Pretty much same here, started watching everything - now just whats left listed in OP.
Ironically, a terrible show as Haruchika is rated high since actually interested to see how it develops and where will go in terms of characterization.
Meanwhile the only shows really granted to provide quality entertainment and exited every week for are S2s.
Even BokuDake, while being greatly adapted, not interesting to watch since read the manga length before.
Mahou shoujo mou ii desukara
Ojisan to marshmallow
Shoujo tachi wa kouya wo mezasu
Why are short anime so good this season?
Blood type kun
BukuDeke Inen Machi
IBO ( Is this really a gundam?)
Schwarzmarken ( How can i watch this without previous muvluv knowledge? )
Showa Rakugou, Boku Dake ga Inai Machi, Haikyuu s2, Gintama
Koyomimonogatari, Noblesse Awakening, Dimension W, Dagashi Kashi
Prince of Stride, Osomatsu san
Enjoying (in that order):
Magical girl short
for some reason
second one was pretty terrible though
Watching for one reason or another (in that order):
Dropped (order irrelevant):
Picked up but didn't watch passed the first episode for reasons, not dropped:
Luck and Logic
Ao no Kanata
Guren no Tsuki
>Dropped/not picked up
Everything not listed.
>Went to shit tier:
>Girls in the wasteland
Koukaku no Pandora
Luck & Logic
Iron Blooded Orphans
Yami Shibai 3
Havent picked up yet tier
Haruchika truly is the hidden gem of the season.
Luck & Logic
Mahou Shoujo Mou ii
>still watching but dont think its relevant to the topic
>gave a time
>didnt even picked up
everything not listed
God tier: konasuba, boku machi, gintama
Good tier: shirayukihime, rakugo, ace of diamond, niijiro days, haikyuu, gste
OK tier: grimgar, pandora, galko
Shit tier: dagashi, phantom, other shit I didn't mention
Even japs are exicted about Drrr finale. Its a big thing and actually interesting, though newfags like you that dont care about LNs might not care.
Overall still the best show this season no matter how you look - in terms of characters, plot, pure fun. Though understandable if random people who got bored through past poorer season might not have much expectations of it wrongly.
Wrong guess. Drrr! is high since it is series finale, and is actually great.
Haruchika is higly rated despite having shit production and direction since its only show this season with any resemblance of plot (Rakugo went to boring shit, least with Haruchika still interesting what happens next episode). Also if you dropped it on first episodes - it actually becomes better later.
MC stays unlikable, but later he`ll be played off as joke character to not be so annoying. Each episode adds to cast, and that expanded cast (and better silly mysteries, not so try hard as first eps) make its worth watching. Basically MC and Chika are least interesting thing about the show. Everyone else is more interesting and best two characters were interoduced one after another in previous and this weeks episode too.
Conan is AOTS every S, so does not have to be listed (not even joking - it IS the best show airing pretty much most of times because of good writing, direction and production delivery at least few truly great episodes arks every season).
Pokemons is shit though. But if we speak long running series - can count Gintama for this season, if its current ark is good - it can compete with others as well.
Its not about what started this season, but what people enjoy watching NOW.
"Is it xday yet?" tier:
Grimgar (I didn't like it at first)
Komugi-chan R (no bully)
AssClass s2 (I just watch the interesting parts and get distracted when the "boring" ones are going)
Dagashi Kashi (It's actually good, but I prefer the manga by a large margin)
Mahou Desukara (it's cute)
Ojii-san to marshmallow (Not enough Wakabayashi)
Dimension W ("read the manga, faggot lol")
Haruchika (well, the girls are kinda cute)
Schwarzmarken (Haven't really caught up)
Dropped & subs where tier:
Anything else really, except maybe Yami Shibai or SEKKOU.
OP here. No, you dont get to decide that. Its not "best new show" ranking, but best this season. Even taking your wrong in the core logic, sequels that arent just direct cour continuation still count. I.e. you can argue Utawaremono or IBO shoudnt be listed this season - but not Akagami or Drr
Flawed but alright:
DRRR if only because things finally stop getting more convoluted and wrap up
Couldn't keep me interested even though I wanted to like it:
Couldn't even be bothered to try the first episode: