[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Home]
4Archive logo
Why?
If images are not shown try to refresh the page. If you like this website, please disable any AdBlock software!

You are currently reading a thread in /co/ - Comics & Cartoons

Thread replies: 213
Thread images: 29
File: ASD.png (221 KB, 394x479) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
ASD.png
221 KB, 394x479
Why?
>>
File: rf just because.jpg (161 KB, 413x500) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
rf just because.jpg
161 KB, 413x500
>>66300034
>>
>>66300163
Because why?
>>
>>66300413
Because the writers decided so. You are not the show's writer. If you don't like what the writers did, stop watching the show.

IT'S THAT EASY.
>>
Have they confirmed this is permanent?
>>
>>66300653
It was always permanent. Think about it.
>>
File: 1366255891043.gif (272 KB, 234x206) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1366255891043.gif
272 KB, 234x206
>>66300034
Because it's cool.
>>
>implying it isn't fucking glorious
>>
>>66300653
By staff on twitter, "status quo isn't always good"
>>
>>66300034
>Why
>is OP a pissbaby
>>
Is this inside of Pennys shell like they were teasing a year ago? What happened to doe Penny?
>>
>>66301418
That was just a baseless fan theory
>>
>>66301053
Gumball confirmed for better than adventure time.
>>
>>66301418
They couldn't use it without getting sued.
>>
>>66300034
Euggh
>>
>>66300034
at least she is cute
>>
>>66300034
>>66300034
I like the shapeshifting aspect of it but find her base design to be pretty shitty.
>>
>>66302010
-mented beautifulness!
>>
>>66302076
yeah it's like one of the shitty background characters that they use.
>>
Oh, is this the thread for the autists and crybabys who like their shitty fanon?

What Ben gave us is glorious.
>>
>>66303272
I like it too, but don't be that faggot who thinks everybody has to like everything.
>>
>>66303272
Enjoying the taste of that french cock, anon?

Slurp slurp slurp
>>
>>66303668

>assblasted furfag is this mad
>>
>>66301976
Fuck you it was never an actual idea anyway eat a dick go fuck yourself go eat a grilled dick sandwich go stand out in traffic look at me when I'm talking to you don't give me that look don't make me repeat myself.
>>
>>66303706
>he does it for free
>>
this is horrible. like really i miss season 1 they were more funny and less romantic same with regular show, this sucks and penny sucks now That it show it ruined thanks to this episode now the new episodes are going to have more love crap, and more fangirls will make anime love crap and love videos. The more fan base the more stupid the show gets like really the fans always ruin the show, Penny isn't a deer shes a weird 2d cartoon Monster which isn't cool because shes just like those monsters in the woods in that picnic episode and by the way what happen to 3d characters they are all gone from season 2 this should of been the last episode if the same happens to Carrie and Darwin screw this show. what were the writers thinking i know its suppose to be cute but What the heck this episode is like twilight cartoon booooo 1/10 i hope this show goes back to funny then romance and all the fan girls who dislike this review IDC my opinion and my favorite character Ron got rejected that sucks anyways bad episode i hope if the have a season 4 it doesn't turn out like this because i can tell they are competing with regular show. Go back to funny humor. Not romance.
>>
>>66304134
That's a marvelous impersonation of a stupid person.
>>
>>66300034

I hoped, at least she was a kind of deer, but this!?, it like if the whole time instead a peanut she were an egg...
>>
File: 0808kimlooking01.jpg (322 KB, 2500x1667) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
0808kimlooking01.jpg
322 KB, 2500x1667
>>66300034
>Why?

