[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Home]
4Archive logo
CYOA Discussion
If images are not shown try to refresh the page. If you like this website, please disable any AdBlock software!

You are currently reading a thread in /mlp/ - My Little Pony

Thread replies: 524
Thread images: 80
File: 1452561055506.png (171 KB, 600x600) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1452561055506.png
171 KB, 600x600
Let it die Edition

ITT:
>We discuss Current, Finished and Upcoming CYOAs.
>Give advice on CYOAs
>Pitch ideas
>Get critique
>Trade art
>Shitpost

List of stories: http://anonpone.pineapplecomputing.com/

Read this advice first:
http://anonpone.pineapplecomputing.com/advice
http://www.tgchan.org/wiki/Advice

>What day is best?
http://strawpoll.me/5151810
>What time is best?
http://strawpoll.me/5151833
>What genre are you interested in?
http://strawpoll.me/5151994
>What if I cannot into art?
http://strawpoll.me/5207921
>What race would you play?
http://strawpoll.me/5498136

Remember: Coltshan's schedule should be an inspiration to all of us

Last thread >>26067147
>>
>>26082801
First for dank memes
>>
File: GlacierClearDed.png (917 B, 128x128) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
GlacierClearDed.png
917 B, 128x128
Second for Dead GC
>>
>>26082801

OiE is back. You said we wouldn't but we are and have been


Stay mad, cucks
>>
>>26082837
Why would I be mad?
I don't care about your cybersex general.
>>
>>26082837

And best of luck to you. It's not as if anyone in here actually cares whether or not your game lives or dies. You just got made fun of when you choose cyoag to QQ all over when it got janitored.
>>
>>26082587
Shit Prince is back for a while.
>>
>>26082844
>>26082847

>Claims not mad
>Claims don't care if game lives or dies
Funny, considering you fags continuously report our thread whenever one comes up :^)
>>
File: 1415508493999.jpg (44 KB, 314x295) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1415508493999.jpg
44 KB, 314x295
Yeeeah baby, work that grill.
>>
>>26078752
Today, had to stay in work a bit longer than usual yesterday, the opening posts are ready, I'm just waiting for hours that are not early even for euros. Also, whoops, missed the fact we already switched to a new thread
>>
File: Nuclear Stockpile.png (173 KB, 2000x1459) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Nuclear Stockpile.png
173 KB, 2000x1459
QM Question:
How often are you forced to improvise? Do you prepare a library of characters, locations and world lore or you just come up with it on the spot and hope nobody notices a fuck up?
>>
>>26082948
neat
>>
>>26083223
A fair amount of my writing time is actually spent simply planning out immediate events. When I write, I think to myself, "What do I want my players to do? What do I think they'll do? What could happen if I write this scenario out this certain way and what would I do then?"

I do have very general ideas for what a location is like, but even then that's subject to change. It's usually the little things that need to be improvised.

I might be doing it wrong, but I find QMing to be a lot of micromanaging to make sure you don't just write yourself into a corner.
>>
>>26083223
I plan out more or less depending on how deep I estimate the quest lore will go, but I never start anything without some worldbuilding, character and event lists that I might end up using or not. I usually leave things open enough so that players help me fill information with their votes. Deviating from the plan due to unforseen votes is something I love, but always having a base to stand on.
>>
>last thread
>>
>>26083435
>fucking ponies
>good thought, players
>Coltshan, really. just improve
>airship thread
>make gay option
>anon want Etherbreeze
>>
>>26083435
>OP dead
>Space good
>coltshan time
>fuck reason
>cyoa posts need Male mares
>>
>>26083490
>anon want Etherbreeze

Amen.
>>
>>26083435
>Anonymous wanted fuck pony body Sejor hard
>>
>>26083435
>make CYOA get
What could possibly go wrong?
>>
File: 1401770304970.jpg (11 KB, 181x144) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1401770304970.jpg
11 KB, 181x144
>>26083575
Nothing
Nothing at all
>>
File: image.png (40 KB, 678x549) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
image.png
40 KB, 678x549
>>26083513
>>
>>26083665
wew
>>
File: 1440896006187.gif (3 MB, 500x390) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1440896006187.gif
3 MB, 500x390
>>26083665
Absolutely based.
>>
Active threads

ButtQuest: >>26080948
M&M: >>26064761
Threshold: >>26041486
Super: >>26079169
YRWYS: >>26041573
Red is Brown: >>26077971
Necroquest: >>26029016
Vampony: >>26031454
Alchemy: >>25979911
Galloping Steel: >>26043559
Archipelago: >>26039125
Long Name: >>26031398
Space: >>26073430
11-54: >>25975103
Trottingham: >>26040196
SIM: >>26029095
Urban Survival: >>25996685
Across the Ocean: >>26054890
>>
>>26083708
Something Something Winter Break Quests dying.
>>
>>26083732
Undertaker?
>>
>>26083748
no
>>
>>26083708
Bah. Light red, dark brown, what's the difference?
>>
>>26083882
The red channel.
The green channel.
And the blue channel.
>>
Player's Question: Why are you such a faggot?
>>
>>26084062
Because otherwise we would only fuck the girls and never get the Seren booty.
>>
>>26084062
The homo conspiracy stretches far and wide, anon.
>>
>>26084062
Because lesbians.
>>
If you could slap any one CYOA pone across the snootle and tell them to get their shit together, who would it be?
>>
>>26084111
Emerald.
>>
>>26084111
Tally.
>>
>>26084111
Whispen.
Pick a gender, damn it.
>>
>>26084111
Fruity and Dandy I'd slap across the snootle and tell them to get their shit together
Everyone else I would slap across the snootle
>>
>>26084121
That mare has got some motivational issues.
>>
>>26084124
Tally, Emerald, and Fruity I can see, but why Dandy? He seems to hold down a stable job and get things done.
>>
>>26083708

>necroquest
>active
>>
File: Inept.png (217 KB, 520x639) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Inept.png
217 KB, 520x639
this picture needs a scythe
>>
>>26084161
I'm not sure that joke works anymore now that Long Name is also on the list. The updates are hours apart.
>>
File: 1452618858712b.png (272 KB, 725x639) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1452618858712b.png
272 KB, 725x639
>>26084167
>>
>>26084248
neat
>>
>>26084248
what about replacing the meat with cyoa pones?
>>
>>26084283
And the ketchup with a bottle of player tears.
>>
>>26084143
He started working in threshold. That is enough reason to get told get your life in order
>>
>>26084143
Dandy would already be dead if it wasn't for the magic mind voices.
>>
>>26084337
I stand corrected. That is actually an excellent reason.
>>
Best Inept quest?
>>
>>26084368
>implying there's an Inept quest that's not perfect
>>
>>26084368
bad mares
>>
>>26084352
>Dandy would already be dead if it wasn't for the magic mind voices.
That is an almost too perfect metaphor for Inept quests in general. A collective anonymous trying vainly to keep a pony alive who the universe is trying to kill.
>>
>>26084386
So Inept quests are the new JAD?
>>
File: 1452618858712c.png (272 KB, 725x639) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1452618858712c.png
272 KB, 725x639
>>26084283
>>
File: yes.png (280 KB, 465x538) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
yes.png
280 KB, 465x538
>>26084412
>>
>>26084412
poifect
>>
Can we talk about quests?
>>
>>26084503
Which quests do you want to talk about, anon?
>>
File: 1408210767666.jpg (29 KB, 206x220) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1408210767666.jpg
29 KB, 206x220
>>26084503
Lets talk about butts instead.
>>
>>26084530
Your favorite ones.
>>
>>26084503
No.
>>
>>26084503
What quests? Any quests? Okay.

