[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Home]
4Archive logo
After this latest Super Bowl victory is there...
If images are not shown try to refresh the page. If you like this website, please disable any AdBlock software!

You are currently reading a thread in /sp/ - Sports

Thread replies: 503
Thread images: 36
After this latest Super Bowl victory is there ANY doubt now that Manning > Brady?
>>
Manning didn't do shit

Von Miller MVP
>>
>>65464847
>0 TD 2 INT

lol
>>
If anything Brady = Manning
And besides Brady was never carried by his defense in a Super Bowl Run like Peyton is
>>
No. His own team didn't even trust him to pass during the 2nd half outside of the 2 pt conversion.
>>
>>65465119
Neither did Brady but he did earn that 18-1 by himself, lol 18-1
>>
Manning didnt do jack shit this game
>>
>>65465242
Just his kicker.
>>
>>65465242
2001 was very much a defensive effort, anon.
>>
>>65464847
By that logic Russell Wilson is better than Tom Brady.
Russel btfo big manning, big manning spank little manning, little manning is tom kryptonite
>>
>>65465395
>1 for 3 in field goals
>carried by his kicker
Pick one and only one.
>>
>>65464847
0 (zero) TD
>>
File: 1391387446937.jpg (104 KB, 600x600) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1391387446937.jpg
104 KB, 600x600
>>65464847
Fuck Brady, but naw - Brady > Manning
>>
File: muh Vinatieri.jpg (14 KB, 480x360) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
muh Vinatieri.jpg
14 KB, 480x360
>>65465395
oh boy here we go again right
>>
>>65465237
I counted 1 INT fâm
>>
>>65465242
>And besides Brady was never carried by his defense in a Super Bowl Run like Peyton is

No he was carried by Roger Goodell who forced Carroll to call the pass on 2nd play which won him his undeserved owl
>>
>>65464847
100%

MANNING IS GOAT

HE CAN WIN THE GAME WITH HIS MIND, NOT JUST HIS ABILITIES
>>
>>65464847
>Manning > Brady

Sad that it has to come to this, and not just appreciate Manning for Manning.
>>
>HGH Man in owls that "he's" won: 1 TD, 2 INT
>>
>>65465533
do you mean 3 for 3?
>>
he didnt do anything lol

he literally just had to trent dilfer it up
>>
Fampai
>>
>>65464847
Trent Dilfer > Peyton Manning
>>
File: 1430182030518.jpg (68 KB, 300x226) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1430182030518.jpg
68 KB, 300x226
>>65465714
Peyton Manning confirmed for willing the Panthers to suck.
>>
>>65464847
Overall Manning has been way better than Brady, but he was shit today.
>>
>>65464847
No doubt.
>100% Brady Owls via cheating
>50% Peyton Owls via cheating
1 untarnished Owl is greater than 0 untarnished Owls.
>>
File: CaqWqsUUkAArNX_.jpg (62 KB, 600x450) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
CaqWqsUUkAArNX_.jpg
62 KB, 600x450
>Manning better than Brady
>all those INTs
>Denver DEs won the game

kek
>>
>>65465237
>2016
>being this uninformed
It's like you're a pats fan or something.
>>
I wonder how Tom feels about getting cucked by the manning boys.
>>
>everyone getting their fingerprints on the ball
>>
>>65466121
He was probably cheating before 2011 too, just like the Patriots were probably cheating before 2007
>>
I wonder how Peyton Manning feels about getting cucked by Von Miller
>>
>literally the two worst playoff runs by any qb ever
>>
File: 1439144333504.png (197 KB, 779x723) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1439144333504.png
197 KB, 779x723
>>65464847
no doubt but at the end of his career rodgers > manning

already better than brady
>>
>>65466448
Just like every single team in the NFL breaks rules. Goddamn you kucks are so naive
>>
>Heavy evidence of HGH usage
>Superbowl QBR of 57.4
>Benched for half of the season

Yeah Manning really is the GOAT guys haha lol
>>
Goodby Peypey, you schill.
>>
>>65466745
this CHeatriot damage control
Tom Brady BTFO
>>
>>65465242
Did you see his defense hold the greatest show on turf to three scores?
>>
IS THIS SCRIPTED LOL
>>
>>65467039
Ebin meme friend. Mind if I post on r/4chan?
>>
>>65466819
>evidence.

I could say that Newton sucks cocks on the weekend, and it would have the same amount of evidence as the HGH allegations.
>>
>4 rings
>actually can throw and lead a team with nobdodies to multiple SB.
>>
>>65466738
you are not funny. get a life nerd.
>>
You guys do know that Brady still has at least 3 seasons in him, right?

He's going to win at least 1 more SB.
>>
>>65467102
>Spygate
>>
>>65467245
HGH was literally shipped to his house. Unless there have been some dicks shipped to cam's house.
>>
He is absolutely the GOAT

Bandwagoners can whine as much as they want, but it doesn't make Brady better
>>
I'm happy for Peyton but I'm not happy for Peypey fans. Brady is still the better playoff QB. Denver D's dominance this game only makes Brady's final drive look even better.
>>
Pey Pey needs two more rings
>>
Nah 4 > 2. He's better than Eli though
>>
>>65467477

>Zero (0) TDs

Meanwhile Brady last year against a better team

>Four (4) TDs
>>
Active players can't have liquor endorsements.

Peyton'a not coming back.
>>
>>65467355
I don't even think they denied the hgh shipments. LMAO manning camp. they still want to keep the excuse that it's for his wife in their back pocket while usa anti-doping agency investigates.
>>
>>65467606
Is that true? Nice foreshadowing.
>>
>main story is how Manning isn't making it all about him
>>
>>65467606
Did he really endorse it, or was it his "I"m going to Disneyland." and he's just stating he's gonna get drunk?
>>
>>65467492
>brady better playoff QB
>manning is 3-1 against brady in the afc championship
>>
The only reason I wanted Manning to lose is because I'm fucking sick of the Manning vs Brady shilling.
>>
>>65465814
No Vinatieri missed every field goal except the last one.
>>
>>65464847
if you have to ask then the answer is no
>>
This legitimately hurt Mannings reputation more than it helped.
>>
>>65467811
Don't have to worry anymore. Peyton is now the official GOAT
>>
>>65467805
Brady has the most play off wins of any quarterback.
Manning has the most playoff losses.

Not even a Patsfag but it's clear who's the better playoff QB.
>>
>>65467575
>better team
>down 31-0 at halftime to a team that Peyton just btfo in the owl

More proof that pats "fans" have never watched football
>>
>>65467575
Nice tears
>>
peyton will win as a coach I guarantee, owners will be lining up to hire him and he can hand pick any situation he wants and make an easy superbowl run

fuck he might even be cams coach in 5 years
>>
Manning will always be a greater passer than Brady, objectively. But Tom is a better winner.
>>
>>65464847
bradys FOUR superbowl rings would say otherwise. brady will always be better. the defense on the other hand...
>>
>>65465242
I mean that's wrong, arguably his first was entirely because of the defense and I'm a pats fag

Brady>manning

4th quarter of Superbowl 49 for proof
>>
Boy, it sucks when pay2win doesn't work anymore doesn't it pats?
>>
>>65465242
How does it feel to be 12 years old?
>>
Manning:
>2 rings
>3 Super Bowl TDs
>countless INTs

Brady:
>4 rings
>13 Super Bowl TDs
>barely any INTS at all

How can Manning even compete?
>>
>>65468231
how do you explain bradys 25% win percentage against manning in afc championships?

if brady is the better playoff QB shouldn't he beat manning in the biggest game of the playoffs every time?
>>
>>65468235
>>65468235
sorry but Peyton didn't do shit, I'm a big fan of defense. Two years ago Peyton got btfo by the best defense, a year later Tom Brady faces the same defense (#1 Defense ) and he smash the defense and does some clutch plays,

Today lets be honest guys, Peyton didn't do any thing, both him and Cam Newton. It was all about defense and special teams, Peyton's offense was all about Anderson's running game.

For broncos
1 TD from defense
1 TD from running game

For Panthers
1 TD from running game

and lets not forget the broncos special teams was unreal all season long, they kept giving manning better field positions than the opponent's QB. He gets easy field position by his special team, his runing back takes him to the FG range and goes for FG, then the defense comes and scores TD and gets INT, give me a break guys

Lets give credit where credit is due, this wasnt about offense or QBs, this was amazing Defense that single handedly won the season for broncos and Peyton is lucky and grateful to be on that rodeo.

Also when Tom missed season NE Pats missed the playoffs, when Peyton missed the season the broncos finished top seed, then carried him through the post season and gave him a SB win.
>>
>>65468486
The Mannings have 4 rings across 3 teams.

And a record of 5-2 against Brady in the playoffs.

Mannings > Brady the system baby
>>
File: Malcolm Butler.jpg (96 KB, 960x797) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Malcolm Butler.jpg
96 KB, 960x797
>>65465242
>Brady was never carried by his defense in an Owl
>>
You do realize Brady has chance$ for his fifth?

Are you this queer?
>>
Literally any other QB could've won today with that D.
>>
>>65468962
>tom Brady and his perfect 4th quarter was the result of being carried by the defense
>>
>>65468999
you say that

but then you realize dog shit like schaub exist
>>
>>65468981
HIS FIFTH!!!!!!!!!!

Like he was Kobe or MJ & some shit.
>>
>>65468760
They don't play each other on the field. And the 3-2 record corresponds to who was at home.
>>
>>65468962
he wasnt carried this was a simple play that every defense SHOULD make, god damn it, what do you want?? brady goes out and plays defense too?? oh wait he supposed to throw and run and catch the ball as well. GIVE ME A BREAK.

Last year if it wasn't for brady's clutch 4th quarter NE pats wouldnt be in this position. GIVE ME A BREAK.

Also guys, you guys are all neckberd fat loser nerds that have no life and have no clue at sports.

How about we check some proper advice from professionals that understand the game like Deion Sanders.

http://www.bostonherald.com/sports/patriots/the_blitz/2016/02/deion_sanders_says_theres_no_argument_tom_brady_is_superior_to

Deion Sanders here says

"Forget that argument. Brady is better," Sanders said. "I can’t put him beside Brady’s accomplishments. I can’t do that."
>>
>>65468235
>>65468253

>Non american football fans
>Pretending they know jack shit

Kek

Seahawks last year would BTFO the shit out of this year's Panthers team
>>
>>65468999
Nah, I see your point though. The offensive line and his receivers outside Sanders didn't show up. Using his brain only finally paid off.
>>
File: 1454898472025.webm (395 KB, 854x354) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1454898472025.webm
395 KB, 854x354
Rodgers is better than both and has a hotter wife than both.
>>
>>65469076
>>65469076
The broncos were doing fine all year long without Peyton, they were top seed and they carried him throw post season and gave him the SB
>>
>>65465242

His firs 3 were entirely his defense and his kicker. Literally could have run a wildcat offense. That and spygate.
>>
>>65468612
Brady also has 4 superbowl winning drives.

I can't remember a single memorable positive play manning had in the SB. His most memorable plays are pick sixes.
>>
>You now realize you could be a SB winning QB if you got to play on that Denver team
>>
>>65469054
>pretending a perfect quarter is a valid argument when a quarter is only 1/4 the game, hence the name, quarter
No matter how many arguments you cherry pick, you can't hide from the fact that Peyton will retire with better stats than Brady.
>>
>>65469109
>bradyfags full of excuses
>>
>>65467805

Manning had home field advantage 3/4 times mate

Manning has never won a playoff game in Foxboro
>>
>>65464847
Without a shadow of a doubt, Peyton Manning is superior in every aspect of the game.
>>
>>65469173
Nice tears
>>
>peyton manning scored literally zero(0) points in the owl


he was literally a game manager. Even Wilson played better when he won his.
>>
>>65469233
Brady had 3 game winning SB drives in his first 3 SBs.
>>
>>65468760
>>65468760
You cant cherry pick like that , please be logical

if you wanna compare post season stats, then brady is better

if you wanna compare head to head stats, then brady is better. Again. (11-6) or some shit.

you cant just pick what you like from this side, and mix it with this side and come upw ith your silly statements lol.
>>
>>65469269

please excuse being 2-2 in Superbowls manningfag
>>
>>65469233
>32-29
>vinatieri was 1 for 3

Okay
>>
>>65469266
>implying an Australian shitposter could successfully hand the ball off in the NFL
>>
>>65469268
>stats
He has like a 60 something rating in the SB.
>>
>>65468880
>dick riding the Manning Crime Family this hard
Dem goons outside your house?
>>
>>65469321
Peyton had the worst qbr of any sb winning QB ever. He was literally the definition of being carried. Trent dilfer was bettter.
>>
>>65469268
Not a Bradyfag but Manning has played in 265 games, Brady has played in 223 games. That is a pretty big difference
>>
>>65469268
>this bait
>>
BILL SIMMONS BTFO
>>
>>65469268
Volume stats in the regular season are utterly meaningless.
>>
how about some stats for the clueless "fans" out there.

