[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Home]
4Archive logo
Has a 2k15 consensus been reached?
If images are not shown try to refresh the page. If you like this website, please disable any AdBlock software!

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 381
Thread images: 100
Has a 2k15 consensus been reached?
>>
>>136193599
No, and it wasnt reached for the other years either, it seems. ping ping was pretentious hipster shit
>>
>>136193625
Who should've won?
>>
>>136193599
>2013
>no KLK
I am so extremely proud you /a/.
>>
>>136193599

Banner of Stars was terrible.
>>
File: 1452503418455.png (412 KB, 1366x768) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1452503418455.png
412 KB, 1366x768
Yeah, it's pic related
>>
>>136193599
Banner of the Stars is overrated.
>>
>>136193625
>ping ping was pretentious hipster shit

Explain to me how it was pretentious shit, anon?
>>
File: aoty chart.png (3 MB, 3019x1096) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
aoty chart.png
3 MB, 3019x1096
>>136193599
>>
>>136193765
>>136193710

Shhhhhhh you arent supposed to admit that
>>
>>136193793
but owari was bad, anon
>>
>>136193793
>2015
>not Shirobako or Haikyuu
>>
>>136193599
holy shit, this is a terrible list.
>>
>>136193710
this
>muh Abh

Is the writer a nazi sympathizer or something like that?
>>
File: owari 18.png (1 MB, 1920x1080) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
owari 18.png
1 MB, 1920x1080
>>136193883
It's the best installment to the series to date, especially the Sodachi arc, Shinobu Mail took a while to get going but the pay off was more than worth it.
>>136193920
Shirobako was pretty good, forgot to put it under runners up for 2015, didn't watch Haikyuu.
>>
I fucking tried watching Banner of the Stars. The only torrent I could find was such bad fucking quality it put me off the series.
>>
>>136193793
NNB R was AOTY

>>136193883
It started kinda slow, but picked up by episode 5 or so. The last 6 episodes were fucking top-tier. Too bad we're probably not getting Mayoi Hell until after two Kizu films are out.
>>
File: 3xv58wctm1skw60.gif (658 KB, 500x281) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
3xv58wctm1skw60.gif
658 KB, 500x281
does tsuki count as 2014 or 15?...
>>
>>136194013
>It's the best installment to the series to date
Nope, that's Koimonogatari
>>
>>136193951

I'm more offended by its utter shallowness, lack of thematic depth or coherency that goes anywhere, and its dull visuals.

>>136194013
>It's the best installment to the series to date, especially the Sodachi arc

How?
>>
>>136194165
2014
>>136194172
I think you mean Nisekoimonogatari anon
>>
File: 044.jpg (14 KB, 246x250) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
044.jpg
14 KB, 246x250
>>136194013
>owari
>better than bake
>>
>>136193599
Don't think it would be reached soon, 2015 was a good year for anime, so many good shows popped up.
I would vote for OPM myself since it actually left me wanting for more at the end of each episode even though I already know the story, but hipsters hate it nowadays.
>>
File: 1447815132913.png (563 KB, 861x990) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1447815132913.png
563 KB, 861x990
There can only be one
>>
>>136194083
Go kill yourself
>>
>>136193599
>2014
>that shitty sports anime
nope
>>
>>136193599
Half of this is hiptster shit.
>>
>>136193793
at least this chart is somewhat accurate.
>>
>>136193599
Since this is obviously the hipster chart, an Ikuhara show wins almost by default.
>>
File: D4S05O5.jpg (174 KB, 1013x1367) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
D4S05O5.jpg
174 KB, 1013x1367
Isn't it obvious?
>>
>>136195088
If you went by consensus opinions SAO would be AOTY for 2012 and SnK for 2013.
>>
>>136195477
gup and love live are more popular than SAO and SnK
>>
>>136195477
Not on /a/. We reached a tipping point this year with OPM and /v/ faggotry, but SAO wasn't even in /a/'s top 15 that year, and SnK wasn't in /a/'s top 10.
>>
Hibike
>>
>>136193599
>consensus

Fuck off
>>
I don't mind if obscure shows are included (Hyouge Mono is excellent), but Kemono no Souja Erin definitely shouldn't be included. Without exaggerating 10% of that show is recycled scenes. The soundtrack must consistent of 2 songs 'la li la, la li la'
>>
>>136193793
>Any Monogatari as best of the year
Kill yourself with a shotgun.
>>
>>136194286
/thread
>>
File: AOTY.png (3 MB, 3019x982) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
AOTY.png
3 MB, 3019x982
Yes.
>>
>>136196025
Not sure if bait or just colossal shit taste in general.
>>
I was thinking to myself... Why is /a/ so gay? Looking at these tastes....

Y'all niggas need to learn about some good animu.
>>
>>136193793
Well you put Joshiraku as AOTY for 2012 so I'm gonna give you a pass but next time include Nichijou and Yuyushiki on your list.
>>
So is non non biyori repeat actually really good or is it just there for the moe bait charts?

I watched NNB a while ago but never got around to starting repeat.
>>
>>136197999
It's really really good. If you liked the first season you'll like the second.
>>
>>136193599
>consensus
No.
Fuck off.
>>
>>136193599
The consensus is that 2015 sucked.
>>
>>136193599
A consensus is impossible because people are too divided between NNB and Hibiki for either camp to surrender, mainly because NNB is a sequel this time.
>>
>>136198324

>NNB moe shit
>Hibike yuri shit

Fuck both of them, OPM is AOTY 2015.
>>
>>136198429
>>>/reddit/
>>
>>136193599
>Hyuge Mono

Did they even finish subbing that pot shit.
>>
>>136193625
>ping ping was pretentious hipster shit
*Ping Pong

Also, that's pretty much most of this chart. You really can't expect anything else out of /a/.
>>
>>136200110
There is literally nothing pretentious about ping pong
You're just throwing buzzwords like a retard
>>
You will never get a consensus because people like different things
But it's funny how quickly OPM fans died out after the show ended
>>
>>136196025
anitwitter/10
>>
File: 2015 AOTY.jpg (235 KB, 764x1075) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
2015 AOTY.jpg
235 KB, 764x1075
>>136193599

Yes, get with the program.
>>
>>136193599

Yamato 2199 was 2012 you faggot OP.

Now stop raping my chart with your shitty edits.
>>
>>136193599
No, because nobody watched AOTY.
>>
File: 2015.jpg (626 KB, 2706x982) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
2015.jpg
626 KB, 2706x982
itt: fakers/pretentious kids who think they have genuine taste
>>
>>136201472
itt: retards who think cute=good
>>
>>136193599

Why the fuck don't we separate by genre.
>>
>>136200735
>honorable mentions
>death parade
>rokka no yuusha
Holy fucking shit go kill yourself.
>>
>>136193599
These fags from reddit want to fit in so bad they wonder what /a/'s "consensus" is.