I hope that Sharp Catalog rises through the ranks of the mafia and becomes Don Twitch.

I hope that Etherbreeze's dark secret turns out to be that she is batshit fucking crazy, and her twin sister is a hallucination.

I hope that Dandy figures out how to restore Squishy's memories and intelligence.
>>
>>26084531
Butts you say? I'm not gay, but I'd totally tap the Fruity booty.
>>
>>26084531
>Carver.jpg
>>
>>26084503
Let's talk about how perfect JAD is
>>
>>26084551
I'd fuck Seren desu family.
>>
>>26084566
>talk about how perfect JAD is
Okay. On a scale of "not perfect at all" to "perfect in every way", JAD is "perfect in some regards".
>>
>>26084552
Carver may be a shit, but at least her ass is decent
>>
>>26084566
No, we'll be talking about how perfect Airshipquest will be instead.
>>
>>26084548
I hope Chalk and Pitch get back together.
>>
>>26084598
More like Airshitquest
>>
>>26084503
Shooting Stars is beyond fucking ridiculous at this point.
>>
File: Carver.jpg (31 KB, 206x220) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Carver.jpg
31 KB, 206x220
>>26084552
>>
>>26084598
it will crash and burn
>>
>>26084598
I'd be more excited if it didn't sound so JAD-like. I don't want to spend bits to purchase upgrades out of a tiered perk tree with a cross-referenced chart of prerequisites. I want to go "hey engineer, what parts do I have to steal so that you can make the ship go faster?"
>>
File: 1405907130900.png (243 KB, 452x456) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1405907130900.png
243 KB, 452x456
>>26084625
>>
For the few that want to continue this thing.
>>26082587
>>
>>26084645
>bumping your own thread
wew
>>
>>26084645
Can you tell me about your name? Why is it a meme?
>>
>>26084575
We need to find a way to fuck Seren when we get him back.
>>
It's just my name. I guess it's meme because of all the times I've tried and failed to do quests.
>>
File: 1437907867167.jpg (34 KB, 218x299) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1437907867167.jpg
34 KB, 218x299
So which CYOA pone is THICK
>>
File: 1415473803476.png (76 KB, 380x284) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1415473803476.png
76 KB, 380x284
>>26084725
>>
>>26084725
muffin top
>>
>>26084631
I'd prefer to have some really basic upgrades that are obvious available to buy, but the cool stuff is taken from defeated ships.

The normal upgrades aren't improvements on what you have, they're just things your ship doesn't have yet (ram, emergency sails, air anchors, grapple launchers etc) that allow you to do new things without improving the other parts of the ship. To actually upgrade an existing part you have to actually hunt down and take a special version by defeating special enemies. Players would decide how they want to upgrade their ship by deciding which enemy sounds coolest.
So you've heard about an enemy ship that has cannons that can fire two different shot types at once, and another that has an experimental auto loading system that lets them shoot faster, and you have to decide which one you're going to go after, and how you're going to take them without destroying the ship or being destroyed.
>>
>>26084759
>air anchors
?
>>
>>26084783
Basically parachutes to slow down really fast.
>>
>>26084759
This doesn't sound like fun though.
This sounds like we have to do work before we get to have the fun we want, I just want to do silly things on an airship.
>>
>>26084624
Yeah, but that's part of the appeal for me.
>>
>>26084827
It'll get boring fast if there's literally nothing to work towards.
>>
>>26084617
Chalk/Pitch/Lovesick threesome when
>>
>>26084840
Never
Everyone you love is going to die.
>>
>>26084832
There's a gray area between autism that gates all your content and 'literally nothing to do'

Also all you need is a plot to keep people interested, upgrades are complete fluff.
>>
>>26084840
Pitch ain't getting none.
>>
>>26084840
Reminder that Chalk is so inundated with ambrosia that she will mutate from any exposure to ichor.

Then Lovesick will be the only one who wants any.
>>
>>26084759
That sounds awesome. I'd play that. I love the image of flying a mismatched jumble of stolen ship parts around, held together only by luck and whatever autistic engineering savant we managed to convince to join our crew.
>>
>>26084855
Silly anon. No one stays dead in Carcasonne, remember?
>>
https://picarto.tv/HappyHorseAdventures
>>
>>26084893
No
Because I don't read it
And that sounds like a cop out for sloth to make sure you can't fuck up and end the quest
>>
>>26084868
I disagree. This isn't about gates. This is about reasonable progression. Your ship can already do plenty, and so can you. You just get things so you can do even more. The ship and it's capabilities are part of the plot.
If we start out being able to do anything in a CYOA about airship combat as a soldier or privateer then what's the challenge going to be?
How many CYOAs have you played where the MC gathers abilities as the story goes on?
>>
>>26084897
Every time someone posts a picarto link, I click on it to see the spoiler and it starts loading secret club without my permission. Please stop spoilering the links. It's not even remotely secret.
>>
>>26084919
Are you on mobile or some shit? You can see spoilers just by hovering over them.
>>
>>26084899
I don't believe the players are dead (haven't made it all the way through yet, though).

But no, its not a cop-out.
>>
>>26084903
I'd like it better if our ship COULDN'T "already do plenty". I think it would be fun to start with a salvaged heap of shit and slowly build up to something great.
>>
>>26084759
>>26084903
Do you seriously think that there are many people here who are willing to keep track of a ton of shit like that when they play a CYOA on /mlp/?
>>
>>26084930
Yes.
>>
>>26084939
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHA
HAHAHAHAAHAHA
>>
>>26084934
>ton of shit
It's barely anything. That's like saying keeping track of your characters inventory is too hard.
>>
>>26084940
I would defend myself, but I agree with you.
>>
>>26084899
Nah it's not like 11-54 where we'll respawn if we die. It's just that death doesn't really work in the city because It's stuck in a time loop, and apparently ponies can be revived with Ambrosia if what Patchwork said early on was true. Though they turn into whatever the hell Patches is. We have 'reloads' in case we ever majorly fuck ourselves, but we've never had to use them.
>>
File: 1412649490999.jpg (9 KB, 225x225) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1412649490999.jpg
9 KB, 225x225
>>26082801
>>Give advice on CYOAs
>>Pitch ideas
>>Get critique
>>
File: fast.gif (79 KB, 500x400) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
fast.gif
79 KB, 500x400
>>26085031
>>
>>26085031
I already dig your stuff, just keep writing.
The only critique I could give is less meta posts and a more regular posting schedule
>>
>>26085031
Anon in G1 Ponyland.
>>
>>26085031
>give advice
Continue being awesome.
Consider being awesome faster.
>pitch ideas
The cutie mark adjustment during our practicum was our fictional sister getting her cutie mark
>get critique
I wish you would post when you think the next update might be at the end of updates. I five hour wait is a lot less difficult to stomach if I know it'll be five hours.
>>
>>26085031
Nips should really stop turning Fruit Flank into such a fucking Mary Sue.
>Can turn his hoofs into all sorts of weapons and hands so he can use weapons others can't use
>He's suddenly become the MC in Prototype
>>
>>26085080
I'll.. Try my best?

