical themes.
Try reading some interpretations of Bergman films. Bergman did become an atheist eventually, but his earlier films had a much more agnostic stance. However, atheists assume that all his films are saying "God doesn't exist", when a lot of his earlier films are solely saying we can't know for sure.
>>64706825 All I know is that if you seriously ask this question to a catholic clergyman, they usually evade the question. I commend you for giving me some ecclesiastical psuedo-philosophical dribble for an answer though.
>>64706825 >1333 At the heart of the Eucharistic celebration are the bread and wine that, by the words of Christ and the invocation of the Holy Spirit, become Christ's Body and Blood. >1413 By the consecration the transubstantiation of the bread and wine into the Body and Blood of Christ is brought about. Under the consecrated species of bread and wine Christ himself, living and glorious, is present in a true, real, and substantial manner: his Body and his Blood, with his soul and his divinity (cf. Council of Trent: DS 1640; 1651).
>>64707379 Yeah, but I don't want to throw my hat in with the fedoras. New Atheism is an embarrassment. Plus, you can meet girls at churches. I'm currently looking for a church actually. I'm gonna hit up exactly those churches, maybe one of those nondenominational churches that play rock music geared for teenagers -- I bet there's a ton of pussy there.
>>64707291 Not really. All of the churches that can trace their lineage to Apostolic times (Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, Oriental Orthodox, etc.) which make up most of the Christian population believe that the bread and wine literally become the body and blood of Christ. That is what all Christian churches believe until the reformation.
Within Protestantism there are a million sects and interpretations, but imo there's a bigger disconnect between a lot of Protestant churches and what Christianity historically is.
>>64702059 >Why do catholics believe they have to talk to god through some priest? the bible never mentions that one person is above another when it comes to speaking to god.
Talking to God is called colloquy and it is common practice in the Catholic Church. The priest is not there to pass on a message you would like delivered to God. Here are the two main reasons why the priest is there:
1. Offer sacrifice. This is the main duty of the priesthood in every religion, to offer sacrifice to God. The Scriptures say that without the offering of blood, there is no forgiveness of sins. Just as in the Old Testament there was a priesthood that offered animal sacrifice to God, so in the New Testament the Catholic priesthood offers the sacrifice of Jesus Christ on the altar at Mass. The Protestants don't believe in the sacrifice of the Mass which is the main reason that they don't have a priesthood, and why imo they don't even deserve to be called a religion.
2. Pastor. To catechise (teach about religion) the people, to teach them about spiritual matters, to help settle disputes in the community. Not everyone has the time to read the Scriptures and study theology. We need people who dedicate their lives solely to this to serve as shepherds of the flock.
I have only mentioned 1 of the 7 sacraments (the Eucharist, which is the sacrament of Mass where the body, blood, soul, and divinity of Jesus Christ is made really/truly present on the altar). The other sacraments include: Penance (Confession), Matrimony, Holy Orders (passing on the priesthood), Baptism, Confirmation, Anointing of the Sick (for people who are dying).
And there is way more to it than that. The Protestants don't really have the Church. They don't have apostolic succession (the passing down of the priesthood from the apostles).
>>64707450 You're gonna be disappointed anon. Unless you're in Texas or something where everyone goes to a church like that. If you're just trying to get into some slit you really should go to catholic church. Catholics can do all the nasty pre-marital stuff they want and jsut confess about it later
>>64707337 >Disobeying your own holy book "2 Timothy 2:24-26 And the Lord's servant must not be quarrelsome but kind to everyone, able to teach, patiently enduring evil, correcting his opponents with gentleness."
>>64707925 Yeah they want you to but so what? They also want you to never masturbate but Catholics are sensible enough to know that nobody is really gonna live like that. Protestants on the other hand have virginity-preserving ceremonies where they marry their fathers temporarily and wear a special ring until they get married to somebody else.
>>64705787 ROI is a great place to live. It's more progressive besides the abortion thing than the Northern Ireland is. I was racially attacked by loyalists numerous times in NI and I knew they were loyalists because I lived in a loyalist neighbourhood without knowing what they were like, I'm Nigerian btw.
>>64701363 okay. so I watched this last night, and woke up this morning thinking about it.
In all a good movie. Thought provoking if not perfect. We should have more like this
Good bits: + Argues the function of the priest, like Christ, is to allow people to shit all over him. To exercise their own demons onto him. + Loved the scenes with the priest and his altar boy. Sharp dialog but with great warmth. Needed more. Kid can't act tho. + It's unflinching. Doesn't shy away from any taboo. + Not fedoracore. You either know what this means or you don't. + CIA. Hell, great performances in general. Except the old American writer who was shit. + Some very unexpected humor. "Chicks with Dicks." CIA taking the karate pose. Good shit.
Bad bits: - Everyone is too fucking eloquent. I know irish are supposed to have "Gift of the Gab" but this is too far. The gunman at the end was the worst case. "No, father. this cynicism is HARD WON." - I know it's a movie, but the extent of the debauchery in this tiny town is just hard for me to believe. Honestly you'd be hard pressed to find this among 6 people in San Francisco. - Serial killer scene OUT OF FUCKING NOWHERE. EDGY!
in all, i'll give it 9/10 for not being completely jewified.
>>64702446 Protestants are still obliged to confess to people at their group therapy sessions.
The essential difference is that Protestants see everyone as essentially alike, or potentially alike, provided that they live by mechanical rules and lack a certain amount of imagination.
Outside of the mechanism of science, many can't quite conceive of an aristocracy, or even a group of people who have read more serious books than they have. For example; someone who is more talented because they're attuned differently.
In much the same way that the Spartans were obliged to call every other Spartan their 'similar', there's a very long tradition of this behaviour among the Vikingers. Yet these groups were often deeply undervalued within Catholic aristocracies, so there's an element of truth to the Protestant position.
>>64701743 Catholics are hardly real Christians. You're essentially "Checklist Christians". You go to church every Sunday and fill out a required ritualistic checklist of Catholic duties, but you don't actually worship God or follow the teachings of Christ which means you're not really Christians. You just do the bare minimum required to label yourself as a "Christian". Any atheist could do what you do.
>>64713766 No, I'm accurately describing most Catholics. It's exactly why the Christian community has an easier time respecting Protestants. It's because Protestants tend to actually carry Christ with them in their everyday lives.
>>64702774 Maybe she was, but for me, the only one who truly wished to repent and get himself closer to God was the rich man. He stumbled, yes, but he was willing to get back up on the horse so to speak.
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the shown content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows their content, archived. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content, then use the post's [Report] link! If a post is not removed within 24h contact me at firstname.lastname@example.org with the post's information.