[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Home]
4Archive logo
Lay it on me /asp/ies, how does this taekwondo...
If images are not shown try to refresh the page. If you like this website, please disable any AdBlock software!

You are currently reading a thread in /asp/ - Alternative Sports & Wrestling

Thread replies: 71
Thread images: 10
File: taekwondo-2.jpg (761 KB, 3500x1878) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
taekwondo-2.jpg
761 KB, 3500x1878
Lay it on me /asp/ies, how does this taekwondo place look
inb4 >taekwondo

Pros:
>Since I'm a student, pretty good price at $95 for 3 months, free uniform included
>Doesn't cost anything to do promotion tests
>According to my seniors in my school's taekwondo club, sparring eventually becomes full contact, once you're intermediate level
>Head instructor seems fairly qualified, former coach for an Olympic taekwondo team

Cons:
>Affiliated with the WTF, so Olympic style sparring
>No joint locks, grappling, or groundwork
>Might just be my paranoia with money, but the instructor that was there seemed a little pushy with trying to get me to sign up

Thoughts? I know taekwondo is memeish, but I'm a college brat with no experience in unarmed martial arts, and I figured this would give me a good kicking basis, and allow me to defend myself against someone who doesn't know what they're doing.

Here's the website: http://www.cwtkd.com/press/
>>
>>951781
>allow me to defend myself against someone who doesn't know what they're doing.
You can do this with just about any martial art except Aikido.
But even with Aikido, you'll still learn basic principles of countering.
>>
>>951781
>Olympic style sparring
What exactly is Olympic style sparring?
>>
>>951781
If the price is right it is better then nothing.

I say go for it and try it out.

Competitive TKD is pretty intense.
>>
>>951781
>Affiliated with the WTF, so Olympic style sparring
This is a good thing. This is the only good thing to come out of TKD. The coach seem good, so enjoy your ancillary art. Get fit.
>>
>>951798
>What exactly is Olympic style sparring?
Not OP

In oly TKD you score points for clean hits. You don't stop and reset with each hit, and fancy kicks (spinning, jumping etc.) and kicks to the head score higher than punches (and kicks to the body), so most people don't even bother with punching.
>>
There's nothing particularly wrong with the World Taekwondo Federation, especially in comparison to the alternative of the American Taekwondo Association, and the International Taekwondo Association is basically the result of less Olympic orientation and more geared towards traditional teaching, from what little of it I partook in. Within itself, Tae Kwon Do has very little to no groundwork or grappling outside of what is demonstrated in one-step sparring and self-defense techniques; this is why Hapkido is generally trained in tandem with Tae Kwon Do. Because the WTF is more oriented towards competition, specifically Olympic sparring, forms and board breaking, there's generally no groundwork, grappling or locks demonstrated unless the instructor happens to have knowledge of it from cross training.

From what you say, it honestly doesn't sound too half bad. The price seems too good to be true in my opinion though. $95 covering three months of training? Do you have to abide by a contract signing up for a year or so's worth of training and/or do you have to pay in advance? Maybe the instructor might be coming off as pushy if class attendance is low. I know that, in military towns, it's difficult to keep students for sure. Looking at their promotional video, while the first kicks I saw of the students seemed a smidgeon sloppy (not that I'm a professional or anything), the rest seemed pretty good. They use Korean terminology and instructor, which is always good to hear. They've a very ample amount of equipment, a large place to train and a decent handful of instructors it seems (despite the slightly-biggish class). They seem to check out well, particularly seeing how it took one of them four years to get 1st dan.

Honestly, I think this place is fine, OP, especially if you have zero martial arts background. Obviously it doesn't seem like it's something groundbreaking, but as far as schools in general go, this seems pretty good. Try it out and tell us how it is.
>>
>>951798

Generally you have two or three rounds per match, ranging from a minute to two and a half minutes per round (all depending on your skill level and what sort of tournament you're attending). Most categories for sparring apply in weight limits, age and belt rank (with 4th dan generally being the uppermost). While not striking limbs, the spine or below the waist, you score points by striking the torso and head - one point for a solid, loud punch or kick, two points for a spinning or reverse kick or and three points for kicking the head (but no punching). Additionally, you are no longer allowed to "check" kicks with your own legs, or in other words, attempt to block an incoming kick with your leg in attempt to counter-attack. In this new age, electronic hogus (chest pieces) detect when they're struck and automatically tally them and whichever opponent has more by the end of the match wins. Generally, at the pace most matches go, opponents typically go for more of an exchange of blows and evading strikes as opposed to blocking them (I lost my first tournament from blocking too much myself). You are confined to a limited space and are deducted points if you leave the arena more than once; you are also deducted points for illegal strikes, failing to abide by referee instruction or failing to engage (you must attempt to make an aggressive movement every ten or so seconds).

