Please tell me what other studio on this earth would actually

>no one does the little things better than Kyoanus.
No sane person could argue against this.

>It's about the little things
Nah, big picture is important.

>>137650901
>with one being better in very slight and nuanced ways.
Wasn't it extremely obvious that Reina's was better? That's how I felt at least.

>>137651483
She was obviously better, but in ways like pitch quality and dynamics. That counts as subtle doesn't it?

>>137651483
I remember when the episode aired there were anons that couldn't tell the difference, but then again, they were probably the same people that couldn't tell how bad the band was at the start either.

>>137652299
>there were anons that couldn't tell the difference

that's pretty embarrassing

File: 1420929446140.png (738KB, 1390x1407px) Image search: [Google]

738KB, 1390x1407px

>>137652694
You are now aware that genuinely autistic people browse /a/.

>>137652832
Nice /v/ style screencap we have all seen dozens of times

File: 1420992385183.jpg (2MB, 1876x4104px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1876x4104px

>>137652910
the one usually posted is different

>>137653228
Why isn't there one that is just the op post, the autistic post, a larger copy of the picture and maybe one of the posts calling him a harem protaganist?

To get the same effect you can record 1 trumpet playing it, then apply different audio processing to make it sound "bright" or "dim". I think its very likely that a lot of the difference in sound heard was due to differences in the audio processing between the two (in addition to differences in the actual playing).

>>137653309
I didnt make it, just saved one of them at the time, I think I have a different one in my phone but cant be bothered

>>137650901

Kyoani didn't record the music, Lantis did.

>>137653309
Because epic numerous replies mate

>>137653364
No, they were both played by two different people that had a talent gap.

>>137653228
>tfw you made it into a part of /a/ history
always a good feeling desu

File: [HorribleSubs] Hibike! Euphonium - 02 [1080p].mkv_snapshot_11.03_[2015.04.14_10.38.51].jpg (115KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

115KB, 1920x1080px

Sure is hard to find recordings and reviews thereof stating which are better and worse.
Sure is hard to be so loaded that you can just buy off the recording's copyright.

>>137653228
>insane moment on 4chan guys loads of replies loads of reaction images!

I hate these so fucking much

>>137653649
Sour Grapes anon.

File: 1415238948888.jpg (28KB, 333x316px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 333x316px

>>137653649

>>137653524
I never denied that.
At the same time, you would be a fool to think that kyoani didn't apply different audio processing to the two recordings.
I'm not saying that explains all the difference between the two recordings, but you would be suprised how much of a difference it does make.

>>137653228
I hope Ara-araragi remembered to wear socks while walking her home gently. Wouldn't want to get bunions.

>>137652299
>>How bad should we have the theme for Abarenou Shogun played so that people will know that it’s being played poorly? Since they’re still a concert band, when we say they’re playing poorly, it doesn’t mean they’re playing awful. However, it needs to be bad enough so that the many potential viewers for the anime who have no familiarity with playing need to think “ah, that’s definitely bad.” And so forth. I was extremely concerned over the “level of badness.” In the end, I went for the masses and concluded “let’s make it extremely easy to tell. They’re going to play incredibly poorly.” I resolved myself to hear the critics say “there’s no way they would play that badly!”

File: 1454810694944.jpg (56KB, 380x380px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 380x380px

>>137650901
Too bad they waste all those efforts in animating garbage stories.

File: How to deal with the internet.gif (2MB, 400x225px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 400x225px

>>137653649
>no fun allowed

>>137653964
>>137653694
>>137653717
>>>/v/

>>137653857
To their credit, those anons probably have never heard the Abarenou Shogun theme before. They also sounded like a typical high school band at the start of a school year.

>>137653301
can someone post the webm?

>>137653964
>unironically posting a scene that got referenced in about 50 m-muh cyber bullying articles

definitely /v/

>>137653524
It could have been played by the same person who simply made an attempt to make one version clearly more expressive with superior tone.

>>137654439
absolutely impossible

>>137650901
this kind of post is why people make fun of kyoanifags

difference in performance quality was a plot point. nobody making that show would have used the same recording, for fuck's sake

>>137655959
Except they didn't actually have to show the performances. The previous auditions were barely even shown.