>a group of anonymous people with no mandatory voting mechanism have a consensus
>Boku no Pico wouldn't win every year

Stop being a bitch and have your own opinoin. go back to reddit if you want a group of people that care what others think while you're at it.
>>
File: 1402846164227.jpg (78 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1402846164227.jpg
78 KB, 1280x720
>>136193625
>it doesn't look like other anime, therefore it is pretentious
it's almost as if you didn't actually watch the show, which turned out to be nothing more than a simple sports/coming-of-age story
>>
I thought nobody even watched Battleship Yamato.
>>
>>136193599
We're still fighting over the last 15 years worth of anime
>>
File: 1420419937429.jpg (39 KB, 720x539) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1420419937429.jpg
39 KB, 720x539
>"Its hipster shit"
No, you're the hipsters you fucking fucks. Stop hating on shit because its popular or because its widely accepted as good.
>>
>>136193599
Where is the one with the 3 Arias? That's the one I agree with the most. As for 2015 it should be Shirobako or NNBR.
>>
>>136193599
No and it never will. This year split people who like SOL and Action too hrd
>>
>>136196025
its ok
>>
One punch man was the best anime of 2015 and probably one of the best of this decade. Owari was a huge disappointment, and Non Non Biyori Repeat blew my expectations out of the water. It's sad how 2016 has had such a shitty start, however.
>>
File: SitOnFence.jpg (30 KB, 350x262) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
SitOnFence.jpg
30 KB, 350x262
>>136193599
I tremendously enjoyed both Hibike! and OPM. I still can't decide which i prefer, mainly because i usually use music as the deciding factor, and both excelled in that area.
>>
File: kg1.jpg (67 KB, 600x400) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
kg1.jpg
67 KB, 600x400
>>136193599
you mean maximum hipstershit show of 2015?

no idea.

>>136196025
could be worse.

>>136201431
was it that good? the cg put me off. same with jk-meshi.

>>136201995
you could say the same thing about tatami galaxy.

The difference is that pingpong was great, unlike tatami.

>>136202326
that's not what makes it hipstershit. Hipstershit is boring and obvious but uses style to make it seem like there's something going on worth watching.

Anyway, AOTY was Koufuku Graffiti.
>>
I will only accept Hibike/NNB:R as AOTY choices. I saw quite a lot of 2015 shows and there's really no other options.
>>
File: 1446100234077.gif (289 KB, 400x225) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1446100234077.gif
289 KB, 400x225
>>136202920
>>
File: You're a faggot.gif (1 MB, 480x270) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
You're a faggot.gif
1 MB, 480x270
>>136202997
>>
>>136201995
>>it doesn't look like other anime, therefore it must be a masterpiece
>>
File: lolipuzzle.jpg (257 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
lolipuzzle.jpg
257 KB, 1920x1080
>>136203761
>>136203784
>>
>>136198641
The anime that killed both it's main subber and Studio.
>>
>>136205834

It's all the OP 1 band's fault, the potheads took everyone down with them.
>>
>>136193920
>Haikyuu
go back to tumblr
>>
>2016
>not posting the official and objective version
>>
>>136200290
>it's funny how quickly OPM fans died out after the show ended
That's just IRC suddenly stopping its "spam OPM" thing. IRC was always the driving force behind OPM threads.
>>
>>136196025
>>136209142
Why did both you two's taste go to absolute shit after 2008?
>>
File: karenv.jpg (130 KB, 721x720) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
karenv.jpg
130 KB, 721x720
>>136209383
Why is Alice so shit? She ruined the whole episode.
>>
>>136209142
>2012
>Hyouka

That shit was boring, eat shit.
>>
>>136209983
Anon, how many times do we have to remind you to take your Ritalin?
>>
>>136210093
Yeah nah.
It was boring, go back to your phantom world circlejerk.
>>
File: 1450006437104.png (69 KB, 236x250) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1450006437104.png
69 KB, 236x250
2015: NNBR
2014: Mikakunin
2013: Yuyushiki
2012: Yuru Yuri
2011: Tamayura: Hitotose
2010: K-On!! (pinnacle of Japanese animation award)
2009: K-On!
2008: Natsume Yuujinchou
2007: Lucky Star (AOTD)
2006: Haruhi
2005: Mushishi
2004: Nanoha
2003: Kino no Tabi
2002: Azumanga Daioh
>>
Shirobako was AOTY
NNBR was close
>>
File: 1447804891464.jpg (89 KB, 829x776) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1447804891464.jpg
89 KB, 829x776
>>136193793
>>136196025
>>136201472
>All these edits of the official version
>>136209142
Doing god's work anon.
>>
>>136209275
It's also really forgettable, it was alright, but people won't be talking about it a year from now.
>>
>>136201525
Where do you think you are?
>>
File: ayumureaction12.jpg (32 KB, 268x402) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
ayumureaction12.jpg
32 KB, 268x402
>>136210534
>Osaka
>NNB
>Mikakunin
>/yys/
>YrYr
>Tamayura
>K-ON
>Haruhi
>Azumanga
>mwfw this guy is awesome
>>
It always changes every time I see it
>>
>>136193599
Yes, OPM won every single poll by a wide margin no matter how hard you try to deny it.
>>
>>136211392
>polls
>on /a/
Were you expecting accurate results without a bunch of crossboard and reddit tier votes, that would be retarded.
>>
>>136211941
No matter how hard you try to deny it.
>>
>>136194768
Shut the fuck up faggot, who gave you permission to speak your mind?
>>
>>136211941
If crossboarders and reddit didn't vote then it wouldn't be representative of /a/.
>>
What are the best subs for ping pong? Did commie meme too hard?
>>
>/a/
>Any sort of agreement
There isn't a single show that existed ever that someone else won't say is shit.
These threads accomplish nothing.
>>
>>136212201
They were legit and they did the BDs so go with them.
>>
>>136212250
Will do. Like most people the art style put me off on this show but I'll give it a shot.
>>
>>136212223
Nobody would call Musashi Gundoh shit.
>>
File: 1436260855016.png (71 KB, 324x370) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1436260855016.png
71 KB, 324x370
>>136200735
>death parade
>>
>>136212088
That logic is absolutely retarded, it's fine when its a small percentage, but when you have newfags and redditors account for a large portion of /a/ that don't respect the board culture and think they can posting without lurking, you get a board that is heavily weighed towards the opinion of the new people, who probably don't watch that much anime in the first place. This results in a large amount of /a/ being cancer that legit think that OPM was the best anime ever. If someone has the picture of the life cycle of a hobby, that is what i am basically what i'm talking about.
>>
>>136212656
Yeah except OPM was legit good, keep crying about it though.
>>
>>136212818
Thats all it was, good, all you faggots make it look like the second coming of jesus.
>>
File: 1411362188013.png (94 KB, 331x369) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1411362188013.png
94 KB, 331x369
>>136211392
>two Google polls that could have been fixed by their creator
>both of them posted on /v/ more than once before voting ended
>>
>>136213100
Stay mad your favorite anime didn't win, kiddo.
>>
File: 1385493632009.jpg (83 KB, 800x770) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1385493632009.jpg
83 KB, 800x770
Non Non Biyori Repeat for AOTY

