Something freestanding. If you are willing to spend enough to get a hille and only need to accommodate one person, definitely go for the soulo. Tell us more about what kind of stuff you aee going to do in your tent. Don't just drop the money on a hille if you don't have some plans to use it fairly extensively, unless you just have too much money.
>>682968 No, they're a niche thing. Also as quickly mobile, discreet, light two-people shelters they're shit. They're not versatile enough, not as sturdy as a standard tent, awkward to pitch, and the circle shape is a misuse of space. Not to mention they're not lighter. Any igloo-type dome tent is better.
>>682968 The tipi is just more durable IMO. Their shape makes them more resistant to wind/snow than a lot of tents ( wall tents specifically come to mind ) and are usually easier to transport. Even without the stove ( which lets you cook meals for the three/four of you if you are gentle with it ) some tipi companies make their tipi with the stove jack built into the center pole.
"If I'm going to buy something for camping I want it to be able to meet all my potential needs" is my mentality. This includes offering shelter to folks on the trail ( if you place your gear outside you SHOULD be able to fit three people ( including yourself ) inside ) if unexpected storms hit, being able to be used in a bug-out situation, being able to be used in all four seasons, etc. A tipi with a small stove fits those needs much better than a tent given tents often times are not built to accommodate heat/cooking sources in your shelter.
>>683105 A tipi from Seek Outside weighs 4 lbs, 2 oz. Their medium sized titanium wood stove with 5.5 feet of pipe is about 2 lbs, 4 oz ( Weight Stove body 20 ounces, Damper/legs/Storage bag 6 ounces, Pipe 2 ounces per ft ) which is surprisingly light. Your total weight for your HEATED shelter is about 6.6 oz ( assuming my math is right ) leaving you able to still pack a tarp/sleeping sack to sleep on and I bet you would be a little over 10 lbs if you packed a bugnet. If you're going on a long term camping trip or bugging out it really isn't a bad option and in the event you really don't know where you will be tomorrow wouldn't you want to be somewhat prepared for the cold?
>>683105 Forgot to mention that you have the option of having a "screen door" sewn into your tipi. If you are really insistent on using a tent you can buy a tent/stove combo for under $800, fitting 2 people ( four without stove, see https://store.seekoutside.com/cimarron-med-stove-bundle/ ) and still being light weight.
>>683133 I've yet to make the hike with one myself but I intend to soon ( buying with my tax refund from either Seek Outside or Kifaru ) and I've been told carrying one isn't as different from a tent as one would think. I do know from experience that they are very nice to be in; very roomy, very warn with the stove going in cold climates, etc.
Your pack weight isn't terrible though, as I said in an earlier post a four man tipi from Seek Outside w/ a medium sized wood stove is 6 lbs, 6 oz ( accidentally said 6.6 oz on original post ( >>683123 but meant 6 lbs, 6 oz ) so you really are not adding too much weight.
Its 6,000mm on the floor and 5,000mm for the walls and is 100g heaver but has actual space to sit up in. its downside is that its very expensive.
In terms of "I don't know where I'll be tomorrow" being cool with using a Bivvi would be the best just for weight and being able to be hidden. Weight super important for tents/sleeping bags because they are the bulk of your weight.
I amazes me how much the car camping mentality affects people and all the extra gear they think they need to bring. Taking a 7lbs shelter for one person is beyond a joke. You need to think about what a shelter needs to be and then work from there:
>Portable >Waterproof/well ventilated >Keep out bugs
Beyond that everything else is "extra features" that just compromise one of the above.
>>682894 I never said anything about car camping. The links I posted mention nothing about car camping. My mentality is that he would carry it all in a backpack. I don't drive; I refuse to simply because I can walk most places and take public transport to get anywhere else I need to go. I respect your opinions regarding whether or not you "compromise" taking a tipi over a tent but I just wanted to set you straight.
That said, very impressive little tent. I could see this being an awesome gift to some of my single friends.
>>683159 A tipi has literally no advantage over a tent other than being readily heated if you carry a stove with you At 8lbs You still need a sleeping mat and sleeping bag A much smaller and easier to carry entire sleeping system with either a tent, mat, and bag or hammock, top and under quilt, and tarp will weigh in far less than just the tipi If op is looking for a I could end up anywhere carrying around a large and heavy system makes no sense at all A I can end up anywhere could require lots of hiking, hitch hiking, maybe climbing, and swamp walking Carrying the extra 5+ lbs makes no sense here and costs much much more
If you argued a tipi as a semi permanent base camp type item I could see that better but even then I would prefer a large canvas tent like pic related
Thread replies: 26 Thread images: 5
Thread DB ID: 506976
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the shown content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows their content, archived. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content, then use the post's [Report] link! If a post is not removed within 24h contact me at firstname.lastname@example.org with the post's information.