>Interesting premise with summoning and sealing phantoms >Gorgeous animation and visuals >Characters are unique and quirky none of these negate the postulation that "the writing for this show is fucking horrible"
>>136160054 Look, personally, I don't give a shit about this show. I don't think it's for me, but other people might enjoy it. Who gives a shit, we all have different tastes. As a side note, I do enjoy my fair share of garbage shows anyway, which I'll admit.
But let's be clear: the positives of the show listed here >>136159915 might very well be true. However, if you read very carefully, they, in fact, don't actually suggest anything about the writing of the show, which is what OP was commenting on from the very beginning.
>>136159612 I work in an engineering lab attached to a large factory. pretty much every random object near me is REALLY important one of a kind prototype. Last month some idiot walked off with a part of a new control system for a new CNC machine thinking it was a coffee maker we weren't using.
>>136159612 It's great to see KyoAni go back to being pathetic enough to use fan service for most of the episode. And it being the only memorable thing about the show. Truly the shining quality of anime.
>>136160191 This post >>136159953 suggested 3 reasons why OP is wrong, however, this post >>136159953 pointed out that in fact, those 3 reasons have nothing to do with what OP said. You called that act of pointing out "pretentious", when in reality, it was just a basic application of reading comprehension and logic. Do you see the chain now?
>>136159953 >interesting premise some shit happened, now there are monsters and only teenagers can stop them for the same vaguely explained reasons SO. FUCKING. INTERESTING. And original, too!
>gorgeous animation Sprinkles on a turd. Sure, it's pretty. But that's all Kyoani can do, apparently. Maybe they don't have a single writer on staff.
>Characters are unique and quirky Sporty tsundere, delicate flower, genki girl and teh rei. And let's not forget the generic MC from the regular vat. Unique and quirky if this is your first anime, maybe.
>>136160235 >The "interesting" thing was among a lot of other crap It was in the robot, if I remember right. >and didn't even work at the time It worked in the same way as PC with blue screen works - i.e. it showed something. >but for some reason Curious genki fairy is enough reason to pick up curious things by her.
I.e. you full of crap and should check your basic logic.
>>136159953 >Interesting premise with summoning and sealing phantoms How the fuck is that interesting? How many anime do you think there are when it's about capturing/defeating Macguffins of the week? Don't even get me started on MC's constant ramblings during the beginning tying to make the premise sound deep. It would be one thing if it was played tounge-in-cheek but they actually want us to think his speeches are important
>Gorgeous animation and visuals I can give you this mainly
>Characters are unique and quirky No anon. They're all cliches. And I have nothing against cliches but that's what they are. Mai is literally a pair of walking tits. All she is there for is for boob fanservice
It's funny how the author can't explain his plot and tries to cover it by saying that the origins of phantoms are clear to humans of this age. Also, this faggot is the same guy that will say that Mekakucity Actors was good because it was pretty. Fuck outta here.
>>136160489 How about you watch the fucking show first? The device didn't show shit. And no, a character archetype is not enough to explain stupid writing you dumb KyoAnus drone.
>>136160824 >extremes The board was literally flooded with these type of threads the 1st week. It's not extremes, it's just the fact of the matter.
>>136160852 You're missing the point, dumb fuck. I don't give a shit about these threads but don't tell me to not make a thread about bad writing of a show if you're allowed to make circlejerk threads about a character you've known for 24 minutes.
>>136160660 >How about you watch the fucking show first? Okay, it was even more simpler - some interesting device that was in safe. Picking up whatever lies in safe doesn't need any justification whatsoever. /thread
>don't like some small shit in a obvious fanservice harem show >THIS SHOW IS SHIT! A SHIIIIIIT!111 AND CHARACTERS ARE SHIT AND STORY IS SHIT! LOOK HOW SHITTY IT IS! SO SHIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIT!111 This is how you look and sound like, a bunch of whiny autists who whine about some small irrelevant crap and don't even realise the whole point of the show and still would call it shit just because duhhh. You have this shit like every season, and so far being generic and mediocre don't really make it horrible and unwatchable because this show IS watchable and has it good points, unlike similar shit. Why does every Kyoani show has this retarded nonsense around them? there's always this kind of horseshit, you sure wanna rant about how this show is the worst of all time? well good for ya, I can bring ten times worse without ANYTHING worth to look at.
