Track Ratings Thread

File: trackratingtemplatefam.png (11KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 828x887px

template

>>61538523
Why is St. Vitus Dance so low?

File: TMB.png (131KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

131KB, 828x887px

>>61538523

File: Hurley.png (279KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

279KB, 828x887px

underrated album

>>61541295
Anne Bonny is an 8 at least

1. 8.5/10
2. 9/10
3. 8/10
4. 8/10
5. 9.5/10
6. 8.5/10
7. 9.5/10
8.10/10
9. 4.5/10
10. 8/10
11. 6/10

>>61539773
Underrated album

>>61542384
No tracks on this album are below a 9, and the album is a 10.

>>61541525
>chinese arithmetic not the best track

File: 1445395380011.png (211KB, 1000x768px) Image search: [Google]

211KB, 1000x768px

>>61542832
last three songs are all 8+ and the best on the album my mayne

>>61539341
he didnt like it maybe? i know thats a wild guess but

>>61539497
Kill yourself

>>61544326
But, he's accurate...

>>61541295
shitty ratings/10

that albums at least an 8/10

>>61545016
lol no

Worst Death Grips album by far

>>61545506
Care to explain these ratings?

There seem to be a lot of tracks you don't like for a 10/10 album

File: The River Ratings.png (137KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

137KB, 828x887px

>>61545506
I meant 8/10 and accidentally forgot to change it.

>>61542166
>>61545393
>>61545506
What the fuck?

>>61545562
I'm admittedly rather harsh. I meant 8/10 but forgot to change it. Some of the tracks feel disappointing in delivery but manage to keep a thorough tone throughout the album. That is mainly my defense for why my three ratings all have overall scores higher than the average score.

3/10 is fine, but disappointing.
5/10 is average and I'm willing to listen to it again at times.
8/10 is very good.
10/10 is once in a blue moon. To Be Kind is the only album I would actually give that rating off of the top of my head.

>>61545714
mine isnt even that bad im not sure why you quoted me. i was trying to be objective even though i think all songs are all really great. its one of my favorite albums.

>>61545074
Plen

File: vinny.jpg (265KB, 826x880px) Image search: [Google]

265KB, 826x880px

>>61545931
It wasn't that back heavy desu

File: template.png (137KB, 828x864px) Image search: [Google]

137KB, 828x864px

Comment what you all think about this album if anyone else has listened to it in this thread.

>>61547161
Listening now.

>>61546326
>the party
>10/10

lets be friends

>>61541144
Really? You thought that Che was a weak point on this? *Shocked*

>>61538523
I couldn't remember whether Supernaut was track 4 or track 5, so I didn't know whether to agree with you or strangle you at first

File: CostanzAkinator.png (367KB, 695x478px) Image search: [Google]

367KB, 695x478px

>>61542384

>>61548482
you didn't even try

>>61548360
8/10 is only weak comparatively bruh

File: 1434327982284.png (198KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

198KB, 1000x1000px

>>61538523
Why is Wheels of Confusion so low? (I understand Changes though)
>>61542023
Hi Mom.
>>

File: 76da69bc46763188726a05a2c3e68f92.jpg (18KB, 600x338px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 600x338px

>>61541295

>>61548859
Boston s/t is amazing. Momrock or not.

File: Blue Oyster Cult template.png (85KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

85KB, 828x887px

>>61548972
I cannot disagree with that. It's a pretty good album.

File: Tyranny and Mutation template.png (152KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

152KB, 828x887px

Uploading more content.

>>61548639

Fuckin' Yes

File: Secret Treaties template.png (134KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

134KB, 828x887px

Ironically enough, I listen to this one the least out of all three of them.

File: Even though this album is a personal 10.png (85KB, 976x887px) Image search: [Google]

85KB, 976x887px

Contributing from my personal collection

File: Tarkus template.png (138KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

138KB, 828x887px

Here's my favorite ELP album.