OPM and GoPri are my honorable mentions.
>>
>>136213143
I'd be concerned if my favorite anime won polls that were posted on /v/.
>>
>>136213180
Why though? You come from there.
>>
File: Capture.png (7 KB, 238x283) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Capture.png
7 KB, 238x283
oh, I just made a list for this
should add osomatsu and lupin though

tv aoty is eupho by a large margin
>>
>>136213222
Nice baseless retort dude.
>>
>>136213325
Likewise.
>>
>>136212656
That's what /a/ is now. It doesn't belong to you any more than it belongs to the cancer.
>>
>>136213340
He's literally saying he thinks the poll's are worthless because they come from /v/. I fail to see how you would think he comes from /v/.
>>
>>136213438
He's making an erroneous leap in logic by assuming that anyone with knowledge of those polls being posted on /v/ must know this because they regularly visit /v/. He erroneously believes that one must regularly visit /v/ to possess that knowledge.
>>
>>136196025
perfect except for 2014 and 2015 and 2004
>>
>>136213438
He assumes the poll came from /v/ the same way he assumes the poll creator fixed the results. My assumption is as baseless as that.
>>
>>136213430
This sort of thinking is self-defeating nonsenese at worst or an attempt to demoralize what you see as opposition at best. Either way you're a faggot.
>>
>>136213501
It's common knowledge that this poll was spread around. How else would such a meh show like OPM get so many votes, you would have to be blind not to see the bias.
>>136213539
The poll creator fixing the votes probably didn't happen, but there is a large bias towards OPM like i was saying. There weren't even that many threads as other shows last year. It's just odd that a show like that could get such a huge vote when most people claiming OPM AOTY were just shitposters.
>>
>>136213693
It's not odd at all, OPM's Sunday threads had from 270/300 unique IPs and this high number of posters (consider the lurkers as well) were there for the three or four full threads they covered that day.
It also aired in Fall so people will most likely keep it (and other Fall shows) in mind more than other series.
It's not really hard to understand why it won every single poll.
>>
>>136213823
Perhaps I should add as a point of comparison that the highest number of unique IPs I saw in live threads were +200 in the last two episodes of Shirobako.
>>
>tons of OPM shitposting when it was airing
>nobody cares about OPM now that it's finished and board quality has gone up
>>
>>136213541
And you're delusional.
>>
>>136213823
Compared to other hard hitters like hibike and NNB, the threads weren't that much different. Not different enough to justify such a large gap in the poll results. Also the threads were really booming while the school children were on break, that could also be the reason for a bias. All of that combined on how it was just such a "ok" show, it just doesn't make any sense.
>>
>>136213541
Its not self defeating, its pragmatism; you cant wish the newfriends away. Also being hostile to them breeds a resentment and a desire for revenge, shitposting and flamewars are the inevitable conclusion. To actively improve the community it's best to speed their transition to a regular member through help and advice, or to simply ignore them
>>
>>136213539
>He assumes the poll came from /v/
Nobody said that.
>the same way he assumes the poll creator fixed the results
Nobody said that either. Learn to read.
>>136213823
>It's not really hard to understand why it won two polls posted on /v/
>>
>>136213929
>now the board has kyoanifags saying that a generic battle harem is good

Is it really better anon?
>>
>>136193599
>not even honourable mention Hyouka for 2012
>Space Battleship 2199 2013
>Meme Pong
>>>/trash/
>>
>2007
>not TTGL

/a/ does sure have shit taste
>>
>>136193599
>only great titles post 2005 are Yuasa's

If there is any consensus to be had is that 2015 was shit just like much of the 10 years preceding it.
>>
File: 1451784838671.gif (2 MB, 422x409) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1451784838671.gif
2 MB, 422x409
NNB helped with my crippling depression and PTSD. Now nam is just another memory.
>>
>>136214013
>Compared to other hard hitters like hibike and NNB

None of them ever had 200 IPs in their threads, especially not Non Non Biyori since their threads were really slow paced and probably filled only two on airing days.

>Also the threads were really booming while the school children were on break

This is just retarded, don't tell me you also believe "summerfags" have some kind of weight here.

>All of that combined on how it was just such a "ok" show, it just doesn't make any sense.

Maybe but then again the manga was really loved and had a big fanbase prior the anime, this plus having a good adaptation it's not really surprising.
>>
One Piece wins every year
>>
Is Tatami Galaxy the only worthy series to come out this past 5 years?
>>
People actually liked think Kaiba was AOTY? It was great until it devolved into a mediocre evangelion ripoff, I guess.
>>
>>136217077
You mean Doraemon
>>
I hate all of your opinions
>>
>>136217883
Katanagatari
>>
>>136217883
Shiki came out in the same year.
>>
NNB R, nothing else even came close in 2015.
>>
>>136216668
Just because the source material was awesome doesn't mean that the anime is also as good. Look at prison school.
>>
File: 1427730674423.jpg (123 KB, 1440x810) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1427730674423.jpg
123 KB, 1440x810
2000: Boogiepop Phantom
2001: Hare+Guu (bad year)
2002: Haibane Renmei (superb year)
2003: Texhnolyze
2004: Paranoia Agent
2005: Mushishi
2006: Haruhi (mediocre year)
2007: Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei
2008: Aria the Origination (great year)
2009: Eve no Jikan
2010: Tatami Galaxy (good year)
2011: Mawaru Penguindrum (great year)
2012: Hyouka
2013: Non Non Biyori (bad year)
2014: Ping Pong
2015: Yuri Kuma Arashi
>>
File: 1447375111148.png (7 KB, 500x182) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1447375111148.png
7 KB, 500x182
>>136215819
>>136217883
>>
>>136193693
KLK was amazing
>>
File: 1448567620723.webm (2 MB, 1280x720) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1448567620723.webm
2 MB, 1280x720
>>136219034
I can get behind a good chunk of this, but:

2000 - Boogiepop Phantom
2001 - Cyborg 009
2002 - Princess Tutu
2003 - Texhnolyze
2004 - Windy Tales
2005 - Mushishi
2006 - Welcome to the NHK
2007 - Mononoke (best year)
2008 - Casshern Sins
2009 - K-On!
2010 - Tatami Galaxy
2011 - Nichijou
2012 - Hyouka
2013 - Kyousougiga
2014 - Space Dandy
2015 - Hibike! Euphonium
>>
>>136219862
It was.
KLK = poorly animated, great characters, great fights, great story
OPM = well animated, shitty characters, shitty fights, shitty story
>>
>>136219862
amazingly bad
>>
>>136219920
>KLK
>great story
The rest is accurate.
>>
>>136219992
Clothes taking over the world was pretty creative, unique and memorable.
>>
>>136193599
Why the fuck are you completely ignoring movies?
>>
>>136193599
Holy shit this chart is so wrong.

Also Hibike is AOTY 2015
>>
>>136220113
>Holy shit this chart is so wrong.
That's because it's the pretentious psuedo-intellectual hipster version.
>>136209142 is the authentic version.
>>
>>136220036
The premise was quite original, but the proper execution of the story is too full of pace issues and asspulls to be called great.
>>
>>136209142
non non biyori is a good show but I fail to see what elevates it to anything beyond a barely above-average seasonal fodder show
>>
>>136220180
It's a great story in the context of its genre.
>battleshonen anime
>having literature-tier stories
>>
File: 1452353867370.jpg (12 KB, 336x352) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1452353867370.jpg
12 KB, 336x352
Non non biyori is shit I dont even understand why anyone would like it. It's even more boring and lazy than Kon
>>
>>136220297
Its execution is paralleled only by ARIA in the context of its subgenre, iyashikei. Iyashikei is either your thing or it isn't. If it's not, you probably won't get why NNB is so loved here.
>>
>>136220376
And if it is, you'll wonder how people dare to compare it to ARIA.
>>
File: dbn.jpg (9 KB, 322x292) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
dbn.jpg
9 KB, 322x292
>>>>>Banner of the Stars instead of Argento Soma
>>
>>136193599
>That Image
/v/ pls go
>>
>>136220376
It's a terrible genre though. It's boring, braindead, and offers zero mental stimulation. It and shounen/haremshit etc are the fast food of anime and manga
>>
File: 1429546360347.png (400 KB, 450x720) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1429546360347.png
400 KB, 450x720
>>136220414
NNB's overall execution level as an iyashikei anime is consistent in both seasons: somewhere between the execution level of ARIA the Natural and ARIA the Origination.
If you compare the overall execution level of both NNB seasons with all three seaons of ARIA combined, NNB's overall execution level is a bit higher.
Episodes 4 and 10 of both seasons of NNB are at least equal in execution level to any of ARIA the Origination's episodes. Episode 4 of NNBR is higher in execution level than any ARIA episode, "Surrounded by That Orange Wind" included.
>>
>>136220158
Hell no.
>>
>>136220376
I don't get how many people don't understand this.
Some people like iyashikei, some people don't. The amount of people on here who shitpost on NNB is ridiculous.
>>136220553
>boring, braindead, and offers zero mental stimulation
>shounen/haremshit etc are the fast food of anime and manga
Kind of contradicting yourself here.
>>
File: elfedorino.jpg (30 KB, 300x300) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
elfedorino.jpg
30 KB, 300x300
>>136220553
>>
>>136220376
The only thing executed in a particularly noteworthy fashion (that I noticed) was the sound design, which was great. What else would you say? Like, I genuinely want you to elaborate because I don't understand.
Also, ARIA is put on a higher pedestal than I think it deserves. Not bad by any stretch, but "unparalleled execution"? Backgrounds and animation are bland and inexpressive. There are a bunch of shows that are better in their "execution." But still, it's a good show. I like it a lot.
>>
File: 1439676751457.png (65 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1439676751457.png
65 KB, 1280x720
>>136193599
this bait is great, mind if I save it?
>>
Hibike! followed closely by Owari.