>>137655991
>Except they didn't actually have to show the performances.
nigga pls

>>137655959
A-1 completely insulted their audiences intelligence with the performance in episode 2 of Shigatsu.

>>137656065
y-you just don't get it anon

>>137656092
How so? haven't seen it

>>137656092
>A-1 completely insulted their audiences intelligence

Isn't that all the time

>>137656137
Every performance is detailed by obnoxious internal dialogue about how mindblowing, unforgettable, and special it is.

>>137650901
So they made 2 different trumpet players play that piece, how is that supposed to be impressive?

>>137656180
attention to detail, anon. It doesn't necessarily have to be hard to execute. Same way a quick shot of feet shuffling or something when they're talking about boys isn't so much "impressive" as it is meticulous.

>>137656137
Main girl is playing a piece completely standard, but everyone in the audience is commenting on how unique and special her interpretation is. The other players by contrast are made to sound boring because they are literally playing a different part of the same piece. If you actually heard the piece before you'd realize how bullshit this part was, but they count on their audience to be musically disinclined and try to sell a point on dialog alone instead of actually bothering to play the music differently. The scene itself is impressive and well animated though, it shows a lot of emotion, but what's being said makes no sense whatsoever.

>>137653857
>>I was also extremely concerned over the differences between Reina and Kaori during the trumpet solo competition. We needed to express that while Kaori plays incredibly well, Reina is outrageously talented. As I was thinking this scene also needed to be oriented towards the general public, I thought how best to make the difference easy to tell. Kaori’s performance was performed by the best girl in the band (Senzoku Gakuen’s freshman team) while I asked a professional concert band’s top trumpeter to perform for Reina. Reina isn’t professionally better than Kaori, so I worried that I might have overdone it, but I needed to emphasize that “easy to tell” portion. Regardless, there were many other worrying points that made me nervous until every broadcast day. It was necessary for experienced musicians and for unexperienced people to understand the story. I thought every day about that balance between the two in my music direction.

>>137656331
How is that attention to detail? It was a trumpet audition of 2 different players, isn't the normal thing to do is make 2 different people play it?
They hired a whole fucking band to record for fuck's sake.

>>137656404
These are nice quotes. Cheers anon

>>137656434
see >>137656340 >>137656404

It's easy to fuck these things up

>>137656527
>hey guys I swear I put a lot of thought into this,. pls care

>>137656608
>I don't give a shit about anything so clearly no one else does either.

>>137656764
It's the director, it's his job to think about shit like this, just because they're not being a cheap sell out jew who rush everything doesn't mean they're fucking jesus.

Almost every other music show ever made has some variant of this trope. KyoAni isn't the first by a mile.

>>137656923
Not every director can come up with/think of everything just because he has enough time or resources

>>137656983
Then they're shit directors, am I supposed to feel sorry for them now?

How quickly people forgot about Tari Tari, this is saddening.

>>137657053
Or Nodame Cantabile

>>137657053
Nobody cares about choirfags.

>>137657086
>shoujoshit

>>137657127
>implying Nodame Cantabile isn't the GOAT music anime

>>137652694
>>137652299
Probably the same people that call sameface on every KyoAni work

>>137657198
>Implying it is still the greatest music anime since Hibike was released
I'll give you that it was the best before it though.

>>137653722
And you would be a fool to think KyoAni processes the audio recordings.

>>137650901
Because that's what they are good at. Doing the little things. Leave the job of making real anime with big things to real studio like Bones or Madhouse.

>>137656065
The novel didn't even include the performance in episode 13. KyoAni decided to add a 6 minute long scene of instrument animation and Taki conducting in actual sync with the music, with a very high number of cuts and close to no stills. All while it wasn't even in the source.

>>137657532
Please hibikek can't even be compared to Nodame. Nodame did what hibikek wanted to do much more better.

>>137657788
Why are you replying to me though

>>137657532
Yes they did, you think they hired a concert hall to record two pieces of music instead of in a studio with all the equipment they need?
Everything is processed one way or another.

