[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Home]
4Archive logo
What's the fastest you've ever...
If images are not shown try to refresh the page. If you like this website, please disable any AdBlock software!

You are currently reading a thread in /tg/ - Traditional Games

Thread replies: 239
Thread images: 30
File: hmm.jpg (17 KB, 408x286) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
hmm.jpg
17 KB, 408x286
What's the fastest you've ever rejected a character, /tg/?

Mine was right from seeing the guy's name.


>Obiwancanblowme.
>>
This reminds me of my best-worst Star Wars name.
A pink-skinned calamari with thin blue mottling named:
>Scrotal Testicus
>>
>Hottpantspalpatine
>Butt saggius

I feel like I shouldn't have bothered playing with these people in the first place.
>>
I'm still surprised my character wasn't rejected.

The more you read about him the worse he gets, but at least he had a character arc unlike half the characters in that campaign.
>>
File: russeconnard.jpg (64 KB, 750x562) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
russeconnard.jpg
64 KB, 750x562
>>44618915
Jrongzinjanzuzin, a skeletal assassin.

>MFW when the guy could pronouce it
>>
>>44621024
I'd guess something like "Juh-rong-zin-jan-zoo-zin". I'd also have given him the nickname Wrong, which would've been the only thing anyone ever referred to him as.
>>
I tried to name my monk Namtab one time.
>>
>>44618915
>>44620829
>tfw using gender neutral fictional names instead of nicks
It's very pleasant. Easy to pronounce in voice games and it keeps people at just the right distance in text.
>>
>>44621346
That's a kinda common joke, knew a guy in WOW while I still played that had two alts named Namtab and Namredips.
>>
>>44618915
"So, my character is a gnome" <-- there
>>
>"My character's alignment is [Any] Evil"
>>
>>44622030
>"My character's alignment..."
in a GURPS game.
>>
Character name starts with small letter.
>>
>>44618915

I don't let elves in my campaigns.
>>
>>44623804
So?
A dnd babby trying to test out another system telling you in the only way he knows about his character.

Clearly an overreaction over tying your character to simpler explanations.
>>
>lol can I play a bear with disguise?
>>
>playing unknown armies
>"I wanna be a pornomanc-"
>"No."

I've played UA for years and there's not a single person who plays that adept type for non creepy purposes.
>>
File: 67677787.png (124 KB, 292x299) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
67677787.png
124 KB, 292x299
>Playing a pathfinder game
>The brother of one of my female players wanted to join in
>sure.jpg
>see his character sheet
>it's a jester type character named, and I kid you not, ''Ronald McFondle''
>>
>>44621860
You sound like my DM
>>
His character's name was Alucard and he was an amnesiac assassin.
>>
>>44623889
Fuck.
>>44623925
How does he remember the target?
>>
>the "lore" references 800 instances of custom vocabulary you'd have to learn via a half day conference
>you can't add any of your own
>>
>>44623935
He probs rolls the dice every time he meets someone new; they might just be the one he was sent to murder.
>>
"Full stop. Your character, your next character, and your backup-backup all belong in the trash. Drop them all. I will listen to your ideas now."
>>
File: stalker2.jpg (84 KB, 640x480) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
stalker2.jpg
84 KB, 640x480
>>44623935
PDAs, son.
>>
File: Sensible Chuckle.gif (27 KB, 250x250) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Sensible Chuckle.gif
27 KB, 250x250
>>44623889
Okay that's pretty funny.
>>
>>44618915
I once let a player play a character named Team Fortress II. He was a Red Mantis Assassin, and the guy just didn't feel like coming up with a name.

It turned out to be a great character, and we rolled with it, the excuse being that nobody really knew his name in the party, they just called him "The Mantis."

But whenever he met his superiors, they would call him by his name and I'd have to fucking say it.

"Team Fortress Two, according to this report... You were seen engaging in a... "dance off," with four members of the Order of the Nail. Do you understand how important subtlety is to our affairs in Korvosa? YOU HAVE COMPROMISED OUR ENTIRE OPERATION."

Those were the days.
>>
File: 1437039060717.jpg (28 KB, 280x280) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1437039060717.jpg
28 KB, 280x280
>>44618915
>my character worships a homebrew deity named Lilium
>>
>>44624583
>I once let a player play a character named Team Fortress II.
>Team Fortress Two
Would II make him Team Fortress the Second?
>>
>>44625625
Yes, son of the former lord of the dance, Tệm Fortreŝ
>>
File: revenant.jpg (271 KB, 768x1024) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
revenant.jpg
271 KB, 768x1024
>>44621024
skeletal assassins are cool
>>
>>44618915
>my character doesn't speak common
>he only speaks X language (that nobody else in the party speaks)
nope.
>>
>Friend is DMing for the first time, using 5e, nice and simple, he's pretty excited and prepared
>Invited a few people he sort-of-knew at the time to fill out the party
>One new person is a girl, says she's played D&D before
>We all make characters, start the session by having our characters be introduced to each other (tavern setting etc.)
>Her character introduces herself as Cuntress
>Entire table skips a beat

It was an interesting session.
>>
>>44625904
Had a character idea of a goblin who knew goblin, but found it beneath him to speak it, but at least made sure that someone else spoke it as well, unfortunately that game fell through.
>>
>>44623891
Sounds like a good DM.
>>
>>44626319

I once DMed a game where a telepathic character considered it beneath him to speak at all. When he couldn't do mind to mind contact, he had a slave to act as "Speaker", who would parrot off what he was transmitting to him.