Why? THIS is why.
>>
File: 1309726693600.jpg (69 KB, 507x307) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1309726693600.jpg
69 KB, 507x307
>>66300844
>>
>>66300034
>>
File: PennyMonster.png (111 KB, 320x240) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
PennyMonster.png
111 KB, 320x240
>>66300034

Is she an alien? I think she looks cool. I'm not a furfag, so I don't care if that doe-Penny headcanon was wrecked.
>>
>>66307021
She looks more like a creature from the woods.
>>
>>66300606
It's not so easy to understand for Adventure Time fandom/hatedom.
>>
>>66304134
oh by the way i said i was gonna use it like this. this post wasn't me
>>
>>66301976
People need to stop spreading this bullshit. There is a such thing as plausable deniability and people coming up with similar ideas on their own. They could've used deer Penny just fine.

But they didn't because deer a shit.
>>
>>66300034
>Muh fanart is ruined
>>
while I always liked the doe-nut theory, because I am a horrible person who enjoys puns. But I have to say, just on pure fucking with the fandom, I support this. I mean, If I ever got creative control of a cartoon, half my decision making process would be "will it troll the fandom"
>>
>>66311650
>Enjoys puns
Jelly filled doe-nut
>>
>>66300034
Artistic liberty
>>
I can understand the reasoning behind it. What could you possibly do with the fact that she is a deer? There's no interesting stories here, and it would also be way harder to explain why she wears a shell in the first place.
>>
>>66300034
>Shapeshifting
>Tentacles
Okay I'm game.
>>
I don't even watch this show.
>>
>>66302076
yeah this

she just looks like a lightbulb with wings
>>
she's naked
>>
>>66311667
CARLOS you motherfucker, show you god damn face
>>
>>66312193
All she had on before were arm bands and shoes.
>>
>>66312215
that didn't stop darwin
>>
>>66300034
I wanna fuck that gelatinous betentacled shapeshifter
>>
File: Tumblr.jpg (347 KB, 1200x775) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Tumblr.jpg
347 KB, 1200x775
>>66300034
>its horns are tumblr symbols
>>
>>66312320
>tumblr invented the "t" shape
you're going full retard, anon
>>
File: response.jpg (12 KB, 328x212) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
response.jpg
12 KB, 328x212
>>66300606
>read that in his voice
>>
>>66312320
Guess what, they are dick symbols too!
>>
>>66312320
>twitter symbols
*x-files theme*
>>
>>66304133
you are autist
>>
>>66304134
You should be appy for a sow to break the status quo like that its revolutionary and anyhow theres always love plots i every cartoon ever its how it alway goes.
>>
>>66300034
>>
>>66312320
Ironic shitposting is still shitposting.
>>
>>66304134
Jesus Christ I've seen this copy pasta like 4 times already.
>>
File: 1398194585186.jpg (12 KB, 220x229) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1398194585186.jpg
12 KB, 220x229
I prefer the cutie moose.
>>
>>66313891
while the deer was cute, what exactly would they do with it? There's no interesting stories to tell with that or even a reason why she was in the shell to begin with
>>
>>66313921
they could tell interesting stories with it the same way they've done it with a cat and a fish.
>>
>>66313931
Get over it, Her being a shapeshifter and her whole family being shapeshifters is a way more interesting plot twist and can branch off onto many stories.
>>
>>66313957
>plot twist
>>
Why even wonder what's "inside" her? I just thought what he originally looked like as a nice design and left it there.
>>
>they don't see the infinite possibilities of shapeshifting girlfriends

You poor, poor plebians.
>>
>>66313957
Disclaimer: I don't actually care what's under her shell. She could have been an actual nut underneath there and I wouldn't have cared.

Creativity isn't throwing the most wacky thing you can think of in there. If you can't branch off many stories from any sort of material, you probably shouldn't be writing in the first place.
>>
File: 128648231012.png (378 KB, 1280x1024) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
128648231012.png
378 KB, 1280x1024
>>66313891
>furfags of all people complaining

also this
>>66314094
>>
>>66314196
>durr I don't care what was under the shell
>hurr why wasn't Deer Penny under the shell?
>>
>>66314364
>baseless trolling
I see.
>>
>>66300034
This episode was kind of stupid.
>>
>>66313891
That's literally a shit colored Gumball. Why was this so preferred?