File: 1436143973536.gif (2MB, 420x360px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 420x360px

this show would be 100x better if it was about a string orchestra

fuckin band geeks

File: violin1.jpg (87KB, 628x565px) Image search: [Google]

87KB, 628x565px

>>137658251
Agreed.

File: ribbon approaching.webm (301KB, 888x500px) Image search: [Google]

301KB, 888x500px

>>137656404
>I asked a professional concert band’s top trumpeter to perform for Reina.
Damned cheater.

>>137658310
The angle and movement of the camera with the way she's walking makes it look like a shot from a horror movie

>>137656404
It's like they're bullying that girl

File: 124312421.jpg (107KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

107KB, 1920x1080px

>>137650901
what was her whole deal

>>137658352
Ribbon is scary so no one wants her and she'll die crying, alone and unloved

>>137658380
She thinks she's more mature than the people around her.

>>137658380
She only exists to play music and disregards everything else as superfluous

100% wife material.

fuck now i feel bad for neglecting my trumpet

any of you f/a/gs got anime sheet music

>>137658404
But why did she refuse to drop the "mask" 100% of the time. Surely if you consider yourself mature you'd have handle enough on your emotions to not hide them all the time.

File: orchestr-a-.png (2MB, 1270x711px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1270x711px

>>137658303
>>137658251
String orchestra anime when?

>>137658465
Teenagers often think being adult means holding the facade up at all times.

>>137658380
She thinks people in the band are a bunch of little shits with bullshit problems.

>>137658461
Please join Orchestr/a/

We need you

https://titanpad.com/orchestra2

>>137658532
Interesting. I definitely found her to be the most intriguing character by a mile. Having said that her overall motivations are still pretty unclear to me.

>>137658577
Just to add, we have plenty of animu sheet music for you to try/record

>>137658595
see
>>137658456

Some generic family problems so music is her only escape

>>137650901
who watch this shit?
>musical

lol

I'd eat Asuka's shit.

>>137658674
I'd let her use me for purely physical reasons while I desperately try to form an emotional connection which she deflects time and time again

>>137658121
>>137653393

>>137658823
Just rape her repeatedly until she likes you desperately, that's how Japan works.

>>137658950
How does that even have anything to do with what I said?

>>137658951
I couldn't. At that point I'm too emotionally damaged by her indifference that I'm completely subservient to her on all levels.

>>137659012
If it doesn't, then what you said doesn't have anything to do with what I said. I'm not even sure you intended to reply to me in the first place.

There was so much detail put into Hibike that I'm frustrated for not being able to enjoy the show because I absolutely hate dramas.

File: asuka is completely indifferent to your suffering.jpg (590KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

590KB, 1920x1080px

>>137659039
>>137658823

>>137650901
I don't care what people say about this anime, you cannot deny the top notch quality animation

>>137650901
kyoanus and hibikek are both garbage anyway

Asuka makes me a lot more angrier than even Ribbons

>>137650901
>Kyoanus

so I guess I was the only one that caught this.

>>137659153
diamonds

>>137658950
Lantis is a record label, not a group of musicians.
ALI PROJECT is with Lantis.

>>137653228
I was expecting the posts to be about the vlc diss lol

>>137659189
Reina essentially ruined the show for me.

>>137659153
Which brings the point that Kaori is obsessed with Asuka because Asuka can read through her, but nobody can read through Asuka.

>>137659278
She was definitely frustrating and a challenging character to watch. Also almost ruined it for me as well, but then I figured it wouldn't be anywhere near as interesting without a fucking chaotic neutral sociopath making everyone feel inferior.

>>137659145
Do you enjoy sports anime?

>>137659224
Which comes around to, KyoAni didn't process the recordings for the trumpet.

>>137659365
>>137659278
Failures

>>137659487
I meant it in a good way, anon.

>>137659371
Not at all

>>137659409
Congrats on arguing semantics. You must be real proud of yourself.
I'm not even the guy who you were arguing with, I just think you're an idiot.

>>137659201
was OP even being genuine

>>137659658
Why me, though? KyoAni didn't touch the audio. First guy said "you'd be a fool to think KyoAni didn't applly different audio processings". I said he'd be a fool to think KyoAni processed the audio. He then went off about how they didn't hire a concert hall to record two pieces of music, which is completely unrelated to who made the decision of processing audio and who did the processing itself. I pointed him to a post that said Lantis is the one in charge or the audio, to prove my point that KyoAni doesn't freaking process the audio. He's stupid enough to then reply saying Lantis isn't a group of musicians, once again saying something irrelevant, or at least in favor of my argument. I stated again that KyoAni doesn't do the audio processing. See the problem now?

>KyoAni doesn't process audio.
>>They wouldn't record a hall for two tracks!
>Lantis is in charge of the audio.
>>Lantis is a record label!
>So, KyoAni doesn't process the audio.

How is it my fault again?

>>137660255
That whole argument is irrelevant anyone. I don't see how it matters in the slightest who actually made the music - it was Kyoani who outsourced it. Are people honestly postulating that it's less credit to kyoani because they didn't carry out the act of recording the music? Why does that matter?

>>137660255
Calm your autism.

The whole point of this thread is that the directors of kyoani are somehow amazing for making a clear distinction between two performances.
I'm the one who made the original post saying that kyoani processed audio. I meant it in the context of the thread: the director wanted a difference, and one possible reason for it is in the processing of the audio.
You then spun it off on a tangent, arguing about who did the audio processing - semantics.

I will rephrase my original statement:
You would be a fool to think that Lantis didn't apply different audio processing to the two recordings at the request of the director.

>>137660853
>I'm the one who made the original post saying that kyoani processed audio. I meant it in the context of the thread
Yes.

>I will rephrase my original statement:
>You would be a fool to think that Lantis didn't apply different audio processing to the two recordings at the request of the director.
Now it's not in the context of the thread. Thread is about circlejerking about KyoAni's attention to detail. When you credit that to another company, nobody cares anymore. Lantis isn't part of this circlejerk.

File: 81WlxTyYsaL._SL1500_.jpg (245KB, 1500x1478px) Image search: [Google]

245KB, 1500x1478px

>>137658516
Soon.

>>137660916
Surely there is a way how to construct it as Lantis being some kind of subsidiary of Kyoto Animation or being dependent on that studio.
Anything to praise KyoAni.

>>137661003
If you want to still give credit to KyoAni, you can do what you did and say the director requested that attention to detail.

>>137654332
What? Link? I don't believe mainstream media would care about what happens in chinese cartoons

>>137661003
>>137660916

Lantis doesn't do its own directing, someone at kyoani (the director) had to tell them what to do.
I'm no kyoani fan, but I think that much is obvious.

>>137660997
Anison strings are great, I love their version of Tsubasa wa Pleasure Line

>>137658251
>>137658516
I could laugh at band shenanigans because I was never in it. Orchestra would bring back too many traumatic memories.

>>137661060
>>137661103
There. Now Lantis has been marginalized, and the importance of KyoAni has been restored. Thread's topic is on track again.

>>137661103
No one (and by no one I mean me) knows if they instruct them how to process the audio, or if they ask them for a specific result and Lantis chooses how to produce that. I'm pulling this out of my ass, but it seems logical to me.

>>137661215
I guess we're both pulling stuff out of our ass now :^)
On the other hand, I find the director working with the music production team on a music anime to be logical, so I guess we're stuck now.

>>137653964
What anime is this?

>>137661272
gotchuman

>>137656404
Ah, I love the process of storytelling.

>>137661257
Shit dude, is there someone else's ass we can pull stuff out of? We're running out.

>>137661195
>Traumatic memories
Were you a viola player?

>>137661196
Why are you acting like Lantis ever even factored into this. It's literally like saying a guitarist should get all the credit for a piece that someone else wrote from him to play. How is this not a clear distiction to people.

>>137661339
>>137658674
I think this guy has someone's ass to pull stuff out of

>>137661433
Let's not go that far. Do you think that if we reach into each other's ass we can dig out some more of our own?

>>137650901
Honestly I'm not really fond of the sharper tone of the better solo performance. The technique and expressiveness is obviously better, but I preferred the rounder tone of the first performance.

File: LouisArmstrong.jpg (10KB, 300x233px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 300x233px

Post trumpet

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2jbZrocd6vs&t=0m8s
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nXaR9jrPxZ4&t=0m12s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yTvbe4nnkYs&t=0m19s

>>137650901
no other studio would do it, because it's a stupid thing to do

File: 24.jpg (17KB, 440x297px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 440x297px

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wKQCAONOxs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HYS2o4VSPAA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LvBtVXieQAg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DTP-nxjcao8

>>137661959
yeah dumb as fuck. I mean just look at shigatsu and how well that worked

File: 1446301234176.jpg (459KB, 850x2353px) Image search: [Google]

459KB, 850x2353px

>>137658310

File: louis-armstrong-3_wide-a592150ac5861ac99e6b602055c945c4e37986bc.jpg (116KB, 1000x561px) Image search: [Google]

116KB, 1000x561px

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EDg--Bb79YM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D2TUlUwa3_o
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4WPCBieSESI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=olAWScUxzqg

>>137662229
Why don't you post someone actually good like Gillespie, Dorham or Morgan?

>>137650901
A-1 did it with shigatsu

Why can't Kyoani make more yurishows with music like Hibike!?

File: louis-armstrong3.jpg (243KB, 500x751px) Image search: [Google]

243KB, 500x751px

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E6wvh6fH4Fs
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s6NvXzApJvM&t=0m14s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=17nXsv7o64k

>>137662352
No they didn't. See here >>137656176

File: Louis-Armstrong-2.jpg (14KB, 290x300px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 290x300px

>>137662287
>Why don't you post someone actually good like Gillespie, Dorham or Morgan?
Nice joke
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7-Y3ifpjsmk

>>137652832
>>137653228
Sometimes I forget exactly the kind of cretins that browse this place.

>>137662523
It's not a joke, technically Armstrong can't compare to a bebop trumpeter.

File: 8ff4ed86a641a8b9528fa0967ae3b480.jpg (10KB, 236x300px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 236x300px

>>137662717
No, that's a joke. It's okay, it's a common mistake by plebs. The heroin did not help Dizzy's playing.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TwtwjHuP_LI

>>137662847
>listening to the most accessible jazz artist together with Davis, only without his originality
>calling someone a pleb

Off yourself.

>>137662936
>the historically most important Jazz player to ever live
>completely changed the way the trumpet was played
>unmatched career spanning from the 20s to 60s from playing original blues to creating jazz and making it a global phenomenon
>endlessly influential singer and player, considered the best of his class

>You can’t play nothing on modern trumpet that doesn’t come from him, not even modern shit. I can’t even remember a time when he sounded bad playing the trumpet. Never. Not even one time. He had great feeling up in his playing and he always played on the beat. I just loved the way he played and sang. - Miles Davis

Eat shit, pleb.

Why didn't they do blind test again?

>>137658380
She's best girl and she knows it.

>>137663125
He wasn't just a trumpeter, he was as known for his singing and his entertainer persona.

He popularized jazz but that was in the swing/big band era pre-bop, once jazz became more technically demanding and profound with Charlie Parker and the bebop era he just said it was "eccentric" and didn't care at all.

>>137662936
Fuck off Scaruffi

>>137663293
Louis Armstrong is one of the greatest musicians of the 20th century, as a historical fact. And in Jazz, he's in the masterclass. The fact that you would even suggest otherwise shows how completely ignorant you are about the subject. You wouldn't be taken seriously in any academic or technical environment. It's like trying to insult Mozart. It just doesn't work.

>"What was the greatest band of the 20th century? Forget the Beatles - it was Louis Armstrong's Hot Five and its subsequent incarnation, the Hot Seven... these bands altered the course of popular music."
>"He's the father of us all, regardless of style or how modern we get. His influence is inescapable. Some of the things he was doing in the 20's and 30's, people still haven't dealt with."
>"Louis Armstrong is the master of the jazz solo. He became the beacon, the light in the tower, that helped the rest of us navigate the tricky waters of jazz improvisation."
>"Armstrong is to music what Einstein is to physics and the Wright Brothers are to travel."
>"(Armstrong was) the key creator of the mature working language of jazz. Three decades after his death and more than three-quarters of a century since his influence first began to spread, not a single musician who has mastered that language fails to make daily use, knowingly or unknowingly, of something that was invented by Louis Armstrong."
>"It's America's classical music ... this becomes our tradition ... the bottom line of any country in the world is what did we contribute to the world? ... we contributed Louis Armstrong"'

cont'.

>>137663488
>"In my opinion, Louis Armstrong is the greatest trumpet stylist of all time and has influenced every trumpet player of his time and long after"
>"You can't play anything on a horn that Louis hasn't played"
>".. Armstrong's improvisational verve and technical virtuosity defined jazz ..."

And the last one, by Duke Ellington himself:
>"If anybody was Mr. Jazz it was Louis Armstrong. He was the epitome of jazz and always will be. He is what I call an American standard, an American original."

When will plebs learn

>>137663488
How didn't i suggest otherwise? The fact that Armstrong pioneered virtuosism and improvisation at a time when jazz consisted of rearranges of popular songs doesn't change the fact that when the most complex genres came, he just shrugged them off.
Charlie Parker is at least as important as him, it just happens that he pioneered a genre and a style of playing that wasn't suited for the masses, so outside of jazz circles he's not as popular.

>>137654017
Most Kyoani worshippers are crossies so it's to be expected

>>137663585
>How didn't i suggest otherwise?
Lad you're drunk
>at a time when jazz consisted of rearranges of popular songs
Patently false. You're showing your idiocy. Jazz, as it was invented and as Louis Armstrong played it, was the blues of native creole subculture.
>when the most complex genres came
There isn't more complex playing than the things Louis Armstrong did. Countless world class musicians such Ellington, Davis and Wynton Marsalis have already stated that.
>Charlie Parker is at least as important as him
He wasn't, not at any time.
>it just happens that he pioneered a genre and a style of playing that wasn't suited for the masses, so outside of jazz circles he's not as popular.
Louis Armstrong isn't a pop jazz player. Would you consider Herbie Hancock a pop jazz player because he had songs that topped pop charts? Fuck off with your hipster attitude, you don't even know the first thing of what you're talking about.

File: 50958849_p0.png (3MB, 2844x1600px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 2844x1600px

>>137656404
I thought Kyoani was a more humane company but they hired one of the country's best trumpet players to BTFO some promising young joshikousei on TV? That's worse than the bullying they pulled with Kokoro Connect.

>>137663765
1. The Hibike band is a college band, actually
2. How is it bullying to compare a college student to a professional? Rather, it's much closer to a learning experience for the former.

Don't post stupid things, Anonymous.

>>137663734
>Patently false. You're showing your idiocy. Jazz, as it was invented and as Louis Armstrong played it, was the blues of native creole subculture.
Jazz in the 20s and 30s was the popular music of the era, that's not wrong at all, and it was mostly devoid of improvisation, that's the first reason why Armstrong was such a big deal, he introduced the most defining aspect of jazz to jazz.
>There isn't more complex playing than the things Louis Armstrong did. Countless world class musicians such Ellington, Davis and Wynton Marsalis have already stated that.
Laughably incorrect, of course to musicians contemporary to him would say that when he actually was at that period in time, but he's not the best trumpeter in Jazz, only the most relevant.
>He wasn't, not at any time.
The same way swing jazz wouldn't have been the same without Armstrong, bebop wouldn't have been the same without Parker, that's assuming it would've been a thing at all.

>Louis Armstrong isn't a pop jazz player. Would you consider Herbie Hancock a pop jazz player because he had songs that topped pop charts? Fuck off with your hipster attitude, you don't even know the first thing of what you're talking about.
What is a pop jazz player? Armstrong was vastly more popular than Parker because entirely instrumental songs, full with modulations and complex rhythms played at 240BPM are uncapable of topping charts, especially when they came at a time when jazz was already fading away in relevance.

You're just giving random quotes by musicians that were mostly contemporary to him (and by extension, influenced by him) saying how he was revolutionary and the best trumpeter, and despite him being in fact, revolutionary and incredibly important to Jazz and popular music, he's not the best trumpeter or the best musician in Jazz, just the most influential together with Charlie Parker.

File: 11861v.jpg (216KB, 800x1024px) Image search: [Google]

216KB, 800x1024px

>>137664007
>Jazz in the 20s and 30s was the popular music of the era
There was never one type of Jazz. The Jazz that Louis played was considered non-pop.
>Laughably incorrect, of course to musicians contemporary to him
Mane of those quotes are from musicians that were not contemporary. And if you want to try and discredit Jazz musicians like Duke Ellington, then you're really just digging yourself into a hole.
>The same way swing jazz wouldn't have been the same without Armstrong, bebop wouldn't have been the same without Parker
Bebeop wouldn't have even existed without Louis Armstrong

>'Without him, there wouldn't be any of us.' - Dizzy Gillespie
>“I don’t like to hear someone put down Dixieland. Those people who say there’s no music but bop are just stupid; it shows how much they don’t know.” - Miles Davis

>Armstrong was vastly more popular than Parker because entirely instrumental songs, full with modulations and complex rhythms played at 240BPM
Armstrong had decades of music like that.

Again, you're a pleb and you're arguing against the best of the very best about the founder and timeless master prodigy of Jazz. It's so fucking retarded you make flat earth theory seem sane. Do yourself a favor and stick to moe anime.

>>137664328
>There was never one type of Jazz. The Jazz that Louis played was considered non-pop.

You actually think that I meant "popular music" as a genre? Jazz was the popular music of the 20s/30s because it was what most people listened to and it would be until the advent of rock n roll.
>And if you want to try and discredit Jazz musicians like Duke Ellington, then you're really just digging yourself into a hole.
I'm not trying to discredit them you dumb fucking retard, im contextualizing their quotes.
Whatever thing someone said 50 years ago might not be true anymore, and considering the development Jazz music had from the 50s to the 90s thinking that no one ever exceeded Armstrong music complexity as of today is ridiculous.
>Bebeop wouldn't have even existed without Louis Armstrong
And? It probably wouldn't have existed without Parker, either.
Bebop is one of the most important genres of Jazz, if not the most important.

Why are you giving even more quotes saying how relevant he was when I never said he wasn't influential, are you just dumb?

>Armstrong had decades of music like that.
No he didn't, he was technically proficient for it's era and yeah, he played with precisión at very fast tempos, but the rhythmic complexity of bebop only came with bebop

And playing a standard blues with whatever deviation of it is far more easier than playing something like Scrapple from the Apple (or most Bebop songs, really), even if the tempo is the same.

File: kumio.jpg (45KB, 569x595px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 569x595px

I am literally going to marry Kumiko

>>137664625
The biggest problem is that your beloved anime character cannot sign the marriage form.
Thus, you'll never be able to consummate your marriage.
You'll have to settle staying true to your current girlfriend, Mister Hand.

>>137664604
>still doesn't understand what type of jazz was the popular music of the 20s, 30s, 40s and 50s and thinks they're all one type
>thinks bebop is the most important genre of jazz
>thinks Armstrong only played pre-Bebop and that he didn't play with Bebop musicians
>not realizing Armstrong was legendary before Parker and played decades after Parker was already dead
>thinks people have exceeded Armstrong's technical complexity despite every giant of Jazz saying the opposite even 40 years after his death
>still arguing against the best with absolutely no credibility
You're done.

>>137664919
>>still doesn't understand what type of jazz was the popular music of the 20s, 30s, 40s and 50s and thinks they're all one type
A type of jazz is still Jazz, stop grasping at straws.
>thinks bebop is the most important genre of jazz
Well, yeah, I also think it's the most technically complex but that's probably a fact.
>>thinks Armstrong only played pre-Bebop and that he didn't play with Bebop musicians
Armstrong played with bebop musicians yeah, but he never liked bebop.
Seeing how you seem to have a collection of quoted, perhaps you might want to add this one to your list:

"Louis Armstrong, a man who rarely uttered an uncharitable word, bemoaned bop's "weird chords", and felt that the intense and intricate new style offered "no melody to remember and no beat to dance to"."
>>not realizing Armstrong was legendary before Parker and played decades after Parker was already dead
Not only is this not relevant to the fact that Armstrong is not the most complex trumpeter in Jazz history, but I never doubted his status as a legend and his legacy.
>thinks people have exceeded Armstrong's technical complexity despite every giant of Jazz saying the opposite even 40 years after his death
>still arguing against the best with absolutely no credibility
Im not arguing against the best, I'm arguing against you.
Jazz musicians from the 50s saying that Armstrong playing was the ápex of complexity is only understandable from the fact that they were from the 50s, there has been an incredibly amount of Jazz evolution, and most critics nowadays put Coltrane at the top of technical proficiency, above artists like Ellington, Armstrong or Davis that were far more influential than him.
Perhaps instead of listening to quotes you should analyze the harmonic structure of standards pre-bop and post-bop and compare them.