>>61548543
fuck you think you're doing rating gravity rides everything so low.
though I'm interested to hear why you rated Alone Down There so highly, I don't think I've ever heard anyone say that was their favorite track

>>61538523
I fucking love Black Sabbath dude, pure fucking gold there

>>61549631
Did I get the count off? Stars Are Projectors is the 10/10. I think I forgot Tiny Cities Made of Ashes (7/10). Alone Down There is a 6. Gravity Rides Everything is low (and 5/10 isn't really that low) because it's always been a little boring to me, especially as the track directly after Third Planet. Lyrically it's good, but sonically doesn't do much for me. I'm also grading the album as a whole very conservatively.

File: 1452118809111.png (194KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

194KB, 828x887px

love this album

File: 1451701500997.png (1MB, 1024x1024px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1024x1024px

>>61545645
My nigger

>>61549934
Can't really disagree too much on there. Although Never Ending Math Equation > Broke > Interstate 8. And I love Medication for nostalgic reasons. And Grey Ice Water/Life Of Artic Sounds are kind of boring.

File: Tago Mago template.png (190KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

190KB, 828x887px

>>61550074
this desu

>>61545753
I pretty much agree with this, and your ratings were fine. It's an album that works best as an album and there are lots of 'filler' tracks which don't stand on their own but make the whole thing a lot better. 8/10 seems fair.

File: 1443581005823 (1).png (156KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

156KB, 828x887px

>>61547295
>Hunter is a better track than Immature
Absolutely disgusting.

>>61550898
>Swerve City not the highest

File: meatismurder.jpg (253KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

253KB, 828x887px

>>61553666

File: queen is dead.jpg (255KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

255KB, 828x887px

>>61553666
>>61553737
gonna be called pleb for this but I fucking love this album

>>61552542
>Kingfisher 10/10
I like you

File: strangeways.jpg (299KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

299KB, 828x887px

>>61553666
>>61553737
>>61553789
aand this

>>61550898
Is this the best Deftones album? or decent starting point at least?

>>61555226
start with either Saturday Night Wrist or White Pony
Koi No Yokan could be their 4th or 5th best
imo

>>61541979
this nigga knows what's up
>>61541144
>>61539555
>>61539159
>>61545506
>>61545931
>>61550349
>>61553789
ew

>>61539432
>also frightened 6
>taste 5
>Bluish and Brothersport the only 10s
This is why people hate animal collective fans desu senpai

>>61539773
THIS IS A VERY GOOD ALBUM

>>61548482
topkek
>>61550349
>implying bring me coffee or tea isn't the perfect coda to come back to sanity after the freakout second disk and makes whole one of the only objective 10/10 albums in rock music
eegh

>>61539773
>Chances that low

>>61539773
one way trigger that low

pleb

>>61545317
>the wheel so low
it's the best song on the fucking album

>>61557734
>Washer not a 10

>>61557734
for dinner - 7
don, aman - 9
the rest - 10

File: surfsup.jpg (296KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

296KB, 828x887px

>>61539497
FTFY

>>61541295
*glass breaks*

>>61545317

No Reptiles that low - what the fuck is wrong with you?

>>61547230
It's an awesome album, way better than I thought it would be.

>>61548639
One of my favorite albums

>>61549101
>>61549227
>>61549337
>BOC
love it. one of the few dadrock bands i still listen to. i like you

>>61560252
>death with dignity that low
y tho

>>61560284
Fuck that's supposed to be an 8, I love that song

>>61545317
distant past and the wheel deserves way higher,

>>61557734
i can see that

File: TheGlow.png (179KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

179KB, 828x887px

I really like samurai sword for some reason??

>>61562817
the only one here I agree with
>>61562554
>>61561936
>>61560252
>>61555018
>>61553884
>>61553789
>>61553737
>>61553666
>>61550349
kill yourselves

>>61562893

>Average score: 9.0
>Overall score: 10
>because /mu/

>>61562945
an album is not just the amalgamation of its tracks babe

>>61563015

it literally is. an album is literally an amalgamation of tracks

>>61563847
a whole is not the sum of its parts

File: fartosphere.png (82KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

82KB, 828x887px

>>61562554
mine

File: OK Kid.jpg (14KB, 257x257px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 257x257px

>>61542166
>motion picture soundtrack 5/10

>>61545435
Based

>>61553884
I started something I couldn't finish was pretty much the best track on there

>>61542832
>Stronger 5/10
what is this

>>61563864
it literally is. a whole is literally the sum of its parts

>>61542855
Polythene Pam, Octopus' Garden, Maxwell's Silver Hammer are all about 5/10 senpai.