>>26085078
[redacted]
>>
>>26085080
What did you expect? SS is the most anime quest here.
>>
>>26085031
First of all, update faster. Right now the CYOA feels more like a greentext story that something I have some control over. I think you should just outright explain some things like our family for one. I really wish there was more character interaction and you've taken a step in the right direction in that regard. Finally I hate your writing format, please, please, please switch to the more traditional greentext style.
>>
>>26085058
>less meta posts
I disagree. Learning about the world is fun too. If the GM doesn't have time for full posts, I will gladly accept worldbuilding fact snippets to tide me over.
>>
>>26085095
I like the current greentext style. It's a welcome break from the usual style, and the spaces make it easier to read. At least keep the spaces if you change the text style.
>>
>>26085091
Ever since the cuckening of GC, Nips realized the market for animu was massive in quest and thus has been retooling SS into Sword Art Online. It's the perfect plan.
>>
>>26085080

He could do that in the first place. We just never bothered doing it because people just wanted to use the gun.
>>
Nipscucks
or
GCucks
?
>>
>>26085109
The spaces and everyone's speech being the same color is what fucks with me.
>>
>>26085138
>We just never bothered doing it because people just wanted to use the gun.
Which shows how much into anime Nips is.
>There's a gun that requires fingers to pull the trigger?
>Fuck that. Fruity can now turn his hooves into hands :)"
And that's just a small portion of the things that is ridiculous with SS.
He just plain refuses to put any limits to what his characters can do, and that's just bad.
>>
>>26085097
OK, but then he should use another name. Because catching up with the pineapple archive and having tons of context-free meta posts is really annoying
>>
File: 1415503591900.png (1 MB, 1800x900) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1415503591900.png
1 MB, 1800x900
>>26085138
Here
>>
>>26085178
You'd rather miss out on important backstory because it wasn't in pineapple?
>>
>>26085177
>There's a gun that requires fingers to pull the trigger?
Retard spotted
>>
>>26085184
I misread that for a second and wondered why Flo had an Inferno attack.
>>
>>26085193
There's a reason most QMs post meta under meta names. And more to the point, all this information should be available elsewhere or revealed in story.
Exposition dumps are cheap.
>>
>>26085197
>Fish with ebola: I am growing stronger
>>
>>26085177

So what you are saying is is that a half changing shouldn't be allowed to make use of his changling abilities because it's too anime? I'm not sure I undertand the complaint. I mean we've seen what happens when he tries to shape shift more than his hands. He nearly passed out. Yes, the party is pretty powerful, but no more than the setting requires. Just think of it like low fantasy settings versus high fantasy settings in Dungeons and Dragons. Shooting Stars is more of a high fantasy setting.
>>
>>26085229
Changeling's powers have been 'turn into other ponies' though. Not 'Shape shift into pretty much anything you want'. None of the Changelings in the show used these abilities to fight.
>>
>>26085229
>the party is pretty powerful, but no more than the setting requires
And Nips will keep changing it so that the characters are no more powered than what is required to defeat their current villain.
>>
>>26085242
That's because they were all stupid bugs without superior erf genes.
>>
>>26085249
Oh god, he's going the Somber route.
>>
>>26085242
If he shifts into anything that's not within the shape of the main 3 races of pony, he can't maintain it for long, especially in combat. It's not that terribly overpowered given this game is full of fucking snowflake races instead of normal ponies, so it balances out.
>>
>>26085242

Shooting Stars also has humans sir. Fruit Flank is only half changling and is incapable of turning into other ponies. What he CAN do is shift small pieces of his body.

I'm going to warn you now, that pointing out things that are not canon to the show in a quest here is a losing battle.
>>
>>26085242
Chrysalis is significantly bigger than Cadance, so actual shapeshifting is canonically achievable.
>>
>>26085253
Because changing your entire bone structure is soo painless and easy, right?
Changing into someone else is one thing. Changing into an entirely different species that has a completely different bone structure is another. And if you give us the shit about Fruity being able to do it just because, then that just proves that Nips is turning his characters into special snowflakes.
>>
>>26085286
>implying changelings and ponies are the same species
>>
>>26085295
> Implying ponyland works on genetics like Earth does.
>>
>>26085258
SS is the Project Horizons of quest confirmed.

>>26085270
Look what the anon said:

>a half changing shouldn't be allowed to make use of his changling abilities because it's too anime?

I was pointing out that Changelings in general have not been shown to be able to shapeshift their bodies at will in the show, and not even in SS. If it was explained that Changelings in SS can do these things though it'd make more sense. Maybe his Mom is from a specific Hive who focus less on just morphing into ponies and deceiving them, but general shapeshifting.

But as of now, no such explanation has been given. As such we have no idea really what the extent of 'Changeling Abilities' are in SS.

>>26085285
>>26085295
Chrysalis can also only change into pre-existing ponies. No changeling has ever been shown to be able to turn into a pony of their own creation.
>>
>>26085285
Hell she went even smaller when she transformed into Applejack.
>>
>>26085270
>pointing out things that are not canon to the show in a quest here is a losing battle.
Right, I completely forgot that this general is filled with genuine autists.
Changelings are able to turn into whatever they want to, even dragons.
Bats are all-powerful.
A single pegasus can destroy an entire village all on her own by summoning hurricanes!
>>
>>26085315
>Chrysalis can also only change into pre-existing ponies
No, she's only been shown to, which isn't the same thing.
>>
>>26085331
The whole point of Changelings comes from replacing people anyway though. It doesn't make any sense they WOULD be able to change into anything they want.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Changeling
>>
>>26085349
And in the setting people are made up of various races. Could traditional changelings not become someone of any race?
>>
>>26085349
Boohoo an AU ponyland isn't fitting my cannon based head-cannon. How dare people enjoy it when I dont I hate it waaa
>>
>>26085349
>It only matters that it makes or doesn't make sense to me
>So obviously it's a fact
>Pony Changelings need to be based on other mythos changelings
My opinion > your opinion
>>
>>26085378
>Boohoo people don't like my headcanon about changelings. How dare people complain waaaa
>>
>>26085415
>complaining about headcanon in fictional works
>>
>>26085321
See. This right here is why it's a losing battle. You present the issue, and when it gets countered you are unable to point at the tv show and use it as your bible, and then it devolves into insult throwing. β€œIt isn't exactly like the TV show, I'm gonna call them autistic and take the thing I don't like and give an example of it taken to ridiculous extremes.”

Fruit Flank has never attempted anything so silly as turning into a dragon. Transforming his arms into claws like the ones on the first black fungus beast he fought alone takes a massive toll on him. He can mimic PART of another creature or pony, but not the full package.

>Bats are all-powerful.
Lily is a useful party member, but I'd hardly call her powerful. She's an alchemist and assists in combat by using the various books we've collected to point out weak spots on monsters. Alone she is fairly defenseless, which is why she is combined with Dullahan to round-out her effectiveness.

>A single pegasus can destroy an entire village all on her own by summoning hurricanes!
No idea what that specific complaint is about, but didn't Rainbow Dash almost destroy an entire village with a snowball nuke in the cartoon? Anything that can control weather is scary in my book.
>>
>>26085369
>>26085378
>>26085382
Again, I'm not saying 'It doesn't line up with m-muh mythos so it's shit'. I'm arguing against the aforementioned anon's point.

>a half changing shouldn't be allowed to make use of his changling abilities because it's too anime?

I'm saying we have no idea what the hell Changeling abilities are in SS and it needs more explanation. It's like if you had a Medusa in your story, only instead of being able to turn people into stone, she could shoot lighting out of her tits. And you just roll with it like the readers should already know that Gorgons can do this even though in almost no other medium ever is this true.
>>
>>26085095
>Finally I hate your writing format

>>26085428

> They actually took a suggestion/critique and DID it.

color me impressed, they changed their style a bit to accommodate the person complaining about the format.
>>
>>26085457
not that anon but that was because rainbow was screwing with the weather factory not exactly for her own
>>
>>26085467
>Character is shown to be able to do things thanks to heritage, it's explained that he can only do it badly because he's a half-blood.
>Instead of assuming every member of that race can do such thing in this world I'm going to complain and say I need more information.