I'd say Teekyuu, but that isn't AOTY. It's the greatest work in any medium to every grace this Earth.
>>
>>136219886
>2009- K-On
Natsume, Bakemonogatari, and Brotherhood came out in 2009.
>2011 - Nichijou
Wandering Son, Chihayafuru, even HxH came in 2011.
>2012 - Hyouka
In the year of Nichibros, no way.
You are a KyoAni friend and that's okay.
Agree with the rest.
>>
>>136220553
>>136220617
Also, this is /a/, what the fuck do you think a bunch of little girls watch. If you want to talk about your manime, go somewhere else.
>>
File: VB.jpg (167 KB, 920x662) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
VB.jpg
167 KB, 920x662
>>136220553
>I am too plebeian to appreciate all genres of anime
>>
>>136220765
This whole bratposting thing needs to be put to sleep. She's too much brat for one girl.
>>
>>136220693
>what the fuck do you think a bunch of little girls watch

Not iyashikei for sure.
>>
>>136220765
epic
>>
File: 1450999637511.png (82 KB, 191x197) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1450999637511.png
82 KB, 191x197
>>136220822
>little girls
>Not liking iyashikei
Loving every laugh, anon.
>>
File: 1347919740747.jpg (85 KB, 640x480) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1347919740747.jpg
85 KB, 640x480
Pre 2003 - Who cares
2003 - FMP Fumoffu
2004 - Irrelevant year
2005 - Air
2006 - Haruhi / Kanon
2007 - Lucky Star / Clannad
2008 - Clannad After Story
2009 - K-ON!
2010 - K-ON!!
2011 - Nichijou
2012 - Hyouka / Chuuni2
2013 - Tamako Market / KnK
2014 - Amagi Brilliant Park
2015 - Hibikek
>>
>>136220644
Both ARIA and NNB manage to create a specific, intended feeling in the viewer (relaxed, at peace, "healed," with a bit of melancholy thrown in, e.g. mono no aware) better than any other iyashikei anime. The whole is greater than the sum of its parts with these two anime.
You say ARIA's backgrounds are bland and inexpressive but their watercolor look/palettes enhance the soothing nature of the show. You don't give enough credit to NNB's writing and direction, which combine the consistently classy execution of punchlines with exceptionally well-crafted healing scenes.
>>
>>136220916
Except that little girls watch Aikatsu, Precure or whatever is on TV at morning or afternoon. Your new is showing.
>>
>>136220680
When I pick K-On! I'm considering the series as a whole, so I'm 100% behind it, it's my favourite show. I haven't seen too much from 2011, only good show I'm weighing it against is Madhouse's HxH, which I don't think is all it's made out to be. Hyouka is the best produced TV show I've ever seen and demonstrates a mastery of craft that's veeery hard to come by. Seriously impressive shit.

That being said you're definitely right, I'm a Kyoani friend through and through, they've put out some great content in the last five years and I seriously respect them as a studio.

>>136220934
that's still fucking gross though
>>
File: otaku.jpg (38 KB, 400x500) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
otaku.jpg
38 KB, 400x500
>>136220822
>>136220916
He's right
>>
>>136220916
>little girls
>watching seinen anime airing 2am
>>
File: 1433522118122.jpg (42 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1433522118122.jpg
42 KB, 1280x720
Hibike was AOTY by a long chalk
>>
>>136193599
I see you guys had to hipster this chart up even more by tampering with some of the winners.
>>
File: 140694797908.jpg (70 KB, 810x780) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
140694797908.jpg
70 KB, 810x780
>>136220973
>Implying that after a long day at school, they don't cuddle with their Onii-chan and watch some NNB.
My little anon can't be this baka.
>>
>>136220949
Can you give an example of good writing and direction in NNB? Certainly not saying it's poorly written but it's a 4koma adaption through and through, doesn't really have a feeling of cohesiveness to it that I like to see from this kinda thing. It's funny though. As far as the direction goes it's got nothing on Sato's stuff. I think there was only one memorable cut in the entire thing, that one on the porch in the final episode of Repeat. Quite liked that, but elsewhere it's just basic stuff that I noticed.
>>
>>136221005
translate it
>>
>>136221144
Yeah and I bet they also end up fucking just like in my doujinshi, epic.
>>
>>136220693
Mahou shoujo, regular shoujo and occasional josei.
>>
>>136221134
If you're trying to make iyashikei fans look retarded then I beg you to stop.
>>
>>136193793
owari very clearly felt like filler before the next big thing. Nise had a same vibe but it actually did things that mattered
>>
File: 1451247533573.jpg (13 KB, 222x227) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1451247533573.jpg
13 KB, 222x227
>>136221177
Get your mind out of the gutter anon, little girls are pure.
>>
File: otaku_eng.jpg (71 KB, 424x500) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
otaku_eng.jpg
71 KB, 424x500
>>136221163
Little girls don't like NNB. Sweaty grown men love NNB.
>>
>>136221259
>Sweaty grown men love NNB.

It's almost like they are the target demographic, surprise surprise.
>>
>>136221157
>4koma adaption
>NNB
Can't even bait right.
>>
>>136221134
Where's the lie?
>>
>>136221157
NNBR Episode 4. The first half is an extremely well-executed buildup=>punchline sequence and the second half is the show's most well-crafted, emotionally powerful sequence, using alternated shots to contrast life and death and perfectly choreographed music/visuals synergy to heighten emotional impact.
>>
>>136193599
This looks less like a consensus and one more like one person's opinion.
>>
>>136221259
>comfortable and functional footwear
At least they've got their priorities straight.
>>
>>136221259
He looks pretty good to me
>>
>>136221236
They do that themselves
>>
>>136193599
2012-2014 should all be their respective monogataris.
>>
>>136221556
>you will never be this honest with yourself
>>
>>136221556
>>136221614
>You will never be this rich
>>
File: 1447801976039.jpg (139 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1447801976039.jpg
139 KB, 1280x720
>>136221614
Feels bad to have to put up a front senpai.
>>
>>136221293
oh is it not one? I just got that feeling from how it was delivered, and the usual format for this kinda thing.