Tom Brady threw more TDs in the 4th quarter against the Seahawks last year than Peyton did in both his SB wins combined.

Nuff said.
>>
>>65465119
>Brady's better than Peyton because of the rings!
>Stats don't matter at all, it's just rings
>Nope doesn't matter that he had better teammates, wins are 100% on the QB
>oh but Peyton didn't do anything to earn this ring
haterz gunna h8. Only QB to ever get a ring with two different teams, Brady is a system babby
>>
>>65470159
So at least we agree Brady > Montana right?
>>
>>65469957
He has also has as many legitimate Super Bowl rings as you or I
>>
File: cammy.jpg (117 KB, 839x440) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
cammy.jpg
117 KB, 839x440
>>65469467
>>65469577
>>65469616
>>65469841
>Peyton is first in all the stat categories that matter
>writes it off cus your subjective favorite can't compare

Guess who is celebrating the superb owl tonight, can guess which QB isn't
>hint: Brady and Cam both didn't win the superb owl
>>
Has Manning ever played with Moss, Gronk, and Hernandez?
>>
>>65467324
No, he's going to lose to Eli again, so Eli can regain his bragging rights
>>
>>65470159
>>65470159
belichick had a losing record b4 brady arrived.
if he was really a goat coach why didnt he have a wining record??

Tom Brady played with 4 to 6 different team lineups, and gues what the results are after each season?? Same ol brady steam rolling his way to a SB win or AFC championship. and the worst happens for him is losing a AFC Championship game.
Brady been so consistent throught out the years. So many different team mates but the results still the same. win win win win.
>>
>>65470243
Which ones weren't legitimate and why?
>>
>>65470287
Holy fuck, Eli is a piece of shit.
>>
>>65470159
Manning has zero memorable positive plays in any of his SB victories. His most memorable SB plays are of him fucking up like the safety or the Tracys porter pick six.

He also has like 9 one and dones.
>>
File: papa johns.jpg (60 KB, 1000x562) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
papa johns.jpg
60 KB, 1000x562
>>65470211
How many Papa Johns commercials has Brady been in?
>>
>>65470358
All of them for cheating
>>
>>65470380
5-6 I think.
>>
>>65470243
>>65470243
i just checked wiki and NFL and they all showing all legit SB wins. dunno what you talkin bout m8.
>>
>>65465242
(You)
>>
>>65470364
He knows there is now no valid argument to be even in the same discussion as Peyton for greatness now. Before tonight he at least had > more rings, to cling to.
>>
>>65468782
I get that you are butthurt about a mediocre game manager who constantly gets btfo by the GOAT Peyton in big moments.

Tom is going to end his career with a painful chokejob loss while Peyton leaves as the winner.

I'm sorry for your sadness but I can't say you don't deserve it for bandwagoning a cheater who spends half the day on his back and the rest on his knees.
>>
>>65470262
>Muh volume stats
>Muh ring for being carried by defense and special teams
No one cares broncofag. You'll get ass raped on opening night next year when the pats aren't a mash unit on offense.
>>
>>65470426
How did he cheat last year? Last I checked the courts ruled him not guilty of any rules violations.
>>
>>65470364
>>65470469

He's the only one that realizes that Peyton literally didn't do shit
>>
>>65470472
How are brady fags sad when they outnumber you retarded broncofags even after you won the SB?

Manning is done. Brady still has 5 good years left to write his legacy.
>>
>>65470472

>that flag
>this topic

kek
>>
>>65470589
It's not like Eli did much to earn his first ring
>>
>>65470589
but the NFL media will now never place those two in the same discussion. He will be forever known as Peyton's brother, and never a great QB.
>>
>>65470472
>>65470472
Flash news, Brady is already the most accomplished QB in history of american football.

4 SB championships
6 confrence championships

That's 10 championships all together. So I doubt brady will be in any "pain".

lets not forget jst 12 months ago every one was talking about how brady's career will be gravy from now on. He cemented that he is the GOAT QB in the game. So any thing he adds now is just a bonus.
>>
>>65470648
or his 2nd
>>
>>65469173
>Cheatriots fans knowing anything about football

Seahawks could barely beat a below .500 Panthers team last year and got rekt against the Panthers twice this year.

Seahawks just looked good last year because they played against a garbage team like the Pats.

http://espn.go.com/nfl/boxscore?gameId=400554258
>>
>>65470714
This. The entire manning family are defense babys
>>
>>65470675
Just a reminder that none of that matters because Peyton literally has the better head to head postseason record
>>
>>65470648
>>65470714
>>65470771
>butthurt Patriots retards

Eli was phenomenal both those postseasons, you're just deluded retards if you think otherwise
>>
>>65470645
>this flag
>this argument

>>65470636
>b-brady has more bandwagon fans
LOL this is literally all pats "fans" have left. Tumbling down.
>>
it's over kids, no one with a serious opinion would pick Peyton. Him playing like garbage while his D carries him will never change that, and even now it's

>4-2
>>
>>65470794

Broncos have the better record because the Patriots have generally been a worse team. Brady carries them year in, year out. Every team Peyton has ever played for has been stacked to the brim with talent, usually by circumventing the salary cap restrictions
>>
>>65470675
>flag
>topic

LOL
>>
>>65470794
That's meaningless when that record was literally due to luck. Peyton was busy going one and done so many times that he never faced brady when the pats weren't injuries to shit.
>>
So is Manning the first starting QB to go to the Owl under two different teams and win for both?
>>
>>65470893
Patriots are the lesser team because they have the lesser QB
>>
>>65470917
Lmao it was luck so it doesn't count. Patsfags are so dumb it's a good thing you are dying of heroin overdoses.
>>
>>65470917
>i-i-i-i-it's luck!!!!!!

Face it. Peyton literally shits all over Brady in the postseason

>durrrrr injuries

So fucking pathetic.
>>
>>65470841
>throws two retarded passes that werected magically caught due to amazing plays by the receiver

Wes dropping the pass and the retarded hEmmet catch are the only reason why Eli isn't ringless.
>>
>>65470270
Faulk, Edgerinn, Harrison, Wayne, Thomas & Thomas, Saunders.
>>
>>65470841
Bullshit he was carried entirely by his defense who didn't show up until postseason. Both years they didn't allow more than 20 points a single playoff game.
>>
>>65470989
if it were the other way around, you'd be the one saying "m-muh injuries tho". you're not fooling anyone
>>
File: btfo.png (821 KB, 916x534) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
btfo.png
821 KB, 916x534
>6 Superbowl Appearances
>4 rings
>3 SB MVP awards

>4 superbowl appearances
>2 rings
>1 sb mvp award
>>
>>65471023
>if u take out da plays den pats win all games
>>
It's obvious Brady is GOAT, but I hate te lulz Peypeyfags so much.

Die, just die, pls die.
>>
>>65471023
If you're seriously calling Manning to Manningham a retarded pass lucky catch then you know literally nothing about football

>Wes dropping the pass

Also a terrible pass from Brady to begin with. The same Brady who fell like a bitch on his ass on the opening play for a safety. The same Brady who threw a ball literally right into the hands of Chase Blackburn which ended up being a Giants TD on the following drive. The same Brady who literally put up 15.5 points on average against the Giants in those two Super Bowls
>>
>>65470974
Tom Brady threw 4 touchdowns in Mile High this year.

Peyton Manning threw 3.
>>
>>65470989
>Peyton literally shits all over Brady in the postseason
Peyton has nine one and dones and a below .500 record. He's objectively shit in the post season.
>>
Fun fact: You could have replaced Peyton Manning with Geno Smith and the Broncos still would have won that game
>>
>>65471041
That doesn't mean he was carried by his defense you retard. He played absolutely phenomenally and came up as clutch as any player in postseason history

You're parroting stale and dead memes
>>
>>65471177
>a below .500 record.
That's wrong, dumb patfag.
>>
>>65471177
Apparently not since he's 3-2 in the postseason against Brady

>>65471046
Well it isn't and you're the retard making the excuses you dumb sack of fucking shit
>>
>>65469209
I REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY
>>
>>65464847
He's not in the conversation and will not ever be in the conversation. Brady is a better quarter back, was a better quarterback and will always be the better quarterback.

Anybody who would take Manning over Brady on a hypothetical All-Time team is fucking delusional.
>>
>>65471159
The Giants fumbled the ball like 3 times that magically bounced their way too if you want to nitpick.

Also that pass to wes was catchable and placed in an area where he wouldn't get killed.

The Manningham catch was equal parts the receiver for keeping his feet in bounds.

Eli is fucking awful anyway and can't even make the playoff without a God tier dline. he's a dine baby.
>>
File: 1404889209170.jpg (40 KB, 614x545) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1404889209170.jpg
40 KB, 614x545
Did Peyton do anything well this game?

2 points

2 turnovers

THIS is the supposed GOAT?
>>
>>65468530
Manning could have scored 10 on Seattle without all of their starting DBs too, faggot.
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v_ED5kaWQRA
>>
>>65468782
>Also when Tom missed season NE Pats missed the playoffs
NE ended that season 11-5, Colts went 2-14 without Manning.
>>
>>65470486
>implying the Pats aren't going to get stomped by Brock for the next one and a half decades
Oh god, those Patriot tears are going to be delicious
>>
>>65471239
OK would you rather say most losses and one and done so in post season history?

Peyton has been compete shit in the post season. He is literally last and second to last in qbr in SB wins. He did nothing in this game and they could have plugged in brock and the result would be the same.
>>
>>65471225
Not allowing a single team to score more than 3 touchdowns worth of points is a tremendous defensive hold, especially in the playoffs.
>>
>>65471276
>he's 3-2 in the postseason against Brady
Because he losses so many times in the first round that it's not even representative of anything anymore. Alps half the time he doesn't even do shit or the pats are injured to shit.

Manning is objectively terrible in the playoffs and this year was no different even if the record shows otherwise. He was even worse than trent dilfer when he went on his SB run.
>>
>>65471741
I didn't say otherwise.

Seems like you can't read
>>
>>65471408
I'm not nitpicking at all. I'm listing pretty memorable and key moments

>was catchable

It was also still a shitty pass

>equal parts to the receiver

It was more of an absolute pinpoint perfect pass

You're just a butthurt retard. He objectively played phenomenally in both postseasons. The defense was nowhere near as impressive in the 2nd Super Bowl run
>>
>>65464847
>implying PeyPey had shit to do with this win
>implying getting carried by his defense in a season where he was one of the worst starting QBs positively adds to his legacy.
>>
>>65470367
He has more wins over Brady in the Playoffs though.
>>
>>65471631
>broncofag actually believe this
lel

You barely beat the mash unit version of the pats. You'll get stomped and embrassed on opening night.
>>
>>65471789
>because he losses so many times that is't noe ven representative of anything anymore

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH

What the fuck are you even talking about?

Peyton LITERALLY owns the superior H2H record in the postseason. Plain and simple

>MUH INJURIES

Every team has injuries you dumb fuck

>Manning is objectively terrible in the playoffs

That's objectively not true.
>>
is this a meme thread?

seriously can't tell anymore
>>
>>65471626
And the Broncos made it to the divisional round of the playoffs under Tebow and fucking Orton the year before Manning. His team has been stacked since the day he signed there.
>>
>>65464847
Nothing about the owl this year puts manning > brady

Denver won with an amazing defense and special teams, that's it.

You can credit a big play by the Pats defense with finishing the game, but Brady was a crucial part of that win.

