If Madoka S2 (12 episodes - 6 BDs) aired today, do you think it'd sell more than the first season or will suffer the usual S2 drop?
Consider how much the fanbase has grown over the last five years.
People who call our fun "cancerous" are cancerous.
There doesn't have to be, but there can be, and that's all that matters.
That wasn't being smug.
THIS would be being smug.
Much less. Rebellion was divisive as shit and no matter what happens, people are going to be pissy. S2 is going to have that hanging around it's neck.
If Sayaka isnt the central focus, Sayakafags will scream.
If MadoHomu doesnt happen, yurifags will scream.
If Homura actually turns out to be irredeemably evil and is put to death, Homufags will scream.
If we get a relatively happy, thematically appropriate ending, sufferingfags will scream etc etc etc
I'm sorry if this is a bit off-topic but its my message for ACK or Anti-Crack-Kun.
ACK I read through your page explaining why crack-pairing is degrading to characters http://besuretoactuallyread.tumblr.com/debate I understand you put some rigorous thought and logic into your stance against crack and I'm not trying to change your thoughts on it, I just want to persuade you to be a bit less harsh to !akemi or anyone who posts crack fanart.
You say that any fan-work that changes the personality of the character or the way they interact from the canon source is degrading them and making their feelings seem worthless. Generalizing this it doesn't have to be crack that degrades them, it could be doujins of them being sex-crazed maniacs or of Madoka being a femdom, or practically anything that presents a deviations from how the characters behave in series. So that would then make OOC degrading. You translate doujins of Madoka Magica, a lot of which are pornographic of the characters showing them behaving explicitly sexual. Do you think middle-schoolers behave this way? Because I sure don't, that technically makes it OOC. By translating these doujins of the characters you are implying support for this OOC doujin since you are applying effort for it. And since you said crack is degrading the characters because it alters their canon behavior and makes their feelings seem worthless, that would then make any OOC fanwork, like the doujins you translated, degrading the characters. You are therefore degrading the characters yourself.
I don't mean to insult you though, practically every large fandom in some way shape or form altered canon settings or characters to explore new ideas, like crossovers to drawing characters dressing in the outfits of other characters. OOC is not such a terrible thing like you've made it out to be, as I have explained here. I hope you agree with the point I put out here, and if you don't please explain in an uninsulting way why it's flawed.
Why must you summon the bastard like this?
If they finally confirmed the yuri in it with a kiss, it would raise lots of controversy and set it's name on fire.
At that point, fanbase would no longer matter. The scandal would be enough to guarantee that its name would last till the ends of time
Otherwise, it would be completely forgettable
I want to fuck Madoka's pussy, I need to fuck Madoka's pussy. I want to stick my rod into her hole and fuck her and fuck her until I shoot my seed inside of her and have her make me a baby!
>you hardly deserve the oxygen you breathe
>You just have the IQ of a small animal
>You clearly didn't read it in full or otherwise you would understand it
I've become numb to the madness.
I'm new here myself, so I'll explain it as I best understand it.
>namefag called !Akemi supports crack and supports it, not sure if he was a shitposter or not
>some anon gets butthurt that he supports crack, goes on rants about how it "degrades the characters" or some shit, acts like a child to anyone who disagrees with him (see his rant above), and becomes convinced there is a conspiracy amongst mods to make crack posters exempt from rules while banning him
>this anon is AntiCrack-kun
>!Akemi leaves, I forget why
>stays dead for months
>start browsing madoka threads
>post some crack here and there because it had to do with discussion, or just to play around
>AntiCrack-kun sees this and rants
>tell him to calm down
>he doesn't; the fires of autism rise higher within him
>start posting crack to bait him for lulz
>turns out he's a lolcow
>begin exploiting this for maximum keks for all to enjoy
>take on the name of Akemi myself in honor of who once was
And so it has been for months now.
I was hoping to have a decent debate with you on the merits of crack but it seems I will have to wade through pools of useless insults to get to your point. I'm not up for it. Go have a one-sided bark frenzy with those other crack posters.
>posts crack and supports it
This is why I refuse to have a discussion with him, he cannot and will not be civil or respectful to anyone, yet demands that same respect and civility to be given to him. He's a hypocrite.
No worries. Feel free to enjoy the shitstorm if you want. Get some popcorn if you have it.
!Akemi did nothing wrong :^)
Two thirds of that was me. You're accuracy's getting better
It's Valentine's Day.
How do the Madoka's celebrate?
You have a name, it's not like it's difficult to pick out all of your posts.
I think you have a legitimate mental disorder, and it isn't autism. Seek a psychologist or psychiatrist's help, because I'm pretty sure you're a paranoid schizophrenic.
God this thread is autistic. Why don't you all don trips so I can filter you?
By eatingcheesecake and tea
, and vigorously fucking like possessed animals until the late hours of night
>But now I realize that it was just a seed post you made yourself so you could have an excuse to post crack. Because you're going to ignore everything I said in this post.
Different person, I just re-watched the main series and wanted to come see if there was any news on the new project or any discussion. Alongside the guy that thinks Madoka hates and will kill Homura you two have been at it for a week now, so I was curious.
>Hello, you are lowering the quality of threads by degrading the characters, please stop.
You have, and never will, talk even remotely like this
FORBIDDEN LOVE BEST LOVE
>Give me a reason to do it. Explain your reasoning. Give supporting details.
>Not going to do it?
Because you think there's this big conspiracy targeting you with mods and tripfags all in on it, despite the contradictory claims (!Akemi got banned for posting CP but he has a mod looking out for him? How does THAT work?) and much more likely possibilities existing.
That's pretty textbook.
I just finished rewatching Madoka so the threads are more relevant to me now, yet pairing autism is all we get. Why must it be like this?
yep this thread went exactly how I expected it'd go
We have no hope. No Madoka to guide us, no Homura to save us, nothing.
People who actually care to discuss Madoka don't go in these threads because they're never actually about Madoka. There's no hope, if you really care to discuss it try discussing it in a non-madoka thread.
That's not how it works here though. If mods did that any other sperglord could just derail any thread he doesn't like by spamming ex.accel spammer.
Just. Fucking. Ignore.
Muduka best meguca
Same as it ever was.
I wish to erase all breasts in every time and place