>>136221332
I'll have to keep an eye for that on a rewatch. It was a good episode for sure, and I could definitely understand the praise the show gets if the whole thing were like that but I don't really think it was. There was no central ordering principle to it, no thematic cohesiveness. Those heartfelt scenes clash with the more voyeuristic shots, or the unrelated gags. More of a montage of jokes and softer scenes reflecting the setting than a unified project.
I'm not saying you're wrong for liking it in the slightest, I'm just not sold on it in the same way you are.
>>
File: images.jpg (8 KB, 230x219) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
images.jpg
8 KB, 230x219
>>136221690
Congratulations, you realise that different people like different things. Here's your obligatory loli.
>>
>>136220376
Nigga I love iyashikei but I don't have the slightest interest in watching NNB. Also iyashikei works better together with tragedy, like with Ai-Ren, or Key.
>>
>>136193793
>Joshiraku over Jinrui
invalidated
>>
>>136221690
>There was no central ordering principle to it, no thematic cohesiveness.
It's a slice of life anime. You're looking in the wrong place for this sort of thing.
>voyeuristic shots
I feel like the use of this term to describe CGDCT anime unfairly implies to some that all viewers of CGDCT anime are pedos. I can't get on board with this at all.
>>
File: 1448542720330.webm (2 MB, 1280x720) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1448542720330.webm
2 MB, 1280x720
>>136221768
Thanks man that's my all-time favourite loli.
Have a cute scene.
>>
>>136220680
K-On is shit but don't you dare shit on Nichijou and Hyouka, especially if the ones who are supposed to take their place are HxH and Nichibros which are mediocre.
>>
>>136220617
>The amount of people on here who shitpost on NNB is ridiculous.
HAHahahahaHAHAHAhahaHAHAHHaHhaAhaaAHhaHaH HOLY FUCKING SHIT ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME? How delusional can you get???

NNB:R has been shilled harder than any show this year, summer was full of you fucking shills making AOTY threads for the whole season time and treating it like God's gift to anime, I even like the show but the autistic worshiping fanbase is horrible, worst shills on this site second only to the Trump shills and that's because those guys make threads on every fucking board. Get over yourself.
>>
File: maxresdefault.jpg (37 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
maxresdefault.jpg
37 KB, 1280x720
>>136221556
>lefthanded
>>
>>136221945
This
>>
>>136221850
>You're looking in the wrong place for this sort of thing.
I don't think so.
>>136221850
>I feel like the use of this term to describe CGDCT anime unfairly implies to some that all viewers of CGDCT anime are pedos. I can't get on board with this at all.
I wouldn't apply it to ever cute girls show, and I'm not implying that in the slightest. Fact remains that NNB does have some more questionable shots in it, and they're there whether the viewer likes it or not.
>>
To be honest I don't have seen enough anime to say which might be the best of the year. I can say what's the best out of the ones I've seen but not the absolute best.

Can you?
>>
Holy fuck all this shit taste.

Any chart that doesn't mention Jinrui in 2012 is objectively wrong. It was the only anime that was consistently mentioned as AOTY in the threads that people didn't argue was shit, the majority of /a/ that watched it and participated in the threads thought it was AOTY.
>>
>>136222235
Shinsekai yori > Jinrui
>>
>>136222345
This desu senpai.
>>
>>136222235
Not my pick for that year but it's a strong show. I think Hyouka and SSY are better. Lack of criticism on /a/ doesn't mean much.
>>
>>136222345
I agree.
>>
>>136222146
You should only be allowed to argue about AOTY if you actually watched the majority of anime airing that year. The majority of these threads are people autistically meme spouting their favorite of the three anime they watch any given season. Granted parts of /a/ end up watching the same things, but this thread is just retarded retconning of the past based on personal preference rather than general consensus.
>>
>>136221945
NNBR = AOTY and Trump will save us all from the enemy we're not allowed to name right now.
>>
>>136221945
Are you going to tell me that shit like this doesn't happen when a good show is aired? Are you thick? Also what the fuck, shilling? I forgot that you should never defend a show, because that = shilling. Maybe when a show gets a lot of threads, it means that /a/ likes it? If you can't handle that your favorite anime wasn't as popular as something else, you should seriously consider suicide
And that one retard making the "NNB is the anime of the decade better than evangelion" isn't shilling, it's just one guy being a massive faggot
>>
>>136222429
Honestly, even if I try almost everything that comes out, I end actually seeing at best 3-4 series each season. I don't see how watching all the filler that comes out makes your judgement any better.
>>
>>136222401
But people generally argue Hyouka was so fucking boring they fell asleep watching it.

And while SSY was interesting in terms of backstory, it's easily called out on being 2DEEP4ME and alienated it's audience with it's homopairings.
>>
File: MemeGirl.png (142 KB, 473x462) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
MemeGirl.png
142 KB, 473x462
>>136222521

Non Non Biyori is AOTD and a better anime than Neon Genesis Evangelion.
>>
File: watchinghyouka.jpg (41 KB, 467x300) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
watchinghyouka.jpg
41 KB, 467x300
>>136222401
>>
>>136222429
If you watch the majority of anime that comes out in a year you probably have shit taste and your vote shouldn't be counted desu
>>
>>136222521
Not that anon, but for most series the amount of "AOTYAY OH MY GOD" shitposting of NNB was annoying. I guess it was because it aired on summer and with that came the usual flow of MAL shitposters, but still.
>>
>>136222429
>the majority
I think that's a bit of a stretch. A few dozen shows is enough to participate in discussion about the year decently, and if you don't have any of the good ones in a set of that size, it's probably because you have shit taste, not because you weren't watching enough.
>>
File: 1420762890799.jpg (49 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1420762890799.jpg
49 KB, 1280x720
Uh NNB repeat?

Pretty sure it was top of everyone's end of 2015 list.
>>
>>136193599
>ping pong
Go away chink fag
>>
You're not helping Le-douche
>>
the biggest thing wrong is hyouka is being massively overrated. 6/10 at best but tbqh felt like 4.5/10 to 5/10.

>>136222708
pingpong was fine.

>>136222678
eupho was best. nnb 2nd
>>
>>136222530
>I don't see how watching all the filler that comes out makes your judgement any better.
If you try everything that comes out and decide it's all shit, that's different, but I still don't want your opinion because you're probably a faggot.
>>
>>136222634
It was just the a couple of shitposters that have nothing better to do, just like this faggot.
>>136222582
>>
>>136222596
>>136222545
I'm not implying that you should watch every shit show every season. Just pointing out there is very clear divisions in /a/ between fujoshits, moefags, haremfags, hipsters, mecha etc. and they ususally don't watch all the shows with relevant threads on /a/ but still shitpost and shill their shit taste every AOTY thread, but that doesn't make anyone's opinion any more valid. Because AOTY thread should be a comparison of the best shows in any given year, but it's redundant if you haven't seen the anime's in contention. It's like the academy of motion pictures voting on who wins the oscar without watching the movie, obviously were not having an award ceremony. I'm just pointing out these threads are usually full of speculation
>>
>>136222530
>>136222596
>>136222659
>>>136222871
>>
File: woof.jpg (111 KB, 571x551) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
woof.jpg
111 KB, 571x551
>>136221945
>>136222521

I'm only going to explain this once: I just want people to watch NNB. That's why I post the things I do. No other show has ever made me feel so good inside and I want others to feel that.
>>
2010 was Sora no Woto
>>
>>136222951
Don't try to give people the wrong idea, it's a super comfy SOL, but it's not really that "good" besides it's comfiness.
>>
>>136223010
>not-K-ON! over K-ON!!
I don't think so.
>>
>>136222951
Why, for every 1 person you convince to watch it, you get 20 to think that it's shit just based on your shitposting. You're just being counter productive at this point.
>>
>>136222235
>>136222345
>>136222373
>>136222401
I wouldn't even know which one to choose out of those three, they're all very good.
>>136222429
That's why I was asking.
>>136222545
People are stupid, more news at 11.