>>66314081
Because people associate shells with hiding something and our inability to see her eyes always made people wonder.
>>
>>66314081
It's more of a step up to most people.
I'm glad Ben is taking risks and made a permanent character change.
So far, he did it right with most people reacting postively, and the show is still going on pretty well and strong.
Penny barely had character before IMO.
>>
File: KefkaGodSprite[1].png (5 KB, 254x254) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
KefkaGodSprite[1].png
5 KB, 254x254
>>
>>66300034
It was pretty underwhelming for all the hype it got.
>>
>>66300034
It's like a flying spaghetti monster.
>>
>>66314526
>>66315003

shit taste confirmed.
>>
>>66315693
Something wrong, m8?
>>
>>66314341

Honestly that entire scene was beautiful.
>>
>>66315693
>dissenting opinions make me mad
>>
>>66300034
Because deerfags needed to get BTFO.
>>
>>66315975
except she's a shapeshifter so they kinda confirmed deer penny
>>
>>66316277
>Not one animal form was an anthro like Gumball
You're not getting your turd Gumball.
>>
>>66316452
she had a couple of anthro forms, a couple of anthro forms, no reason to assume she can't have an anthro animal form.
>>
>>66316277

except any deer penny now would be a Jelly doenut
>>
>>66316839
>She never turns into an antrho animal form.
>Assume she can just cause.

Dem straws will break in your grip.
>>
Meh. Deer-penny was better.
>>
>>66316942
slurp slurp slurp
>>
>>66316960
Why would a deer wear a shell in the first place? At least with her being a shapeshifter having a shell in the first place would make sense. I wouldn't have minded if there was nothing underneath the shell but her organs. The original design was fine. This one is okay too, much better than the deer at least.
>>
>>66318214
Why does a lightbulb or a bunny or a wolf need a shell?
>>
>>66316960
>>66317126

>assblasted furfags preferring their own shitty head canon because of muh waifu
>>
>>66316960
This. Don't see why it's so hard for people to understand that.
>>
Base Penny form should have been more deer like.
>>
File: 1385741542450.jpg (18 KB, 360x360) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1385741542450.jpg
18 KB, 360x360
>>66318414
Because it's not?
>>
pics of dragon form, plz
>>
>>66318338
She's neiither of those things. She's a shape shifter with a poor method of control. A method so poor she can be something truly monstrous if she feels shitty enough.

>>66318414
Because how is antlered brown Gumball inexplicably wearing a shell better?
>>
>>66318484
>>
>>66318414
Must be kinda embarrassing when dA amateurs can design a better character than professonials.
>>
>>66318454
It clearly is, bro.
>>
>>66318338
She can't control her shapeshifting because it's based on emotion, and needs a shell to contain the shapeshifting. Her base design could have been something other than a lightbulb, sure. I like it well enough though.
>>
penny should have beebn a deer. How am I going to fap to this? 0/10, Ben.
>>
File: 1340747981610.png (123 KB, 300x168) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1340747981610.png
123 KB, 300x168
>>66318516
Except it's not
>>
>>66318488
Well then there's nothing preventing her from adopting deer penny form.
>>
>>66318511
Yeah. Oh well.
>>
Deer Penny fans really are the worst "fans" of the show.
>>
>>66318519
>Her base design could have been something other than a lightbulb, sure.

right, like a deer girl
>>
>>66318598
I just think her base design should have been the deer or more deer like to at least give a nod to the fans. The one we have is pretty shitty, and deer base form would make much more sense as she already changes into other animals.
>>
>>66318598
Oh hai. You must be new.
>>
>>66318617

No, because they could have been sued. And deer Penny was boring waifushit for braindead furries like you.

Slime girl Alien Shapeshifter>Wretched furfag design
>>
>>66318537
Except there is no emotional state that can be represented with being a humanoid deer. I don't know what state she could use to be a regular deer. And on top of it all, there is no confirmation she can be a humanoid form of an animal at all.

stop deerfag.

