If there's such an issue with Manhwa and RWBY on /a/, why

>why not make manhwa and RWBY boards?
Because /trash/ already exists.

>>404232
Because it's already on /co/ nigga
And I wouldn't call /wsr/ and /his/ useless

>>404258
The entirety of Roosterteeth is pushed into one general and the manga pours into /a/. A web series or some other shit board would make sense.

>>404241
/thread

>>404266
I would love a board for Webshows/Webcomics so I have a dedicated place to discuss Homestar Runner, Jaltoid, RWBY, Dragon Ball Z Abridged, Let's Plays, Video Game High School, The Guild, Doctor Horrible's Sing Along Blog, The Program, Bojack Horseman, 7p10e, High Maintenance, Red Letter Media, Foldable Human, House of Cards, and the like.

>>404284
And manhwa could even go there because a majority of them are webcomics, it's killing two birds with one stone. This would also help /v/ with all the videogame reviewers, Death Battles, and all that shit.

It's honestly not a bad idea. Do mods ever actually listen to /qa/ though?

>>404293
No, they don't.

But actually getting things done isn't my goal of posting here. I'm just here to have fun and say ideas.

Just contain your weebshit on /a/, you weaboo faggot!!

>>404232
>pointless boards
delete /a/

>>404232
Because thre is already is boards for this shit. They would be
>>>/co/
>>>/trash/
>>>/b/

>>404266
The manga doesn't pour into /a/, shitposters are trying to force it

>>404460
Read
>>404266
The entirety of Rooster Teeth is pushed into one general and as much as you don't want to admit it, there are people on /a/ who like RWBY and want to discuss the manga. You did link /b/ and /trash/ though, so you probably didn't want an actual response.

>>404232
RWBY is RoosterTeeth garbage made by reddit-tier hacks. FUCK no it doesn't need to be on /a/.

The autism against Korean manga is mostly undeserved though.

File: 1441059037471.png (97KB, 600x476px) Image search: [Google]

97KB, 600x476px

>>404487
>waaaah I don't like it so this manga doesn't belong on /a/!

>>404491
How is this any different from Frogposting? Other than obviously not having a frog in it, you know what I meant.

>>404491
Read between the lines, anon.

RoosterTeeth = American
Reddit-tier = SJW friendly trash

Stop being an idiot.

>>404496
Does "SJW friendly" mean "Has a black person in it"?

>>404472
That would be because /co/ is shit and general hell. A new board won't fix that, because it's users will come straight from /co/. As such, it will also be just generals and generals and oh yea, more generals. What a fucking pointless useless board. Generals are bad and need to be banned

That like 1% of /a/ doesn't matter. The amount of /a/nons who care about RWBY is very small, even more so after the shit /co/ and RWBYfags pulled last time. The only people who want to talk about is shitposters and /co/. On-top of that, they won't talk about the manga, they will /always/ talk about its garbage source. That shit belongs on fucking /co/ and the mods/janny shouldn't have to babysit the thread to keep them in check. Allowing it on /a/ and it will most likely turn into a general as well, since most people who like it are generalfags as well. It just simply doesn't belong on /a/, it already has a board for it that suits it better and it doesn't need its own board

There is no need for a web series board either, there isn't enough interest in it. Plus, its stupid and other places it would fit better. That should actually belongs on either /co/ or /tv/. I redirected you to /b/ and /trash/, you idiot, because they are catch all boards. I know you might be a newfag, but I'd expect you to at least know that /b/ isn't a porn dumping edgy ground, its a catch all for all the loose content that doesn't belong elsewhere. And /trash/ is the offtopic board. Both serve the exact purpose you want without making a almost dead general board that will be filled with advertising

>>404496
>stop being an idiot
I'm not the one against manga being posted on /a/.

>>404499
>That like 1% of /a/ doesn't matter
Stopped reading right there. The majority of users on /RWBYg/ say they only come to /co/ for RWBY.

>>404498
Of course not.

>>404500
If I created a comic, should it automatically be /a/ worthy? Tell me why or why not in detail.

>>404504
>If I created a comic, should it automatically be /a/ worthy? Tell me why or why not in detail.
You don't live in Japan and it wouldn't published in a magazine or distributed through official sources. Same reason RWBY wasn't /a/ even though it had non-hentai doujins from Japan.