Long story short, instead of the aim being to incapacitate your opponent, it's to score points just as you would in a boxing match, although like both, having the opponent unable to continue yields a victory.
>>
>>951958
What's the reasoning behind not being able to use your legs to block?
>>
File: rabbitkickwebm.webm (2 MB, 422x212) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
rabbitkickwebm.webm
2 MB, 422x212
>>951958
>In this new age, electronic hogus (chest pieces) detect when they're struck

Just dropping by to say that using the e-hogus and counting pretty much all connections as equal with them led to some brutally silly shit, namely the rabbit kick as seen in the webm. A spastic hopping heel from the clinch is perfect but a knee? No sir taekwondo don't play like that. Shit's ridiculous.
>>
>>951963
If you were able to use your legs to block, given that they're your only real offensive tool, you'd have stalled matches as the advantage goes to whoever waits for the kick and checks.

In Muay Thai, you can't do this because if you check and he doesn't kick, or fakes the kick, you can get punished with a punch or low kick. That's not a possibility in Taekwondo, so there'd be basically no way to counter an overly defensive fighter.

>>952000
I agree that the E-hogus were a fucking joke and have basically removed the point of the hogu to begin with, which was to encourage powerful, penetrating kicks.
>>
File: 0.jpg (19 KB, 480x360) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
0.jpg
19 KB, 480x360
>>952000

Fucking leg fencing bullshit.

I wanna watch somebody's jawbone go flying, not watch two guys straddle each other like they're trying to fuck standing up in the shower.
>>
File: 1400312390350.gif (2 MB, 250x180) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1400312390350.gif
2 MB, 250x180
>cute grill wants me to do tkd
>I just can't get over how fucking stupid and ineffective it is
>>
>>952000
>mfw Olympic TKD is a whole separate style than ITF and even WTF styles

>>951798
Imagine if boxing was in the olympics, but you had to wear a full body bomb suit and were only allowed to move on a grid, and only hits to the belly button counted

that's the comparison to TKD
>>
>>956459
You don't remember the electronic boxing they did?
>>
>>956464
My TKD club hates OTKD, it's a joke and makes the art look good.
>>
>>956464
OK, now imagine the whole world only saw that, and that's what they thought boxing was.
>>
>>952000

That's absolutely hilarious and infuriating at the same time. I joke around doing that kick in sparring to be funny, but little to my knowledge was I emulating something professionals do - I say that very tongue and cheek. That's just plain dumb, goodness gracious. I sure hope I have little to do with that nonsense in future tournaments.

>>956398

>I just can't get over how fucking stupid and ineffective it is

That's a nice meme you have there. Can I borrow it?

Sure, it's not as street-practical as other martial arts, but to go so far as label it as ineffective is rather arbitrary, wouldn't you think?
>>
>>956466
The problem is worse than that. When the olympics did that to Boxing, the boxers, and the coaches, and the teams, revolted.

They weren't going to go through with the bullshit that every punch, signified by the glove making contact with anything, was equal, and they weren't going to train people for it.

The problem is that Taekwondo, and especially the Republic of Korea, is really, really invested in the olympic financially, and so rather then protesting this shit, and setting up something real on their own, they change their training to suit this shit.

>>956482
>I sure hope I have little to do with that nonsense in future tournaments.
You shouldn't, unless you get to a 'high' level. WTF TKD reaches it's highest standard in high school and college gyms, with two guys swinging for the fences to take each other's heads off with spinning hook kicks for 4 minutes.

It's still not the most effective striking art out there, but it's worth your time at least.
>>
>>956512
TKD was literally founded by an Ex-Japanese slave as a counter martial art to Shotakon karate.
>>
>>956569
Does it actually work in that regard? I'm curious as to why he decided to focus on kicks when making his art.
>>
>>956569
Taekwondo was founded by a bunch of different schools coming together and pretending they had a unified art that totally wasn't Japanese.
>>
>>956717
>Does it actually work in that regard?
Yes, but pretty much everything counters shotokan.