>>66318617
No. That's stupid.

>>66318598
It's going to get worse from here on out. Gumball threads will now go to shit with Penny episodes.
>>
>>66318640
Nah, they couldn't use the deer for legal reasons.

This ways best. They showed Penny beneath her shell, but they kept the fan interpretation canon too. Best of both worlds.
>>
>>66318640

>make more sense

Nothing makes sense in Elmore

>>66318642

While everyone who was an actual fan of the show was talking, everyone loved the new designs.
>>
>>66318668

Gumball threads won't get worst, because these asswipes don't post in them, and just realized Penny isn't a deer, days after the fact.

They're not fans of the show.
>>
>>66318692
Right. The deer penny fans loved the new designs, in addition to the old one still being canon.
>>
>>66318640
why give the nod instead of doing something unique and probably planned since S1?

>>66318650
Much as I hate deer shit, fearing lawsuits was never a reason against deer shit.
>>
>>66318509
more plz
>>
>>66318725
Fans or not, they could take this as a sign that Gumball threads would be fun to troll with using deer Penny. Especially next Penny episode.
>>
>>66300034
Because Ben is a hack, and TAWOG is shit
>>
File: 1413003828752.png (152 KB, 997x717) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1413003828752.png
152 KB, 997x717
>>66318757
>>
>>66318734
Uh, no, not including fan content is a standard policy on all TV shows and other professional media.

A lot of shows even have their employees sign contracts forbidding them from reading fanfiction, just to prevent it.
>>
>>66318734
>why give the nod instead of doing something unique and probably planned since S1?


Because it was such a popular fan theory that got destroyed by something with absolutely no forshadowing. Her feet hands and antlers all pointed to (if there was anything actually underthere) deer.

A mix between the two would have been much fucking better then lightbulb girl.
>>
>there are seriously people who don't think Deer-Penny is superior to this
>>
>>66301791
kek. let's see them actually go through with this first
>>
Is it wrong that I just want to see Gumball and Penny make out and see Penny transform during the kissing?
>>
>>66318798
screencaps preferred
>>
>>66311099

But this isn't Adventure Time.
It's Gumball.
>>
>>66318814
Deer Penny is not a ground breaking or unique concept. It'd be piss easy to claim the idea was alluded to with the antlers already there.

Coincedences happen and no one gets sued over it by fans.
>>
File: smugpig.jpg (39 KB, 430x430) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
smugpig.jpg
39 KB, 430x430
>>66318214
>Why would a deer wear a shell in the first place?

Because it would make her a doe-nut.
>>
>>66318827
>Because it was such a popular fan theory
doesn't mean shit.

>Her feet hands and antlers all pointed to (if there was anything actually underthere) deer.

The only one you have is the antlers. Nothing about her hands and feet (when did we see her feet) points to anything.
>>
>>66318889
It was ground breaking and original enough for a lawsuit.

Back in the eighties some guy wrote a Star Wars fanfiction where Luke Skywalker visited a planet of teddy bears, so after ROTJ came out he sued them for plagiarizing the Ewoks. Cost them hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal fees alone.
>>
Can someone post the download link for the episode?
>>
File: Shl75.png (903 KB, 1364x768) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Shl75.png
903 KB, 1364x768
>>66318849
>>
>>66319029
https://mega.co.nz/#!OwpEWYwa!BTWaogp3dgNpeZt4J2zcbyu2weuJU3y_NkzvufjcZ0A
>>
>Tina bullies Gumball
>Penny's dragon-face when
>>
>>66318982
>It was ground breaking and original enough for a lawsuit.

No it wasn't.

>Back in the eighties some guy wrote a Star Wars fanfiction where Luke Skywalker visited a planet of teddy bears, so after ROTJ came out he sued them for plagiarizing the Ewoks. Cost them hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal fees alone.

You need to source this because I think this didn't happen.
>>
>>66319109
Did deer penny exist before the fanartist first drew it? No?