>>404504
I don't have enough information to answer your question. Do you live in Japan?

>>404510
Ding ding ding! Looks like we have someone who can use basic logic here.

>>404511
No, I'm American and so are my values and themes.

>>404513
Then your comic doesn't belong on /a/.

Thank you for that non-sequitur. RWBY's comic is made in Japan by a Japanese Man for the Japanese audience and circulates in Japanese Manga magazines.

>>404513
Are you retarded? RWBY has an official manga in Ultra Jump by Miwa Shirow. It doesn't even follow the series.

>>404503
I seriously doubt most /a/nons owuld actually go into /co/ and on top of that, into a general. Unless they are generalfags, there is a low chance of that happening. And generalfags don't matter at all and all need to be banned, so again, they don't matter

The number was an extreme estimate, but even then, the number is small. On fucking top of that, unless your stupid general gets thousands of users daily saying they came from /a/ to /co/ to rwby, they don't fucking matter. 4chan is a millions user website and /a/ is the 4th highest posting speed board. 50 users saying they came from /a/ isn't even a fucking minority, they are a drop in an ocean. I doubt you didn't read the rest and just decided to ignore it, because writing anything about it would discredit you

File: 1452113180237.gif (232KB, 314x311px) Image search: [Google]

232KB, 314x311px

>>404516
>>404517
But the studio the franchise exists under is American.

>>404520
Nobody listen to this dumbass. He doesn't know what he's talking about. His doubts have been noted and will be promptly forgotten about. Nobody cares about his view of the world. It doesn't reflect reality.

>>404525
That isn't relevant.

>>404526
>OH NOOO this guy is right lets fucking pretend like hes a retard and ignore every point he says in hopes people listen to me instead
Fucking /q/babby

>>404520
>no no! I know what all /a/nons are like because muh board culture! They definitely wouldn't go to /co/!
No, stop with your fucking bullshit and realize not everyone in a board is the same. Stop thinking everyone who goes into a single general is the same kind of person, they're all different.

There are tons of people that watch webseries and things like podcasts on /v/ and /co/. Why would you care if the board was dead anyway?

>>404535
Nobody listen to this whiny pot kettle black caller. They're a fool and they don't know what they're talking about.

File: 1451436488171.jpg (48KB, 512x384px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 512x384px

>>404525
That has literally never been relevant in deciding whether something was /a/ or not.

>>404537
>Why would you care if the board was dead anyway?
Why would we need to make a waste of bandwidth for a small loud minority who exist in other boards already perfect fine?

We don't need anymore boards. On top of that we don't need any more boards that would attract retards to the site

>>404549
>wah wah I just wouldn't! It would make things bad!
That's your argument? Anime has already brought retards to this site.

>>404558
Wew lad, is shitposting, quote misuse and strawmanning the only thing you can do to support your arguments?

>>404568
So you have no argument.

>>404548
>>404529
Fair enough. Just know that the average /a/utist is way more unreasonable than me and try to keep it off the board on principle alone.

>>404572
I don't care. The average 4chan poster is a /pol/ or a /b/ user. The average internet user only uses facebook and nothing else. The average human has no access to the internet and the average mammal isn't a human.

File: 1336961093102.png (25KB, 150x140px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 150x140px

>>404569
No, that would be you. Your only argument is that it should be on /a/ because you said it should and that we need new boards because you think they are needed. What a great argument

>>404572
The point of the thread was so /a/utists would stop complaining about manhwa and RWBY on /a/ by moving them to a new kind of board where both could go.
/co/ hates RWBY and shit like Homestuck.
/a/ hates manhwa and the RWBY manga.
/v/ hates podcasts, death battles, and other gamer culture sites.

>>404582
The OP didn't suggest "Web Original Content" actually. That was >>404284 but I agree that this would be a fine board that would just be shitpost central.

>>404580
The manga belongs on /a/ because it's a fucking manga, retard.
We don't NEED a new board, but it would be possible to put some of the hated shit from other boards into one where they all could go without being an off topic kind.

>>404585
Every board is a shitpost central when it first starts. There is a whole board made entirely for one little girl's cancerous cartoon and it doesn't get shitposted.

