Just bought this, partly out of interest; partly because it was so cheap at my Op Shop. What do you think of it, /lit/?
>>9401623
I don't think anyone on /lit/ has read it.
I once sold my mother's copy on eBay because I was embarrassed that she was reading it
>>9401628
Was it "used", anon? Did she "bend the spine", as it were?
Can someone give me a good explanation of Plato's reconciliation of Heraclitus and Parmenides? (even personally biased (if done with passion)).
After some dispersed reading I've convinced myself to start with the complete works of Plato and work my way up to actuality, and I don't know a lot about pre-socratics: to whomever's worthy and feeling positive enough to explain such reconciliation, could it be pleb-friendly?
Read the pre-socratics.
Parmenides and Heraclitus write on nature (physis).
Read the pre-socratics.
Heraclitus is the process philosophy guy, the only permanent thing is change itself, everything else is impermanent, ever-changing, ever-becoming. You find this in Asian philosophy a lot.
Read the pre-socratics.
Parmenides is the essentialist and idealist guy. Thinking itself is being. Parmenides also introduces the principle of non-contradiction, by the way.
The solution is Plato's distinction of matter and Form and to read the pre-socratics..
>>9401619
Any single book that explains them all?
>>9401638
Non-fiction
WWI did not take place
>>9401330
That's why I'm asking about The Great War, senpai
Guns of August seem to be well received among critics. Yay or nay?
itt: fav art of philosophers
Schelling: Oedipus by Sophocles because of how well it illustrated freedom vs necessity or fate.
Hegel: Antigone by Sophocles because it's a perfect tragedy of two competing good princples (state vs family) with a very satisfying (for hegel) resolution
Schopenhauer: Norma by Bellini because
>that tragedy causes its spectators to lose the will to live. "The horrors on the stage hold up to him the bitterness and worthlessness of life, and so the vanity of all its efforts and endeavors. The effect of this impression must be that he becomes aware, although only in an obscure feeling, that it is better to tear his heart away from life, to turn his willing away from it, not to love the world and life." He praised Norma for its artistic excellence in producing this effect. "…[T]he genuinely tragic effect of the catastrophe, the hero's resignation and spiritual exaltation produced by it, seldom appear so purely motivated and distinctly expressed as in the opera Norma, where it comes in the duet Qual cor tradisti, qual cor perdesti. [What a heart you betrayed, what a heart you lost.] Here the conversion of the will is clearly indicated by the quietness suddenly introduced into the music. Quite apart from its excellent music, and from the diction that can only be that of a libretto, and considered only according to its motives and to its interior economy, this piece is in general a tragedy of extreme perfection, a true model of the tragic disposition of the motives, of the tragic progress of the action, and of tragic development, together with the effect of these on the frame of mind of the heroes, which surmounts the world. This effect then passes on to the spectator…."
Kierkegaard: Don Giovanni by Mozart
>>9401263
why tho, i tried reading either/or but it was too patrician for me
Weininger: Ibsen's Peer Gynt
>In 1912 German writer Dietrich Eckart adapted the play. In Eckart's version, the play became "a powerful dramatisation of nationalist and anti-semitic ideas", in which Gynt represents the superior Germanic hero, struggling against implicitly Jewish "trolls". Ralph M. Engelman says, "Eckart meant his adaptation of Peer Gynt to represent a racial allegory in which the trolls and Great Boyg represented what [Otto] Weininger conceived to be the Jewish spirit." Eckart's version was one of the best attended productions of the age with more than 600 performances in Berlin alone. Eckart later helped to found the Nazi party.
>>9401237
Nietzsche: Chopin in general, he said that he would have gladly renounced to the rest of art for him.
What is the best book cover you've ever seen?
Definitely not the best, but I do like the everyman's library covers.
>>9401239
I've been laughing at this for a legit 6 minutes
My stomach hurts so much
Recommendations for less known dystopian novels? In two days I've read A Clockwork Orange, 1984, and A Handmaid's Tale, and I need more. Preferably oppressive governments or strange new societies vs. apocalyptic scenarios.
Parable of the Sower
>>9400947
Darkness at Noon
Dhalgren
http://www.thegreatcourses.com/courses/great-utopian-and-dystopian-works-of-literature.html
Pirate this.