Manning could have been replaced with cutler and Denver would have won. You cannot say the same about Brady for any of his superbowls

You can argue manning is better, but SB50 does nothing for that claim
>>
>>65464847

>how can king with only 2 ring?
>>
>>65471864
So does Eli you moron
>>
>>65465550
huh you sure thats right?
Devin Hester opening kickoff 11-13 seconds or did they tie it?
>>
Brady>Manning

When Brady wins again in the next two years then there will never be a point in debating this shit.
>>
Peyton Manning in the Superbowl:

4 appearances
2 wins
2 losses
3 touchdowns
5 interceptions
20 points scored
2 fumbles lost
1 safety conceded


Tom Brady in the Superbowl:

6 appearances
4 wins
2 losses
13 touchdowns
4 interceptions
78 points scores
0 fumbles lost
0 safeties conceded
>>
[spoiler]Papa John[/spoiler]>Manning
>>
>>65471789
Speaking of representation, Peyton has beaten TOM three times in a row to REPRESENT his team in the super bowl.
>>
>>65471844
>He objectively played phenomenally in both postseasons.
Scoring 17 and 19 points is not "phenomenonal" you idiot.

The 2011 pats also had the worst defense in the league making eli's performance even embrassing.

Eli is a dine and wes drop baby. He's terrible and that's why he can't even make the playoffs without an elite defense.
>>
>>65468782
>SAME DEFENSE
come on
also denver was more injured during that sb
>>
>>65472080
retard
>>
>>65471870
>keeps calling me a broncofag
I am not a broncofag, I just don't see football through a narrow tunnel like you. There is more to football than brady, and Brady is about to become Brock's bitch.
>>
>>65467872
>>65465814

BTFO

Absolutely beautiful, thank you anon
>>
>>65470767
>>65470767
Thats why the year b4 that they ass fucked the broncucks?
what was the score 55 - 4 or something
the broncucks have been btfo many times, cant remember lel.
>>
>>65471912
>Peyton LITERALLY owns the superior H2H record in the postseason. Plain and simple

So does eli, but no one thinks eli is better than brady because it was the defense that won them those games same for peyton.

Peyton literally did jack shit against the pats this year. he was carried by kicking and defense just like his first SB run.
>>
>>65472100
Two games don't represent either postseason run you dumb sack of fucking shit

Regardless, he still performed well in both those games and came up with game winning performances.

You're just some butthurt actual retard. You're not even trying to think objectively

>15 TDS, 2 INT, 7.4 YPA, 63% completion percentage, 99 QB rating

yeah, real embarrassing shit performances

I don't even need to list the stats, you're just a dumb aspie that didn't even watch the games

His defenses weren't even elite in those years they won. They just showed up in his first SB run come playoff time

Then again you're probably just a dumb lonely troll

I won't waste any more of your useless time
>>
3 of Brady's 4 rings have asterisks. 1 of Peyton's 2 rings has an asterisks as well. They each have 1 legit ring.
>>
>>65472170
>Brady is about to become Brock's bitch.
lel

This is even more retarded than that idiot who thinks eli played "phenomenal" in the SB.
>>
>>65469268

>No matter how many arguments you cherry pick,

You literally cherry picked the goal line interception. How retarded can you be, my friend?
>>
>>65472283
Yeah, but Peyton is being compared to Brady so that is relevant

>literally did jack shit against the Pats this year

He beat them. That's more than Brady did, ignoring that absolute laughable performance he put in against the Broncos D
>>
>>65472083
and who has won more? and who has been more?

Not Peyton, despite juicing himself and his chicken parm arm to the gills to compete every year
>>
>>65469109
>they dont play each other on the field

But they play against other teams in the playoffs so Brady gets credit for his team wins while Peyton gets credit for the losses

Okay

That's totally not a double standard
>>
>>65472386
Tell me when Tom puts up a 56.6 rating and people act like he won a (5th) ring. I mean you saw the game, Peyton did shit. Your heart and mind knows it, yet here you are.
>>
>>65472322
>claims eli played phenomenonal in SB
>lists irrelevant playoff stats to hide mediocre SB performance

The Giants defense was the reason eli is even relavent. Holding all your opponents to under 20 points a game is elite as fuck and the only reason why eli has any rings.

17 and 19 pointsoup in the SB, one against the worst defense in the league, is God awful and you're a moron to say otherwise.
>>
>>65472465
His first Super Bowl was a pretty mediocre performance

Regardless. You can't just flaunt rings and act like it's the end all then proceed to disregard's Peyton's

Peyton did better than Brady in that AFC title game. That should speak volumes more on how shitty Brady was
>>
>>65472330
just checked NFL.com I didn't see any asterisks
>>
>>65465293
3rd and 1 shotgun lmao
>>
>>65472489
>irrelevant stats

I see, you're just trolling

Very funny.

It's probably beneficial for your future if you don't act like a mindless barely functioning aspie though
>>
>>65464847
4-2>>>>>>2-2
>>
>>65472386
Brady was the only QB to throw for 300 yards against the broncos D and wins that game if Belichick isn't retarded and kicks FGs or ghosts makes a pat.

Brady was more expressive in that game than manning was and brady didn't even play that well. That's just how shit and irrelevant manning was to the broncos SB run.
>>
Brady has the team accomplishments (wins, SB rings)

Manning has the stats. As individuals, it's clear who the better player is.

The things that Brady can hold over Manning are Bill Belichick's accomplishments.
>>
File: soberguy.jpg (27 KB, 632x357) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
soberguy.jpg
27 KB, 632x357
>>65472529
yeah Peyton was amazing on defense that game, he had 2 sacks and got constant pressure
>>
>>65472381
Do pat fans just not know when to give up? Brady is the Manning Bro's bitch, and Peyton is about to pass his torch to Brock. Accept it before it starts to destroy you.
>>
>>65472529
>His first Super Bowl was a pretty mediocre performance

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXllTqkkk_8
>>
>>65472659

haha
>>
>>65472440
You know that's not an argument I ever made, you transvestal lube.

Brady's done more for his team. If the Broncos were down 10 points with 10 minutes left, the Super Bowl would be over. Not so with Brady.

Manning has literally become the system babby that gets dragged to the Super Bowl by his defense.
>>
>>65472570
It's irrelevant to bring up non SB stats when you were talking about SB performance. Fuck you're such a fucking idoit. Just leave already and stop embrassing yourself.
>>
>>65469570
>Who is Ben Roethlisberger
>>
>>65472529
Brady had the game winning drive in his first SB. He literally topped manning in good SB moments when he was only 23 years old.
>>
>>65472705
We're not just talking about Super Bowl performances you literal fucking retard

Fucking castrate yourself if any woman will ever even bother listening to your dumb ass for more than 5 seconds

Take a rake to your microcock and just go to town, spare us anything that could remotely emulate you

>19/34, 255, 2 TDS, 1 INT
>30/40, 296 yards, 1 TD

>game winning drive each time

OMG THE DEFENSE CARRIED HIM, WHAT A SHIT QB

I fucking hate you. I would literally kick your dumb ass if I ever saw it
>>
>>65472704
Manning isn't even a system baby. His a QB that the team wins in despite of instead of even "managing" anything. He's literally worse than trent dilfer.
>>
>>65466500

He enjoys watching a black dude do all the hard work and he gets off by watching.

feels good.jpg
>>
>>65472697
That was one of the last Super Bowls of the hard nose NFL. Now it's all about ratings.
>>
>>65472704
>4 Super Bowl appearances with 4 different HCs
> System babby
Pick one and only one
>>
>>65472704
>You know that's not an argument I ever made

No, I don't. Because you responded to something that was talking about team record you fucking retard

I find it so baffling how unbelievably literally autistic Patriots fans get when they talk about Peyton. They cannot even comprehend the most basic of conversations

You're talking about irrelevant shit right now. Peyton has the better H2H and he outplayed Brady this postseason as Denver won the Super Bowl
>>
>>65472647
Yeah Brady kicked those amazing game winning field goals and made an amazing interception at the goal line

Jesus fucking christ
>>
>be Brit
>think NFL looks fun
>see all these people being talked about
>see all the references to stats and shit
>don't understand a fucking thing about NFL apart from how to score

Fuck sake. I'll never learn this thing...
>>
File: 1390754777719.jpg (48 KB, 600x750) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1390754777719.jpg
48 KB, 600x750
I'm a hug PFM fan but that blowout loss to Seahawks and the resulting win next year by the patriots put the Brady vs manning debate to bed. i like to think if manning stayed healthier or if he had the patriots system he would have done better but we will never know.

he would have to come back next year and win it again for it to even be a discussion, we joke about QBs be carried by kickers/defenses a lot but there is no denying that's what happened this year, if i was Peyton i would just leave this ring in a box and never wear it.
>>
>>65466738
You were banned for racism.
>>
>>65472841
Those weren't the fucking stats you posted early you fucking retard and they're still medicore as fuck and far from "phenomenal".

17 and 19 points, one against the worst defense in the league is fucking awful

Eli is and forever will be a dline baby. The guy is the luckiest QB to play in the last two decades.
>>
>>65472998
you have all off season to educate yourself, i recommend watch NFLs top 100 players of all time
>>
>>65472980
>>65472980
he fucking carried the team throught out the match and scored points against the no.1 defense. The NE pats interception at SB last year was the first good play they came up with in the last 6 years. Its all been about Brady. Dont fool your sefl.

Also 2 weeks ago Brady played better than peyton manning and he was facing No.1 Defense and without a proper O-Line.

Peyton was facing a shitty defense and performed much worse than brady.
>>
>>65473105
>those werent' the fucking stats

THAT'S NOT THE FUCKING POINT

HOW FUCKING

STUPID

CAN

YOU

BE

>still mediocre as fuck

Just stop. It hurts too much.

>far from phenomenall

Oh god, you still can't read, JUST stop

Jesus fucking christ, please drench your gene pool with chlorine you fucking aspie

You are so fucking stupid

You're literally burying your head in the sand and just sperging out screaming "NO!!!!!!"

Oh god, just stop, you got me, you baited me perfectly

Here's your (You)

Please fuck off now
>>
>>65472930
>he outplayed Brady this postseason as Denver won the Super Bowl

Brady throwing for 300 yards and willing his team back against that defense in Denver with zero protection was more impressive than manning game managing his way to 20 points.
>>
>>65472841
>>65472841
You are so fucking thick in the head.
Wining drive AHAHAHAHAHHAHAHA
the second SB win the NE defense just let the giants run up and score so brady can get the chance with the ball for 10 seconds. THATSHOW BAD THE NE DEFENSE WAS.

AHAHAHAHHAHAHA
>>
Manning was carried by his D. But at least he has two rings without cheating, which is two more than Brady has.
>>
>>65472930
Peyton did not outplay Peyton this postseason. He's done. He probably had better stats than Cam today but that doesn't mean he outplayed him. If you'd prefer wobbly pass Peyton over Cam or Brady, you're a homer and probably a gay too.
>>
>>65472067

There was a safety called on Brady in 46 for "intentional grounding" after he overthrew Branch by 15 yards.
>>
>>65473250
>loses argument
>goes into autistic rage

Typical mentally damaged retard.
>>
>>65473306
>HGH sent to his wife, admitted by his rep

This is a fact, but nobody cares.
>>
>>65473210
Now you're just being delusional and you know it

>Brady played better than Peyton Manning

That's just stupid. You can say all you want about Peyton being shit that game and this posteason but Brady was absolute dogshit in that game, plain and simple

>he was facing a No.1 defense

All you're admitting is that Brady was shit that game

>and without a proper O-line

How many more pathetic excuses are you going to make? Brady probably has less than you do. If you hadn't noticed Peyton is made of fucking glass right now and still managed to outperform Brady in the AFC title game

>shitty defense

Ranked 9th in the league.

>performed much worse

There's nothing that supports that, just excuses
>>
>>65469237
The bomb to Reggie Wayne vs. the Bears?
Derp.
>>
>>65472930
>>65472930
No manning didnt out played brady you thick headed bastard. Stop eating too much chease you fat greesy fuck you are getting so stupid. Its your national sport and you still dont fucking know Manning faces the NE defense and Brady faces the Broncos defense.

god plz help me with this fuckin dumb kunt.