Okay. This explains a lot about you familia.
>>
File: check em.png (17 KB, 458x332) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
check em.png
17 KB, 458x332
>>
>>26085467
>only instead of being able to turn people into stone, she could shoot lighting out of her tits
Yes, because shapeshifting and shapeshifting are that different.
>>
>>26085515
Wew lad.
>>
don't fuck cyoa when?
>>
File: 1414895722155.png (136 KB, 320x240) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1414895722155.png
136 KB, 320x240
>>26085515
>>
>>26083435
make quest give anonymous pretty coat
>>
>>26085532
Jacku's thinking about it
>>
>>26085485
I'm kinda surprised.

Thank you YGTNTGM.
>>
>>26085485
dropped
>>
>>26085095

speaking of it being like a green-text... I kind of like it. It feels like the main character is more of a character than just a flat 2D paper doll we are dragging around on strings.
>>
>>26085550
>Jacku's thinking about it
so that's a maybe?
>>
>>26085457
>and use it as your bible
Then please do tell us when changelings were able to do the same things in the show that Fruity is able to do right now.
>>26085457
>She's an alchemist and assists in combat by using the various books we've collected to point out weak spots on monsters.
>She can suddenly crate a bag that can carry en enedless supply of items just like that

>which is why she is combined with Dullahan
>Someone who was brought back from the dead just because
>"DEUS EX MACHINA" is what Nips shouted right before he brought Dullahan back from the dead
>>
>>26085533
Fuck you I tried to go to the 5555 but my mouse clicked over the Post button accidently ;_;
>>
>>26085608
kek
L.O.S.E.R.
>>
>>26085607
Please tell us when in the show it is explicitly shown that they cannot do what fruity is doing right now.
>>
Dumb changelingfags trying to shove their autistic headcanons about their stupid bugs into every CYOA.
>>
File: 1404438152567.png (211 KB, 741x600) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1404438152567.png
211 KB, 741x600
>>26085725
zezezezezez
>>
>>26085676
>>26085725
i just got here what did i miss?
>>
>>26085725
Butthurt batfag detected.
>>
File: 1451128237004.png (151 KB, 339x288) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1451128237004.png
151 KB, 339x288
>>26085157
>being any in the current year
>>
>>26085747
well, I see a lot of Nipscuck defending Nips and their special snowflake changeling headcanons so...
>>
>>26085725
>Dumb trans-pegasus fags trying to shove their autistic headcanons about their stupid wingless pegasi into every CYOA.
>>
>>26085676
So what you're saying is
>Muh headcanon is canon unless stated otherwise!!
Yep, that's a sign of autism, no doubt about it.
>>
>>26085607

>Responding to a counter with literally the exact same thing that was countered.

Doing the same thing over and over again with the expectation of a different result is insanity sir.

>She can suddenly crate a bag that can carry en enedless supply of items just like that

What???

Stop trying to use the show as a bible sir. I've already told you that it's a lost battle. All you keep doing is ignoring the people telling you that quests don't follow show canon and demanding that we point out instances of what you dislike in the show.
If a quest doing things that aren't canon in the show really bothers you as much as this seems to. Perhaps you should make a quest of your own that follows 100% of things only shown in the cartoon.
>>
>>26085788

I'm surprised you aren't throwing a fit about him being a half changling or the fact there are humans. Those don't exist in the cartoon either.
>>
>>26085788
I bet he thinks the movies and the comics are canon
>>
>>26085812

Now you're just being cruel.
>>
File: pinkie popcorn.jpg (27 KB, 385x360) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
pinkie popcorn.jpg
27 KB, 385x360
http://strawpoll.me/6520759
>>
>>26085607

Chris chan is that you? I swear we still call her Derpy here. Please don't mace me.
>>
>>26085788
What I'm saying is that the above anon's request is flawed; aside from the fact that the universe of the show and the CYOA are never explicitly stated to be the same, neither side can be proven (absence of evidence).
Regardless, this is a discussion of the past.
Whether or not it is canon to the show is irrelevant.
We're not playing something dictated by the rules of the show, we're playing something dictated by the rules of a CYOA, which has its own 'canon'.
You can kindly fuck off with the autism label. It's all autism in here. This is the rule, not the exception.
>>
>>26085845

I can dig it.
>>
>>26085836
You mean Muffins?
>>
>>26085593
I have to disagree with you. Though Etherbreeze is a great character it's only been shown in little ways and for the most part she feels rather thin, more than likely because she puts on for other ponies.
>>
>>26085193
The archive is designed to turn a quest into a story that can be read smoothly after the fact. Meta is great for fleshing out a world or giving context to active decisions but it constantly interrupting the reading experience is annoying.
>>
File: amusemario.png (223 KB, 500x445) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
amusemario.png
223 KB, 500x445
>>26085770

Hehe

>>26085795
Anyone who has played a pont'n'click adventure knows, inventory space in unlimited.
>>
>>26085931
>HURR DURR THIS ISN'T A POINT AND CLICK
>>
>>26085931
Anyone who has played a j-rpg knows you can actually only carry 99 times the same object
>>
>>26085931

How the fuck do people hold so much in their pockets anyway in those?
>>
>>26085962
>Playing j-rpgs
>Any year
Remove yourself :^)
>>
File: 1419536003539.jpg (6 KB, 225x225) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1419536003539.jpg
6 KB, 225x225
>>26085968
magic
>>
>>26085954
>tfw you point with your cursor on the updates to reply to them
>tfw you click the post button
>>
>>26085968
https://youtu.be/ieP84IZLGTs?t=1m14s

Trans-dimensional pants connected to a chest of holding.
>>
>>26085993
2deep
>>
So from what I'm gathering from this Thread.
People want more things set in the Shooting Stars universe to help explain aspects of the world that are going unexplained due to the limited scope of Fruit Flank's direct experience.
Right?
>>
>>26086010
time skip doesn't work genius
>>
>>26086022
Click the link and not [Embed] you humongous faggot.
>>
>>26085795
Show me where the Dust Valley exists in canon. Damn nips and his special snowflake locations.
>>
>>26086018
I want to be the little sea mare.
>>
>>26086034
longname has an entire snowflake nation called Torrento.

I hope its full of brown ponies for us to bomb.
>>
>>26086034
>his
Technically no, not his.
>>
>>26086078
hers?
>>
>>26086018
faggots here don't know what they want, they just want to bitch
>>
>>26086137
Nips is a dude, dude.
>>
>>26086137
xis
>>
>>26083223
I have lore for the whole world and several possible events in it.