I thought about it and maybe the first episodes of Owari are the best thing I've seen this year. But I don't know, there's Jojo other things I haven't seen like Lupin, Akagami, NNB etc.
>>
File: 368c8944.jpg (89 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
368c8944.jpg
89 KB, 1280x720
>>136223016
It's the comfiest, m8.
>>
>>136222871
Who the fuck would consider an anime AOTY jusy because there's BL, a robot or a harem? If it's good it's good.
>>
>>136222587
This desu.
>>
>>136223010
Nice meme.
>>
>>136221259
>He doesn't tuck his shirt in
It's like you want to look like a retarded douchebag with an IQ of 17.
>>
>>136223109
If I wanted comfort women I'd go to Corea
>>
>>136222871
I have my inclinations towards certain things but I'm able to recognize the quality in a show even if it's not in my hit zone.
>>
>>136223156
The point is that there are tons of people who mostly watch their favorite genre.
>>
File: 1406585210684.webm (544 KB, 440x570) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1406585210684.webm
544 KB, 440x570
>>136222770
I was gonna agree but your Hyouka comments are hurtful Anon.
>>
>>136193599
pretty good list, 2015 AOTY is Shirobako, special mention to Shokugeki no Souma
>>
>>136223575
Lelouch, Lelouch, I think about you everyday,
I'll always be here to call you a gay.
You may think my comments are rude,
But deep down, I think you're a pretty cool dude.
Although your posts make me feel real sick,
I kinda want to tickle your dick.
I want to mail you gushing barrels of my shit,
And arrive straight at your door to nibble on your boytit.
I wish to bungle your boypussy until you queef,
And spread my mayonnaise on your angus beef.
I know this isn't quite halel,
But I really want to drop my salty hummus on your falafel.
I sometimes dream of your tender lip,
All over which I'd spill--my white bean dip.
Ignore all the anons who tell you die.
I'll forever remain by your side, to shower you with coconut cream pie.
You may find this poem to be poorly-written and disgusting,
but always remember that you'll be the cake to my frosting.
>>
>>136193793
gatari fag here, owari sucked
>>
>>136224831
*fag here, owari sucked
>>
>>136221880
>Nichibros and HxH
>mediocre
That's Nichijou. Nothing wrong with Hyouka.

>>136220984
Stick to it, anon. Theres nothing wrong with it but needed some something. I found Sora no Woto to be better for a somewhat similar series, kyoani freind.
>>
File: 1393547091315.gif (179 KB, 500x281) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1393547091315.gif
179 KB, 500x281
>>136225269
Nichijou never failed to make my heart warm.
Fuck you.
>>
>>136225269
No no no, Nichijou is miles above average. I don't even know how anyone could watch an episode and say "yes this is standard anime television."
Sora no Woto's a bit of a mess, tonally, but it had a couple things I liked.
>>
>>136193599

>2014
>ping pong

I agree.
>>
>>136225660
I got a few chuckles but never real laughs like Nichibros. Agreed on Sora no Woto. Sora no Woto had problems but had the something that K-on lacked.

>>136225549
You too, anon.
>>
Is NNB really as good as anons say it is? It just looks like an okayish SoL. Nothing special but nothing bad.
>>
>>136225784
People who laugh watching Nichibros probably have 4 neurons.
>>
>>136225885
Just watch it yourself.
>>
>>136193783

Can an anime almost no one watched be a consensus best pick?
>>
File: 1452124574074.png (571 KB, 800x640) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1452124574074.png
571 KB, 800x640
>>136225955
I guess I will.
>>
>>136225969
Definitely not but that doesn't make it pretentious hipster shit.
>>
>>136193599
Regardless of how much people will try to dunk on ping pong I think it will always be one of my favorite animes just because of its great story. I would have put Barakamon to the honorable mention roster for its story too.
>>
>Stardust Crusaders
>best of 2014

I'm a huge Jojo fag and even I think this is bullshit.
>>
>>136226087
Enjoy!
>>
>>136225914
The fact it didn't need to be completely silly like Nichijou to be funny makes me that about Nichijou. Both were good but Nichibros was better for that.
>>
>>136226180
>animes
Fuck off.
>>
Is there a list of shows that you should have watched with /a/ - shows that caused the biggest shitstorm of the year etc.?
>>
File: 1430258283922.gif (404 KB, 342x342) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1430258283922.gif
404 KB, 342x342
>>136226249
I hope I do!
>>
File: 1423496770267.jpg (149 KB, 1440x810) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1423496770267.jpg
149 KB, 1440x810
>>136222678
>>136222770
1. Yuri Kuma. Only anime by a true auteur and the only veritable masterpiece that aired last year.
2. Hibike
3. NNB
>>
>>136226501
oh come on
>>
File: 1428116274937.jpg (77 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1428116274937.jpg
77 KB, 1280x720
>>136226575
I know /a/ hates it, but I thought it was as good as Utena and almost as good as Penguindrum.
>>
File: 1423107047928.png (168 KB, 380x392) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1423107047928.png
168 KB, 380x392
>>136226996
I loved it, but I can't for see it as anything but a perfect example of style with no substance, yes there's some meaning in everything but when that meaning isn't compelling or interesting there's only so far charm and spectacle can go.
>>
>>136226996
I liked it quite a bit but it's sloppy as hell and clearly compromised. Also fuck off with your "only anime by a true auteur" shit.
>>
File: erin.jpg (79 KB, 790x494) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
erin.jpg
79 KB, 790x494
>>136195828
But where'll you find a good coming-of-age anime like Erin in recent years? The other ones I can remember are from WMT, and they are at most from the 90s.
>>
We all know that in truth, there are only 5-9 genuine NNBfags and perhaps 15-20 genuine OPMfags.
The rest are just shitposters falseflagging on both sides, rigging the polls to whatever generates the most butthurt.
It was a good joke though.
>>
>>136195346
i liked mine fujiko better this lupin series
>>
File: 1452859384728.jpg (49 KB, 270x412) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1452859384728.jpg
49 KB, 270x412
>>136220376
Non Non Biyori is a good series, hell it's a great series, but like most iyashikei it' just pure escapism. It's very relaxing, but only a fool would think it's better than something that excels an telling an actual story.
>>
>>136227196
I'm not trying to be pretentious. I just think that even if it wasn't 100% perfect, it was instantly recognizable as Ikuhara's work, with all his familiar themes and his distinctive style of storytelling.
There's a serious lack of such anime nowadays, almost everything is produced by faceless committees going for inoffensive blandness, resulting in an impersonal style, impossible to be traced back to a creative individual's personal expression.