Manning faced a shitty defense and he was carried by his runing back

Brady faced the best defense and he beat them. It was mistakes by his coach (for not going to FG) and mistakes by his kicker (not gettin the extra 1 point).

Thats what made them lose.

Also the season game was decided by coin toss, belichek wanted broncos to start first and tht cost them the game.
>>
>>65473443
No need to be so hard on yourself.

You didn't know any better

I get it. If I was too fucking autistic to function and read a few sentences I'd be fuming too
>>
>>65472535

>implying NFL.com would show the truth.
>>
>>65473298
It was the game winning drive you dumb fucking aspie.

Or do you think that the Giants didn't take the lead that game?

I mean what the fuck are you even arguing about? You're literally looking for anything to make Brady look good

>let the giants run up and score

That's so they could have more time to score on their drive you fucking retard

You so pathetically bandwagon your team and you don't even know a single thing about them
>>
desu if you actually believe manning is better after watching his turd of a performance tonight, you probably have some form of mental impairment.

that said i am very confident most of you don't believe that and are just trolling
>>
>>65473474
>>65473474
>he was facing a No.1 defense

All you're admitting is that Brady was shit that game
WHAT?? how is that "addmiting he was shit" are you fucking stupid??? PLZ BROTHER for the love of god for the sake of humanity stop eating so much cheese, you are so fukcin stupid ahahahahahah.

Brady defeated the broncos Defense, it was mistakes by his coach and kicker that gave the win to broncos.

Brady had no defense, no proper wide recievers no runing game, and no O-Line. He single handedly carries the team. On the other hand Manning has best defense, top notch quality recievers, mvp running back and best O Line in the game. Not to mention his kicker is like 100% this post season, WTF, the broncos kicker was kicking the 40 and 50 yards kick as well THATS FUCKING INSANE.
>>
>>65469335
Viniateri kicked three FGs, you mean. Thank the Panthers for kicking off out of bounds, putting the Gaytriots only 35 yards out of fiekd goal range to begin with on their last drive. Look at the stats again. Fucking Jake Delhomme played a statistically better game than Brady in SB XXXVIII.
>>
>>65473421

oh shit I forgot about that, good call
>>
>>65473640

Single handedly? Couldn't move the ball in the 4th without Gronk. I love the Pats as much as anybody, but Edelman was having trouble separating and the O-Lineman was no match for Miller, Ware, and Co.

Brady's stats may have been garbage, but I'll be damned if he wasn't fighting that whole game to the last second. Probably wishes he could have been on the onside kick team to try and recover that ball himself.
>>
>>65473640
Jesus christ you're not even trying anymore. You're just raging out like the underevolved subhuman you are

You're just making excuse after excuse, essentially just admitting that Brady wasn't good enough

Maybe if you were a bit more evolved you could understand simple reading comprehensoin

>Brady defeated the broncos defense

Scoreline and his performance say otherwise

>Brady had no defense, no proper receivers, no no no no no nono!!!!

You are so fucking pathetic. Please get help for your crippling idolatry and delusional autism
>>
>>65464847
>THIS MUCH B8

I hate Brady but he's better than Budweiserton Manning
>>
>>65473594
>>65473594
>>65473594
AHAHAHAHHA god you are so fucking stupid.

READ WHAT I FUCKING SAID.

In the 2nd super bowl in the last fucking drive, when the giants were 20 yards away form the touchdown zone, the NE defense on purpose allowed the giants to run and score a TD so brady can get the ball back and try to score.

Does your thick head know why they did this?? Coz the NE defense is so shit , that every one (including the D) knew they are so useless so might as well jst let em score.

Do you think this woulda happend if brady had the broncos defense??
>>
>>65473594
No one but you thinks eli is anything more than a dline and wes drop baby.

19 points against the worst defense in the league. If brady isn't forced to take a safety the pats don't even let the Giants score so 19 points is generous. He was Medicare and lucky as fuck. Nothing more.

Eli should kiss a picture of Justin tuck every night because that's the only reason why he has any rings at all.
>>
File: Tom Terrific.jpg (22 KB, 616x340) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Tom Terrific.jpg
22 KB, 616x340
>>65473647
>Gaytriots

just kill yourself you inbred faggot, Tom Brady shit on your team and no crying will change that. And it wasn't a 56.6 rating game either you salty cunt

Oh and Cam's a criminal nigger and will never win because he's criminal nigger
>>
>>65473505
Jesus christ you're one little pathetic aspie

A little pathetic aspie bandwagoner whose opinion literally doesn't even matter

>faced a shitty defense

Wasn't shitty at all. You're just some third world bandwagoner living in a mudhut sucking up to your idol who'd probably laugh in your ugly fucking aboriginal face

You're making a bunch of shitty fucking excuses for him yet completely ignore Peyton being completely broken and outperforming Brady

God, you are pathetic
>>
>>65473110
Does that really explain all the intricacies of NFL? I want to learn because UK is getting into NFL now just like USA got into football in the 80's and recently.

>I'll never be the first MVP for Britbongistan American Football Team in the Top Show Bowl.

Shame.
>>
>>65472038
The clock stopped at 14:46 for hester
>>
>>65473640
When the Broncos went to the super bowl in the 2013 season Peyton was much better than Brady and Peyton offence was good just like his was. Now the Bronco's went into the superbowl with a better defense and won but their 2013 offense was better than anything Brady has done, and 90% of that was Manning passing ability. Brady is shit and cheated on every single win or is alleged of it. His wife looks kind of like a dude, and well he's going to be 39 and Peyton will be 40. Great I hope he plays his last season by not making the play offs and leaving giselle for her money
>>
>>65470486
>caring about what some else posts on a Chinese cartoon image board
Consider sodoku
>>
>>65473687
Brady was more expressive than manning in that game against the broncos and brady wasn't even that good -- that's how shit and irrelevant manning was that game. He only scored 3 points in the second half and that was 100% on CJ anderson. The broncos literally won because CJ broken off a long run.
>>
>>65473704
>Coz the NE defense is so shit


That had nothing to do with it. They let Bradshaw score on that play because they didn't want the Giants to waste time and potentially score with no time remaining. That's smart playcalling

I wouldn't expect some little underdeveloped monkey from the mountains to understanding something beyond basic comprehension

Surprised they got internet in your little swamp.

>do you think this woulda happend if brady had the broncos defense

Would that have stopped him from that humiliating safety, horrible pass to Welker, and horrible pass to Blackburn, not to mention putting up 17 points against that mediocre Giants secondary?
>>
>>65473726
Tom Beiber didn't shit on my team. You have no idea what team I'm a fan of. this is just empiracle statistics. The Gaytriots didnt even play my team this year, shitstain.
>>
>>65473708
>a bunch of autistic Pats fans think Eli was a fluke so he clearly is

Just stop bro, you already embarrassed yourself before and pathetically backtracked

I don't want to make you sperg out and cry again
>>
What was written on the Broncos players tablet when Joe Namath was walking with the Super Bowl trophy? The camera cut away and it was really hard to read
>>
>>65466819
>being this loomy
>>
>>65473687
>>65473687
NO YOU FUCKIN ASSWIPE

Im trying to get to your thick fucking head and tell you football is not just about QBs, there are 52 players on each team.

Those examples im giving you that brady played better than manning but lost becuase the rest of brady's teammates played like shit and the rest of manning's teammates played like goat.

THATS THE REASON WHY THEY WON. FUCK ME YOU ARE SO FUCKING STUPID.

why the fuck you americans obssessed with QBs so much? thats what i noticed the most about you kunts, you love to suck the QBs dick like no 2moro.

FUCK OFF FAGGOTS GET OF THEIR DICKS.
THERE ARE 51 OTHER PLAYERS THAT CONTRIBUTE TO THE GAME.
>>
Manning has better

Postseason qb rating
Single season td average
Single season qb rating avg
Single season passing yards avg

So how is Brady better
>>
Let's dispel this fiction once and for all that Peyton Manning doesn't know what he's doing. He knows exactly what he's doing; he's undergoing a systematic effort to drive the ball down the field and win his last game. If the Broncos win, we'll embrace what makes football the greatest sport in the world.

>Let's dispel this fiction once and for all that Peyton Manning doesn't know what he's doing. He knows exactly what he's doing; he's undergoing a systematic effort to drive the ball down the field and win his last game. If the Broncos win, we'll embrace what makes football the greatest sport in the world.

Let's dispel this fiction once and for all that Peyton Manning doesn't know what he's doing. He knows exactly what he's doing; he's undergoing a systematic effort to drive the ball down the field and win his last game. If the Broncos win, we'll embrace what makes football the greatest sport in the world.

>Let's dispel this fiction once and for all that Peyton Manning doesn't know what he's doing. He knows exactly what he's doing; he's undergoing a systematic effort to drive the ball down the field and win his last game. If the Broncos win, we'll embrace what makes football the greatest sport in the world.
>>
>>65473872

you live in america mate.

literally the dumbest 1st world country on earth.

NZ may be small but they at least can form opinions based on facts and not meme's
>>
New England had a better ranked defense in 2007 than the Giants

Brady put up 14 points to Eli's 17

lol

2011, Giants had the 27th ranked defense and Brady only put up 17

lol
>>
>>65473981
shut up australia
>>
If it wasn't for Mo Lewis, no of you fuctards would even know Tom Bray's name.

P.S., his wife it a beard more than Kelly Preston or Katie Holmes ever were. Fact.
>>
>>65473981
>another third world shithole full of undervolved aboriginals and criminals shitting on America

AHAHAHAHAHHAAHAHHAHAHAAHAH

>based on facts and not memes

AHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHHAHAAHHAHAHAHAHA

You are monkeys in the zoo. I just watch you retards fling shit at each other
>>
>>65473981
Sheep fucker
>>
File: cutler.jpg (107 KB, 800x450) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
cutler.jpg
107 KB, 800x450
>>65473981
>mfw Australia can't handle the bantz on Super Bowl night
>>
>>65474063

that's why my standard of living is objectively higher then yours and my country is also statistically whiter then yours

nice fedora tipping response ;)
>>
>>65473943
>there are 52 players on each team

Except apparently when Brady wins, because it's all literally him

>why are you Americans obsessed with QBs so much

I'm not the aspie worshiping Brady and making every excuse in the book for him

You literally brought up the rings argument then said there are 52 players on each team

You are so fucking pathetic. You're literally as dumb as your flag would imply
>>
>>65473903
>I don't want to make you sperg out and cry again

Is this something retarded austic coping mechanism?

You literally threw an autism tantrum when I destroyed your idiotic "phenomenal" eli SB myth and you're just projecting like a retard right now.
>>
>>65473916
Yeah, I notice that. The camera cut away real fuckin quick. That 5 second delay for editing kicked in.
>>
>>65473872
>>65473872
or maybe if they had a decent fuckign defense, they let them play so the NE defense intercept the ball and score a TD on their own?? what is that too much to fucking ask?? every single SB won by the defense, except Tom Brady. He has to do his on his own!!


>>65473678
>Couldn't move the ball in the 4th without Gronk.

ohhhh wow, thanks bro for making it clear for me. So brady is supposed to throw the ball, run up and catch it himself. cool.

but ya i knw brady played like shit (for brady's standard) but still played much better than manning.


who cares about our opinion, we are mainly fans and are biased.

when deion sanders said dont compare brady with manning, he said it for a reason you cheesy fat fuck.
>>
>>65474115
Who gives a shit about that?

You live in some country overrun with literal monkeys and descendants of criminals

I'm surprised your country could even function a computer

I mean just look at you, you can barely even communicate without sperging out like your jungle ancestry encodes you with
>>
>>65474135
>no you

Great argument bro ;)
>>
>>65474000
Yeah, the Giants defense became elite as fuck and held every team they faced to 20 points or less including a prime mvp arron Rodgers in their two super bowl runs.
>>
steelers fan:

no doubt in my mind before this win
spygate helped the pats win aginst us in 2004
it helped them win against us in 2001

good for pey pey
c yinz in the hof soon
>>
>>65473916

world champs
>>
>>65474128
>>65474128
i bourght it up bcoz this thread is about manning and brady you fucking dumb kunt.

seriously look at what the cheese doing to your brain. you are so fucking thick now.

you shit kunts keep making shitty threads like these. like deion sanders said, you just cant compare manning to brady. no way you can do that, you just cant put manning with brady's accomplishments ( the ones that matter you fat cheesy fuckwits)

4 SB
6 confrence champs

total 10 championships.
>>
>>65474181

you keep saying people are sperging out, but to be honest the only person here who seems to be in some sort of autistic rage has been you.