Character had a bit of a breakdown when his speaker was killed in an ambush. Good times, good times.
>>
File: R2-D2_41dacaa9.jpg (78 KB, 768x432) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
R2-D2_41dacaa9.jpg
78 KB, 768x432
>>44625904
>>my character doesn't speak common
>>he only speaks X language (that nobody else in the party speaks)
>>
>>44625771
You could consider his one-of-a-kind dance moves a sort of Tệm Fortreŝ classic.
>>
>>44626535
>That nobody else in the party speaks
>C3PO
>Equating movies to p&p game sessions

Consider me b8ed mister fisherman
>>
>>44626535
a bunch of people understand him, they just cant speak it in return. and he understands them, which is the main point.
also, like >>44626564
said, C3PO
>>
File: darths0992.jpg (227 KB, 600x800) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
darths0992.jpg
227 KB, 600x800
>>44626564
>>That nobody else in the party speaks
>>C3PO
Not always together, but fair point.

>>Equating movies to p&p game sessions
A character is a character.

>Consider me b8ed mister fisherman
It was a cheap joke that fell apart under a moment of scrutiny.
Party on, anon.
>>
>>44626673
Luke speaks binary too, tho. Well, he understands it.
>>
File: Wall-e.jpg.jpg (362 KB, 1280x1199) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Wall-e.jpg.jpg
362 KB, 1280x1199
>>44626702
>>44626601
>>44626564
As I said, it was just a cheap joke.
Also, I picked the wrong droid.
>>
>>44622030
No love for Lawful Evil? It makes more sense the Chaotic Neutral.
>>
>>44626294
Storytime.
>>
>>44623951
>discovers a random hobo is his target and kills him
>"So Alucard, why were you hired to kill him?"
"....I don't remember."
>"Oh..who hired you."
"Uh....."

>Alucard now rolls anytime he meets someone new to see if they were the client.
>>
File: MixedAlignmentsLE.png (87 KB, 404x385) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
MixedAlignmentsLE.png
87 KB, 404x385
>>44626904
I love me some Lawful Evil.
My second most successful character was LE.
>>
Christmas of 2014, back in my hometown running a oneshot with my old DnD group, one of them makes a dwarf rogue.

>Names the character Fuckface McMurderstab

Told him to re-roll or at least rename the character, so he ended up calling him Don Trumpet instead.
>>
>>44626673
Is this the same person who did that Lord of the Rings comic? If so, sauce?
>>
>>44626994
Darths and Droids, it says it right in the top-right corner.
>>
>>44627043
Welp. I feel stupid.
>>
>>44627043
This
>>44626994
Also, it was partially inspired by the Lord of the Rings one, but not done by the same people.
They started with Phantom Menace and are into Return of the Jedi now.
It's very good for what it is.
>>
>"I made this half-orc monk who specializes in grappling and is a masked wrestler with a shark motif-"
>"Los Tiburon?"
>"..."
>"I browse /tg/ too. Can you make something else?"
This actually happened. I ended up letting him play it, but it turns out to be an extremely boring gimmick to actually use in combat.
>"What do you do?"
>"Uh, I guess I... grapple. Again."
>>
>>44623889
Not my fucking tempo.
>>
>>44625881
room temperature, actually
>>
>>44626294
>>44626970
Yes, please.
>>
>>44627099
>I ended up letting him play it, but it turns out to be an extremely boring gimmick to actually use in combat.

This is how all gimmick characters end up panning out, and why people who describe their character primarily in terms of capabilities and powers as opposed to personality traits and goals are always a massive red flag for me.
>>
>>44627153
heh
>>
>>44623889
Keep Abortion awesome!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=74Bk01X67LM
>>
>>44627099
That's just D&D tho.
>Uh, I guess I... hit it with my sword. Again.
>Uh, I guess I... throw a fireball. Again.
>Uh, I guess I... fire an arrow. Again.
>>
>>44627551
Well, unless you play 4e.

>Uh, I guess I... throw a fireball. Again.
Isn't even true in 3.5 tho.
>>
>I want to play a wizard in dnd (any edition)

Only power gamers do this.
>>
>>44627551
>That's just D&D tho.
>That's just boring players though.
FTFY

Seriously, any game or activity can be reduced to that.
>Uh, I guess I... [action]. Again.

Draw a card.
Throw a ball.
Move a playing piece.