>You're done.
You got that right.

pretty fitting that the thread devolved into jazz arguments. I'm proud of you anons

>>137665786
Why would you be proud of two autists arguing over inconsequential shit on an online message board?

>>137665826
what isn't inconsequential shit, anon? What isn't

>>137665908
who best grill is

>>137665974
That was decided long ago >>137658380

>>137667749
Asuka is not even a top 5 girl. The competition is just too hot in Hibike.

>>137662465
they did with later part though, you can hear arima's tempo going off and such
if you don't notice it then it's your ear

>>137668153
Every single performance is marred by obnoxious voiceovers. Even if they did do subtle shit as well, it doesn't matter because the voiceovers ruin the scene entirely.

>>137668228
won't argue with this
the voiceovers is pretty obnoxious

>>137668263
BUT THE AUDIENCE HAS TO KNOW

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EbH3HJvh2N0

>>137658380
Her whole backstory is about 1 volume long.

>>137669638
that's pretty cool

File: 3excellent.png (5KB, 261x261px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 261x261px

>>137669638

>>137669743
neat

File: 10214927213.png (398KB, 576x720px) Image search: [Google]

398KB, 576x720px

>>137667749
Wrong.

>>137671177
But does she want dick or pussy

>>137650901
Hibikek is a poor man Cantabile.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WrpCHXaCK_c
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1gU0rkrT9Ig

>>137671464
>15 seconds of 3DPD hands, the rest is just the characters moving slightly while sitting in the same spot
>2nd video is 3DPD everything
>poor man
The irony.

File: [HorribleSubs] Hibike! Euphonium - 08 [720p].mkv_snapshot_04.00_[2015.07.17_22.30.14].jpg (66KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

66KB, 1280x720px

>>137658823
How does it feel knowing Asuka can never love you?

>>137650901
THIS IS CHILDREN PORNOGRAPHY

SHE'S INSERTING THAT PHALLIC OBJECT IN HER MOUTH AND TENDERLY HOLDING AND CARESSING IT WITH BOTH HANDS

DISGUSTING

>>137671848
I still wonder how someone could create a text about hibikek being child porn while making the same text so erotic

That was gold. The person who wrote that is definitely sick in the head

>>137671685
>animation is important in a show about music

>>137671965
>animation not important in anime

File: 1429043455529.jpg (66KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

66KB, 1280x720px

You simply can't praise Kyoani enough these days, They just have really good standards and they never drop it.

Apart from Chunni S2 but they learned from it.

>>137672003
animation is only important is your anime lacks in every other aspect

/a/ - Jazz Discussion

File: bi master race.png (1MB, 1284x1440px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1284x1440px

>>137671378
Judging by how she rejected her childhood friend, Kumiko is a major lesbo.
Reina, however...

File: what's wrong with you.gif (726KB, 446x251px) Image search: [Google]

726KB, 446x251px

>>137672045

>>137672045
Animation is literally the one aspect that makes anime different from all the other medias.

>>137671464
>disgusting tip top kek 3D hands

You fuvking blew it

What really bothered me was how accurately they managed to make the band sound when they were awful, and then in a few months the band played like gods with perfect intonation and everything.

Everyone with band experience knows this is basically impossible.

File: mamiko.png (50KB, 195x408px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 195x408px

>>137673162
They practiced quite a lot, didn't they?

>>137673402

Unless everyone happened to be a virtuoso, there's no amount of practice that can help you sound like that. I can at least speak on behalf of all the brass players, because there's just no way to rush that level embouchure control through sheer amounts of practice within that short amount of time.