The Fat Years
Greeting /lit/ I realize this is a slow board so I'll be patient, but as a avid /his/ browser, I have bare bones understanding of philosophy (I'm more informed than normies on it.) and I know my philosophers pretty well from studying history. I've started with the Greeks from a historical and literary standpoint but not philosophical.
I have a decent knowledge of the Socratic method, Socratic and Platonic dialogues, and I think it's better time spent If i skip the pre-socratics and go straight to Plato. Is this recommended? And if it is can anyone give me a quick Plato rundown and what I should expect?
You can do it. The presocratics are interesting but barely anything from them survives, so you can really only get the gist of their ideas. There are some books that give you context and all of their writings and it totals to only about 270 pages.
Yes.
>>9400892
Perhaps you'd like to start with Heraclitus and Parmenides. Their works are short.
>tfw I can write well but I can't write long
How do you go about stretching a story into a 50,000 word novel? How do you drive the plot on?
By spreading out what I write.
You probably spend too much time on one sentence. You should just write as much as you can, then revise later.
>tfw I can only write short, florid pretensions which take me a 3 words a minute
>>9400801
It's just a consequential series of short stories that have an interlinked, overarching plot. View it as several smaller stories that create a whole. Write 10x5000, and then meld into a whole.
Is it worth reading Infinite Jest for a non - American (non - anglo, and even non - European for that matter) or would not being able to get most of the cultural references ruin it for me?
t. Third world dweller
>>9400669
Frankly no, it is a meme, and consumed ironically by a post-hipster nu-male """""intelligentsia"""". I had always thought the phrase "no discernible talent" was a meme itself until I read this book, and realized that it had neither prose nor plot merit.
most references are explained in the footnotes. it is a good book. you should read it.
these 2 haven't read it
>>9400676
>>9400793
>>9400669
it is the atlas shrugged of /lit/
why is stoicism so popular among normies nowaday?
>>9400550
examples? stoner?
>>9400550
answer me!
>>9400550
>normies
>having any kind of philosophical framework outside of their own self interest
Ich bin verzweifelt auf der Suche nach Testlesern, da ich keine ernstzunehmende Kritik aus meinem Freundeskreis erwarten kann und auf entsprechenden Webseiten nicht die nötige Aufmerksamkeit bekomme.
Ich hatte mir den Rat von /lit/ zu Herzen genommen und versucht, etwas in meiner Muttersprache zu verfassen:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/vx198mtci8v6oc5/Badland%27s%20Champion.pdf?dl=0
https://www.dropbox.com/s/03e26eii05h4akk/Badland%27s%20Champion%202.pdf?dl=0
https://www.dropbox.com/s/rr757v6kgcooc1h/Badland%27s%20Champion%203.pdf?dl=0
https://www.dropbox.com/s/n6p2r8nq7gjjxg2/Badland%27s%20Champion%204.pdf?dl=0
(Momentaner Arbeitstitel, Kapitel 1 zur Sicherheit und Übersicht aufgeteilt)
Ich hab dazu besonders folgende Bedenken:
>zu langatmig?
>nicht-authentisches Verhalten der Charaktere?
>Was wissen wir über die Charaktere?
>Behindernde Unklarheiten?
Werde k1 Virus anklicken Brudi, poste mal den ersten Abschnitt
Benutzt du Discord? Würde einen Auszug lesen, aber lieber über Pastebin oder etwas vergleichbares
vonranke#6687
Ich schau in 2-3 Stunden nochmal in den Thread
>>9400539
Wie ein Toter, der es noch nicht wahrhaben will dass er tot ist, trottet eine kleine, schwarzhaarige Mumie -mehr oder weniger zielstrebig- durch den gelbgrauen Sand.
Die Körner haben sich gegenseitig im ewig währenden Trommelfeuer bereits zu feinen ,stumpfen Staubwolken zerschlagen, nun an der Mumie zerrend, drückend, versuchte sie laut heulend zum Aufgeben zu zwingen.
Immer wieder unter Schubsen und Wehen fragend, ob dieser halbtote Haufen an verbrannter Haut, hölzernen Sehnen und trocknem, dickflüssigem Blut doch nicht eine gemütliche Grabstätte sich aussuchen wollte, die sicherste existenzielle Tatsache allen Lebens endlich akzeptieren wollte?