You are being silly.
>>
>>44627643
>4e

Opinion instantly disproven
>>
File: Jrongzinjanzuzin.png (43 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Jrongzinjanzuzin.png
43 KB, 1920x1080
>>44621024
>Jrongzinjanzuzin
I was going to guess that was foreign for something, but google is only taking me back to this thread.
>>
>>44627764
Wizards are still pretty much the best in the game at being a controller, so the argument could be made that its a power gamer type of choice.
>>
>>44628022
Wand wizards.
>>
>>44627761
My nigga.

I always make sure to spice up anything my characters does with some vivid description. If I'm DMing and the players don't give me shit to work with, I describe it in full detail.

They love it when I DM.
>>
>>44627551
That's the point where you go, "How do you swing your sword?" or you describe how the fireball flies from his fingers to incinerate the enemy, or where the arrow hits, or something like that.

Most boring weapon to fight with is a rapier, because all you can do is thrust. Thrust thrust thrust. Fitting for a bard, but boring, especially when the other guy is using something like a mace or a broadsword.
>>
>>44626993
The character could've turned out to be a nice guy, you know.
>>
>He's a famous dragonslayer
>level 2 paladin
No, Fuck off.
>>
>>44618915
>Jedi Master Bates
>>
>>44628721
During that one session :
>The dwarf formerly known as McMurderstab chockes a prostitute and tries to blame it on the fat merchant he was sharing her with.
> Fat merchant dosen't want to take the blame so the dwarf formerly known as McMurderstab punches the merchant to death with his bare hands.
> Brothel security comes storming in because of the ruckus, the dwarf formerly known as McMurderstab grabs the merchant's moneypouch and jumps out the window, without any of his own gear - including all his clothes - and face-plants into the street six floors below.
>>
Guy complained about his ranger not being as useful as the druid even when he minmaxed the shit out of it with 2hd weapon, power attack and cleave, he also wanted me to through at him his favoured enemies at least once every 5 games, I had enough of his bullshit so I kicked him. PF btw.
>>
File: bait.png (85 KB, 200x200) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
bait.png
85 KB, 200x200
>>44629285
>>
>>44627551
No that's just shit players

I've played with people like this and I've played with amazing roleplayers who get really into the game, both in d&d. Just depends on the person
>>
>>44629285
What were his favored enemies?
>>
>>44628440
Rapiers do have an edge, you know. Sport fencing can give the wrong impression.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SVaslN1NiT0
>>
>>44629557
not that anon but im gonna guess goblinoids of some kind for easy XP or some other shit

If i were playing a ranger, I'd play an Orc Ranger with preferred enemy Humans because for RULE OF NATURE and also humans tend to be the most dirty fuckers around when it comes to sanitation and I'd be going around "I know how you think and I don't like it you filthy human scum"
I would make him drop his spaghetti to halfling woman though
>>
>>44629685
>goblinoids of some kind for easy XP or some other shit

The fuck is that even supposed to mean? Either they're challenging enough for XP or they aren't, creature type doesn't enter into it.
>>
>>44629557
I dunno, I think animals, undead and evil outsiders, like I care, he thought I was going to give him free bonuses? nope.
>>
File: bait of babylon.jpg (69 KB, 625x626) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
bait of babylon.jpg
69 KB, 625x626
>>44629815
>>
>>44629771
generic goblins are easy to kill in D&D, so its easy XP
>>
>>44629815
>Hey, I'm the Cleric. Is there anyone for me to heal?
>Nope, like I'm going to give you free bonuses.
>Hey, I'm the bard, is there an inn in this city where I can perform?
>Like I'd give you the free bonuses.
>Hey, I'm the paladin - who do I smite?
>No one, I'm not going to give you any free bonuses.
>>
>Litra Leehu
>>
>>44629846
>>44629915
>giving him +4 or +6 to attack and damage to absolutely anything
No, fuck you
>>
File: bait3.png (136 KB, 622x626) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
bait3.png
136 KB, 622x626
>>44630006
>Fishing this hard for a D&D martials argument.
You're not fooling anyone except for this guy >>44629915
>>
File: Sensible chuckle.gif (993 KB, 250x250) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Sensible chuckle.gif
993 KB, 250x250
>>44624202
>>
>>44630006
man, the entire point of rangers is that they're dedicated to preventing a particular destructive force from despoiling the land and terrorizing innocents. Their entire training is dedicated to tracking and eliminating one brand of monster. A small bonus on attacks and damage against a small set of potential enemies is hardly game breaking. They're like fantasy Judge Dredd.

I hope you brutally restrict the wizard spell availability then, to keep things fair. Wanna learn a new spell? No free bonuses; better find the lost spellbook buried somewhere in the swamp.
>>
>>44626971
>"There are two types of people in this world..."
>"Clients and targets."
>>
>>44621024
>>44627806
I'm no native speaker and even to me this is perfectly pronounceable.
/dʒɹɒŋ.zJn.dʒæn.zu'zJn/
>>
>>44630226

Vocaroo or fuck off Poindexter
>>
>>44626987
>>44626904
I'm trying to make a lawful evil character right now.