It depends on locations. I have several pre-made ones, rest is improvised. Same goes to characters. Due to free will I do not completely plan immediate events. I sketch possibilities.
>>
>>26086155
biologically or does he identify as guy, but doesn't actually have the dangly bits? Or at least a very feminine penis.
>>
>>26086171
Yes.
>>
Trottingham continues:
>>26086277
>>
If /cyoa/ was a CYOA, who'd take which role?
>>
>>26086333
Shiny would play Shiny.
>>
>>26086333
Anonymous would be the MC, Anonymous would be the designated love interest, Anonymous would be the love interest the gay agenda pushes for, Anonymous would have a ton of memes about him, and Anonymous would be offed early for being so autistically annoying.
>>
>>26086333
I want to crash my airship into you.
>>
>>26086333
Batfag anon and anti-batfag anon would be our two useless comic relief party members.
>>
>>26086364
>tiny airship waifu
>>
>>26086372
Someone pls draw.
>>
>>26086369

The batpony and mothpony party members get along just fine. The two anon's representing the love of bats and moths each constantly fighting and trying to pit the two against each other, with it never working. The batpone and Mothpone end up making out at one point, sending the two anon's into a blind rage.
>>
File: file.png (63 KB, 359x330) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
file.png
63 KB, 359x330
>>26086372
Allah Akbar
>>
>>26086403
What about the satyrfag anon?
>>
File: ezgif-2336400537.gif (232 KB, 359x330) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
ezgif-2336400537.gif
232 KB, 359x330
>>26086372
>>26086490
Copy image doesn't seem to work with gifs.
>>
>>26086333
>Nips would be a necromage due to the whole lich thing.
>Hijacker would duel-class master-monk and alchemist so he could use all the items that he complains that his players don't use and pull off sick combos.
>Inept would be a support mage that has feats in trap recognition.
>Res would be a bard
>Coltshan would be a barbarian so he could do everything with brute force.
>Craft would be a cleric due to all of the lore he knows.
>And Amm would be the king that gives them the main quest.
>>
>>26086525
We up, for those who care
>lel who cares etc etc
>>
>>26086527
>LongName would be an immensely powerful NPC that only shows up every ten sessions to do exactly one awesome thing before immediately fucking off
>>
File: 1436313258367.jpg (65 KB, 477x720) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1436313258367.jpg
65 KB, 477x720
>>26086075
Language barrier: the quest.
>>
File: e94gbonemeal.png (16 KB, 718x848) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
e94gbonemeal.png
16 KB, 718x848
I'm surprised it survived two days with no updates, but Threshold continues!
>>26086854
>>
So, it looks like I will be able to run Vampony tonight, however I feel like I've held the reins for a bit too long.
If any of the other QMs were planning on running, let me know.
If not, I'll run tonight.
>>
>>26086927
It's ok mango. We know it's just you now. You don't have to keep up the act. This is an intervention.
>>
>>26083530

Well it's true
>>
File: 1452451013412.gif (1 MB, 300x227) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1452451013412.gif
1 MB, 300x227
>>26086583
>>
>>26084947
Ever read Hijack? Because that proved to be too hard on a number of occasions. Nobody wants to have to scroll up to find a pastebin.
>>
File: dasitmane.png (12 KB, 143x154) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
dasitmane.png
12 KB, 143x154
>>25996685
Pls enjoy
>>
>>26087265
The combat system, yes. I'm assuming Innkeeper wasn't planning on HP and combos.
>>
>>26087274

No
>>
>>26087274
l
e
l
w h o
c
a
r
e
s
>>
>>26087290
I'm expecting something more strategy and timing based for that. Since we're dealing with the scale of airships and not individual fighters. Like a 3d chess board
>>
>>26086018
Nips said he would make a sort of Lore book.
Maybe that will help
>>
>>26086372
>>
>>26087665
wew
>>
>>26086372
>>26086396
>>26087665

Idea was too cute not to contribute.
>>
>>26088013
I admire you.
>>
>>26088013
I will accept that.
>>
>>26088013
prefic
>>
>>26088013
I want to pop tiny airship waifu's balloon and watch as she plummets to the earth
>>
>>26088013
The need for you to run a tiny pony quest grows.
>>
We need some cyoa airships to compete, cooperate, and converse with in airship cyoa

What's the primary attack strategy, aesthetic, and profession of each one?
>>
File: 1331181393970.png (276 KB, 602x562) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1331181393970.png
276 KB, 602x562
Hey Anon!
Please remember to stand up at least once every hour for about five minutes. It's great for your circulation and helps negate the effects of sitting for prolonged times!
>>
>>26088117
I'm utterly drunk, what now?
>>
>>26088138
Hi bath
>>
>>26088138
Hi Ficfic
>>
>>26088106
crash and burn
>>
>>26088138
Pull your pants all the way down, raise your arms in the "winner pose", lift your head and close your eyes.
>>
>>26088183
Fific is too busy harvesting tears
>>
I'm disturbingly sober right now.
>>
>>26088364
I'll bite. Why is that disturbing to you?
>>
>>26088214
Been there, done that.
>>
>>26088371
Do it while pissing. Top of the world.
>>
>>26088385
I'm not going to piss in my flat, lad.
>>
>>26088055
probably wouldn't kill her, since distance isn't relative when it comes to terminal velocity.
>>
>>26088397
Do it in front of your loo, m87. Or do you need one hand at your dick at all times to control where your stream is going?
>>
>>26088419
brb
>>
>>26088441
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3rzDXNQxjHs
>>
>>26088476
Dude I peed all over the toilet, fuck you. I hope you will die in pain.
>>
>>26088540
No skill. You are a shame to all of humanity
>>
>>26088540
I used a ladder.
>>
>>26088540
I assure you, it is possible to do it cleanly. I think your mistake was doing it drunk.
>>
>>26088370
All I have is old rum and I'm sick of rum.
Also, I didn't really expect someone to want an explanation.
>>
>>26088540
Dude what the fuck? It's not my fault you can't piss properly. You clearly need more practice.

Try this next time you gotta piss: Aim at the bowl and as long as you feel you got a good pressure, slowly back away, increasing your angle and see how far you can go, before you have to step closer due to the decreasing pressure. I made it to the door, which is about 1,40m (~4'7") from the toilet. It was such a beautiful arch and it all went where it was supposed to go.
>>
>>26088610
*arc
>>
>>26088540
You must be 18 years old or older to browse this website.
>>
Where were you when /cyoa/ moved from shitposting to pissposting?
>>
>>26088676
Right here, pissposting.
>>
>>26088676
It doesn't have to be like this.
All we need to do is make sure we keep talking.
>>
>>26086527
>master monk alchemist

This is satisfyingly accurate
>>
Current airship status:

Main cast: finalizing details. Need more cardboard.

Plot: still hammering details out. Working through indecisiveness.

Mechanics: threw most of it out. Scaled down and simplified.

Tiny airship waifu: inflated. Still making tiny horse noises.

Launch date: hopefully this weekend.
>>
>>26088855
>Hopefully this weekend.
You heard him boys. Expect it Q2 2017
>>
>>26088855
>scaled down and simplified
>trips and dubs
This bodes well.
>>
>>26088855
Whelp JAD is dead
>>
>>26088855
Does this mean our innkeeping is going to be replaced with airship captaining now?
>>
>>26088855
>needs more cardboard

Great, all we need. A airship version of Treads.
>>
File: Box.jpg (111 KB, 1600x1066) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Box.jpg
111 KB, 1600x1066
>>26089082
"Hey Small Sun, check out my Bf-109!"
>>
>>26088855
not even started and it's already perfect
>>
>>26089108
>flying tanks
>>
>>26089320
>>
File: Wew.png (40 KB, 356x337) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Wew.png
40 KB, 356x337
>>26079169
Super's live.
>>
>>26089339
[citation needed]
This doesn't seen to work at all.
>>
File: 1447996592126 (1).png (305 KB, 1080x768) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1447996592126 (1).png
305 KB, 1080x768
Would you let tiny treads escort you in her tank?
>>
File: image.jpg (4 KB, 300x57) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
image.jpg
4 KB, 300x57
>>26088855
>Mechanics thrown out
Please tell me we get to keep the pony cannon
>>
>>26089400
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antonov_A-40
>>
>>26089419
Yes
>>
>>26089419
I would burn her "tank" down just to show her how stupid is she and her idea
>>
>>26089461
Just pour a glass of water over it. And then have her eat her tank-sludge.
>>
>>26089461
Easy please.
>>
>>26089486
Hey now, Easy's not a dick just to be a dick.
>>
>>26089523
Rly tho?
>>
File: 1451478168722.png (256 KB, 600x600) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1451478168722.png
256 KB, 600x600
>>26089523
>>
>>26089538
>>26089541
pls no bully the doll
>>
>>26089538
>taking bath's shit seriously
Unless treads was a super then no she would not be that cruel.
>>
File: dakka.jpg (136 KB, 602x800) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
dakka.jpg
136 KB, 602x800
>>26088855
I want this to be an upgrade.
>>
>>26089570
I remember using these in IL-2 Sturmovic 1946. Forgot what they were called, but they wrecked shit like hell.
>>
File: 1421971047218.png (69 KB, 608x402) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1421971047218.png
69 KB, 608x402
>>26089430
Holy shit, they actually thought this would work and even sketched a prototype. The idea is nice and all but you can't just ignore air draft and make the most shitty non-aerodynamical plane and think it'd work.