I was under the impression we were talking about web original content from the beginning. It's not a bad idea

>>404582
>/v/ hates podcasts, death battles, and other gamer culture sites.
All of those need to be straight up fucking banned, not catered to.

>manhwa
Almost every single one of those threads deserve the shitposting for having such garbage OPs. They are always 'haha what superior manhwa r u weading /a/ :^)". They deserve it. You could make a thread for Witch Hunter trying to talk about it without the mention of manhwa and it won't get shitposted. You know why? Because it's OP isn't retarded and bait

>rwby manga
Majority of the fanbase is /co/, majority of /a/ doesn't like it or its fanbase, it has a general on /co/ and people will just talk about its source even on /a/. Stays on /co/

>/co/ hates RWBY and shit like Homestuck.
I don't use /co/, so I wouldn't know. But if both of these thread types get shitposted to hell by /co/mblr users, then they just don't get allowed on the site except on the random catch them all boards. 4chan doesn't need to hold topics for everything. It's primary a nerdy hobby and japanese centric site

>>404591
Its not wanted not just for not being a manga, fucking retard. We don't need a board for pointless shit not wanted on boards. Also, there is already a fucking board for that that Hiro made recently. It's called for /trash/. It /is/ the offtopic board

>>404602
>wah I don't like it so it should be banned!
All you've done is cry about shit without providing actual arguments.

And regular manhwa threads were actually deleted on /a/.

>>404607
It's not entirely for things people don't want, it's an actual board that all this shit I mentioned people didn't like would fit.

/trash/ isn't an option due to its rules that allow shitposting and furry shit. If /trash/ is such a great board, why not delete /a/ and put all anime discussion in it?

>>404613
>podcasts
E-celebs don't fucking belong

>death battles
Don't get me fucking started on power level shit. It's some of the most autistic retard shit. The stuff shouldn't be on /v/ in the first place and actually belongs better on /trash/ or /b/. Unless you made a gaytube board, it wouldn't belong in any other board

>gamer culture
Board meta. On every board meta discussion is fucking bad and cancerous as hell. Even on fucking /a/. That shit doesn't deserve its own board. It needs to be banned and only allowed on an odd occasion

>regular
So generals? Link me to some so I can pick on their OPs

>>404625
None of those things even have anything really in common. You are just going to make a board that is just going to be generals. What's the fucking point? There is no need for it and it'll just breed more types of shitposting and bring in retards for those generals who will then treat the rest of the site like those generals

>If /trash/ is such a great board, why not delete /a/ and put all anime discussion in it?
Because you are a fucking idiot. What a nice line of text saying 'i have no argument so lets try and make a argument that holds no points or value in the current discussion SURELY THAT WILL WORK IM A GENIUS". Webcartoons, webtoons and manhwa aren't a entire proper functioning boards worth of content, you moron. It would all end up stuck in singular threads, that while shitposted at first, would end up being left alone by everyone else. Just like they already are on their respective boards, except manhwa!

>>404628
>they don't belong
How can you not fucking see that you are providing no arguments? Let me put it simply: let's say /co/, /a/, and /v/ had random furry posts (of characters related to their respective board) sprinkled around the boards and everyone else hated it. Should those furry posts have stayed in these boards or would making a new one to contain them all be better?

https://desustorage.org/a/thread/135344398/#135344398
https://desustorage.org/a/thread/134202542/#134202542
And you have no idea what a general is if you think there has ever been a manhwa one. By regular I meant non-shitposting ones.

>>404637
>What's the fucking point? There is no need for it and it'll just breed more types of shitposting and bring in retards for those generals who will then treat the rest of the site like those generals
You actually think this is valid?
>it will create plebs!
No, it fucking won't you idiot. The generals in /co/ do absolutely nothing to /a/ no matter how much you think they do. You're hung up on what your average /a/utist tells you and you ignore basic logic.