> I'm curious as to why he decided to focus on kicks when making his art.
Among other things, the kick emphasis was native to Korean martial arts even before Taekwondo. While there's very little evidence of direct continuity to Taekkyon, Taekkyon matches were basically trying to knock each other around around with Teeps. Hapkido also has a weird emphasis on leg techniques, some of which don't even show up in TKD.

After that, I suspect it was a combination of flashy kicks selling the McDojo practices, and the fact that it was a niche that could define themselves in, especially against Japan (and pretty much everything in Korea is about defining themselves against Japan).
>>
>>956569
>>956717
This is bullshit. The first schools that would eventually form taekwondo were primarily led by koreans that had lived in Japan and studied karate, mostly Shotokan, by their own free will. There were a few that had other influences like undefined undefined styles of chinese martial arts or other schools of karate, and nowadays a lot is said about connections to Taekkyon and other extinct korean martial arts, but Shotokan was definitely the main parent art. They were unified into Taekwondo by government action and the efforts of General Choi Hong Hi, though what degree of influence he really had is debatable.

What's known is that there was a big push from the government to band all these schools under a single banner, for the cultural reason of having a martial art that could be called Korean as a sort of symbol of the country's strength after the japanese occupation and also because having control of institutions that'd teach martial arts to the populace gave the state an extra degree of monopoly on force. China's attempt to erradicate then completely control martial arts was a similar situation.

As for the kick focus, pretty much what >>956732 said.
There's very little evidence of a link to Taekkyon but it's likely that Choi or others were eventually introduced in some way to the near-extinct style (it had been practically wiped out during the japanese occupation), saw it had a lot of kicks and went with it. The rest is definitely trying to commercialize and appeal to a larger audience while separating themselves from karate.
>>
How is taekkyon as a fighting style? Does anybody even teach it anymore?
>>
>>956959
It's pretty bad. A lot's said about it having fist and elbow techniques and takedowns and throws and headbutts along with its kicks but the actual practice is garbage, a variant of foot fencing. There's some standup grappling and it allows low kicks but after that any and all hand strikes are forbidden and you have the addition of forced triangular footwork kinda like the capoeira ginga but more subdued. You can only score by tripping or throwing the other guy to the ground, pushing them out of the ring or kicking them in the head.

Ever since it was declared as an intangible cultural asset by the korean government it's been spread around all over the place because of course it has, this is Korea we're talking about. Add to that how it's often promoted for having pressure point techniques and it just winds up looking like Korea narrowly rescued one of its legitimate martial arts from extinction only to drain it of martial application and turn it into some sort of cultural spectacle.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xwmlxBzOvFw

I don't know if this is better or worse than OTKD, but I sure as hell know it wouldn't be my first choice for practice. Hell if I'm gonna do something dancy I'll go with Capoeira since it actually looks cool.
>>
>>956959
There's some people who have a style called Taekkyon, but that's a reconstruction at best. It's dead, and was dying before the Japanese showed up. We have very few sources on the original, actually.
>>
>>956398
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sPNoGhdhKyw
>>
>>957220
I just made a gif.
>>
>>957220
>>957378
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6UlAh9rnkYM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ibExPvFD18Y
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=irfXUqHXpm8

If you only want to watch one, watch the first. I don't think Taekwondo is total garbage but it sure as hell isn't as effective and well-rounded a base as Muay Thai. It's a good supplementary art, fantastic for developing your kicks, but in kickboxing or MMA, MT takes priority.
>>
>>957441

I agree with you, excluding calling Muay Thai well rounded. It's street smart and practical in a scrap, particularly close-quarters, but it isn't any more well rounded as Tae Kwon Do. It trumps TKD because its kicks and strikes are more practical in most fights, but unless you mean to tell me Muay Thai also teaches throws and ground-wrestling, outside of learning BJJ or Judo, I wouldn't jump the gun and say it's "well rounded" like Krav Maga or Karate.
>>
>>957441
You just have to use Taekwondo the right way.
You need to use Taekwondo like you would use it against a Muay Thai practitioner, not use Taekwondo against a Muay Thai practitioner like you would use Taekwondo against a Taekwondo practitioner.
>>
>>957462
Taekwondo almost exclusively practices kicks above the waist, forbids elbows, knees, punches to the face and clinchwork in competition. Muay Thai allows kicks to the legs, punches to the head and is famous for its elbow and knee techniques as well as the effectiveness of its clinch fighting. High level nak muay are also prone to throwing and sweeping opponents off the clinch and blocked or missed kicks, and do so quite well even if it's not as much of a focus as in Sanshou/Sanda. So yes, I think Muay Thai is much more well rounded than Taekwondo.