Thanks for the source.
>>
>>26089613
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsar_Tank
>>
Male earth guard pony quest when
>>
>>26089678
This might be one of the dumbest designs ever.
>>
>>26089691
right after don't fuck up 2, don't fuck quest is finished.
>>
>>26089703
Which of course comes after Nyx and Anonfilly in Cutequestria quest.
>>
>>26089691
Was that one that flopped an earth pony?
>>
>>26089691
Why so specific?
>>
>>26089730
>unicorn guard: steel charge
>pegasus guard: anonguard
>earth pony guard: ???
>>
File: tiny pone.png (87 KB, 1000x476) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
tiny pone.png
87 KB, 1000x476
>>
>>26089756
Good, now that ant won't have to break tiny poner's kneecaps.
>>
>>26089756
tasty sugar water
>>
File: ayy lmao.png (225 KB, 317x409) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
ayy lmao.png
225 KB, 317x409
>>26089797
>>
>>26089756
>multi-QM quest thingy
I'm liking this idea.
>>
>>26089751
Spearhead is an earth pony isn't he?

Same thing with the one the griz blew up
>>
>>26089559
I've never played/read Super Pony. Is it basically genocide quest only with super ponies?
>>
>>26089832
I'd be cool with that since I'm stuck running Threshold even though I said I'd do something tiny poner-related.
>>
>>26089853
No
Not at all
We really only hate supers and don't want to kill anybody
>>
>>26089853
Her only genocidal action was burning down a building with people in it to kill a superhero who had tracked her to her apartment.
>>
>>26089873
Thats... kinda fucked up.
>>
>>26089868
>>26089873
So it's 'Genocide all superheroes' quest.
>>
>>26089895
And anyone who gets caught in the crossfire, apparently.
>>
>>26089895
Are you intentionally being this daft?
>>
>>26089895
More like revenge quest that took a dark turn that the MC is now trying to make up for.
>>
Space CYOA discussion:
Discussion post:
I don't think we're trying hard enough to put our batarang in Zara'a dragon's lair, if you know what I'm sayin'. Shit, how does Shepard do it?
>>
>>26089919
What was the revenge over?
>>
>>26089961
MC was trying to find Boomerang for sending her to prison for three months.
>>
>>26089961
>super busts into our work place
>kick their shit in because nobody will rob us on our watch
>said super sends us to jail
>really fucks up any chance of a normal life
>>
>>26089428

Like I could ever get rid of something so perfect.
>>
>>26089832
>Wolvan involved
No you aren't friendo.
>>
Just a heads up, I'm planning on starting Cough Syrup sometime this week.
>>
>>26090098
Can't wait, anon.
>>
>>26090098
Sure you are, Anon.
>>
>>26090098
Okay see you next month.
>>
File: brushie.png (79 KB, 486x488) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
brushie.png
79 KB, 486x488
>players want to do something BUT it would out of character for the MC
if you were the QM what would you do?
>>
>>26090075
remember when vampony was a multi-QM thing and everyone just ignored quakela?
>>
>>26090125
Tweak it to make it in-character.
>>
>>26089958
I haven't really been catching up but the last time I checked I thought fizzy was designated waifu
>>
>>26090135
But she's young and innocent. We wouldn't want our roguish outlaw mercenary captain to do something illegal like underage booping, would we?
>>
>>26090131
This. Spontaneously add whatever backstory is necessary to justify it.
>>
File: 1436355275219.jpg (41 KB, 408x376) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1436355275219.jpg
41 KB, 408x376
>>26090125
>>26090131
Dis. You have more than the MC to work with when receiving suggestions, also.

Make him conflicted or have something happens that apparently gives him far less say in the matter.
>>
>>26090125

If I could, >>26090131

If it was completely and truly out of character though I'd just state such.
>>
File: Playtime's over.gif (2 MB, 400x225) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Playtime's over.gif
2 MB, 400x225
>>26090186
>underage booping
>>
>>26090186
Again. Last time I checked we didn't know her age
>>
>>26090210
>>26090210
running a necroquest session now
>>
ButtQuest
M&M
Threshold
Super
YRWYS
Red is Brown
Necroquest
Vampony
Alchemy
Galloping Steel
Archipelago
Long Name
Space
11-54
Trottingham
SIM
Urban Survival
Across the Ocean

Aranges these in order of least edgy to the most edgy.
Then arrange them in order of least serious to most serious
>>
>>26090377
Least serious is butt
>>
File: 1452197830033.jpg (62 KB, 829x645) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1452197830033.jpg
62 KB, 829x645
>>26090377
The current order suits both categories.
>>
>>26090126
I kinda wish it still was
>>
>>26090428
>>
>>26090377
Going purely off my gut and having acknowledged i haven't read most of these:

edgy

SIM
Colt Quest
threshold
11-54
YRWYS
urban survival
Vampony
Necroquest
Super
alchemy
Space
Long name
M&M
Galloping Steel
Archipelago
buttquest
Trottingham
Across the ocean

least edgy
>>
>>26085031
>YouGetToNameTheGM
Then I do hereby dub thee Sir Dongus.
>>
>>26090496
Pretty close actually, though I'd bump Archipelago past GS.
>>
>>26090456
It's mostly because I'm dealing with another QM's character and I can't hide my poor character writing skills with 'gameplay' right now.

I really hope I haven't fucked up his character since it seem like he put a lot of thought into her.

>>26090496
Mind explaining your rating for Vampony? I'm actively trying to retain the inherent edge in the concept, so I'd like to know if I've been successful in that.
>>
>>26090567
>retain
I meant restrain.

Make it less edgy despite Vampires being naturally edgy.

fuck
>>
>>26090521
We don't actually get to name the GM of Long Name. He is already named. His name is "YouGetToNameTheGM" and he runs the "YouGetToNameThe" CYOA.
>>
>>26090567
>Mind explaining your rating for Vampony?
Bathwater killing the maid.
>>
>>26090496
Urban's above Vamp?

Jeez, Vamp's had the MC torture people to death and has very explicit visceral content.
>>
>>26090496
>Urban above M&M
>>
>>26090496
I'd probably move vamp above YRWYS and put Coltquest below it.
>>
>>26090581
No, his name is "YouGetToNameTheGM" and he runs Long Name.
>>
>>26090377
For some of ones I read. A lot of this is kinda hard to judge though, hardly accurate.

Edge:going down least to most

ButtQuest
Threshold
M&M
Urban Survival
Super
JAD
ColtQuest
11-54
Vampony

Serious Feels like this one's more subject to personal opinion than edge.

ColtQuest
ButtQuest
Threshold
JAD
Urban Survival
Vampony
11-54
Super
M&M
>>
>>26090586
>MC torture people to death

I will say that was totally player choice.