How do you run them with out creating too much friction?
>>
>>44618915
"Ever played Final Fantasy 13?"
>>
>>44630344
Take your pencil. Erase the E. Add a G. Done.
>>
>>44618915
I have never actually rejected a character. I try to make sure I'm at least minorly involved in character creation, to steer away from anything egregiously unreasonable, you know, keep everybody on the same powerlevel more or less, keep everything explainable within the fiction. But typically, I find letting the player experience the consequences of actually being their dreamt up special snowflake to be more than punishment enough. They learn quick enough. I broke a freeformer of his faggotry.

>>44620839
I've actually been in that boat.
>>
>>44630226
gesundheit
>>
>>44623951
just keep checking your dossier. We had an incredibly near-sighted ninja/assassin type in one.

He had a tendency of incapacitating/kidnapping random suspects, squinting at them, then a photo, then back at them, and then apologizing, freeing them and making a batman disappearance.

He was ludicrously powerful, and abnormally stealthy for someone of such gorilla proportions, so if you were is target, heaven help you. But most of the time, he had the wrong guy and ended up letting them go.


I'd imagine an amnesiac would work similarly.
>>
>>44625516
>my character worships a homebrew deity named "player name"
FTFY.
>>
>>44625904
My character is a blind deafmute who communicates through telepathy

(actual character I've had to deal with. why it wasn't rejected I don't know.)
>>
>>44626535
droid is a common language, many spacefarer's understand it. its just no organics speak it.
>>
>Pathfinder
>Dude submits a lucario monk named chiggles
>Pokemon don't even exist in this setting.
WTF?
>>
>>44625904
Just enforce it. They are required to speak gibberish at all times at the table. They'll ask for a new character soon enough.
>>
>>44630742
Yoy wouldn't believe how many people try the race builder thing and insist it's a balanced thing in a setting where you are being cleat that it's not being used.
>>
>>44626844
but it speaks actual english.

"*points to self* Waaaaaaa~leeee"
"EVA!"
"Plant!"
>>
>>44626971
Plausible deniability man. No trail. Perfect anonymity. That's a feature, not a bug.
>>
>>44630433
Lawful Gvil?
>>
>>44631051
LG
>>
>>44630957
You are my hero.

Not for your argument, but for typoing 'yoy'. It's such a rare and hilarious typo that I can't help but commend you.
>>
>>44630102
I actually do this.
But with costly components, not learning the spells themselves.

I mean, where in a bunch of peasants are you gonna find 30,000 in onyx, fashioned into a headband? Sounds like quest material to me.
>>
>>44631067
but LG cause even more friction than LE!
>>
>>44632865
Yes. But you never hear people say "You can play a good aligned character if you do it right". Evil aligned characters just generally cause more problems than they solve.
>>
>>44632439
>Not Whatever_floats_your_stoat.jpg
You had one job.
>>
>>44629815
>free bonuses
How are they free? The entire character is based on them. That's like saying a wizard shouldn't have spells because they are free bonuses.
>>
>my PC doesn't worship any god
>>
>>44632891
I have....
Only to people who repeatedly paladin badly, but still.

I guess that's it. its just most of the people who end up playing evils are edgelords, not people who want to play it right.
where as LG, its just dealt with on a case by case basis, because it has fewer edgelords.

really what we need to do is just ban edgelords.
>>
>>44634611
What's wrong with that?
No socrateses?
>>
>>44629194
That was an actual person in the EU though.
>>
>>44618915
First sentence of his character summary
>Atheist Tech-Priestess
>>
>>44635091
Like Major Major, or Private Parts
>>
>>44618915
>half-dragon
This was in 3.5 before dragonborns were a thing, but just noped that along with the players follow up choices of Yanti, Drow, and Psionic. He knew very well I wasn't allowing monster races with a level adjustment above 1. Oddly enough he refused my suggestions of lizardfolk, kobold, tiefling, and aasmire.
>>
>>44626485
>He was secretly in love with his speaker, and they used to teleflirt all the time.
>>
File: Kronk.gif (492 KB, 500x313) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Kronk.gif
492 KB, 500x313
>>44629285
Idk man, I think it's reasonable for someone to want to fight their favored enemy. It's literally their favored enemy. It's the enemy of theirs that they favor fighting the most.
>>
>>44636481
Part of why it's important to know what kind of campaign is going to be run, and get an idea of what sort of enemies you think you'll be fighting.
>>
>>44625904
Reminds me of how it went down in a Star Wars game I play.
>take a droid character, droids are cool.
>Realize too late that I only have Binary as a language
>Ask people if this is going to be a problem
>Other player tells me it's fine, his character can understand Binary and will translate for me.
>The first time my character comes up with a good plan my translator relays it to the rest of the party and then claims it as his own.
>From then on whenever I come up with any good ideas the translator PC just tells the party they were his ideas while I beep and whirr furiously in the background.
>>
>>44621024
Sounds like pandarunes
>>
>>44636520
this is a legitimate representation of the source fiction.
I could see that very gag being pulled in-universe.
>>
>>44630651
I can actually see this working just fine.
My paladin represents my will in two ways.
I dig.
>>
>>44636520
That's actually pretty funny.
>>
>>44636582
>>44636746