>>136227101
Lots of people thought Utena was style without substance. Or Mind Game, Kaiba, Tatami Galaxy,Ping Pong, Angel's Egg, to name just a few hyper-stylized show. It's rather subjective criticism since these kind of anime require a lot of exploration and gap-filling on the viewer's side, and no everyone is equally successful with that. And then it's easy to blame one's failure to see depth in a certain anime on the creator.
>>
>>136221259
would be /fa/ is he got better shoes, untucked his shirt and had better fitting pants
>>
>>136227969
>serious lack of such work
We got new shows from Imazaki and Yamada, the director of Death Parade shows a lot of promise, new movies from Yoshinari, Hara, and Hosoda, and a whole host of content from the animator expo. Each of these people can rightfully be called an auteur alongside Ikuhara; to hold him as the only one is insulting to all the other people putting in work.
>>
>>136227370
Where did you get those numbers? A rough estimate?
>>
>>136228154
>that body shape
sorry m8. he's got to be ottermode or skelly.

>>136227370
OPM is fun and NNB is relaxing but admittedly a bit slow (which i guess is the appeal of it)
>>
>>136227791
>excels at telling an actual story
If your definition of "excels at" is "literature-tier," then no anime ever does this. I honestly think you're looking in the wrong medium for excellent storytelling. Anime is good for ridiculous fight scenes that are difficult to impossible to do in live action/3DCG, and for cute girls doing cute things. That's it.
>>
File: still only c-rank.png (119 KB, 1344x756) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
still only c-rank.png
119 KB, 1344x756
>>136229835
>Anime is good for ridiculous fight scenes that are difficult to impossible to do in live action/3DCG, and for cute girls doing cute things. That's it
>>
>>136229835

This post is correct except for the fight scenes part. There is no fight scene that Hollywood can't pull off with modern technology now. Thus, anime is only good for cute girls doing cute things.

You were close, anon.
>>
>>136229835
Oh fuck off.
>>
>>136227969
>There's a serious lack of such anime nowadays, almost everything is produced by faceless committees going for inoffensive blandness, resulting in an impersonal style, impossible to be traced back to a creative individual's personal expression.
Whether you think certain directors are good is up to your own taste, but if you think Ikuhara was the only person last year to direct something clearly recognizable as his own work, you either didn't watch a lot or you're just not as familiar with other directors.
>>
File: 1444446267651.gif (499 KB, 1024x576) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1444446267651.gif
499 KB, 1024x576
>>136229835
The "I actually think all anime is mediocre even though i'm on /a/" guys are the worst kind of shitposter
>>
>>136230153
But that's not the kind of person you're responding to. That guy could easily love anime, he just isn't looking for innovative and detailed emotional storytelling or some shit. I'd argue that the people who are looking for that and find it to their satisfaction in about three series a season and don't bother with anything else are much more guilty of the attitude you described.
>>
>>136193762
/a/ will never accept this hard fact.
>>
Nah pretty sure Umaru is AOTY. Shit probably AOTD if I dare say :^)
>>
>>136230229
>That guy could easily love anime
I love the shit out of it. Hollywood could never pull off a TTGL or a K-ON.
>>
>>136229913
dunno, most anime fight scenes are very stylized and wound't look very good on Live Action ,also stuff like EoE would cost humongous amounts of money
>>
File: episode-12.png (1 MB, 1200x675) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
episode-12.png
1 MB, 1200x675
>>
>>136193599
How do I vote for K and Oregi=airu?
>>
>>136193599
>2005´s honourable mention: Eureka Seven

OH NO YOU FUCKING DIDN´T.
>>
File: 1319011308947.jpg (147 KB, 632x576) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1319011308947.jpg
147 KB, 632x576
>>136193599
>consensus
>over 300 posts of arguing
Guess your question was answered OP.
>>
File: smile.png (607 KB, 761x720) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
smile.png
607 KB, 761x720
2000: Ippo
2001: Baki
2002: Chobits (not a very good year)
2003: Kino
2004: Major s1
2005: Major s2
2006: Code Geass R1
2007: Kaiji
2008: Clannad AS (Best year)
2009: Tokyo Magnitude 8.0
2010: Rainbow (close runner up is Kemono no Souja
2011: Steins;Gate
2012: Kids on the Slope
2013: Ippo Rising
2014: Ping Pong
2015: Diamond no Ace (bad year)
>>
>>136233456
Its a transcendental bait, its wrong on more than one possible world!
>>
>>136225885
>Is NNB really as good as anons say it is?
No.
>>
>>136233939
I think if you're gonna make a conclusive statement like that you gotta provide evidence to back it up.
>>
>>136225885
Mediocre at best, non non it bores me being good is a meme because it won an AOTY poll with proxies.
>>
>>136193599
>2006
>Samurai champloo doesn't even get an honorable mention.
Shit list
>>
File: 1448064773161.jpg (27 KB, 329x400) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1448064773161.jpg
27 KB, 329x400
We had that google poll and OPM was rank 1 so if you want to go by what the majority thinks then it would indeed be the caped Baldy.

But since the "most popular anime" on /a/ is never actually "the most popular anime" and rather "the most vocal minority", whatever anime fanbase is yelling, crying and shitposting the loudest will probably be declared the anime of the year 2015, just like every other year.

I don't even need to read this thread to know it is another shitposting feast of insecure people declaring that their favorite anime is officially and objectively the most popular anime on /a/, because they simply can't handle the fact people enjoy different things than them.
>>
I think we can all agree on this.
>>
>>136234264
gochuumon is ass get some taste, faggot
>>
>>136234325
I'd say the same thing about literally any other show which, like GochiUsa, tries to do nothing but be cute. However, GochiUsa is the cutest fucking thing I have ever seen, so it gets a pass here.
>>
File: Areyouretarded.png (230 KB, 311x560) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Areyouretarded.png
230 KB, 311x560
>>136234264
How can a 2014 show win the Winter award?
>>
File: 1357757551879.jpg (50 KB, 637x822) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1357757551879.jpg
50 KB, 637x822
>>136234264
At first I thought you were just a fag. Then scrolled down and see you were also salty as fuck.
>>
>>136234456
it aired in 2015 you BAKA
>>
>>136234481
Get back to reddit, you newfag.
>>
>>136234456
Special circumstances (that season being fucking shit) allow it in this isolated example.
>>
>>136234481
>I don't understand what cours are

>>136234264
Also, YKA should get an honourable mention for EDOTY, I think.
>>
>>136234512
Oh, wow, don't let people say you are an annoying circlejerker.
>>
>>136234545
YKA was pretty boring wasn't it? Pretty flat visuals, if I'm remembering it right. OP song was sick though.
>I don't understand what cours are
The second aired in 2015, the show ended in 2015, it's just as much a 2015 show as it is a 2014 show. It's really stupid to whine over it being included.
>>
>>136234623
>YKA was pretty boring wasn't it?
The ED, I mean.
>>
>>136234512
>Kamisama S2
>shit

Go back to whenever you came from, fag.
>>
File: 1448968135328.jpg (49 KB, 600x600) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1448968135328.jpg
49 KB, 600x600
>>136209142
>Non Non Biyori
>deserving AOTY

>Hyouka
>deserving AOTY

>Sora no Woto
>deserving anything
>>
>>136234264
>ending of the year
>not NNB
The NNB ED is one of the only anime songs i downloaded the full version of and listened to more than 200 times, it blows gochiusa out of the water.
>>
>>136234874
>can't even bother to use an anime-related reaction image
Ladies and gentlemen, /v/eddit.
>>136193625
>ping ping was pretentious hipster shit
Wow, this thread was done in one.
>>
File: 1375430304781.png (873 KB, 855x1008) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1375430304781.png
873 KB, 855x1008
>>136234264
This fucking guy.
>>
>>136235045
The animation quality of Gochiusa's ED plays a significant factor here. I do, however, think there was something magical about the very beginning of NNB's ED, musically, and how it segued the curtain call part into the actual ED segment.
>>
File: 13810774762199.jpg (1 MB, 2560x1440) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
13810774762199.jpg
1 MB, 2560x1440
>>136235087
>Ladies and gentlemen, /v/eddit.
Really, what's the best you have?