>>26090622
Yeesh, blatant, constant, child rape is less edgy than Vamp?
I need to address this then
>>
>>26090651
it's not rape if he wants it
>>
>>26090659
Legally it is, though you could say that it's a legal fiction or whatever.
>>
>>26090672
You'd have to know the laws there to say that and you don't.
>>
File: 1444197577360.gif (64 KB, 156x167) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1444197577360.gif
64 KB, 156x167
>>26090672

Statutory rape in Equestria? FFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUU-
>>
>>26090683
Just going by the fact that Joyride is able to charge outrageous prices for Emerald, I'd guess it was illegal.
>>
>>26090672
Legally fictional entities are not persons and thus they can't rape or be raped.
>>
>>26090672
Well it's either legal or literally nobody gives a shit seeing as like a million others have porked Emerald.
>>
New additions:

Cuddle Mercenary:
https://anonpone.pineapplecomputing.com/cuddle/

Dirty Work:
https://anonpone.pineapplecomputing.com/dirty/

Macro-Quest [completed]:
https://anonpone.pineapplecomputing.com/macro/
>>
>>26090754
>Macro gets a fetish quest
> No inflation quest.
>>
>>26090764
Anon pls.

I need this.
>>
>>26090651
>Yeesh, blatant, constant, child rape is less edgy than Vamp?
Being ethically dubious doesn't make something edgy.

A story is edgy if it's dark because the author thinks darkness is cool. Edginess is when fiction embraces the moodiness and immaturity of teenage angst.

Colt Quest is self aware and very lighthearted. It might be full of pedophilia, but that alone doesn't make it edgy.

There's no gore or pedophilia in Sonic, but Shadow the Hedgehog is still considered edgy. He is supposed to be cool, deep and awesome because he's sullen, tragic and moody. It's this immature admiration of darkness that makes him an edgy character.

Please note that when I say "edgy" I mean it in the disparaging 4chan sense of the word β€” I don't mean the dictionary definition.
>>
>>26089797
Check this out
>>
>>26090990
Already posted, fuckwad.
>>
File: 1430436763751.webm (2 MB, 500x280) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1430436763751.webm
2 MB, 500x280
>>26090990
>>
File: If you say so.jpg (51 KB, 676x858) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
If you say so.jpg
51 KB, 676x858
>M&M's is over
>>
File: I'm not ready yet.png (375 KB, 497x732) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
I'm not ready yet.png
375 KB, 497x732
>>26091034
>
>>
>>26090990
>another trans pone
nice to see trans people is getting the representation they deserve
>>
File: FUCK YOUR MEMES.png (765 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
FUCK YOUR MEMES.png
765 KB, 1280x720
>>26091062
>Hero's face when
>>
>>26090186
Yes. Yes we would.
>>
Waiting for Cough Syrup CYOA
>>
>>26091326
Never ever
>>
>>26090990
So Wood Spire is an Earth Pony who wants to be a unicorn. Etherbreeze is the unicorn who wants to be a pegasus. Who is the pegasus who wants to be an Earth pony?
>>
>>26091627
fluttershy
>>
>>26091636
It seems so obvious in retrospect.
>>
>>26091627
One is a tucute, the other is a truscum.

>tumblr
>>
>>26091627
The one in the CYOA you're going to make.
>>
>>26091651
Well, you sent me to google, and I came back less happy then I was before. Good job, anon.

Which one did you imagine was which?
>>
>>26091688
Etherbreeze was described as a genetic defect (her body is wired as a pegasus, it just fucked up), which makes her truscum, Wood Spire is described to 'feel like' he's a unicorn so the mental retardation makes him tucute.
>>
File: 1446516526143.gif (335 KB, 308x246) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1446516526143.gif
335 KB, 308x246
>>26091708

Pony species dysmorphia is a real condition, anon. Quit triggering me.
>>
>>26091708
I thought "tucute" meant that there's no real dysmorphia. AKA there's no actual mental problem, the person is "trans" without any diagnosis by any real psychologist. They're just "trans" to get oppression points, basically.

I think Ether is closer to IRL "intersex" people, while Wood is a truscum transfaggot.
>>
>>26091708
Makes sense.

>>26091778
You must have different definitions then the ones I found. When I looked up those words I got the following.

Truscum: believe that you are only trans if you want to become a different gender

Truscute: believe that you are also trans if you feel like you already are a different gender and do not need to transition
>>
>>26091778
>>26091832
Truscum believe there needs to be dysmorphia to be considered 'trans' which is usually based upon biology. Their brain/chemicals/hormones/whatever don't match their sex. Your body is fucked up and needs to be fixed. Transitioning is what currently has the highest success rate for the cost.

Tucutes believe that as long as you say you're trans, you're trans because you can't shackle their feelings. And they don't like the oppression of medical definitions, which is why they truscum truscum. Since your body isn't fucked up, you don't need to transition.

Intersex will fall into the Truscum category if they need to transition.

Etherbreeze is a truscum, Wood is a tucute faggot.
>>
>>26091778
That's not really what the word "intersex" means, even though some people use it like that.

>intersex (plural intersexes)

>Any of a variety of conditions (in a dioecious species) whereby an individual has male and female sex characteristics; the state of having the physical features of both sexes; intersexuality.
>>
>>26091879
This.
>>
>>26091879
I don't think we know enough about wood yet.

His brain might be miswired too, especially since he was able to learn basic TK.
>>
Tumblr pls.
>>
I want you all to cut this shit out right now
>>
>>26091927
Actually, I think we just finished.
>>
So what would Fluttershy be? Connection to animals, plant, or nature are all Earth pony magic, and she sucks at flying.
>>
>>26091963
Dumb
>>
>>26092091
>S-sorry.
>>
File: XwBJPQF.jpg (163 KB, 273x3686) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
XwBJPQF.jpg
163 KB, 273x3686
>>
>>26092929
ants
>>
>>26092929
Couldn't have blown it up a little bit? It's kind of really tiny.
>>
>>26092955
that's not the full comic

Im writing green for the full comic
>>
There, you happy Craft? I bumped all the cyoas for you.
>>
>>26093043
What.
>>
What do you people like about my cyoas the most
>>
>>26093205
This is bait.
>>
>>26093205
It's kinda like when someone watches a movie like Sharknado.
So shit it's funny
>>
File: buckle up.jpg (15 KB, 420x420) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
buckle up.jpg
15 KB, 420x420
>>26093205
>>
What do you people like about my cyoas the most
>>
>>26093233
Butts
>>
>>26093233
The original content
>>
What do you people like about my cyoas the best
>>
Give me fifty dollars and I'll ask what you like about my cyoas the most.
>>
Hey, I just got home right now, and the most I could probably do before I HAVE to sleep is like 1 post. I don't really Think I should but my quest is kinda stuck in a limbo area at the moment that I should try to get out of. So should I one post tonight even though I don't think that will move the quest along far enough to get out of the weak prompt area or should I just draw something else for the thread tonight.

>>26093233
Honestly Hijacker I mostly enjoy the lighthearted sense of humor in your quests. I find your characters fun in the way that they interact with the world and some of the things that are in the world that compliment their actions add a lot of flavor to the settings.
Nothing ever comes across as too heavy or too serious which is really where the strength of your quests lie.
>>
>>26093271
Leave it for tonight.
>>
>>26093233
Catbirds
>>
EG CYOA when?
>>
>>26093297
EG?
>>
>>26093313

Equestria Girl, I'm guessing.
>>
>>26093233

Definitely the butts.
>>
>>26093500
>>
>>26093505
>Urban Hijack
>>
File: airships.png (3 MB, 4452x2000) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
airships.png
3 MB, 4452x2000
didnt mean to delete
>>
>>26093541
Inept's is clearly superior. A true terror of the skies.
>>
>>26088855
Tell us the setting you faggot.
>>
>>26093617
The sky.
>>
>>26093541

Okay, that minotaur one is too awesome to not include in airship cyoa.
>>
>>26091708

I must have have missed that, where did the gm say she was mis-wired?
>>
>>26093663
Isn't her magic pegasus magic or some such and that's why the tats work?
>>
>>26093659
The minotaur ship throws punches. Literally
>>
>>26093677
Nah, they just use excess magic to fuel a spell.
>>
>>26093684

Like I said, too awesome to ignore. And it fits so well with what I've already got prepared.