I am perfectly calm, i made over $800 backing the broncos to win by 14+ today, and just came online to enjoy some american tears.
>>
>>65474221
I already destroyed your stupid arguments. You're just shitposting and throwing around memes now because you're butthurt and autistic
>>
>>65474140
It was 2nd and goal on the 10, with a minute left, the Giants are only down by 2. It was a logical move

>they let them play so the NE defense intercept the ball and score a TD on their own

This must be that elaborate Australian shitposting I've always heard about. You can't actually be this stupid can you? Nature doesn't always dictate behavior, does it?

Oh god, you might actually be retarded.

I'll leave you alone then. That 2nd half of the post only confirms my suspicions
>>
>>65474259

stop falling for their bait.

if an american actually expressed these opinions in real life they would be laughed at. It's just something american neckbeards on /sp/ say because they never played sport and have no idea about anything
>>
>>65474181
>descendants of criminals


same goes with the US bud

the women were prostitues of in europe and the men were theifs and murders. so european were trying to clean street from the filth and decided to put your ancestors in a ship and sail them accros the oceans.

thats why when your criminal ancestors landed on the new world they started killing and stealing the lands of the natives.
>>
>>65473726
Way to deflect, dipshit. Want to actually comment on the fact that you team ended up with the ball lst, and all Brady did was get them about 35 yards, so Vinatieri could save their asses with a field goal at the end of the game. Once again, Jake fucking Delhomme played a better game the Brady in SB XXXVIII. Tell me I'm wrong. Shit, if it wasn't for that tuck rule bullshit, no one would know Brady's name. Everything has an asterix for the Gaytriots. Everything.
>>
>>65474225
And the Patriots proceeded to have 15 PPG allowed in that postseason so Eli surpassed expectations

And if you're gonna go solely off points then the Patriots were actually ranked 15th in the league that year in points allowed

So there's go your argument I guess

Not that you even had one if I'm being honest
>>
>>65474288
>It was 2nd and goal on the 10, with a minute left, the Giants are only down by 2. It was a logical move

A position they were only in because the Giants elite as fuck dline forced a safety. Otherwise they play that situation completely differently and Eli isn't gifted points.
>>
File: ;lk.jpg (11 KB, 376x370) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
;lk.jpg
11 KB, 376x370
>>65474259
>football is a team sport!!!!

>brings up the ring argument
>>
>>65474273
>no you!!!!

Real mature.

God you sound like such a child.

Do you third worlders have nothing better to do? Where are you gonna spend those 800 dirt dollars anyways? To get some clean water?
>>
>>65474337

autism: the post
>>
>>65474288
>It was 2nd and goal on the 10, with a minute left, the Giants are only down by 2. It was a logical move


sigh this guy so fucking STUPIDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD

do you fucking think the seahawks defense or 2nite's broncos defense woulda done the same?
NO FUCKIN WAY

do you know why fatty?

because the seahawk and broncos defense will just rush the fuck outta QB and push him back and do something usefull,

in the other hand the NE are fucking USE LESS
they are there jst riding of tom brady's offense. if brady was playing against that defense then it would be blowout. get real
>>
>>65474279
Destroyed them with what? By sperging out and calling Eli shit because you don't like him? Being completely incapable of basic reading comprehension?

Yeah great ""argument"" bro
>>
>>65474422

I truly hope you see a professional and get help for whatever disorder it is you seem to be suffering form.

Genuinely.
>>
>>65474337
If Vinatieri isn't 1/3 against the panthers Delhomme isn't even in the game. He could have easily been the reason they lost just like he was the reason they won against the rams.

>Tuck rule

lel at this pathetic autist. It's been fucking 15 years and this still makes these idiots mad.
>>
>>65474438
>let the Giants run the ball and get a game winning field goal with no time

Or

>let them get a touch down and give yourself time to get a score

Sounds logical to me. Then again little monkeys from your armpit of the world don't have that do they :(

>riding of tom brady's offense

The same Tom Brady offense that put up 17 points that game hahahahahhaha!
>>
>>65474489
I see what's going on here

You've come to realization in which someone has exposed your brash immaturity and dared to even remotely called you out on it

For once you're actually exiting your child like state of ignorance and facing the real world

In a sense, you're getting the maturation you clearly lacked early on in life for whatever reason

I think you're just scared of what reality has to offer, and I can tell I've gotten to you based off your hostility

I intimidate you. That's not how I want these sort of revelations to happen but it's apparent it's the only way you can learn as your juvenile ways are based off of intimidation and condescension

You need to help yourself, but I will help you if need be
>>
>>65474456
lel at this backtracking

17 and 19 points, one against the worst defense in the league and 6 points came from the pats giving up a TD are not "phenomenal" performances.

You never refuted this ever and just started raging like a autist afterward.

In b4 you reply with another autistic tantrun
>>
>>65474429
Once again, ad hominem all you want, but is anything I typed untrue in the least? I Thought not. No address what I've stated, or piss off. did that last kickoff not go out-of-bounds. Did Brady only have to take the offense 35 yards down the field for a fucking field goal (like all 3 of their first SB wins)? Did Jake not play the better game, just Brady ended up w/ the ball last?

You're fucking out of you element, Donny. (If you're even old enough to get the reference , you bandwagonning Gaytriots child).
>>
>>65474238
Jerome Bettis pls go
>>
File: CQQbUiqUcAA0S2B.jpg (60 KB, 600x593) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
CQQbUiqUcAA0S2B.jpg
60 KB, 600x593
>>65474337
Whenever someone brings up the tuck rule, bring up the 1976 Patriots vs Raiders Divisional game where the Raiders were not only being refbabbies, but Al Davis literally flooded the field against one of the best Patriots teams of all time.

If it wasn't for that bullshit no one would know the Raiders name. Everything has an asterix for the Gaiders. Everything.
>>
>>65474512
>The same Tom Brady offense that put up 17 points that game hahahahahhaha!

The Giants held every team they faced including prime MVP Rodgers to 20 points or less in their post season runs. They were elite as fuck.
>>
>>65474621
>vinatieri was 1/3 in easy field goals that game
>no he carried brady lel
Ok
>>
>>65474603
>say he put in a great postseason performance

>give stats

>THOSE DONT MATTER, I WAS TALKING ABOUT SUPER BOWL

>give Super Bowl stats

>t-t-t-they suck

And the only refute you have is this stupid argument about defense which has nothing to do with how Eli performed, bringing up team points solely when individually he played just fine and put in two clutch performances and two game winning drives

Your refute to this is just babbling autism and an inability to actually read, willful idiocy I imagine

You're just disregarding his performances because they shit all over your argument and you're just arguing with me because you want to get one over on me, not because you even believe your own nonsense at this point
>>
>>65469209

Oh great she's in super hero movies now... literally why
>>
>>65474621
Some of those Brady SBMVPs should have went to Adam.
>>
>>65474683
That's not relevant to the fact the Patriots weren't riding his offense

In that 2011 season the Giants D was ranked 24th in total D, hardly elite.
>>
terrific thread lads
>>
>>65474621
Vinitari was 1/3 in that game both misses within 30 yard range. His fuck ups were the only reason why the panthers were in the game. It's literally retarded to claim he was the reason he won because he finally made a kick when the only reason why they didn't close the thing out already was because he fucked up earlier.
>>
>>65474778
Thanks bro
>>
Boy this thread has pretty much just boiled down to mindless dogs barking the word "autism" at one another.
>>
>>65474700
You said he had phenomenal SBS you backtracking autist.

Also you bring up brady "only" putting up 17 points against the elite Giants D like it's some fucking crime against humanity while making every excuse in the book for eli only put 19 points up with a gifted TD against the worst defense in the league.

You're a joke and I've destroyed you to the point that you sound like nothing more than a raging autist. Pathetic.
>>
>>65474745
They held every team they faced to 20 points or less in both super runs. That's elite of the elite. Stop throwing them under the bus when they're 99% of the reason why the Giants won anything in the past 3 decades.
>>
>>65464847

Manning (vs. Brady 3) wins/4 AFC title matchups

Brady (vs. Mainning) 1 win/4 AFC title matchups

Though they're never even on the field at the same time, when they've met to decide who's going to advance to the SB "all the marbles",
Manning has won three out of the four meetings.
>>
>>65464847
>threw for 100 yards the whole game
>better than the all time GOAT who's going to win another ring next year

Lmao
>>
>>65474873
I also said he had a phenomenal postseason each time you fucking dumb piece of shit

>elite Giants D

The one that was ranked 24th in the league that year and Brady looked like a fucking amateur against them

You still literally haven't refuted a single thing I've said you pathetic sack of shit

Eli puts in a great performance, objectively, you backtrack, then just deny the greatness of the performance because the defense was shit

That's not how a bad performance works. This is your pathetic and very dumb ass grasping at straws because the big bad meanie is smarter than you :'(

Tell me what was wrong with the performance. You act like it's a crime against humanity for not torching the Pats D which by the way let up only 15 PPG in that postseason
>>
>>65474933
Except they were 24th ranked in 2011, I'm not denying they didn't play a role. I'm just refuting your fucking retarded insinuation that Eli wasn't phenomenal in each postseason run.

In 2011 especially Eli was great

Here you are talking strictly about Super Bowl performances then bring up non-Super Bowl performances while getting your diaper all riled up because I talked about Eli's non-SB performances

Your non-existent argument is collapsing on itself
>>
>>65474966
>Eli puts in a great performance

19 points with 6 of them giftwrapped because the D literally let's you score is mediocre at best (lel at "great") and no amount of autistic backtracking and rage posts is going to change that.

Eli is a D line and wes drop baby. Nothing you said refuted that and this eli phenomenal sb myth is literally only in your mind.
>>
>>6546878 Yeah, the Pats missed the postseason, but they had a better record than they did WITH Brady the next season. Ooops. 11-5 without Brady in 2008, 10-6 the next year with him, in 2009. You done fucked up, son! By you Patriots fans' logic Cassell>Brady.
>>
>>65470287
Even dad looks disappointed. Probably because Peyton didn't waste his college career at Ole Piss.
>>
>>65475039
>In 2011 especially Eli was great

He was Medicare in the SB and Alex Smith would have beat him if not for that idiot returner muffing a punt.

No one with eyes thought he was "great". The Giants D was great though. Eli and you should be thanking them.
>>
>>65475098
Points aren't the only metric of performance

Of course you know this but you're just intentionally being retarded in an attempt to salvage anything to get something of value of this

You're not getting anything. You're literally denying everything I've said with things that simply do no matter

That New England D only allowed 15 PPG in that postseason beforehand so Eli surpassed that average anyways. So your point is quite moot

You keep autistically echoing the same points that are completely irrelevant

And are still conveniently ignoring the rest of his postseason performances because you're so pathetically fixated on this

I literally am your entire life right now aren't I? If you can somehow get something here, your life will somehow not be entirely shit, won't it?

That's sad man. What's even sadder is that you're not even close to being right. You're just burying yourself in ignorance

I can help pull you out. But you need to help yourself first
>>
i live in montana and know brock osweiler. I live in bigfork but know lots of people from kalispell. ask me anything
>>
>>65475228
Oh yeah, I forgot 295 yards for a TD and the game winning drive was "Medicare" whatever the fuck that means in your aspie language

>No one with eyes thought he was great

Well I do, so your point goes out the window

However anyone who isn't a blithering autist thinks he did great in the Super Bowl and the postseason

You're not even refuting what I'm saying anymore. You're just pathetically attacking me because you're so damn scared of losing this argument

It's already lost. This is just you crying right now like the pathetic bitch you are

I've got a shoulder for you
>>
>>65470211
Not a Montana fan, but Montana never threw a single a SB interception. Brady threw two in his last game, alone. NOPE! And I wouldn't even put Montana in my top 5.
>>
Brady is in the same age bracket as Manning, how come his arm is still functioning correctly? Manning's passes are just dogshit
>>
>>65475230
>That New England D only allowed 15 PPG in that postseason beforehand so Eli surpassed that average anyways.

