itt: rate a bands discography. Discuss if others are right or

File: The Holy Bible.jpg (56KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 500x500px

Manic Street Preachers

Generation Terrorists: 5/10
Gold Against the Soul: 6/10
The Holy Bible: 9.5/10
Everything Must Go: 10/10
This Is My Truth Tell Me Yours: 7/10
Know Your Enemy: 6/10
Lifeblood: 7/10
Send Away the Tigers: 5/10
Journal for Plague Lovers: 8/10
Postcards from a Young Man: 3.5/10
Rewind the Film: 6/10
Futurology: 7.5/10

>>61747305
>Pixies
Surfer Rosa: 9/10
Doolittle: 7.5/10
Bossanova: 5/10
Trompe Le Monde: 8.5/10

>Unwound
Fake Train: 9/10
New Plastic Ideas: 9.5/10
Future of What: 8/10
Repetition: 8.5/10
Challenge For a Civilized Society: 7/10
Leaves Turn Inside You: 10/10

>Manic Street Preachers
Generation Terrorists: 8/10
Gold Against the Soul: 7.5/10
The Holy Bible: 10/10
Everything Must Go: 9/10
This is My Truth Tell Me Yours: 8/10
Know Your Enemy: 7/10
Lifeblood: 7.5/10
Send Away the Tigers: 7/10
Journal For Plague Lovers: 9.5/10
Postcards From a Young Man: 5/10
Rewind the Film: 7/10
Futurology: 8/10

>Arctic Monkeys
Whatever People Say I Am...: 8/10
Favourite Worst Nightmare: 7.5/10
Humbug: 9/10
Suck It And See: 4/10
AM: 6/10

>>61747373
>>61747472
wew lad we got the same idea

>>61747472
Op's is more accurate desu

File: gybe13.jpg (664KB, 1600x1200px) Image search: [Google]

664KB, 1600x1200px

Godspeed You! Black Emperor

>F#A#
9/10
>Slow Riot
9/10
>LYSF
10/10
>Yanqui
7/10
>ADBA
8/10
>ASOD
7/10

>>61747496
this

>>61747472
>>61747373
never really tried Manic Street Preacher

>>61747472
I listened to AM a while back when they came out with their first record and I thought it was alright (5.5/10) but I gave their newest record a listen and I did not like it at all. I'm scared to see what's in-between.

the mars volta:
tremulant ep 10/10
live ep 10/10
deloused in the comatorium 10/10
frances the mute 10/10
scabdates 8/10
amputechture 10/10
the bedlam in goliath 9/10
octahedron 4/10
noctourniquet 6/10

>>61747541
Humbug is definitely their best. Really good lyricism, odd but melodic riffs, great use of effects to convey atmosphere. They sound mature and in total control of their sound. It's a shame they went downhill from there.

>>61747519
My ratings would be
>F#A#
8/10
>Slow Riot
9/10
>LYSF
9/10
>Yanqui
9/10
>ADBA
3/10
>ASOD
4/10


Nico

Chelsea Girl
>7/10

Marble Index
>5/10

Desertshore
>8/10

The End
>9/10


The Antlers

In The Attic
>8/10

Hospice
>9/10

Burst Apart
>8.5/10

Undersea
>8.5/10

Familiars
>10/10

>>61747305

>This Heat
This Heat: 8.5/10
Health and Efficiency: 8/10
Deceit: 7/10

>The Chameleons
Script of the Bridge: 8.5/10
What Does Anything Mean? Basically: 8/10
Strange Times: 7/10

>David Bowie
David Bowie: 3/10
David Bowie (2): 5/10
The Man Who Sold the World: 5/10
Hunk Dory: 6/10
The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders From Mars: 7/10
Aladdin Sane: 6/10
Pin Ups: 5/10
Diamond Dogs: 5/10
Young Americans: 5.5/10
Station to Station: 7.5/10
Low: 8/10
Heroes: 8/10
Lodger: 6/10
Sugar Monsters: 6.5/10
Let's Dance: 4/10
Tonight: 4/10
Never Let Me Down: 2/10
Tin Machine: 5/10
Tin Machine II: 4/10
Black Tie White Noise: 5/10
1.Outside: 5.5/10
Earthling: 6/10
Hours: 5/10
Heathen: 6/10
The Next Day: 5/10
Blackstar: 7/10

>>61747620
>Nico
>those ratings
no

Chelsea Girl: 5/10
Marble Index: 8.5/10
Desertshore: 9.5/10
The End: 6/10

>>61747519
>no ALFotHAD

>>61747746
Why do people think The End isn't as good as Desertshore? What's your reason?

>>61747573
2 many 10s mate a lot of tmv is Omar wankery. Tbig is a solid 3/10

>>61747305

Diagrams like these fucked my shit up as a little kid. I remember putting my fingers on the frets like in the pic and trying to chord.

>>61747573
>noctourniquet 6/10
That is the most generous rating I'm going to see all year and it's January 14th.

>>61747791
thats just stupid.

>>61747789
I was not being fair. I think it probably ranges from a 6 to a 7 so 6.5 but there are no outstanding tracks like the are on Desertshore. I like that it's a lot more darker and more minimal than before. Eno did a good job on this record. Idk I just don't feel it sometimes. I should re-visit.

>>61747305
Doolittle is better than Surfer Rosa

You've overrated early Unwound and underrated Challenge for a Civilized Society

EVOL and Sister are better than the debut and Confusion is Sex. I could see them being on par with Bad Moon Rising but not worse.

Washing Machine is better than you give it credit for. Thousand Leaves could probably use an extra point. NYC Ghosts and Murray St. are at least 7/10. The Eternal isn't great but it's better than Rather Ripped.

>>61747862
youre right i actually mistyped that, ill just say a 5

>>61747305
Interesting, what don't you like about Bossanova?

>Timber Timbre
Cedar Shakes: 5/10
Medicinals: 5.5/10
Timber Timbre: 7/10
Creep On Creepin' On: 7.5/10
Hot Dreams: 7/10

>>61747305
>Arcade Fire
s/t EP: 4/10. The song concepts are good but fuck that low quality.
Funeral: 8/10. Can get pretty boring at periods.
Neon Bible: 6.5/10 Lyrics are slightly worse, interesting instrumentals. Album doesn't quite flow as it should. Still enjoyable for the memories.
The Suburbs: 10/10. Wonderful lyrics, wonderful instrumentals, wonderful song structure, even the interactive music videos were good.
Reflektor: 7.5/10. Arcade Fire becomes arrogant. Love the theatricality. Love the new drum-based sound. Gets boring at points.

>>61747305
Surfer Rosa 8.5/10
Doolittle 9.5/10
Bossanova 7/10
Trompe Le Monde 7/10

>>61747948
I feel this way every time someone mentions bossanova. It's tied with Doolittle for me, I enjoy the songwriting more on those albums over surfer rosa

>>61747305
>The Knife
s/t: 5/10
Deep Cuts: 4/10
Silent Shout: 8/10
Shaking the Habitual: 10/10