The minotaur will also need to strike a few poses.
>>
>>26093541
>ship that is a knife with rockets on the end of it
Radical.
>>
>>26093541
>big collage of sick airships
>tiny poner floating on balloon

I'm torn between designing a new one altogether and just overhauling the S.S. Tinypone into something more intimidating.
>>
>>26093803
>a heavily armed pone tied to a spiky balloon
>>
>>26093809

Armed with just a big pointy stick.
>>
>>26093803
Absolutely not!
I love SS Tinypone

It is perfect on every way!
>>
>Gisela got her boat

Gisela's Pirate adventures when?
>>
>>26093541
I really like that one dead center with the swirly clouds on it. It definitely looks the most 'pony' out of any of them.
>>
>>26093865
Take a wild guess on which ones are pony engineered
>>
>>26093892
The dragon and minotaur.
>>
>>26093933
Dubs confirm that ponies build dragons.
>>
>>26092929
Perfect ending.
>>
CYOA you want others to run so you can participate?
>>
>>26094179
Tiny Pony Quest.
>>
>>26094179
Special division of Luna's guards that travel in the dreamscape to hunt Nightmares.
>>
>>26094210
But Luna does herself that perfectly.
>>
>Cuddle and Super died
I'm disappointed in myself
>>
>>26089823
>not who all wander are lost
>>
File: 1402708273707.gif (1 MB, 240x200) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1402708273707.gif
1 MB, 240x200
>>26094393
>Super died
>>
Anonfilly, Nyx and Hemera in Cutequestria
>>
File: 4444.jpg (98 KB, 1155x849) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
4444.jpg
98 KB, 1155x849
>>26094444
but those quads didnt
>>
>>26094235
>Special division of Luna's guards that travel the world to hunt Nightmares.
How about this?
>>
>>26094571
What are Nightmares doing outside dreams?
>>
>>
>>26095050
>implying green isn't yellow.
>>
File: 1440953205582.png (782 KB, 490x1015) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1440953205582.png
782 KB, 490x1015
>>26094210
>>26094235
>>26094571
Better way to fix all this:

Takes place before NMM's return. They're one of the last remaining division of the nightguard that weren't abolished. Tasked with doing Luna's dreamwalker duties and occasionally dealing with Nightmare Moon using her own powers to invade the dreams of some ponies and manipulate them in their dreams, along with other magical creatures that like to fuck with dreams.
>>
>>26095050
>tumblr
>>
>>26095100
Imagine all the dream-sex they must walk into on accident.
Now imagine all the sex dreams they start on purpose
>>
>>26094393
I go out to walk the dog and you pull this shit?
We're done Anon.
For good this time.
>>
>>26095050
pot and anon are obviously blue
>>
File: 1442670285946.png (896 KB, 800x924) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1442670285946.png
896 KB, 800x924
>>26095151
>A degenerate batpony could be fucking your waifu in her dreams right behind your back
No wonder bats have been genocided in the show.
>>
>>26095235
Relax Anon, she's not your waifu if she'd cheat.
>>
>>26095151
I bet that's what the players are going to do when the dream is not a nightmare. Rape ponies in their dreams with no consequences.
>>
>>26095250
They'd probably get kicked off the guard and arrested though
>>
>>26094393
>>26094444
>>
>>26094235
>>26095100
>>26094571
>>26094210
I actually had an idea like that for some time
It would be after the whole Tantabus ordeal after which Luna decides she can't remain the only one to be knowledgeable about dream magic, and decides to test training some of her guards to support her in her dream duties.
>>
So we recently had a couple of our longer quests wrap up quietly. With over 200k words and over 1k posts each both Mazes and Medusas and Space Vex have finished their quests.

I want to thank Hero and Space Bug for crafting their adventures for us to participate in even though crappy writing mistakes and retarded players. If they hadn't JUST 7 months ago then we would have a little bit less horse fiction to obsess over and compulsively whine about. So thank you. And always remember: Not everyone is bound to succeed. But you both managed to skate by by the skin of your teeth and finish what few faggots dare to dream.
>>
>>26095315
Could combine both ideas. Dreamwalker guard existed before, but was abolished when Luna was reformed since there didn't seem to be any need for them. After the Tantabus thing though, Luna decides to try and reform it.

The MC is one of the last recruits and technically was a part of the Dreamwalkers. He/She just joined literally 1 month before NMM escaped though and wasn't even complete with training.
>>
>>26095339
Yeah. That.
>>
>>26095339
>Space Vex
Wew
>>
>>26095339
>M&M
At least there will be no more shitposting

>Space Vex
Literally who
>>
I'm glad medusa is dead.
>>
File: evill.jpg (46 KB, 500x375) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
evill.jpg
46 KB, 500x375
>>26095379
>No more shitposting
>>
File: 1451568721017.png (62 KB, 249x234) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1451568721017.png
62 KB, 249x234
>>26095379
>no more shitposting
>>
>>26095393
>>26095407
At least no more M&M shit posting like the whole 'gay agenda' shit
>>
>>26095379
M&M drama pretty much stopped after the gay bathhouse fiasco

Hijacker has been the lead shitpost magnet QM for a while now.
>>
>>26095379
>those responsible for the shitposting will now surely fade into the ether!
>>
>>26095423
>implying the gay agenda hasn't jumped to JAD
>>
>>26095339
>Space Vex ended
Damn, I might have to catch up on it now. I hope Space CYOA will hold up now that one of the two QMs is gone.
>>
>>26095450
Space Horse is going to need to step back up again. He's basically been in a coma for months.
>>
>>26095423
M&M shitposting has always been below average, with the exception of that one day where they had a purge.
>>
>>26095463
There were three or four incidents. But yeah, it was pretty low except for the one everyone remembers.
>>
File: 1446965184147.jpg (41 KB, 640x360) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1446965184147.jpg
41 KB, 640x360
>>26095423
>make a joke about the talk in discussion
>shitstorm explodes and it becomes a meme
>>
Running Wander Quest for a bit.

>>26095460

>>26095460
>>
>RGS ends on thread 50
>M&M ends on thread 20
This pleases me
>>
>>26093541
What the fuck is the one nips drew
>>
>>26095574
battle bug
>>
>>26095585
But WHY
>>
>>26095597
Well why the fuck not?
>>
>>26095610
I meant why draw a bug when the others are airships
>>
>>26085962
No-uh, in dks 1 and 2, i have 198 twin humanities and 198 divine blessings
>>
>>26095616
because bugs are cool
>>
File: 1416147219130.gif (231 KB, 778x722) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1416147219130.gif
231 KB, 778x722
>>26095597
>>
File: 1435965252064.png (273 KB, 376x340) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1435965252064.png
273 KB, 376x340
>>26093541
>bathwaters ship with whales
>>
New thrad when
>>
File: Untitled.png (2 KB, 450x96) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Untitled.png
2 KB, 450x96
I found 35's favorite tag.
>>
>>26095728
Shouldn't it be ear hair?
An