Because the pats played garbage qts like tebow, no acl rivers, David Gerrard, and Joe flacid. The fact that eli did barely better than them is fucking embrassing to your entire "phenomenal" argument.

He also almost lost to Alex Smith so he wasn't particularly elite or great in the playoffs in 2011 either. He had a chance to have a game winning drive and sucked balls and was bailed out by a miffed punt.
>>
>>65470211
Brady and Montana atm are equal as the GOAT

If Brady gets another ring he's on his own
>>
I really like both of them, and enjoy seeing both play. I'm more of a Brady fan but I'm really happy to see Manning win another Superbowl. He deserved more than one and he got it! :)
>>
>>65466500
Give him a Budweiser and Von Miller will do the rest
>>
>>65475291
>I forgot 295 yards for a TD
lel is this suppose to be impresive? And against the worst D in the league?
>>
>>65475327
The postseason was the 2011 postseason

You're still not actually denying facts. Just making more excuses

>Joe Flaccid

The same that also goes elite mode almost every postseason

Eli put 300 yards and 2 TDs on the 4th ranked SF defense in that NFC title game. 20 points in your autism funland

Both teams were playing in shitty conditions. The Giants prevailed

You're making excuse after excuse, completely denying facts

I'm genuinely worried you might actually be autistic. You cannot comprehend simple linguistic cues and are just weaseling out of every single thing I'm saying.

Sooner or later you're just gonna have to address the fact there's no room for you to wiggle out of. You've yet to refute a SINGLE thing I've said

Face reality
>>
>>65475291
>Well I do, so your point goes out the window
The phrase is an implication that you're blind. You're literally fucking autistic lol
>>
>>65475121
ahhahha that did happen. did worse when brady came back.
>>
File: 1454380047245.jpg (40 KB, 680x848) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1454380047245.jpg
40 KB, 680x848
>>65465242
>Brady was never carried by his defense in a Super Bowl run like Peyton
>>
>>65475327
>the chargers are an AFC team
Lol
I forgot about that, it's been so long
>>
>>65475404
Led the game winning drive too

Wasn't the worst defense in the league since they only allowed 15 PPG that postseason

Oh thats right, worst defense in the league applies to yards since the Pats were 15th in points allowed that season

You didn't know that. It makes too much sense

You have no argument. Everything you're saying is literally conflicting with each other. You're arguing with yourself at this point and I'm actually helping you understand what YOU'RE trying to say

This is sad, I'd just pack it in for the night, but your ego is at stake here
>>
>>65468962
Up until that interception the Xehawks O was marching down the field
>>
>>65475467
It implies I have eyes

Jesus christ, you're more autistic than I thought. You literally cannot comprehend basic language.

Get

Help

Sincerely
>>
>>65475443
>Eli put 300 yards and 2 TDs on the 4th ranked SF defense in that NFC title game. 20 points in your autism funland

With a terrible completion percentage and it was only 17 points. He was gifted 3 off a miffed punt. He had 2 game winning drive attempts that failed too. He did not play phenomenal no matter what cherry picked stats you throw out.

Ironic because his stats werected similar to brady's against the number ranked broncos D yet you shit on him for it. Hypocritical bitch is what you're exposingredients yourself to be on top of the autism.
>>
>>65469289
That also means Brady can't win in a dome or a mile up.

>>65469321
He got 2 points.
>>
File: 1453141077498.png (532 KB, 1597x1600) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1453141077498.png
532 KB, 1597x1600
>>65465242
>>
>>65469570
>QB in clash of great defenses has bad QBR
What a surprise. Cam really lit it up too, right? Manning didn't sperg and turn the ball over constantly. He made one mistake and played a very conservative game.

That's what QBs do. They read the game, get a feel for it, and try to do what is necessary to get their team a win. He did that, on a fucking mush ankle and without the ability to throw the deep ball. It was pretty impressive honestly.
>>
File: Triggered.webm (3 MB, 768x432) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Triggered.webm
3 MB, 768x432
>>65475586
tell it to the record books patsfag
btw, when you layer insults like *dumb bitch giants fag fan lolkek* you might as well have a trip
If you're going to pretend to be anon at least hide it

>you're mad as shit
>>
>>65475507
>Led the game winning drive too

That means fucking nothing. Brady lead his team to a game winning drive against the rams and he did play "phenomenal" that game either.
Wasn't the worst defense in the league since they only allowed 15 PPG that postseason

>Oh thats right, worst defense in the league applies to yards since the Pats were 15th in points allowed that season

Which is a mediocre position and Eli match that in the SB making his performance mediocre.

Also it makes posting his retarded yardage figure even more stupid because the pats were dead last against the pass I yards that year. Eli barely did better than the average the pats D was giving up.

You're getting destroyed now. Just stop.
>>
>>65475649
>Implying
He didn't do enough to help his offense get going
That said, he's an old man now and has an elite d specifically for situations like this
>>
>>65475586
>the points don't count because I say so!!!!

You're literally living with delusions. This is not healthy. But you know what you're doing, and it's all because you cannot grasp the realities and truths of being wrong

>2 game winning drive attempts that failed too

And still won the game

>no matter what cherry picked stats you throw out

What's cherrypicking, listing the majority of stats and a definitive game winning drive or just listing completion percentage? You're just making excuse after excuse. You're cherrypicking by ignoring the larger picture and just making excuses for every single thing I'm saying

You''re not even arguing about Eli anymore. You're just arguing for the sake of arguing against me.

>his stats were similar to Brady's against the ranked Broncos D

Brady threw a TD, had 2 picks, was consistently missing targets, QB rating was much much worse

Eli had two TDS, no picks, significantly better in every regard

It's not comparable

You are so fucking pathetic. The only reason you're even grasping at this lost argument of yours is because I insulted Brady

Get help. Idolatry is not healthy

You have yet to refute a single point I've made. Your autism is astounding
>>
>>65464847
Tons of doubt left, but I agree, OP.

I'm a neutral(somewhat) Packer fan. I was rooting for Peyton to get one more before his time was up. Even I know he's on borrowed time and has been for years. Did he deserve it more than Cam? Or Brady? Objectively, for fuck's sake no. Subjectively, hell yes. But that's the key point of such a vague descriptor like "the greatest". It's like quicksilver, and it will always be impossible to hammer down into a set order. Are there tiers, plateaus, levels of "greatness"? Sure, you will always know that Rodgers is on another level than say, Matt Stafford-- but those are equally fluid and subjective. Point is--these two will be THE dominant quarterbacks of their era, overshadowing just about everybody shy of Favre(who I love to death, but I readily admit was clearly not the best).

There's legions of people out there who love Peyton but hate Brady, or vice versa, for their own reasons. I happen to loathe the Patsies, I feel nauseated by Brady and Belichoke. I never necessarily rooted for Peyton, but I admired and respected him immensely. Not -as many- people seem to do that towards Brady. There seems to be this reputation about the Pats that has lingered since Belichoke rose to prominence, like the cliche villains in any YA novel or show. They win, and they win, and they win, but no one likes them. Not out of envy, but because something about the way they do it just never sits right with them.

Peyton never really had that stigma about him. Most of his detractors are honest to god butthurt fans of AFC rivals. He only ever had one ring up until now(make that two), but people felt more comfortable with Peyton winning, and it didn't seem at all like a simple lack of people skills or personality. They both seemed equally friendly in front of media and fans.
>>
>>
>>65475666
>tell it to the record books patsfag
lel Pats have 4 rings. I think ill live. Enjoy not even making the playoffs though and posting shit that happened almost a decade ago.
>>
File: 1453329725175.png (535 KB, 736x736) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1453329725175.png
535 KB, 736x736
>>65475754
I can't hear you over the sound of not having 7 rings like you should

>MANNINGS BTFO BRADY

Inb4 Eli retires with 4 rings and Boston commits mass suicide
>>
>>65474671
>Stadium is below sea level
>shocked that it's wet
Are you going to claim Ray Guy filled his footballs with helium next? At least he inflates his balls unlike Brady who deflates them.

Oh and I don't see the rules being re-written to favor the Raiders any time. Brady can't take a minor hit to the knee and suddenly the QB can't be breathed on without a flag being thrown.
>>
>>65475683
>leading the game winning drive means nothing

You are so fucking pathetic. And now you're throwing idol under the bus just to get one over on me too.

Brady's stats against the Rams were not as good as Eli's against the Pats either time

Not even remotely comparable performances. But of course you're so desperate to try and get me somewhere that you bring up such an idiot point

>which is a mediocre position

So it's not the worst defense in the league or is it? So Eli's performance isn't as bad as you actually thought and now you're just backtracking

>because the Pats were dead last against the pass that year

A running game can set up a good pass attack as well

You don't know that of course because you have no idea what you're talking about

>the Pats was giving up
Holy christ

Your entire argument is just denying facts and clinging to the fact that Eli didn't do as well as he should've rather than how well he actually did

You're so obsessed with me you're going on this autistic rage just embarrassingly denying that you're wrong in your dumb face

You are literally obsessed with me. That's the only thing that can explain this non-neurotypical behavior
>>
>And still won the game

Based on fluke that he had nothing to do with.

Look nothing you've posted stats or points or even memorable plays has proven eli was "phenomenal" at anything put hurling up one pass to Manningham and him catching it. Everything else he did was mediocre or against who cares.
>>
>>65475749
So maybe it'll come down to this: Manning will have a greater legacy, a greater impact on the game, not for his insane "video game numbers" or his rings or his ability to play, but because he will be perceived as the better man. The squeaky clean country boy from down south with simple needs and a broad smile. All he wanted to do was win. Brady wanted to win, too, and he won. A lot. But for some arbitrary reason, and it doesn't sit well with me to admit this, Peyton will come out of all this looking like the squeaky clean role model, while Brady will always have a bizarre, intangible stigma about him. Brady will win, and win, and win some more, but like the de facto main rival in any story, his winning never won him the same admiration and appreciation. Maybe Brady doesn't really care, nor should he, but in terms of the greatness argument, that's pretty much the measuring stick from where I'm sitting. Maybe it's not fair, but big whup. Both QBs really have nothing left to want for or prove. At least they didn't go out like Favruh...
>>
>>65471058
>hated
>will always be plagued by cheating allegations
>>
>>65475873
The point is leading the game winning drive, which you were only in the postion to do because your defense forced a safety earlier in the game, in not indicative of a "phenomenal" performance.

Neither is spamming less than 300 yards against a defense that routinelygave up that yardage to bums like Rex grossman.

You're being destroyed. Just stop. It's getting pathetic.
>>
>>65475880
And what fluke was that?

You're again just desperately clinging to non-existent excuses

You've yet to actually definitively address or refute a single point I've made

>or even memorable plays

So leading the winning drive means nothing but "memorable" plays matter?

What the fuck is wrong with you? Are you alright?

>hurling up one pass to Manningham

You really do have absolutely no clue what you're talking about

You really are just a pathetic obsessed aspie

Pleas stop posting and do yourself a favor and stop embarrassing yourself and your fanbase. They already get enough shit for having sorry sacks of shit like yourself. No need to further the stereotype

You still literally haven't refuted a single thing I've posted
>>
>>65475977
>And what fluke was that?

The 49ers returned miffed a punt. That's literally the only reason why the Giants were in FGermany range.

You don't even remember how the fuck the Giants got to superbowl aND youre telling us with a straight face about elis "phenomenal" 2011 post season. Hilarious.
>>
>>65475965
>only because your defense forced a safety

I'm genuinely astounded how many degrees of pure autism you are willing to go

You are pulling out every retarded excuse you can

Here's one

Brady's entire career is predicated on Drew Bledsoe being injured, if Bledsoe was never hurt, Brady would be a useless piece of shit.

Brady's entire success and abilities are attributed to to Bledsoe's injuries

You still have yet to refute anything I've said. You have got to be the most pathetic person I have ever seen on this website. That's saying something since I've seen literal stalkers who've built up hundred page dossiers on a single tripfag

You've managed to transcend that level of autism

Give yourself a big hand. Because no one else will
>>
>>65476015
>that's literally the only reason why the Giants were in FG range

What about Eli's previous contributions that got them on the board to begin with? Do those not count because they don't fit your argument?