Sora no Woto was fucking garbage. Non Non Biyori is fine for what it is, but certainly not anything worth an award. Hyouka fell fucking flat with poorly executed characters and mysteries, it only looked pretty.
>>
File: 1422329780680.png (280 KB, 622x480) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1422329780680.png
280 KB, 622x480
>>136234623
Fucking this. YKA had the best op last year.
>>
>>136235166
Well there was no animation quality in the NNB ED, it was a slideshow, but when the catagory say's ED of the year i just assume the music, which i probably shouldn't, since the animation is a part of the ED. Actually, I take my opinion back, the Usagi ED was better. I just really liked the NNB ED track better. The picture's were nice, but nothing special.
Also
>it segued the curtain call part into the actual ED segment
I loved how it did that.
>>
>>136234623
The YKA ED wasn't inventive or anything, but the dancing bear was great.
>>
>>136225969
do you even know what pretentious means you idiot?

Anyway i'm happy Birdy the Mighty Decode 2 was an honorable mention. They had low budget and i love the OP by Nirgilis
>>
>>136235244
It was fucking great, sexy as hell and it sets the tone for the show so well.

>>136235386
Oh yeah I liked it, it just didn't really stand out for me.
>>
>>136235192

Sora no Woto is a better anime than Neon Genesis Evangelion.
>>
File: 1451654783693.gif (1 MB, 235x240) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1451654783693.gif
1 MB, 235x240
>>136193599
>No yuri shit as any AOTY

Legitimately impressed, although I feel some thing are missing.
>>
File: sabagebu[1].jpg (149 KB, 770x429) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
sabagebu[1].jpg
149 KB, 770x429
AOTY 2014
>>
File: 1432485367111.gif (178 KB, 428x427) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1432485367111.gif
178 KB, 428x427
>>136235475
Yeah, kill yourself. I don't even like eva, but sora no woto is fucking garbage. The pacing, the animation, the characters, the fucking design choices, it all leads to an absolutely fucking inexcusably trash product.
>>
>>136235723
not big on Sora no Woto either but your criticisms are laughable to say the least. Either say you don't like it and leave it at that, or provide an actual argument
>>
OFFICIAL AND OBJECTIVE 2010 ANIME POWER RANKINGS

1. Sora no Woto
2. K-ON
3. Hidamari Sketch
4. Working!!
5. Ika Musume
6. Arakawa Under the Bridge
7. OreImo
8. Hanamaru Kindergarten
9. Panty & Stocking with Garterbelt
10. Seitokai Yakuindomo

POWER GAP

9001. Dragon Ball Z
90001. Angel Beats!
90000000000001. The Tatami Galaxy
>>
>>136236065
ew why
>>
>>136236065
>Oriemo over The Tatami Galaxy
I like a few of those shows, but holy shit get fucked.
>>
How to spot a troll list
1. Madoka not 2011
2. NNBR for 2015
3. Any Gatari listed besides Bake
>>
>>136236710
Having Madoka for 2011 is equally trolly.
>>
>>136236710
How to spot a /v/ list
1. NNBR not 2015
>>
>>136236788
No objective viewer could put NNBR as AOTY, AOTS maybe (highly debatable), but definitely not AOTY.
>>
Jesus christ NNB was so boring. You'd have to be 100% detached from life to endure more than an episode of that shit. "Comfy" meme seriously needs to die.
>>
>>136236877

Get out, normalfaggot.
>>
>>136236877
>not being detached from life
>>>/out/
>>
>>136236877
Jesus christ OPM was so boring. You'd have to be 100% detached from life to endure more than an episode of that shit. "Shounen" meme seriously needs to die.
>>
File: 1448841112018.jpg (66 KB, 372x334) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1448841112018.jpg
66 KB, 372x334
>>136236956
>being this paranoid

No need to defend your favorite anime this much. Nothing in that post indicated or even implied I watched one punch man.
>>
>>136237329
I'm not implying that NNB is my favorite anime either, just pointing out how retarded your post looked to everyone else senpai.
>>
File: welcome.jpg (247 KB, 1366x768) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
welcome.jpg
247 KB, 1366x768
>>136236877
But there are plenty of parts in NNB which are decidedly uncomfy, like the part where Renge makes a friend and then she leaves.

Maybe it's not for everyone, but I don't know how you can't enjoy the "simple pleasures" aspect of it, like the isolated, natural setting and the beautiful shots of breathtaking landscapes.
>>
>>136237596
What I really loved was the OST and the backgrounds. I don't see nothing AOTY about it but in hindsight, compared to the season, it's up there.

>>136237478
The way you replied, and the way you specifically targeted that one anime suggests you were pretty hurt by my comment. It's okay, no need to lie, we're all anonymous.
>>
File: nonnoncast.jpg (155 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
nonnoncast.jpg
155 KB, 1920x1080
>>136237699
Your right, i'm super mad right now, i need some cute anime girls to calm me down.
>>
>>136234264
This dude have good taste.
>>
>Yahari S2 wasn't mentioned once

Good job.
>>
File: 1451306711836.gif (2 MB, 202x360) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1451306711836.gif
2 MB, 202x360
>>136238291
>melodrama hs bullshit
>>
>>136237329
the implication is your a normie faggot who likes OPM and can't appreciate NNB or ARIA like a true little girl.

>>>/v/
>>
>>136193599
Shirobako is easily AOTY for whatever year you want to put it in.
>>
>>136238832
Nice paranoia, and fix your grammar before calling anyone else out.

>>>/school/
>>
>>136238910
There were shows I liked more from both years, but yeah it's a great series. I think it's pretty easy to criticize, but watching it really made me feel like "yeah I love anime" which is some of the highest praise I can give something.
>>
>>136193599
Hibike! Without a doubt
>>
We already agreed with which one.

http://strawpoll.me/5952116/r
>>
File: Nah__dude.jpg (9 KB, 296x333) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Nah__dude.jpg
9 KB, 296x333
>>136239141
>We
>>
File: 1335324752901.jpg (34 KB, 377x421) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1335324752901.jpg
34 KB, 377x421
>>136238832
>uses normie on /a/ while asking other people to go to /v/
>>
>>136239141
I remember making this strawpoll
Keit-ai was a joke
>>
>no ttgl
>no space dandy


>>>/trash/
>>
>>136239492
>ttgl
guaranteed_replies.jpg
>>
>>136193599
This is 100x better than that moeshit chart.
>>
>>136239141
FIND WAY
>>
>>136240516
>>
Rabbits was AotY
NNB and OPM were runners up. I honestly can't remember what good shows came out last year besides those, so it's possible there are better runner up's, but Rabbits was quite literally perfect and so it doesn't really matter what else came out.

Also anyone who thinks Himouto is anything but sub-par/trash can be disregarded immediately.
Thread replies: 381
Thread images: 100
Thread DB ID: 449924



[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Home]

[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the shown content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows their content, archived. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content, then use the post's [Report] link! If a post is not removed within 24h contact me at [email protected] with the post's information.