Yeah I actually love it, it's a good joke. The game isn't very serious either, we're just a bunch of wandering Space Assholes. Mercenary criminal scum from the Republic pre-prequel era that got accidentally frozen in carbonite halfway through our first mission and were only dethawed 100 years later in the vague 'After ROTJ but before Force Awakens' era.
Now we're wandering around the new galaxy trying to figure out how to claim over a century's worth of back-pay.
>>
>>44630765

No they won't. Stop being a passive aggressive bitch of a GM and just deny the character.
>>
>>44634611
I'm okay with this.

What I'm not okay with is

>I'm an atheist cleric

No I don't care what the fluff says; there are no clerics of abstract concepts in my setting. Pick a god or pick a different class.
>>
>race:kender
>>
>>44630344
> I'm trying to make a lawful evil character right now.
> How do you run them with out creating too much friction?

Easy:

1. Don't be the leader. THIS IS IMPORTANT.
2. Find a "Loyal" reason to follow him blindly. Something you can't ditch. Vassalage, Life Debt, Oath, Religious Edict...
3. Suggest easy, expedite, violent methods when allowed by the rule of law (exemple: take no prisoners if target wanted dead or alive, Self-Defense with lethal attacks).
4. Suggest others do things for their self-interests.
5. Never make evil actions unless allowed/alone. Never make chaotic actions (that would destabilize government) unless specifically ordered, and even then with reluctance.

Enjoy!
>>
>>44636856
its a thing in ebereron.
and 5e paladins technically get their powers from "their oath to the spirit of justice" rather than a god.
sooooooo
>>
>>44637281
and make sure to make devil's deals.
think like a Blackmana planeswalker.
>>
>>44637281
Yea, I find that lawful evil is a fine alignment if done right. I played a LE dwarf wizard who was basically Donald Trump once.
>>
>>44637394
Did you use a bunch of wall spells?
>>
>>44637288

You are missing the keywords.

> there are no clerics of abstract concepts in my setting.
>>
>>44621024
The moment my character hears that, I tell him, 'Yeah... I'm calling you Skully.'
>>
>>44621334
I was thinking it'd have more of a nederlandish phonetic about it
>Ear-Rone-sihn-yahn-susan
>>
>>44629857
Or you could kill one vampire and get the same XP a few hundred goblins would give you.
>>
>>44637394
Impossible. Donald Trump is Chaotic Good.
>>
File: 5867587685767.jpg (50 KB, 500x334) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
5867587685767.jpg
50 KB, 500x334
This sheet was seriously put in front of our DM
>Name Elrich Vin'haldel
>Race: High elf
>Samurai class (Ronin)
>On a quest to find the man who killed his father and discover the demon blood that he was born with when his father made a deal with the devil
>wears a white cloak and a samurai helmet
>when taken off he shows his demon face

Our DM read the name and said ''No, roll a different character''
>>
>>44627099

You just gotta add more flair to it. If you're just saying "i..uh...grapple" you're obviously doing it wrong.

The player I like the most in our group is the one who acts like a cheesy anime fight all the time, naming his sword attacks in game (even if it doesn't always work out like he wants).
>>
>>44638203
What's wrong with the name? It's an Elf. They all have kind of dumb names. Even the cool ones.
>>
>>44618915
Didn't even get a name
>here's my character
>it has a specific combination of items and abilities that lets it instantly kill anything that I hope you don't recognize on sight
I recognized that shit immediately because I used it motherfucker.
>>
>>44618915
>race: kender
>>
>>44638284
I'm intrigued.
It wasn't a bag of rats was it?
>>
>>44638327
At that point I would throw them out of the house.
>>
>>44622030

Whenever my group already has a paladin, pretty much this.

On the other hand if there's already evil in the group I don't usually let a new player join with a paladin.


Might work for one shots with a good enough reason but there would be no way to make them work together for any appreciable length of time without trying to kill each other.
>>
>>44637288
That can happen for paladins in 3.5e too. It's not exactly new. But it happening for a cleric is a bit idiotic, because it misses the point of their character.
>>
>>44618915
Nigga I'd never reject that character and I think you're an asshole.

I'd reject that player though. I get it if you're here for fun and all but I want some seriousness from the outset and if you ain't putting any effort in then I'm not and me not putting in effort means I'm not fukken running for you.
>>
>>44638959
>Yfw you can rearrange obiwankenobi into Ion Kebab Wino
>>
>>44638933
Is it? Whats the difference between a god and a sentient concept with magical powers, really?
>>
File: why god why.png (174 KB, 279x400) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
why god why.png
174 KB, 279x400
>>44639238
First off, would atheism be established as a sentient concept? Because it seems distinctly paradoxical to worship it, which a cleric would do - which is different from what a paladin would do, which is follow its tenants or some similar such ideal.