>>61541295
you completely missed the point of the album if pillbox hat was your favourite song

can't even be mad, stay pleb

>>61564981
>second best track is the song about cruising a gay bar

File: either or track by track.png (212KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

212KB, 828x887px

white hot opinions coming through

>>61565099
Put aside the lyrics, Raw Deal is riffy as hell. And yeah, Priest were inconsistent and still finding their way on Sin After Sin. I could do without D&R; they couldn't really do justice to what was a very personal song for Joan Baez and the production also has an unwelcome disco feel to it.

Sinner is an unimpeachable masterpiece as KK Downing has said and I like Starbreaker just for its ultra-campy late 70s-ness. It just captures that era so perfectly.

>>61539432
>Summertime Clothes an 8 not a 10

pleb

File: SkinnyFistsMovements.png (211KB, 837x900px) Image search: [Google]

211KB, 837x900px

>>61564769
Figured I'd do each movement

>any RHCP album
>give the singles 7/10-10/10, the rest 1/10-3/10

Seriously, they're a band that you'd be best just buying a Greatest Hits CD of.

File: lSDJffc.png (229KB, 1858x964px) Image search: [Google]

229KB, 1858x964px

I did it

>>61565080
nigga what

Master of Reality is 10/10 GOAT metal album for real

And I'm the one who made the Vol. 4 chart

>>61547161
>this much effort

>>61565280
Paranoid is better. MOR has three outstanding tracks, the rest...eh. They peaked as a band really early and really fast.

File: TPABTrackRating.png (114KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

114KB, 828x887px

this is really a testament to how consistent the album was

>>61565075
lmao, how did I miss the point? I get what they were going for, it just sucks, simple as that.

Everything after Anne Bonny sounds totally unfinished. Like some really good ideas for songs, but poor execution all-around.

If anything, even though I love pillbox hat, it doesn't fit in with the album at all. It's the only song on the album that sounds fully fleshed out. Even Anne Bonny could use some work, and that's the one that everyone seems to jerk off over.

I will never understand why there are people who think Government Plates is the best Death Grips album.

>>61565163
>I could do without D&R; they couldn't really do justice to what was a very personal song for Joan Baez and the production also has an unwelcome disco feel to it

"The record label was always asking us to do covers. We recorded quite a lot of them, most we didn't use because the song either didn't fit us or we didn't like how it came out. A few covers like Green Manalishi and that old Spooky Tooth song Better By You, Better Than Me turned out really well."

-- Rob Halford

>>61546326
I love you literally

>>61565333 Paranoid is the worst of their debut three albums IMO. Both it and s/t are 9/10's though, so I guess it doesn't matter.

>>61565044
9/10's senpai.

File: SV.png (215KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

215KB, 828x887px

>>61565608

File: keasbeynights.png (166KB, 863x889px) Image search: [Google]

166KB, 863x889px

>>61548639

>>61565648
fair enough

File: GNFPWLBN.png (139KB, 830x887px) Image search: [Google]

139KB, 830x887px

i love this album, i've never understood the hate for it. i guess because it's poppier than their earlier stuff?

>>61565703
That's pretty much the reason why. I've found it's really up and down. Plus all the interludes (except for Milo, which is amazing), sort of take away from it.

>>61563500
why the fuck is touched rated so highly

>>61538523
FUCK YOU
CHANGES IS 10/10

>>61565733
Touched is fine for what it is.

File: Pink.png (169KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

169KB, 828x887px

>>61565818

>>61565835
>airbag and the tourist that low
what's the meaning of that?

>>61565869
Guess I just never really enjoyed them all too much. Always felt they were the weakest two songs on the album.

