Am I a Hall-of-Famer?
Why or why not?
Thanks! (My dad asked. He say my big brother Peyton is getting in but isn't sure about me :/)
in terms of standing out consistently relative to your peers, absolutely not.
But you've been a stalwart for one of the most historic teams in the largest market, you've been at least good for a very long time, and you got it done in the most clutch of times. I can't stand your fanboys or your team, but you probably get the nod along with huge ben. i've got no problem with it.
>fulfilled the prophecy
>implying booty blasting the Pats both times he made it to the Superb Owl isn't the grandest acomplishment of all time
If Joe Namath did than you definitely should be. Better stats and more rings than Namath. You cucked Brady twice with one of them being 18-1. If you win a third one than it is a lock, but I still think you will have no problem getting in.
If you have to use the Joe Namath argument, you probably don't have a very good case.
Eli's never won a playoff game when the opponent scores more than 20 points, he just isn't that good of a QB. He might get in because of those two seasons, but he's not a HoF talent.