Secondly, it does depend on the setting - in 40k, the Chaos Gods technically are sentient blobs made from human emotions. But in something like D&D, gods are gods, not just concepts.

Also, how narrowly are we defining atheism? Is it 'a lack of belief in gods' or 'believes that there are no gods?' The former you could wriggle around as 'my character does not believe gods have the power to affect mortals,' which is a bit weird but if you could flip flop it into mortals taking power into their own hands, I might allow it for a cleric. The latter I would disallow if gods are considered to obviously exist in the setting, and even if I didn't disallow it (like in a setting where that's not clear) I wouldn't allow it for a cleric.
>>
>>44639458
http://forgottenrealms.wikia.com/wiki/Ur-priest
>>
>>44629113
Naw, you should've instead accepted the char, and then have a dragon land in on the village, snarling and rampaging, while the frightened people get behind him and plead him to slay the beast to save them. Like he did the last time. At level 2.
>>
>>44639458
>not believing in Atheismor, the self-refuting god
>>
2 characters i've made that were quickly rejected
>a sniper called kenny
>a merchant with a big nose
R8
>>
>>44639881
very random, anon, good work
>>
>>44639458
It doesn't matter if gods obviously exist in the setting if WIZARDS also obviously exist in the setting, because then I, the fantasy atheist, can always explain any miracle or divine appearance by saying "a wizard did it."

Hell, I could MEET a god face to face and could still reasonably accuse it of just being a 20th level adventurer who wants extra praise.
>>
>>44639947
That's just semantics. If a wizard can do anything then there's no point in making the distinction between him and a god.
>>
>>44634611
As long as they're not an atheist in a setting where gods clearly have an impact. A character I'm planning to play won't worship any gods either. He's a street urchin and basically figures that the gods don't give a shit about him so he doesn't worship any in particular, but acknowledges their existence.
>>
>>44639238
A god has his own agenda and plans. An ideal just goes like: "Just do good as best as you can"
Right?

There is no complexity to an ideal.
>>
>>44618915
I saw someone post a homebrew class on a dnd 5e thread recently and it was obviously a class based on the show RWBY and I immediately scrolled past the whole thing as soon as I realized what it was. Apparently is sucked horribly because the people started bashing that homebrew to death.
>>
>>44640293
That depends on how complex an ideal is.
>>
>>44640361
Can you give me an example? I'm not sure I follow.
>>
>>44640374
For example chivalry is a pretty complex ideal with different possible interpretations and things to focus on.
>>
>atheist cleric
>good necromancer
>paladin redeeming succubus
>gnomes
into le trash u go
>>
>>44640501
>>paladin redeeming succubus
So, is it a paladin that's trying to redeem a succubus? Or is it a succubus that wants to redeem a paladin? Is it a succubus paladin?

Speak plainly, anon.
>>
>>44640567
>So, is it a paladin that's trying to redeem a succubus?
correct
>>
>>44618915
Elan Sleazebaggano.
>>
>>44640587
Yeah, that's probably the dumbest one because it can technically happen in almost any game. At least a succubus paladin character can fit only into specific settings like planescape, where the bizarre is supposed to be the normal sometimes.
>>
File: kylo ren.gif (555 KB, 256x192) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
kylo ren.gif
555 KB, 256x192
>PC has the same name as a famous fictional character
>>
>>44638203
Knowing my players, if one of them put this in front of me I would either let it pass on sheer audacity, or let it pass because I know it's going to turn out to be a deconstruction or some ass-backwards shit.

Either way, we're having a conversation about backstory before the campaign starts.
>>
>>44627551
>Uh, I guess I... throw a fireball. Again.
>In D&D
If you're going to shit on a system at least learn how to play it. The one thing that D&D has going for it is the sheer amount of material to work with. If you use only a single spell out of hundreads of alternatives and complain that it's repetetive then you deserve to have a boring time.
>>
>>44640870
Hell, there's even easily-accessible metamagic feats that can make it so that even if your entire spell list is literally only "Fireball", you can still do a lot of shit to change the flavor or operation of that fireball.
>Sonicball
>Expanded Nonlethalball
>Maximized Coldball

You can make a really stupid Evoker with the elemental sub metamagic feats and the best Evocation/Abjuration spells from each level.
>Acid Arrows now are whatever element you want
>Even Nonlethal, the thing that almost nothing in the game is resistant to.
>A spell that ignores SR and offers no saving throw and deals consistent chip damage
>Any element you want.
And that's without getting into shit like Lightningbolt and Ice Storm.
>>
>>44640903
>Spell focus in evocation
>Any element I want
>1d6/Caster Level starting
>>
>>44640903
You can also do nice things to pump up the range, area, and damage, as well as the save DCs and change the typing. Burning Ray is probably always better than Ray Fireballs, though, even if they can't fall to hit.
>>
>>44626485
You ripped that idea from that really dumb episode of Star Trek when that deaf mute telepathic negotiator was trying to bang counsellor troi.
>>
>>44635110
>Atheist Heretek
FTFY
>>
>>44639118
Man, I hope I remember that next time I roll a Star Wars character.
>>
>>44640501
>le trash
Insert yourself immediately afterwards.
>>
>>44618915
>can I play a robot?
>no
>>
>>44642050
Depends on the setting, but what's wrong with that? I like robots.
>>
>>44639947
But gods exist. They're not just a concept in a person's mind, but something that definitely exists on their own plane, and you know they exist through their worshipers and the times they mess with reality.