Obviously. Pure autism is the only way you can effectively communicate
>>
>>65475938
>Allegations
>Team has been punished twice for cheating
Don't forget Goddell covered up the real bad shit in regards to spying by destroying all the tapes and bullying people who wanted to testify against the pats into staying quiet because he just gave them a slap on the wrist.
>>
>>65475938
>whiney fans of shitty teams opinions matter
>>
>>65470159
>literally didn't even throw a touchdown in the last 2 Super Bowls
>didn't even play half the season

Oh sure manning totally carried his team lol
>>
File: 1410224591489.gif (4 MB, 399x328) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1410224591489.gif
4 MB, 399x328
>>65476015
>not watching the 2011 playoffs
>regurgitating bullshit from commentators

You are literally the worst Patsfag anywhere, let alone this board
>>
>>65468544
>Broncos
>Not p2w
>Talib
>Ward
>Ware

Whoa
>>
>>65476016
>You still have yet to refute anything I've said.

I've refuted everything you've said. You've now resorted to mindless garbage about bledsoe.

>Muh stats that were worse than Rex grossman against the worst D in the league
>Muh game winning drive that was only possible due to elite D getting a safety and the pats letting him score

That's literally the only two points you made and they're both stupid as fuck. Go cry yourself to sleep because I've embrassed you all night.
>>
>>65475749
>>65475925

PS Favre was a horrible QB on paper, but by god he was the most enjoyable quad-coverage-throwing son of a motherfucker I've ever seen before or since. Space fucking mountain QB form. INTs everywhere but fuck if that wasn't quality entertainment to watch. peace
>>
>>65476016
Lol Brady was going to replace Bledsoe no matter what.Bill knew that Brady was more talented it just worked out well that Bledsoe got injured. That's why Bledsoe didn't get the starting job back when he recovered you dumb fuck
>>
>Brady
>most wins in playoff history
>most super bowl appearances in playoff history
>has 4 rings

>Manning
>has most losses in playoff history
>has a tied record of 2-2 in the super bowl
>only 2 rings
>one was gift wrapped by Rex Grossman, the other by Denver D

I think I just solved this.
>>
>>65476041
>What about Eli's previous contributions that got them on the board to begin with?

Wasn't enough to win. Getting bailed out on a muffed punt is a sign of a " phenomenal" performance.

Weren't you also raging about the panthers kicking the ball out of bounds in the SB? lol hypocrisy strikes again!
>>
>>65475925
>Manning
>squeaky clean
>rubs his ass on some womans face and does HGH

top kek
>>
>>65476104
>I've refuted everything you said

You actually haven't. You've just made excuse after excuse

Still not actually criticizing the performance itself. Just the expectation of the performance, as well as just calling things a fluke when you think it can fit your argument

>mindless garbage about bledsoe

Oh how surprising, the literal aspie still can't comprehend basic linguistics

Again, you're not even arguing about Eli, you're just arguing about me.

You're basically just echoing what I'm saying in an attempt to get one over me

The difference is in what I say is that it actually applies to you. I'm describing you perfectly and it's infuriating you. You're just trying to think of an insult to infuriate me

You're pathetic. You're quite possibly actually autistic. And you're not even trying to be something otherwise

I can only imagine that you're going to reply to this by saying "no you're dumb and I'm right" yet again not addressing anything I've said

You are so pathetic. I'm actually starting to laugh at you.
>>
>>65476128
Nope. Sorry. Only reason Brady started was because of Bledsoe's injury

Just like the only reason the Giants got towards the 10 yard line against the Pats was because of the Patriots safety
>>
>>65476186
You're not even on topic anymore and reverted to autism rage again.

L O L
>>
>>65475814
>Eli
>4 rings
LOL
>>
>>65476156
>wasn't enough to win

But he won the game anyways, and your excuses don't make a difference

>weren't you also raging about the panthers

Nope, that's just your autism funland imagining things again


I wouldn't expect you to comprehend anything I've said in this argument
>>
>>65476216
I clearly addressed where you didn't address anything I've said and where you aren't actually analyzing performance, just expectation

But you've clearly entered the point where you cannot argue anymore and are desperate to get out of here

Not gonna happen buddy. Your autism especially won't allow it
>>
File: al sharpton.gif (2 MB, 275x248) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
al sharpton.gif
2 MB, 275x248
>tfw you demolish another legion of Brady aspies
>>
File: el camino.png (60 KB, 243x141) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
el camino.png
60 KB, 243x141
>>65476167
Neat.
>>
>>65476246
>But he won the game anyways

So do retarded game mangers who luck into elite as fuck Ds like trent dilfer and peypey this year. You however claimed eli was phenomenal that game when he clearly wasn't. He choked twice on game winning drive attempts that game too. He was borderline bad and nothing close to what you say.
>>
>>65476062
salty
>>
>almost 400 posts from a meme thread

this discussion was ended years ago. brady came out on top. everyone who posts under me is a gay faggot
>>
>>65476316
Go ahead and compare Eli's stats from that year to Peyton's this years and Dilfers in 2000

Oh that's right. It completely demolishes your argument and continues to make you look like the complete loser autist you are

>choked twice on game winning drive attempts

I thought game winning drives didn't matter? ;^)

Would you look that, it's you being a hypocritical bitch again :)

Christ, you are so pathetic. You're not even trying anymore. Get your pathetic ass out of here and go tell me mommy the meanie screwed your puny ass into the ground
>>
>>65476387
Game winning drives only matter if your team didn't shit the bed and give up the lead, or it's a tie game and you just bullshit your way to a field goal.
Remember kids


Manning = Montana > Brady
>>
>>65476424
>backtracking

>again

Pack it up kiddo, time for bed. You've officially lost
>>
Do you all you dipshits want a definite point of realization regarding "who's done more with what" / "who's better", etc?

Well, here it is:

How many rings would Brady honestly (and I mean honestly, Pats fans) have without having Belichick as his coach his entire NFL career?

Now...how many would Manning have with the luxury of having Belichick since pretty much from the get-go of his NFL career?
Exactly.

It'd most likely be Brady=maybe a ring
Manning= 5 or 6 rings, easy.

Take everything truly into account, kiddos.
>>
>>65476387
>all these retarded strawmen

I said leading a game winning drive by itself was not indicative of a phenomenal performance.

Russell Wilson was clutch as fuck last year against the packers, more clutch than eli ever was, but no sane person would claim he had a phenomenal performance because they were in the hole they were in because of his previous fuck ups.

Neither is just winning. Just because you do better than terrible game managers like trent and peyepey doesnt make you elite. It just makes you not shit. Eli's stats were not great against the pats nor the 49ers and his single "game winning" drive was due to his defense balling out.


your arguments are ruined once again.
>>
>>65476339
No anon we need to shitpost for ages and ages about this, ok?

MANNING

BRADY

REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
>>
>>65476452
That wasn't me you idiot.

No one thinks game winning drives are the end all be all of anything. That was a shitty strawman you knocked down because I've ass blasted you all night and you got nothing else.
>>
Manning=Marino

Brady=Montana

Marino is ranked higher in history but Montana won more. That's how they'll be remembered
>>
>>65476594
>I said leading a game winning drive by itself

You basically said it was useless. You have such poor communication skills you cannot even communicate such a simple response correctly, or better yet you're just backtracking again which seems more likely

>Russell Wilson was clutch as fuck last year against the Packers

So you're just gonna disregard the awful performance beforehand that actually objectively got them in that hole to begin with, and the onside kick the Seahawks got

Okay, that's not surprising, you've made numerous double standards

It's really no surprise your obviously autistic ass can't elucidate a single comprehensive point

>just because you

Yet you were directly comparing them before

Backtracking again

You literally still are not directly addressing the argument

You are so fucking pathetic. Please leave, I'm getting second hand embarrassment from your autism
>>
>3 TD, 5 INT in 4 Super Bowls

Really? Elway in 4 losses is better than that shit
>>
>>65476644
dumb frogposter

learn to sports
>>
>>65476706
>You basically said it was useless.
No I didn't. Stop knocking down strawmen and conflating me with other people because even they are thinking your points are shit.


>So you're just gonna disregard the awful performance beforehand that actually objectively got them in that hole to begin with, and the onside kick the Seahawks got

I literally said the same fucking thing in post you quoted you retard. If eli had scored more points there wouldn't have been any a need to have game winning drives that were only possible due to his elite defense. Learn to fucking process a thought you imbecile.
>>
>>65476689
>that wasn't me

That's completely irrelevant because you made the double standard regardless you fucking moron

How fucking stupid are you?

No really, how fucking stupid are you?
>>
>>65464847
Manning was always the better regular season quarterback. Brady is still the better postseason QB.
>>
>>65476812
>No I didn't

Yes you did, and you have absolutely no idea what strawman means and you still backtracked on game winning drives you fucking aspie

You still yet again made another absolutely retadred comparison

Wilson and Eli did not have remotely comparable performances and it's another pathetic attempt at grasping at non-existent straws

You're an absolute fucking aspie with no fucking argument

You're so fucking stupid you can't even fathom an original thought so you just slightly revise my insults

You're fucking pathetic

You're still not refuting anything

God you are so laughable. You are so fucking stupid yet do it very knowingly. Worthless
>>
>>65476820
There is no double standard. I never said that game winning drives weren't good. I said they're not enough to offset otherwise mediocre or bad play which described Eli's play against the 49ers and pats perfectly. Once again learn to fucking process thoughts you autistic idiot. This is embrassing.
>>
As a Panthers fan, the one highlight of tonight is knowing that Manning (x2) > Brady
>>
>>65476918
>I never said that game winning drives weren't good

AHAHAHAHAHHA

Holy shit. How much of a blithering aspie can you be? You're not even trying anymore

I'm literally fucking done with you. You are so fucking stupid

You have no argument. You've yet to actually refute mine. You don't even know what yours is.

You're so obsessed with me alone that you're even mimicking me.

I'd recommend you to a fucking witch doctor to fix your shit but you're just a child with no grasp of anything semi-intelligible

Goodbye you pathetic fucking retard. I can't help you out here. This is something you and your parents have to sort out, they clearly haven't spanked you enough.

I'll be reading your response in the archives later this afternoon to see what autism you conjured up in response to this

By the way I won this argument and you literally did not refute a single thing I said. You're an immature embarrassing child that needs help. Help that I'd gladly give but that you need to give to yourself

But I did win this argument and enlighten your stupid mind

You're welcome
>>
>>65476880
Learn to read you moron. Wilson scored 3 TDS in like 3 minutes. The point was to say that being the most clutch performer of all time wasno eveb enough to offset shitty performance for 3 quarters in the same way one flukey drive set up by your elite defense getting a safety isn't enough to make up for scoring 10 points against the worst defense in the league.

You're so stupid it hurts.
>>
>>65477014
Let it go bro you lost
>>
>>65476486
Please, don't address this this, by any means. Just stick you fingers in your ears and go "nah,nah,nah" when someone brings this scenario to your attention.
>>
>>65477002
Looks like I've broken you again so you're not even on topic and reverted to aspiring rage once more. What's that 5 times now?

L O L
>>
>>65477046
You lost, let it go.
>>
Tom Brady is a system quarterback. Not to say he's not good, but he's a system quarterback. Need proof? Matt Cassel. Period.

Without Bill Belichick, Brady is selling life insurance somewhere.

Switch Tom's and Peyton's places, and see what changes. Assuming Bledsoe gets injured, what changes in New England? Little. They go on a tear, and win multiple chips. What changes in Indy/Denver? We never see Brady to Denver, we see Brady out of the league 3 years into his career because the Colts barely held shit together for a SUPERIOR TALENT quarterback.