also
>karate
>the krav
aayyy lmao
>>
File: image.jpg (97 KB, 600x620) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
image.jpg
97 KB, 600x620
>>957220
I love reading the comments in matches involving two country's martial arts. There'll always be fanboys from the losing country declaring the other cheated.
>>
>>951787
desu, while aikido is obviously less effective you can, provided you have some experience, probably throw an unexperienced guy to the ground.
>>
>>957488

Just sayin', but I'm pretty sure not allowing kicks below the waist in tournaments doesn't mean kicks below the waist certainly aren't taught. Also, strikes with elbows and to the head are most certainly taught, both in sparring forms as well as belt forms.

I think you're more well rounded in general.

Get it? I called ya fat!
>>
File: 1418822301614[1].jpg (61 KB, 500x329) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1418822301614[1].jpg
61 KB, 500x329
>>957537
>no we totally do these things, they're in the forms you see
>we just don't actually apply them in the competition format we follow
>also you're fat
>>
>>957600

Well I was kidding about the fat part. I'm sorry.

We do forms in tournaments, and the forms have the strikes. Are there Muay Thai tournaments that allow knees and elbows to the face? I'd assume so. That seems quite scary.
>>
>>951958
>instead of the aim being to incapacitate your opponent
Keep in mind though OP that a knockout is a win, and isn't rare in competition.
>>
>>957608
>Are there Muay Thai tournaments that allow knees and elbows to the face?
All of them in Thailand.
>>
>>957708
Not that anon, but amateur (including MMA) doesn't allow knees to the head or any elbows in any of the cards I've fought on or worked.

Kyokushin does allow elbows to the body (both in training and competition when I was training Kyo) so there's that.
>>
>>957737
Actual Muay Thai events, including amateur ones, typically allow for knees and elbows to the head. Amateurs usually require pads. Muay Thai in Thailand is trained for pro bouts, which allow and even encourage elbows and knees to the head thanks to the scoring system. Elbows are typically banned in K1/oriental rules kickboxing which also limit clinchwork for knees. Amateur MMA rules as promoted by FILA also ban elbows to the head, but they also ban hammerfists and slams as submission defenses, all for safety reasons.
>>
>>958094
The events I've fought in and worked have usually been billed as "K1 Rules".

I've not seen any promotions (acquaintances with a few pro+ammy MMA and kickboxing promoters) for anything amateur that allows knees to the head or elbows at all.
>>
>>957608
If you don't allow ellbows and knees you can't call it muay thai. Thats like saying hey guys, come to my kickboying tournamnet, only punching is allowed.
>>
>>964306
>kickboying

sounds fresh
>>
>>964040
Yeah K1 rules are a lot more common because the big international kickboxing companies use them and they're seen as safer for fighters. Hell MMA in Japan completely forbid elbows for safety reasons despite allowing a ton of dangerous shit like kicking or stomping a downed opponent on the head, that should give you an idea of how dangerous elbows are seen as. But actual Muay Thai uses elbows and knees, they're an integral part of the discipline.
>>
>>964796
>2016
>Hell MMA in Japan completely forbid elbows for safety reasons despite allowing a ton of dangerous shit like kicking or stomping a downed opponent on the head
nigga wut
>>
>>967206
Past tense nigga. Also
>implying any japmma other than PRIDE is worth talking about

Pancrase and Shooto might both predate the UFC but their talent pool is hilariously shallow and their viewership is minuscule, while Deep has always been a b-tier feeder territory at best. The only reason Shooto gets any sort of respect is because it has an amateur league and schools in all of Japan's prefectures so it's usually the best way for young athletes interested in MMA to start practicing and competing.
>>
>>951781
If your poor do boxing or judo. those are both effective and really cheap. i would avoid TKD entirely especially if its WTF.
>>
Tkd is honestly in my own personal experience for children to get into to ease themselves into more tougher combating sports like boxing
> I train boxing at home
> used to go to the gym
> I was Allright but wasn't a fan of the gym
> it's best to learn a skill then practice it in a more comfortable environment
>>
>>951781
A lot of people miss the idea of TKD, the main focus of it

There are people who do TKD for hand techniques, for the grappling, yes.