Well then if the show had used it, the fanartist could have sued them.
>>
>>66319227
By your logic, anyone who made edgy Sonic recolors before Sonic Adventure 2 could sue Sega over Shadow the Hedgehog. Anyone who made girl finns before Fionna and Cake could sue Cartoon Network. That's NOT how law works.

The fanartist would have to prove that they had contact with Ben and friends and showed off Deer Penny to them. They'd have to prove that Deer Penny wasn't already an idea by Ben since he can easily make up a defense about her antlers forshadowing it.

There'd be alot more fan lawsuits in the world if your idea of the legal world had any basis in reality.
>>
>>66319227
that's not how copyright, or intellectual property works. Nor is it even how creativity works.
>>
>>66319435
>>66319435
Maybe if deer Penny were a Gumball recolor, you'd have a point. Different body type, different nose/muzzle. Different eyes. Different ears. Hair. Freckles, etc.

I know you're trying to force the whole "it's a Gumball recolor"meme, but nobody's picking it up.
>>
>>66319530
penny deer is sonic tier OC.
Thats all
Just the pure true
>>
>>66319500
No, it is. Some artist designs a character, that design is theirs. They don't need to be a professional artist. They don't need to go down to the Copyright Office and have a notary public officially register it.
>>
>>66319576
>who is Ken Penders?
>>
>>66319227
>Well then if the show had used it, the fanartist could have sued them.

No, they couldn't have, since the fan-artist was just making a wild interpretation of what he thought was underneath there based on visual clues the lead designer put there, if this actually made it to court(and it wouldn't, it would have been tossed out like last weeks sack of shit) the show runner could have used the argument that the artist guy just guessed correctly based on the clues he laid down.

In reality, it's just because the showrunner looked at deer-penny and said "Fuck that, that's not amazing enough." and made something more amazing.
>>
http://strawpoll.me/2767038
>>
>>66300034
I think she looks cute. Monsters are cute.
>>
>>66319617
A guy who actually worked on Sonic and took advantage of an incompetent company.

>>66319530
No you really don't have a point. "Deer Penny" by itself already suffers from being a derivative of Penny Fitzgerald which is owned by whomever owns the Gumball franchise. That fanartist can be sued into oblivion if CN were they that vindictive towards fans drawing fanart.
>>
File: orangeporn.png (102 KB, 283x178) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
orangeporn.png
102 KB, 283x178
so why are we talkinga bout this and not that fact that gumball walked in on a banana person masterbating to naked oranges?
>>
Who's that? What's wrong with her?
>>
>>66319585
Okay, seriously. Can you name a single instance, just one, where a fan, NOT A LICENSED ARTIST, designed something based in an existing property as a fan-work, the OG creator used or referenced this work, and then sued for it? Just one?

One time, come on, it's called "citing precedence'
>>
File: shl89.png (1 MB, 1364x768) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
shl89.png
1 MB, 1364x768
>>
>>66319715
If the artist were making money off of the character "Penny Fitzgerald" then CN could sue them for copyrights violation.

However, if CN had used the "deer Penny" form for their character on the show, then the artist could have sued them.
>>
>>66319791
Thats not how US copyright laws work though.
>>
>>66319530

same head shape
same body type
same eyes
same general art style

the reason deer penny is so popular is precisely because she's easy to draw along with gumball. She doesn't look like something that belongs in a world as crazy as the show's. The deer is too cute and normal.
>>
>>66319791
>However, if CN had used the "deer Penny" form for their character on the show, then the artist could have sued them.

No, they couldn't have, what the hell is making you think this? I do not get why you think this is how this works when there is not a single instance of it happening ever. Just google it or something for fucks sake.
>>
>>66319879
>what the hell is making you think this?

This is typically what happens when you commit plagiarism.