>Because you are a fucking idiot. What a nice line of text saying 'i have no argument so lets try and make a argument that holds no points or value in the current discussion SURELY THAT WILL WORK IM A GENIUS"
So you have literally no counterargument? Got it.
>It would all end up stuck in singular threads, that while shitposted at first, would end up being left alone by everyone else. Just like they already are on their respective boards, except manhwa!
So why does this hurt you again? /v/ threads that I mentioned always get shitposted and the generals on /co/ are absolute cancer. If generals weren't allowed in the hypothetical new board, there would be absolutely no problem.

>>404638
>make a new board for something incredibly small
No, you don't retard. I like how you used furrys to try and make your argument. If those furry posts leave their respective threads and/or are talking about furryshit, they get banned. Simple as that. Furryshit is against the rules

>mahnwa thread
Again, shit OP. Every thread of all kinds that does this deserves a fucking ban and to be shitposted into hell. A manhwa thread made as a catchall for manhwa discussion deserves bans. You don't see people going 'Manga Threads what manga r u reading? :^)". No, they make a thread for a certain manga and talk about it and then that thread extends to others. My Witch Hunter point goes here.

ToG isn't a manhwa, it's a webcomic. Webcomics that aren't Japanese sit on very fucking thin ice and can get removed at any time. They, technically, are not allowed. /a/ is for japanese stuff, the other stuff is allowed on the exception of the mods

>>404655
So you want furry generals on each board instead of a furry board? What?
A board for all of internet original content isn't any smaller than /vp/ or /m/.

>You don't see people going 'Manga Threads what manga r u reading? :^)"
We have One page threads.

>Again, shit OP
And what about the second one? A perfectly fine thread. Even the non deleted manhwa threads have actual discussion deleted and shitposting left in.

>>404672
What? I went with the assumtion you were going with furry characters in a series. In which case, discussion of those characters do not leave the threads for that series and if discussion of said characters enters furry land, again, gets banned

One page threads need to be banend as fucking well. It's just a general thread a this point filled with the same people wanking each other and sourcefags. Same as the 3x3 threads. OPT still aren't a catch-all manga thread. The point of them was to post really really really good pages from manga to show off the art work and increase interest in said manga. They are different to 'Manhwa thread'. Again, OPT still need to be banned. And please reread my last line, Tower of God isn't a fucking manhwa, its a webcomic. The OP for that isn't actually that bad as long as he removed that first line and reworded the rest to not make him sound like such a faggot

>>404701
I actually thought we had a furry board. Then let's change that to something like MLP which was hated by most of /co/. No one liked it but that didn't stop people from posting it. Because no one liked it, it was moved to its own board and became a bannable offense if posted elsewhere. No one tolerates anything I mentioned before (manhwa, RWBY, Homestuck, /v/ culture shit like podcasts) and almost always shitpost their threads or posts related to them. There is literally no reason not to have this moved to a new board. It's got plenty of shit to discuss (much more than /gd/, /f/, /n/, /t/, and a lot others) and would keep it away from all the boards that don't like it. You can complain all day about how it brings in more cancer, but that's an absolutely ridiculous fallacy.

>One page threads need to be banend as fucking well
But they aren't. They are almost exactly like those manhwa threads except the OP disguises itself from mods.
>Tower of God isn't a fucking manhwa, its a webcomic
So is fucking OPM but that's allowed.

>>404729
We've /never/ had a furry board, except that one time moot was god and thought it'd be funny to make a furry board and then a few months down the line ban every single ip that posted on it. MLP wasn't pushed off to its own board because /co/ didn't like it. It's because mlpfags were spamming their shit everywhere, were obnoxious, annoying and had to force their shit everywhere. They were no different to the fucking furries. They shouldn't of even gotten their own board, but for some reason moot gave them their own board instead of giving them the furry treatment. No one fucking knows why moot did it, he was probably a slight ponyfag himself.

Have you ever actually thought why people don't want certain topics on boards? It's not because people don't fucking like that topic, I can tell you that. It's because the majority of the people who talk about those topics are fucking annoying, obnoxious and the board plain just doesn't like them. /a/ doesn't want Narutofags because its fanbase are newshits and are plain annoying. /a/ doesn't want mananimefags, despite watching a lot of it themselves, don't want those people because they are normally new to the medium, watched eva, cowboy bebop and then a seasonal anime and then went 'anime is dead its all moeshit'. /lit/ wouldn't want twilight and the like because the people who read it and talk about it are underage girls with their heads up their arse. If /v/ wasn't just newfags, they wouldn't allow CoD, because its played and talked about mainly by edgy 12 year olds. There is no reason to give any of these safe haven boards for them. 4chan doesn't need to cater to everything. These topics already have better places on the internet to talk about them and communities that would fit the discussion better. The only argument for your boards is 'i want to talk about x free of shitposting despite the number of people wanting to do so are very small'. There doesn't need to be a board for fucking everything.

cont.