It'd be like saying a wizard made trees or animals just try to convince you that other living things exist. Most gods would probably exist before the 20th level adventurers did (being not necessarily mortal), and would be more powerful than they could ever be.
>>
>>44645109
>Depends on the setting
I think that answers your question. Presumably, he doesn't normally run settings where a robot would fit in. That said, there are a great deal where they fit fine, including many fantasy settings, from Eberron to Slayers. Err, well, the point is there's a lot of them.
>>
>>44621860
>>44623891
you sound like my kind of guy
>>
>>44630626
I had a far too vivid image of this gorilla-like man squatting next to a terrified handcuffed individual as he silently examined them with a jeweler's precision as they tried not to piss themselves.
>>
>>44622030
There's literally nothing wrong with playing an evil character, even if the rest of the party is good.

As long as you dont think "evil" means "eats orphans for breakfast, kicks puppies for sport and just stabbed the town guard because it felt like the evil thing to do", there are plenty of ways for an evil character to work with a good party.

Well, assuming the party doesn't have a Paladin, anyway. But Paladins played like that are shit anyway, so it's not the evil guy's fault.
>>
File: 1362724023473.jpg (97 KB, 475x470) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1362724023473.jpg
97 KB, 475x470
>>44640677
>kylo ren.gif
>>
>>44628440
There's only so many ways I can describe a sword being swung and only so many times I can do it before it gets tedious, anon.
>>
>>44629265
It's how he would have wanted to go, I'm sure.
>>
>>44645637
The problem is that the vast majority of players go for the former instead of the latter interpretation, and will then piss and moan about how you're railroading them if they experience consequences for their actions from the NPCs, or how the other players are assholes and they're just playing their character if they experience consequences for their actions from the PCs.
>>
The fastest I've ever rejected a character was before I even looked at the character.

Got a message on roll d20 from 'Satan'. Immediate nope.
>>
File: edf.jpg (44 KB, 598x448) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
edf.jpg
44 KB, 598x448
I was going to run a fairly serious campaign of Pendragon when a guy showed up asking to play a white-haired Celtic warrior princess and used something like this as his character reference.
>>
>>44647789
Come on dude, I'm just so bored. The only people who want to play an RPG down here were all horrible players in their lifetimes. I was actually thinking I'd play a lawful neutral character, maybe make a parody of the servants of the big guy up there.
>>
>Fantasy setting
>Every fantasy and RPG cliche played straight
>New players joins, shows his pregenned character
>It's an alien
>Literally little grey man with a spaceship and a ray gun
>mfw ayy lmao in kitchen sink fantasy setting
>>
>>44645586
this would in fact be the correct vivid picture to have.
just add an Oni mask.
>>
>>44645736
nonsense. that's literally how Exalted runs.
and dungeon world for that matter, but nobody plays it because its few good ideas are mired in pretentious crock.
>>
File: 1413926847899.jpg (72 KB, 356x461) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1413926847899.jpg
72 KB, 356x461
>>44618915
>Obiwancanblowme
fucking lel
I would reject it, but I am still laughing.
>>
>>44622030

>"I want to play a Chaotic Evil Rogue! It'll be so FUN!"
>Not a system with alignment at all
>>
>>44640501
Can't necromancers be done as good? Wait wait, hear me out.
If you make the necromancer more of a spiritual/death counselor, and focus on witch doctoring more than skelebums, can't you create a good, or at least neutral, necromancer?
>>
>DJ Pocahantas

He was a Gnome Barbarian. Three years later, my girlfriend left me for that guy.
>>
>>44652939
good good necromancers are technically doable.

I have however yet to see a player do it right.
>>
>>44630963
Mostly he speaks proper names and my dog understands more english than Wall-E speaks.
Wall-E is a decent example of a character that works without speaking the language.
>>
>>44653022
Heartbreaking.
>>
>>44653227
Well, I mean, Pixar are masters of showing not telling. look at that montage in UP.
>>
>>44653300
Exactly.
>>
>>44637908
I'm Dutch as well but that's bullshit. Proper Dutch phonetic pronunciation would be
>Ju-Rong-Zin-Jahn-Zuzin
>>
>>44653404
dutch has non-y js?
>>
>>44621024
I keep expecting this to come out as a pun or clever phrase, if I could only pronounce it right.
>>
File: header.jpg (13 KB, 249x239) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
header.jpg
13 KB, 249x239
>>44623935
It can be done.
>>
>>44653445
yes, quite a few of them, actually. your is jouw, yes is ja, etc...
>>
>>44653445
English Y as in You == Dutch J
English "Aye" sound (or like Ayy) == Dutch Y or IJ
>>
>>44618915
>my character is a psychopath
>>
>>44653898
right.

so to an english speaker, this would sound like >>44653404
"You wrong zin john zuzan," yes?