Fan-characters count as property of their creators.
>>
>>66319879
If I said the name "derpy" would that mean anything to you?
>>
>>66319692
Bumbing this.
>>
>>66319692
DEER PENNY FAGS BTFO
>>
>>66319109

I cannot back up that guy's claim about star wars, but what he's saying is actually true, about the lawsuits, it's actually part of Cartoon Network's policies, Lauren Faust (while she was still working on Fosters) explained this while doing a AMA session on the Toon Zone forums some years ago, she explained that, at least in CN, they're forbidden to look at fanfics and implementing ideas from there.
>>
>>66319997
It's not a fan character. It's an interpretation of an exisitng character. Deer Penny is still Penny property of Cartoon Network.

>>66320040
Wouldn't that be an example of fanwork being integrated into a show just fine? The worst thing that happened is they took away her name and voice because of bitching parents saying it's offensive.
>>
>>66320040
Yes.

It would mean the exact opposite of literally everything he just said.

>>66319997
Seriously man, google it. They would have no precedence to claim a viable case. It has never, once, happened. And why? Well, because obviously if this dumbass came up to a lawyer and explained this case, the lawyer would in fact inform him that you do not need to be making any sort of money off a fan-work in order to be sued for violating copywrite. Which means Deer-Penny is something they could sue HIM over, not the other way around.

He would have no case.
>>
>>66320120
The name was the fanwork. When the legal department found out about it, they had is scrubbed. And that's not even a fan artwork or fan fiction. Just a fan nickname.

Same thing with comics. They fired the artist when he put some fan OC in the background.
>>
Couldn't transformation Penny turn into a deer anyway? Except glowy?
>>
>>66320087
http://strawpoll.me/2767158/

I wasn't really asking the right question I suppose.
>>
>>66320101
http://articles.latimes.com/1990-01-24/entertainment/ca-796_1_george-lucas
>>
>>66320101
In order to avoid implementing ideas from fanworks, you have to know what those ideas are. But since you can't read fanworks, you will never know what those ideas are.

So your only option is just to write and draw whatever you like and if some fan is ballsy enough to try and take them to court, utterly wreck them.
>>
>>66320207

no, her shapes are all determined by how she feels.

"deer" is not an emotion.
>>
>>66320178
>The name was the fanwork. When the legal department found out about it, they had is scrubbed

Nope, they still own the trademark for the name, they pulled it because of complaints and, in fact, it is still present on several DVD's. They still own the name "Derpy", they just can't use it because of the complaints.

> They fired the artist when he put some fan OC in the background.

Wrong again, and in fact putting background OC's in there is something they do all the time. The issue was the OC in question raised ire because, in fact, she was the OC of a misandrist individual who, no joke, said "all men were better off dead" and only got in because she gave a t-shirt to the artist.

Oh, and bonus points! This OC of said horrible person? Was put on a WALL OF HEROES.

Now, see if anyone's got a problem with the eight billion other OC's put in there.
>>
>>66320178
>They fired the artist when he put some fan OC in the background.

This is somethign totally different tho, the owner of the OC was actually happy about it and bragging about what happened.

The guy was fired when it was brought to IDW's attention that said OC was from a person known for profitting from MLP while also using the MLP characters to spread Hateful messages.

It wasn't because she sued over her ownership of her crappy OC.
>>
>>66320226

That's not really a defense.

>I couldn't have plagiarized him because I never read his work!

How can you possibly prove that? In copyright lawsuits, the primary determiner for whether something is plagiarism is how similar it is and how easy it would be for someone to mistake the two as being the same thing.

The 'I didn't read it' defense has no legal viability because you can't prove you didn't.
>>
>>66320178
It was scrubbed because of complaints about it being offensive to retards. Not because of some lawsuit fear bullshit.

And that artist was fired because he was showing appreciation for someone who utterly despises the male MLP fanbase. Again, not over anything legal.
>>
>There are people on this thread that don't think her base form looking more deer-like wouldn't have been perfect.
>>
>>66320233

im not one to defend Deer penny (infact true form penny is my new waifu and i have been doing anything but drawing her lately) but this is a flimsy excuse, Jackalope and dragon aren't emotions either.
>>
>>66300034
What's this? A living condom?
>>
>>66320288
>How can you possibly prove that?