>>404835

>You can complain all day about how it brings in more cancer, but that's an absolutely ridiculous fallacy.
4chan history says otherwise. What has the creation of /v/, /pol/, /vg/ and /r9k/ done to the site? Bring in newshits. What happens on one board affects the others because people crossboard, that's how it works. The creation of new boards brings in new users just for them. People advertise them off-site, people use those boards and then believe the rest of the site is the same as them. They then proceed to refuse to lurk because they never did on their other board and then shit up everything. You are asking for boards for shit that's considered garbage on their already respective board with retard fanbases. A new board won't suddenly make it the pinnacle of quality, it will be the opposite. It will be garbage and its userbase will be retarded as hell filled with generals. Those little retards will one day use other boards and will shit them up with their retard culture because they don't know any better. You can call it a fallacy all you fucking want, but the sites history says that fallacy's is in full fucking effect always. The website should only add boards for nerdy hobbies and japanese shit in the first place

OPT are fucking image dump threads with occasional discussion. x thread is a lite general thread made for discussion. They are two different things, but they are both as cancerous as each other. The only reason OPT is allowed is because its a general and the mods are too fucking lazy to clean up after their mess of them

OPM is a fucking Japanese webcomic, not a korean one. Reread what I fucking said. /a/ is for Japanese shit, everything else is allowed on exception. Korean webcomics AREN'T ALLOWED. They aren't manhwa

>>404835
So your entire argument boils down to "this fanbase is so cancerous and everyone in this fanbase is the same"? We like to joke about how you're the greatest user ever if you're an oldfag, but you need to shut the fuck up and realize you being here so long has devoid you of all common sense. Shitposting Naruto threads was just the cool thing to do at the time, the fanbase was no worse than Bleach, One Piece, or any other shonen shit.

> 'i want to talk about x free of shitposting despite the number of people wanting to do so are very small'
There are at least 3 other suggestions for a web content board on /qa/ right now, and there have been several threads on /v/, /a/, and /co/ that would relate to a board like this. It would be no smaller than the other boards I mentioned.

>4chan history says otherwise.
No it fucking doesn't. You've connected the dots in all the wrong places. /v/, /pol/, and /r9k/ were created when 4chan was fairly small. It's not because of the content of these boards, it's because the site got fucking bigger.

>The website should only add boards for nerdy hobbies and japanese shit in the first place
So you basically want it to still be your sekrit club? Get the fuck out and learn that things change.

File: sekrit club hurr.jpg (187KB, 1012x471px) Image search: [Google]

187KB, 1012x471px

>>404874
>this fanbase is so cancerous and everyone in this fanbase is the same
No, it's that those fanbases are mostly filled with cancerous retards who are incredibly loud and will quickly over take the board. The only reason fucking /a/ isn't like every other anime forum is because of who originally inhabited the fucking site. They were mostly people from the old internet generation and they had particular sets of culture. That culture rooted itself here and as a result the site for a long time was anti-outsider and 'elitist' until newfags swarmed and the oldfags left getting sick of them as a result every board except /a/ losing that culture. /a/'s usage of that culture got twisted as well.

>Shitposting Naruto threads was just the cool thing to do at the time, the fanbase was no worse than Bleach, One Piece, or any other shonen shit.
No it wasn't. The other shonenshit fanbases were annoying, but Naruto was worse. Naruto was the most entry level one there was and had one of the worst fanbases in existent in its prime. Allowing it on /a/ was the same as saying to those drooling retards you are welcomed here, post more, act like a mindless idiot here. At it's prime there probably was a cool factor to banning it, but its fanbase was god awful and it was banned to prevent them from posting here, shitting the place up.