"You wrong then, John Susan?"
>>
>>44640501
Are good necromancers truly that hard to do? I'm sure there's a good motivation out there for a non-evil person to want to be able to raise the dead.
>>
Goku
>>
>>44657440
the problem isn't the motivation. the problem is the players.

only certain kinds of players are attracted to playing necromancers. none of them are actually qualified to be good at being necromancers. they're either psychopathic pragmatists wanting skellies for the utility, or edgelords wanting to be edgelords.
>>
>>44657685
But the anon was just outright rejecting anyone that wants to play a good aligned necromancer despite it not being a stereotype or anything all that common really. I would think you'd have more trouble with the aforementioned edgelords than a Ned Flanders.
>>
>>44657825
>despite it not being a stereotype or anything all that common
Maybe anywhere that isn't /tg/, but it's the first thing that gets posted in necromancer threads on here.
>>
>>44657848
I would think because it's just something that breaks the mold, which /tg/ tends to like when done well.
>>
>>44657943
except it never is.

all of the wankery /tg/ loves, we love to fantasize about but cannot execute. that may even be the reason why we fantasize about it. it becomes a holy grail, some impossible goal to aspire to. its why everybody tries to come up with plans to beat the tarrasque severely underleveled, or convert a succubus to good despite evil literally being a part of her physical existence, which would have to rewrite itself completely, or play a well-reasoned, well-acted necromancer of good alignment.
>>
>>44645163
I'm now wondering how a solipsist illusionist gnome wizard would go over with my DM.
>>
>>44618915
The second I became aware of my character's existence I rejected him.
>character was me irl
>>
>>44629857
>>44638059
>not killing 30000 giant rats.
It's 2016 guys
>>
>>44659774
do it, but a campaign where that's true for ever player character.

everybody play themselves? everybody play you, and watch the hijinx ensue? I'll leave you to interpret it as you wish.
>>
>>44626904
>>44630344
I always think Lawful Evil fits nicely on mercs and blackguards and shit, contract workers that don't do shit unless they're getting paid and aren't afraid to turn on their employer when they aren't getting paid.
>>
>>44629265
Tall brothel.
>>
>>44659948
Everybody plays the person to their left.
>>
>>44660436
Lawful Neutral. Allows you to follow and adhere to your own code, such as doing stuff for money.
You'll get upset if somebody swindles you, and probably kill them.
>>
>>44638374
meh probably bag of holding portable hole arrow
>>
>>44630344
Okay here's the best example of lawful evil
A heavy duty min/maxer
>yes it is possible to do that
>yes that is okay in the rule
>No you shouldn't use an oversight to come out on top

the ultimate joy for a LE is for a CG, LG or CE to submit to how the LE does things.
>Force the paladin to fall and kill the BBEG who surrendered. the paladin must sacrifice his "justice" to save thousands
>Force the Ranger not to kill the slavers, the local economy would collapse, some are better off in chains
>Carefully build an Army of undead and soundly crush the BBEG necromancer have him fall in line under your rule.
As a note LE is not as fun if your character isn't stronger than who ever your antithesis is. LE requires power, that's why they are often nobles, lawyers or politicians.
>if the paladin is strong enough to keep the BBEEG in check he'll ignore you
>If the ranger can kill the slavers himself he'll ignore you
>if the fight against the BBEG is hard won he'll ignore you
>>
My friends first character
It was literally just himself, backstory was that a portal opened up for no reason and transported him to the fantasy world
>>
>>44640397
Alright, I'll give you that it can be complex. But it's also complex with no real reason behind it.

"You shall not strike a woman, not even with a flower."
What's one to do when there's a woman who is about to kill a defenseless kid in striking distance?

I think it is pretty inscrutable, for such a short-sighted ideal.
>>
>>44663162
>But it's also complex with no real reason behind it.
So? That's the same as real world religion. It doesn't matter to a follower of the ideal if there is no reason, he can make up his own reason. Or are you saying that every follower of a god in an RPG actually knows the reasoning of their god?

Besides, most ideals have plenty of very good reasons behind them. A strange example like you made being invalid doesn't mean that all, or even most, are also invalid.
>>
>>44623843
underrated.
Thread replies: 239
Thread images: 30
Thread DB ID: 385608



[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Home]

[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the shown content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows their content, archived. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content, then use the post's [Report] link! If a post is not removed within 24h contact me at [email protected] with the post's information.