Doch der Halbtote Haufen hatte bereits zu viel mit dem pochendem, zähen Blut zu tun, welches unter Kopfschmerzen nach einem Lösungsmittel schrie, oder mit den matten Augen welche nur noch Sterne sahen.
Deshalb gab die Mumie keinen feuchten Dreck darauf, dass sie bereits tot sein sollte.
...
Etwas weiter entfernt, in irgendeiner der vier Himmelsrichtungen, hatte eine kleine Siedlung, welche sich im Tandem mit einem durch dessen Mitte laufendem Fluss schlängelte, keine derartigen Probleme.
Diese Ortschaft, welche das Glück hat, den Unrat von nur drei weiteren in Nähe des Oberlaufs thronenden Gemeinden in seinem Wasser zu beherbergen, kann sich nicht gerade über solche ungewöhnlichen Dinge beklagen.
Die Menschen hier haben nämlich die erfreuliche Angewohnheit, sich ihrer Sitten zu besinnen - So wie es sich für Tote gehört, bleiben diejenigen die in Hayett sterben auch schön ruhig liegen.
Um ihre Nachbarn nicht plötzlich zu erschrecken.
...
In der Gemeinde Hayett, deren Architektur von schiefen, kruden Lehmbauten und dem ein oder anderen Kleinpalast dominiert ist, dort wo der Wüstenstaub mit der schwül-feuchten und von Blutsaugern durchsetzten Luft vom Ufer zusammenschlug, tummelte sich ein bunter Haufen aus Einheimischen, Händlern und Landstreichern.
Ein wohlhabender Vermieter, dem die Stechmücken oftmals lieber waren als seine eben genannten sonstigen Nachbarn, war soeben damit fertig, einen tiefen Zug aus seiner uralten Tabakpfeife zu nehmen und über die grauenvollen Drohungen eines zugesteckten Erpresserbriefes zu grübeln.
Das Wachssiegel auf dem Umschlag war ihm unbekannt, aber das leise, tönerne Knirschen des kleinen Apperates unter seinem reich geschmückten Turban erinnerte ihn daran, dass ein Vergehen gegen die Worte in diesem ominösen Brief ihn trotzdem unter die Erde bringen kann.
Do I need to read The Odyssey before Ulysses? What's the best version of Ulysses?
You need to have a fairly good grasp of the Western canon before reading Ulysses, and that includes the Odyssey.
Penguin Annotated Student's addition
>>9400406
What would the essential canon be? I imagine Homer, Virgil, Dante, Bible are all at the very least?
>>9400417
You'll never be well read enough to understand everything in Ulysses, so I recommend reading Portrait of the Artist and then jumping right in. If you like it, you will want to reread it, and you'll have a better idea of what you should read before your second read (Aristotle to better understand Stephen for example).
Hey /lit/ I've read quite a bit of leftist literature, but I've never read anything truly opposing those views. Can you recommend some right-wing or otherwise opposite reading material?
Bear in mind that I'm not looking for someone from /pol/ to try and "red pill" me ITT. I'm just looking for book suggestions.
real life.
>>9400378
Poor contribution
>>9400364
probably read Leo Strauss I guess. I dunno. it's hard to find stuff that makes genuinely compelling arguments, & when you do find them they're usually about as cryptic as Strauss is.
I guess Strauss, Raymond Aron, and Ernest Gellner would be the three people I would recommend as being genuinely smart and making good arguments without being total fucks. Opium Of The Intellectuals is a pretty fair start I guess.
also, Hannah Arendt is hardly a conservative, but I would strongly encourage reading her for anyone interested in these topics, she's the best
Redpill me on John Green.
Worship me.
>>9399999
Nines
>>9399997
John Green is the redpill
Holy Hell this was one of the most unexpectedly touching and well-written novels I've ever read. Is anything else in Fantasy this good or has White ruined a genre for me?
Bumping for interest, the once and future king is my favorite
>>9399951
he ruined it bro, you mostly will find shitty tolkien ripoff
>>9399951
I haven't read much fantasy but Steven Erikson is fantastic.