Brady is good, but nowhere near as good as the all time greats. Manning has been transcendent where he's played. (Full disclosure - I believe he should have hung it up after last year, so this year is a total fluke.)
>>
>>65476486
Well considering Belichick's record as a coach for the pats pre brady I'd say not much changes. I mean, you say this like Manning has just been playing with shit or mediocre teams for the past decade, he's been apart of some of the most stacked teams to ever play in the last decade. I mean, fucking hell did you watch today? He objectively played terrible and was literally carried by his D to a ring.
>>
>>65477065
>>65477036
>resorting to retarded same flagging because he got destroyed all night
Pathetic
>>
>>65477099
Just let it go. It's over now. You lost. Let it go
>>
>>65476760
Elway didn't lose 4 SBs, he only lost 3. You have no idea what the hell you're even talking about. Lost against the Giants, Redskins, and 49ers in the '86, '87, and '89 seasons; won in '97 & '98. If you weren't around to watch them as the happened, please refrain from throwing your incorrect two cents in.
>>
>>65477119
>aspie lying himself because he can't argue without getting destroyed
Even more pathetic.
>>
>>65477152
This is just sad. Stop. Let it go
>>
File: 1452795095628.jpg (29 KB, 599x453) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1452795095628.jpg
29 KB, 599x453
>Hurr durr Manning vs Brady head to head means something

Last I checked, they both played the opposing teams defense. Also, last I checked Manning has never won in Foxboro and Brady is fucking shit in Denver for whatever reason.

Fucking hell you people have no clue what the fuck it is you're talking about. Do you even think about the shit you're typing?
>>
>>65477188
The whole point of that is really to highlight the idiocy of the rings argument

It's the same exact same thing

Or did you just miss the memo that apparently everyone else got?
>>
>>65477137
That's funny considering you became a broncofag in 2012
>>
>>65477172
>can't even admit that he's giving up so he resorts to samenfagging and passive aggressive bullshit
You're fucking spineless on top of everything else too and you want to tell me about being "sad"?

The projection is unreal.
>>
>>65477072
He's played for shit coaching staffs, don't deny that. Dungy was his only decent coach, and he came to Indy after being fired from the Bucs, who won the SB with Gruden immediately after he replaced Dungy, because they knew Dungy couldn't get the Bucs over the hump to actually win a title. Seioously, give me you estimation on how many SB's a Manning/Belicheck combo would have attained if they were a partnership since 2000. I bet there wouldn't have been a 10 year drought between titles with those two, like with Brady.
>>
>>65477229
Not a Broncos fan at all, actually. Just stating facts. You were wrong; don't dodge and deflect. Been watching football since the mid-80's, kiddo, so I can put things into persective better than most on here.
>>
That superbowl definitely hurt Manning's reputation more than it helped him.

>actually being forced to pretend that a 2 point conversion in garbage time was as good as a TD pass
>>
>>65477236
This is getting really sad. Just stop
>>
How the fuck can anyone say Manning > Brady after that shitshow? If anything it shows that Brady = Eli > Peyton
>>
How come everyone I know IRL agrees that Brady had a better career than Peyton but only I only see aspies on /sp/ say otherwise? I don't even live in New England.
>>
>>65477229
Just because I can list every teams' sb wins and losses off the top of my head, don't assume I'm a fan of any specific team you don't know about. I can't help it if I know more about teams' history that I could give a shit about than your bandwagon ass knows about your supposed "favorite team". I'm an all-aroung student of the game.
>>
>>65477326
Probably because you live in a town full of inbred monkeys
>>
>>65477326
Because /sp/ is full of fucking idiots who blindly hate Brady.
>>
>>65477326
Typical 4chan counter culture. Don't worry, like most of /sp/ these peypey fags probably work at walmart and will never amount to more than a wageslave burnout cuck worshiping a Budweiser shill
>>
>>65477301
>Brady = Eli

come on now

just cause Eli is Patriot kryptonite don't mean he's really on Brady's level

he plays different
>>
Brady in 2 Super Bowl losses looked better than Peyton in his 2 wins

...and I'm a Giantsfag
>>
>>65477352
Wouldn't inbred monkeys like the New Orleans country boy more than the California pretty boy?
>>
>>65477379
>t. neet aspie on my mother's computer
>>
>>65477433
Go to sleep, Chris. Your shift starts at 7.
>>
>>65477407
Inbred monkeys flock with like minded people

Hence the correlation
>>
>>65477405
Yeah

You really are a giant fag!
>>
>>65477446
I'd tell you go to sleep but it's obvious that's more determined by how much you labor through your rolls of fat to tire you out
>>
>>65477405
peyton in 9 seasons ending in one and dones because of his awful fucking coach looked better than brady in 9 seasons ending in whatever

peyton does it all for 10 years, doesnt win superbowl. does bare minimum for one year, team wins for him. its poetic justice and he deserves it.

tony dungy elected into HOF because he rode the best QB of all time to a bunch of wins and then got outcoached EVERY SINGLE YEAR in the playoffs IN ONE GAME. rofl. had to get a nigger coach in the hall though. just had to.
>>
>>65477468
0/10
>>
>>65477326
It seems to me that most of these Manning fans are the same type of people who love NASCAR and genuinely think Dale Jr is the best driver.
>>
>>65477326
That's usually the opposite where I am

Maybe because I don't live in an unedcuated shithole

Tomato tomato
>>
>yfw Manning is literally a better playoff quarterback than Brady
http://www.footballperspective.com/the-best-playoff-quarterbacks-in-the-super-bowl-era/
>>
File: knockknock.jpg (70 KB, 600x400) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
knockknock.jpg
70 KB, 600x400
>>65464847
>>
>>65477581
If only he acted like it.
>>
>>65477581
>January 2014

Peyton statistically has gotten way worse while Brady didn't. Also that article holds sacks against a QB....really?
>>
>SB 49
>Brady against a #1 defense
>still posts 28 points, the highest against the defense in that season
>has a career 2nd half comeback
>4 touchdowns
>4 super bowls

>SB 50
>Peyton shitting the bed
>0 touchdowns
>carried by his defense again
>Broncos probably would've played better with Brock
>2 super bowls

I can imagine only a fucking moron would agree with you, OP.
>>
>>65477671
So why wouldn't you agree with him?

Because I can't possibly imagine how you could argue 3-2
>>
>>65477072
Yes. The last two sentences of what you wrote is correct. Manning had next to nothing to do with today's win. But that's not what I'm talking about. Please answer my original question honestly:

After his ring today, how many rings do you honestly think that would have given Peyton if he was paired with Belichick since 2000?

Why won't any of you Pats fans answer this simple question honestly? That was rhetorical, I admit, I know the reason why.
>>
>>65477682
I think patsfags would rather have 4 super bowls than a 3-2 record against a retired QB, m8

isn't that record kind of dumb anyways? quarterbacks don't face each other. That record is completely dependent on how well defenses are, which the Broncos have had a great defense over the past few years
>>
>>65477703
Tony Dungy is no slouch really. Plus Peyton had more HOF receivers with Indy
>>
File: 1419805763374.jpg (18 KB, 510x476) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1419805763374.jpg
18 KB, 510x476
>>65477682
I'm cringing at how obsessed bronc/peycucks are with that 3-2 record. Do you seriously think that's a good substitute over actually winning 3+ super bowls? Do you think that 3-2 record is what people will be talking about 30 years from now?
>>
File: feeling agitated.png (555 KB, 811x870) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
feeling agitated.png
555 KB, 811x870
>>65475938

>cheating allegations
>allegations

>a claim or assertion that someone has done something illegal or wrong, typically one made without proof.
>>
>>65477742
It's the only argument we need, Sean
>>
>>65477742
Joe Montana had a losing record against Phil Simms in the playoffs...

Brett Favre had a losing record against Troy Aikman in the playoffs....
>>
>>65477720
>quarterbacks don't face each other

And quarterbacks don't play every single position on the team so there's really no point in bragging about rings then getting butthurt about head to head

Objectively speaking, per the 3-2, Peyton is better than Brady in the postseason
>>
>>65477724
No slouch, that's why I said Dungy was the only decent coach. He's no Belichick, though. Agreed?
I mean, shit, Peyton took the Colts to the SB with Jim Caldwell as the fucking coach!

He did have HOF receivers, circa 2003-2006 (Marvin & Reggie). But only a short window of both those. I'll admit, those were squandered years for titles. Brady also had Welker, so he can't count for Manning over Brady (esp. when Brady had him in his prime, Manning didn't). Manning never had Randy Moss in a record-setting-season prime like Brady. What was it, throw it off your back foot for Brady randomly 50 yards down the field, and Moss will come down with it 90%+ of the time. 27 reg. season TD's, I believe?

Also, Manning never had the greatest TE I've seen in my lifetime (Gronk). D. Thomas was shit this postseason, he had more drops than catches. Brady, over the past decade, has all-in-all had just as good, but likely better, receiving corps than Manning.
>>
>>65477853
Nobody's comparing Montana to Simms

Nobody's comparing Favre to Aikman

Dilfer has more rings than Marino

Eli has two more rings than Marino

Flacco has more rings than Marino

etc. etc.
>>
>>65477857
Tom Brady is .710 in the post season. Peyton is .519.

>>65477853
And no one cares about Troy Aikman and Phil Simms compared to Joe Montana and Brett Farve, which just proves my point.
>>
>>65477893
Think the Aikman/Simms post was agreeing with you
>>
>>65477893
>Tom Brady is .710 in the postseason

Tom Brady's teams are, just like Tom doesn't literally go head to head with Peyton

>and no one cares about Aikman and Simms and

Well people care about Peyton-Brady and there's much more to that than the other two you mentioned, so no it doesn't remotely prove your point
>>
>>65477926
Then you agree that the 3-2 record is dumb? Since it's not Brady vs Peyton, it's the Patriots vs Broncos.
>>
I know Peyton's team won, but this game won't ever be shown again because their just weren't any highlights by Peyton. Elway's last game he looked good
>>
File: zxc.jpg (111 KB, 314x475) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
zxc.jpg
111 KB, 314x475
>>65477857
>Objectively speaking, per the 3-2, Peyton is better than Brady in the postseason
>Objectivity is independent of context

Go read a book nigger.
>>
>>65477942
In the same way that the rings argument is dumb and that it is team v team, yes
>>
>>65477724
>After his ring today, how many rings do you honestly think that would have given Peyton if he was paired with Belichick since 2000?

And still, no one will answer this question. On either side; I don't even have a horse in this race. I just think it's an important thing to consider. Am I typing in fucking Japanese and I just don't realize it; that's why no one will answer me? I hate when people play politics and don't answer a question directly. I swear most fans are like fundies with their dogmatic ignorance.
>>
How can you even say Peyton > Brady when Peyton proved to be worse than his fucking backup? Lmao peyfags will always be delusional.
>>
>>65477956
That's one of many definitions of objectivity that you just cherrypicked to make a stupid insult. Congrats, dummy
>>
>>65477960
Would Peyton have had to play outside in New England and Brady indoors?
>>
>>65478007
Completely random, all things being equal, kind of shit. Say Brady was drafted by the Chargers and Manning the Texans, or pick any two random teams you wish, just that Mainning had Belichick since 2000.
>>
>>65478038
Belichick wasn't really a good head coach though until Brady started. Good coach yes but not head coach
>>
>>65477979

Yea, lets just ignore context in sports. Flacco is GOAT
>>
>>65478038
>drafted by the Texans

Peyton was drafted in '98, and the Texans didn't exist until 2002
>>
>>65477299
Yeah I know. Your spineless autisitc self is the so pathetic you're stuck repeating the same thing over and over again.
>>
>>65464847
>0 (zero) touchdowns
>>
>>65478202
I know that, that was just me exemplifying the whole 'pick any two random teams for each respective QB'. Titans and Bengals work for you?
>>
>2 less appearances
>same amount of losses
>double the wins
>defensive player winning MVP
>>
Any Denver fan will tell you that Elway > Manning.
>>
Manningfest Destiny > everyone else
>>
>>65470893
>broncos create agreement to pay two players late due to funding of a new stadium 20 years ago

>th..they cheaters too....
>>
>>65475509
i wouldn't call one circus catch marching
>>
>>65478478
It's just Clot cucks, they stole their team and now have no problem rooting for other teams. Indianapolis should be nuked
>>
Could teboq have won that owl with that defence?
>>
>>65464847
Peyton Manning is a terrible playoff QB.

>3-1 against Brady and Belichick

How this happened is a mystery to me, but I watched every one of those games and the reason definitively wasn't Manning for all except the 2006 AFCCG.
>>
>>65479882
it's almost like football is a team sport and it's difficult to pass the ball in the winter in january and playoff wins are mostly determined by your run game/defense
>>
It's a contest of Manning and Montana now.

Not even up for debate. Brady can fight for 3rd
>>
>>65479902
Manning played in a dome most of his career. All those one and dones were in a dome.
>>