>>64497398 this this is such a god damned hard choice overall though hobbit > prequels. There's at least 2 solid good hours of Hobbit even though BOFA is infinitely worse than even the prequels >>64497502 I agree, sans BOFA
>>64497522 This appears to be the consensus on /tv/ and I don't get it. I thought AUJ and BOFA were both decent. DoS was the one that I fucking hated. It was so long, the 30-min action scene at the end sucked ass, and gandalf's subplot was unbelievably boring.
>>64497986 >It was so long, the 30-min action scene at the end sucked ass, and gandalf's subplot was unbelievably boring. exactly how I felt about it too, but apart from that garbage everything else was ok BOFA was just that horrid ending action and Gandalfs shitty subplot but for 3 hours
>>64497370 BOTFA is only "bad" in that it's just one big long battle scene where nothing really happens and what should've been the final climax to the second Hobbit movie was painfully stretched out to feature length. So it's better than AOTA, which I may add is actually my favorite prequel movie.
>>64497370 I remember feeling more upset about the third hobbit than I was about attack of the clones. The friends I went to the theatre with actually like the third hobbit movie. I just silently judged them.
>>64498235 I recently watched a Hobbit fanedit condensing the three movies into one and it had like a whole fucking hour of BOFA. It was so dreadful all I want it >AUJ with the orcs cut out and saruman subplot cut our >DOS with the end action scene, romance, and gandalf subplot removed >literally 20 mins max of BOFA to tie up the plot
I dont understand why they named it the Battle of the five Armies. All it did was build up this huge epic battle that didnt have near as much at stake as any of the lotr battles. Then it couldn't even deliver. The Hobbit: There and Back Again would have been a nice name and it wouldn't have gotten everybody's attention focused on a huge fucking battle. I still liked it more than the full green-screen shit that was episode 2
DOS: Remove romance, cut the barrel scene to them just escaping and none of that terrible action nonsense. Skip or heavily condense the gold melting scene, transition straight to the town battle. Skip to end of Battle of the Five Armies. Boom.
>>64498553 >Why? Because PB is superior to BD in gore effects and other little tweaks not gonna lie I didn't mind the barrel scene. I took it as fun kiddie schlock and thought it was OK. Felt the same way about it as I did the dwarves fighting their way out of Moria. It was interesting to me at least >Skip ... the gold melting scene, transition straight to the town battle. Skip to end of Battle of the Five Armies. Boom. the fanedit I saw dealt with the drama and bullshit of Thorin not wanting to pay his debts and the plot of how he got to dual the shitty cgi orc and die on the lake wondering how you could make that transition without the convoluted and retarded plot
Probably Attack of the Clones. But they are both the worst movies in their franchises. The only thing that really puts the hobbit on top is that it doesn't have that fucking awful romance and the CGI is better.
>>64497370 I was so disapointed with the Hobbit. The scene with Smaug was perfect, exactly like I envisioned when my dad read me the book as a kid. Peter Jackson did not need to alter one fucking thing from that book, the battle of five armies was a disgrace to all movies based off books.
I tried watching AotC today and it was painful how bored I was by the end. I was groaning at the TV begging for it to be over, and this is during the Battle of Geonosis so I should've been excited. It had completely crushed my spirit.
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the shown content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows their content, archived. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content, then use the post's [Report] link! If a post is not removed within 24h contact me at email@example.com with the post's information.