/qa/ doesn't determine how fucking much something is wanted at all. Most threads are made by a small minority screaming loudly. Again, there isn't that big of a userbase for webshit nor is there any reason for it. That shit already has their own respective boards it belongs on and /trash/

No, its because of the content of those boards. The size of the site was a factor, but the biggest reason was the content of those boards and what the userbase of the people outside of 4chan for those were like

4chan was never inclusive and had a unique culture and way of doing things. It never needed change and that was only wanted by newfags who didn't like it

>>404886
>I'm an oldfag, I know everything about board culture and how all anons should act
I bet you call out all the newfags in every thread because you can tell by the pixels too. Why did it take me this long to realize you're one of these kinds of retards? You're a crotchety oldfag that shits up boards more than newfags ever did under the guise of "preserving board culture".

>>404896
>I'm an newfag, I know notihng about the site, but I think the site should cater to me
I bet you call out everyone who calls you a idiot, because you think the site should be welcoming to everything. Why did it take me this long to realize you're one of these kinds of retards? You're a upset newfag that shits up boards more than shitposters ever did under the guise of '4chan should be inclusive and cater to everything i want'

File: 1447659055907.png (104KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

104KB, 600x600px

>>404902
Original, but no. I've been here for years, but I've spent time on other sites and I've actually lived my life like a normal person. I don't feel the need to flaunt oldfag status like it means my opinion is more valid.

I think it would be best if you spent more time around other sites and learned about the shit you're talking about instead of eating up what your average anon says.
>generals cause newfags to act newfaggy
No, they're the exact same posters as they were before they went into the general. There is no magic process that changes how you think posting works.
>new boards bring in newfags
No, the majority of the users of new boards are the same people here who were talking about this shit before it became a board. Even then, the people who came to 4chan specifically for that board will have most likely adapted before they even think of going to a different one.
>the naruto fanbase is worse than bleach and one piece
No, the average Naruto fan reads all 3 of them. Shonen is literally made for young teens.

File: 1450373578362.gif (1MB, 400x225px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 400x225px

>>404886
https://desustorage.org/_/search/filename/sekrit%20club%20hurr.jpg/
>complains about posting from a phone
>complains about manga threads on /a/
>shitposts when someone sauces shit
>muh reddit is invading!
And what a fucking surprise, you ARE an "oldfag" who makes boards worse by preaching board culture all the time. I knew you were bad, but holy fucking shit it's worse than I thought. Tell me, what did RWBY do to you to make you this anal ravaged?

>>404929
Not the same person as the other one, I just keep the filename as my image downloader is set to keep the original filenames

File: 1428940330276.png (109KB, 500x397px) Image search: [Google]

109KB, 500x397px

>>404932
Sure thing, buddy. On a scale of 1-10, how much does this image trigger you?

File: 1447885803622.png (114KB, 753x479px) Image search: [Google]

114KB, 753x479px

>>404936
Keep trying anon, I'm sure one day you'll stop hating yourself and find something better to do with your time that isn't shitposting

>>404941
>>404936

You are both shitposting and dumb.

>>404886


When the fuck will /a/ remember that 4chan is a shithole of losers and idiots talking about irrelevant, unimportant crap--not some glorious legacy that needs to be defended?

>>404943
Because there is thought pattern and environment difference. Old 4chan is a sporadic fun environment with its own unique culture and way of doing things. People came to discuss things and had fun doing so. Everything was for the moment. New 4chan is hardly fun, most people don't like being here but only are because the rest of the net is shit, the culture of the site is warped and in general it is no different to the rest of the internet and lost all uniqueness. People don't come for fun discussion, they come for shitposting, memes and le edgy anonmouse. Things are done with a attempt to be the next biggest things, even if its forced, rather than for the moment

There is actually a good way to simplify this. Old 4chan users came for fun enjoyable discussion and only ever threw pebbles into the ocean and enjoyed doing so. New 4chan users come for memespouting, shitposting, discourage discussion unless its in some eternal general and hate the idea of being a pebble and constantly try to be the biggest boulder thrown into a pond. At first glance, the former is the same as the latter, but its actually different. The biggest one is the former actually enjoyed their time here

>>404955
So basically you got too old and jaded for 4chan and now you're blaming everyone else for it? Okay.