But i want you to listen to every critisism of TKD and apply it to boxing

"Boxing doesn't work on the streets"

Well no, boxing punches will break your hand. Re - Hairfracture, you need to fight different

>boxing doesn't cover grappling/kicks
Well no, it's about focusing on hands and moving.

Same with TKD. Every day you make yourself "well rounded" is a day you practice swinging a long sword

yeah, it's a lot more practical for real combat (swords have been in almost every culture! It's easier to get and own then a gun in some places )

But it won't help you accel in your sport.

and in TKD, that's the olympics.
>>
>>972077
Boxing is honestly, in my personal experience, for children to get to ease themselves into more complex, and more difficult to understand, combat sports like MMA.
Boxing is like the first things you learn in elementary school prepare you for middle school, and eventually, high school.
>>
>>972270
Correction someone with average hand bones might break there hands any martial artist knows you have to train and condition something before using it in a real fight
You can easaly break someone's nose by punching them in the face
>>
>>974362
With the way Boxing is today, you can easily break your hand if you're not wearing all that protection, and you miss the nose and hit the forehead.
>>
>>974362
>>974367
Hell, you could even break your knuckle on someone's cheek bone.
>>
Well shit I guess this thread is full of prepubesent babies
>>
Condition your hand and arm bones and you won't have this problem
>>
Steer clear of Olympic TKD and head straight for military TKD.

That shit's basically MMA.
>>
>>974362
>train and condition something
Yeah i punched a steel beam for five years, i know more about conditioning then you do, trust me

And no, it's just a zero-sum gain. How many opponents do you need to defeat before you'll accept a injury that could hinder you for the rest of your life?

Compare the risk against kicking him, or body punching, or elbows, or wrist striking, or knees, or ANYTHING but punching without protection

And yeah, a nose is a possible target, if you have really good control and he doesn't move 3 cm so you hit his cheekbone and shatter your knuckle.

Legit, i've punched people in the face with the TKD guards on (between bare knuckle and light mma gloves) and i do not want to even do THAT again.

>>976050
But ironically, your kicks won't be up to TKD caliber.

the pains of specialization.

But you can learn MMA anywhere. you can only learn true TKD kick mastery competing in the WTF
>>
>>974784
XD LOL
>>
>>976085
>your kicks won't be up to TKD caliber.
that just means you're not training enough.
>>
>>976085
>Yeah i punched a steel beam for five years
Sure you did sport.
>>
>>978279
Right I didn't even dignify that with a response
Anyone who things it takes 5 years or thinks that steel is a good punching bag is obviously a krotyfag
>>
>>979042
No that's resident shitposter TKDBrah. He's just gotten smarter about not posting under the name all the time for results but it's still fairly obvious.
>>
>>951781
>>951886
Rubbish

My club is WTF but we don't do Olympic sparring, we do sparring with the gear on, but we are trained outside of combat to kick lower as well
>>
>>979370
>Rubbish
>My club is WTF but we don't do Olympic sparring

Yeah, and I specifically said "oly TKD" where oly=olympic.
>>
>>976085
End your life
>>
>>979385
I meant Olympic style sparring is rubbish
>>
>>952091

You mean like this?
http://images.google.de/imgres?imgurl=https://i.ytimg.com/vi/WkdzGLWIdOA/hqdefault.jpg&imgrefurl=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v%3DWkdzGLWIdOA&h=360&w=480&tbnid=66ApsOwMW590gM:&tbnh=116&tbnw=155&docid=uOPkfUa_zkrVaM&usg=__8PVkTDaA2Dwr26fMO6WiIBG_0pw=&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiW2trey_jKAhVJJJoKHdEXC94Q9QEIKzAD
>>
>>979269
>not posting under the name all the time for results
Not TKDBrah, but I vary my grammar, vocabulary, and posting structure, to also give me an edge.
>>
File: my_fucking_chin.jpg (213 KB, 1264x838) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
my_fucking_chin.jpg
213 KB, 1264x838
>>974784
Who the fuck reported or deleted my post?

I said:
>I've got plenty of pubic hair
Thread replies: 71
Thread images: 10
Thread DB ID: 521309



[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Home]

[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the shown content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows their content, archived. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content, then use the post's [Report] link! If a post is not removed within 24h contact me at [email protected] with the post's information.