>>61549934
>interstate 8 and broken
>no 10/10

File: templato.png (173KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

173KB, 828x887px

who even knows about tally hall lmao

>>61545645
quads confirm Pure Heroine is average

>>61562893
>my boy
>8/10
>NO 10/10
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAH

>>61565434

I'm 28 years old, I'm probably older than the majority of people on /mu/. I've studied music theory in college for five years. I play more than five instruments including guitar and violin. I'm part if a rock duo and I perform monthly at various places. We've been working on an album since 2014. I think I know what I'm talking about.

To all you Pet Sounds fags, how much music theory do you know? What instruments do you play? I'm guessing none.

>>61566076
It's Broke, you sperg!

>>61566181
>And I'm a pretentious faggot

you forget that one, I studied theory tho. you don't have to tell everybody that.

>>61566225
I'm sorry anon.

>>61564981
Worst track on Sin After Sin is the best track on Unleashed In The East.

File: 1452121314464.jpg (239KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

239KB, 828x887px

mine.

>>61566247
it's a meme

>>61565845
Here's your daily reminder that Pinkerton is better than The Blue Album

>>61566442
yr average is actually 9.8

>>61564358
Explain how Screen Shot and A Little God in my Hands aren't 10's

>>61566442
How is Taste better than Summertime Clothes?

>>61567163
screen shot has really great tension build and the intro is awesome but the payoff is lackluster

a little god in my hands just doesnt do anything grand for me, only like crazy good songs deserve 10s. bring the sun has the immense build and just raw power, oxygen has the intense ferocity,to be kind also has that power

>>61542166
>How To Disappear Completely 7/10

You can go ahead and die now

>>61544942
Very accurate, the first half of Exmilitary is so much better than the second

>>61565651
Gross, listen to the catch 22 version

>>61564334
And you didn't even include the 2nd disc. I couldn't believe my ears when I heard this. Dreadful.

>>61563500
Great taste, completely agree with the top 4 tracks although I'd give When You Sleep a 9.

>>61562805
Well it is the best song on the album

>>61555865
It's a fantastic track and it makes for a great coda, but it's just not that memorable. By the way, this is my 4th favorite album of all time. 10/10

>>61565005
pizza = good
cotton candy = good
pizza + cotton candy = ?

>>61569457
also
pretzel= boring by itself
salt= gross by itself
pretzel with salt= yum

>>61569457
doesn't sound too bad t b h

>>61555611
Why would you start with SNW? White Pony or Around the Fur.

File: AllTheRightReasonsScoresheet.jpg (333KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

333KB, 828x887px

lmao

>>61566090
One of my first favorite bands, I used to go on binges looking for rare tracks and performances. I've got an Edu - Sketches cassette too.

Have you checked out that cool demo collection they recently put on bandcamp?

>>61565119
Artists 99% make sure the opening track to an album is a strong one. There's probably something wrong with your head

>>61569762
>photograph
>1

>>61565703
It has [spoiler]wonderful singles[/spoiler]

>>61565163
I personally liked the cover of Diamonds and Rust. The album could do without Last Rose of Summer. Great album though.

Sad Wings of Destiny is still their best imo.

>>61567349
This

File: finch-shts-rate.png (237KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

237KB, 828x887px

Severely underrated album

>>61565835
Let Down is the worst track off of OK Computer

>>61570502
No, that's Exit Music

>>61570502
No, that's Climbing Up the Walls

>>61570502
No, that's Fitter Happier

>>61570403
this album's a 10 tbhfam

>>61570571
>>61570595
>>61570618
No that's Planet Telex

>>61565845
how the fuck is the good life worse than getchoo

File: Latterhalfcarriedtheformerhalf.png (151KB, 845x939px) Image search: [Google]

151KB, 845x939px

I haven't been on /mu/ for awhile so I don't know if this album is meme status or hated or disliked but fuck it. I had fun with it.
>>61565845
>Pink Triangle is a 9.
And it better stay that way.

>>61545435
radiogrunge/10

>>61569002
>Emotion an 8
>I Really Like You a 10

File: MPP FAM.png (258KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

258KB, 828x887px

>>61539432
I respectfully disagree.

>>61571485
Why is Daily Routine so low compared to the other tracks?

>>61571511
I'm not a fan senpai.