Innocent until proven guilty, motherfucker. It's is on the fan to prove he read it, not the creator.

How do you not know the most basic of legal proceedings?
>>
I'll ask again WHO IS THIS CHARATER?
>>
>>66320330

>m-muh waifu!
>>
>>66320349

they represent something.

the little rabbit was fear.

the dragon was defiance.
>>
>>66320364
No not really, I just think Lightbulb girl is shit the more I look at her. She looks like a fucking background character.
>>
>>66320355
>Innocent until proven guilty, motherfucker.

No. It doesn't work that way when it's something that is impossible to prove.

That's not how plagiarism cases are settled. They're settled by examining the work and determining if it's something the guy could reasonably have created without viewing the other person's work.

If it was the way you described it then no plagiarism case would ever be won by a plaintiff.
>>
>>66320396

If there's an episode where Penny makes an OC and then refuses to give it up when a show debunks it, then she could turn into a deer.
>>
>>66320396

By the same logic the deer could represent something, would be contribed as hell, but again, it's not impossible.

but i for one think they will not do it, i don't want them to do it, but the fact is, it reminds a possibility.
>>
>>66320412

No, actually. Deer Penny is boring. Nu Penny is exotic and interesting.
>>
>>66320352
It's a gril who takes barbed cat cock.
>>
>>66320471
Yes I agree, Nu Penny is a great concept and I prefer it to old idea.

BUT. Normal lightbulb looking baseform Penny is horrifyingly bland and shit.
>>
>They didn't use our retarded dA-tier fan theory? What the fuck?

/co/ can really be awful sometimes.
>>
>>66320547

She's not bland. No one in Elmore looks like her. You're just a sad furry who thinks that deer Penn is the hottest shit, and are baffled that someone thinks a lazily designed deer isn't captivating
>>
>>66320439
>They're settled by examining the work and determining if it's something the guy could reasonably have created without viewing the other person's work.
And you think deer penny is something that couldn't be created without seeing some Deviantart trash? That when they put antlers on Penny's S1 design, no one could possibly have thought about deers?
>>
Kind of funny how the only people who still talk about Deer Penny are the ones who don't like Deer Penny.
>>
Did anybody care who Penny was before she put on the shell?
>>
>>66320552

Most people in this thread love nu penny, it's just a very loud and vocal minority.

They're not even fans of the show. During our actualy talkback, everyone loved the episode and design. It's non-fans who liked deer Penny.
>>
>>66320586
>She's not bland
She's a lightbulb with wings and antlers, thats much more bland then Old Penny.

Stop trying to defend bad designs.
>>
>>66320661

>says the one supporting Deer Penny

The irony is delicious. Keep crying.
>>
Okay, the people arguing that Deer-Penny artist could have sued CN have got to be trolling.

Just out of curiosity, what the hell do you think they're suing them over? Because, and here's a shocker, when most copyright cases go to court, it's because Company A, doing the suing, feels company B, who is being sued, are resulting in the loss of money or the degradation of their brand or intellectual property.

Now, I want you to pretend you're a lawyer for a second here, go eat the soul of a small toddler if it helps get into the groove. What, I ask, is he supposed to say?

"Gee, your honor, I know my clients fan-work is technically a result of an existing intellectual property, and thus if he had been in any way profiting from this it would be illegal, and in fact it's technically illegal anyway, and I know his intellectual property is not being degraded because, again, he has no means to gain monetary or exposure value from this depiction of a character he does not own, but my client is owed money for this, somehow, because otherwise he would just keep not making money off a property he does not own."

You want to know why this has never once happened? Because if they tried, the lawyer would just never stop laughing. He would laugh until he upchucked the unborn fetuses that give him the strength to make it through the day, and that would be the end of it.

Because they're not this stupid.
>>
>>66320612
5 fucking threads one after the other since the episode aired. Whoever didn't get on this by then doesn't actually care about the show, or if he does now is suffering because this is all the talkback he'll get
>>
File: $_35.jpg (14 KB, 300x225) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
$_35.jpg
14 KB, 300x225
>>66300034

Nobody gets it, her and her parents are peanut shaped because they are nutty putty.

It's why she's odd colors and can shapeshift.
>>
>>66320715

Oh wow
>>
>>66320688
No, I support a mixture between the two because the one we currently have is shit.
>>
>>66320715

WELP! I'm appeased for now then.
>>
>>66300034
I honestly would've preferred Penny just stay in her shell, but this is... fine, I guess.
>>
>>66320755

To your prion-addled brain, yes. But thankfully, dreadfully shit taste like yours is in the minority.
>>
>>66320691
It doesn't matter. Networks don't like to take risks so they make their employees sign contracts that prevent them from taking ideas from the fans. In rare cases, an instance can be approved by the network, but even then you would need to be dealing with somebody specific. In this instance, the "creator" of Penny's deer design posted anonymously. That's not legally kosher.
>>
>>66320691

We all know it's stupid, but then again the following things are also stupid and happened:

Suing God
Suing mcdonalds for being fat
Suing a judge on a rape trail because he used the word "rapist"

Nowadays, this isnt even about winning or losing, but rather about bad publicity, small as it may be, hence why a lot of these kind of frivolous cases are solved out of court.

But regardless of how stupid, or unlikely, the fact is, CN still has policies to prevent it, so you know, it has to be an issue to some degree, no matter how unlikely and laughable it is.
>>
>>66320691
>when most copyright cases go to court, it's because Company A, doing the suing, feels company B, who is being sued, are resulting in the loss of money or the degradation of their brand or intellectual property.

By using something they created without permission and not paying them for it? Sounds just like that.

If you were some guy who wrote a story for fun, and someone plagiarized it and then published it for profit? Then you could sue and win even if you had no intention of making money off the story on your own.
>>
>>66320862
>suing mcdonalds because the customer did not know the coffee was hot
why are americans stupid?
>>
File: 3512684651.jpg (274 KB, 661x716) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3512684651.jpg
274 KB, 661x716
>>
File: kaboom.jpg (23 KB, 251x240) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
kaboom.jpg
23 KB, 251x240
>>66320715
alll of my keks anon

/thread
>>
>>66320811
Whats wrong with a mix? Whats so great about what we have currently? She goes from lightbulb looking chick to a bunch of animals.

I get the feeling you all only like it because its not deer penny and cannon and any design would have won over your apparent low standards.
>>
>>66320927

Funny thing about this case, thanks to this incompetent customer and her lawsuit they found out the temperature mcdonald's served their coffee at the time was absurdly hotter than what was healthy or legal to, making it it justified.
>>
>>66320952
This is depressingly accurate.
>>
>>66320952
>>
>>66320812
That's because networks would rather not waste time and money crushing idiots who more than likely don't have the money to repay them in a countersuit. So they'd rather their employees not screw around. At the same time though, they don't expect their employees to somehow know what ideas fans have made and thus to avoid them. Hence why they are just given free reign instead of giving them the contradictory order of "don't read fanfics, but don't make stories that resemble fanfics.

>>66320862
Sources. Stupid suits happen, but I'm almost certain all those either didn't happen or were laughed out of the court.

>>66320868
What they created was a derivative of someone else's work. You don't get to make derivatives of people's works and sue THEM.
>>
File: 152123455.png (388 KB, 769x609) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
152123455.png
388 KB, 769x609
>>66320956
the fuck 4chanX thats not the picture i uploaded this is...
Thread replies: 213
Thread images: 29
Thread DB ID: 16545



[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Home]

[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the shown content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows their content, archived. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content, then use the post's [Report] link! If a post is not removed within 24h contact me at [email protected] with the post's information.