>>136161484 Is there any anime based on a fantasy LN with multiple girls and one bland MC in a highschool setting that doesn't become harem sooner or later? Legit question, the only ones I can think of were adapted from actual novels.
>>136161825 >fanservice harem show There's a good fanservice harem show(KonoSuba) and there's a bad fanservice harem(this) And what's wrong with people calling characters shit? Are you implying they aren't boring as fuck. Yeah they look pretty, but that's it.
>>136161970 >there's good show(that I like) and bad one(that I don't like Nice opinions right there, the point is that this show is not especially trying to be super serious plot driven story with lots of serious drama and character development, it's just entertainment, a popcorn, a fastfood. You don't watch this for serious story, you don't really give a fuck about story, you just watched for simply the fact it's entertainment trash or whatever, just to pass time, and there's all set up for that, fanservice some fightan, some animation and bright colors, that's it. There's no need for an tons of shitposting this show gets, yeah it's generic, so what? there's shows like this, yet you can find enough people to watch that shit and even enjoy some of it, but they surely don't talk about super interesting story, but a which girl they would fuck. So why exactly this show get this much of criticism? oh I will tell you, because Kyoani show, and it doesn't get popular unlike shitposter like to claim, it's quite opposite.
>>136162264 >I say things >they are true because I say so >I don't bother reading actual post or providing any actual argument but rather cut of context some few words I seemingly disagree and throw some pointless comeback without any actual conext whatsoever Well if trying to put some sense into mindless morons and underage idiots who are not used to actuall discussion because unlike simplistic namecalling and one liners it would require at least some decent amount of brain cells to use, this is bait.
>>136162311 >So why exactly this show get this much of criticism? This show gets as much criticism as any other, but if I had do blame something, it would be how many threads it gets, with many of them (baiting or not) claiming it to be AOTY. That's like asking for people to criticize the show, which ends up creating shitposting.
To me it seems that you're more upset about people criticizing a show that you like.
>>136162311 >Nice opinions right there, the point is that this show is not especially trying to be super serious plot driven story with lots of serious drama and character development, it's just entertainment, a popcorn, a fastfood. Well, where did I imply I was against this point? KonoSuba fits that description perfectly and it's very entertaining despite not having a good animation, while PW is boring as fuck and plenty of people besides Kyoani haters agree. Also this show gets a lot of criticism not only because of the story, but because characters are bland and dull.
>>136159915 Wait what? Look I watch this show and enjoy it, but only for very shallow reason. This edge-tier writing really is making that pretty hard and official subs ruined the encode so much that not much of good animation is left. And aesthetically speaking this show is also pretty shit. It really just has tits for it going and I don't need to watch more than episode 1 to know that. >It's common knowledge, but I'll explain anyways
>>136162091 Well I honestly also drop most shows after the first episode, unless they are recommended to me or something. Why should I bother to see if it becomes good and not just watch something else or masturbate? This show for me is the masturbation part.
>>136162311 I'd usually agree with your post, but this show sometimes really tries hard to be edgy. They really want the mc to be smart and therefore have to make him say all that shit about >muh phantoms in mah brainz I wish they would stop all the unnecessary exposition, if they don't want to make a story driven show.
>>136163473 >>136163509 Okay edgy was definitely the wrong word here, but maybe pretentious fits better? The whole beginning of>>136163473 EP 2 quoting Kant and what not really felt unnecessary to this show. I don't think it fits the general mood of the show.
>>136163823 I though so myself, but then why do they not cut this way shorter? Not a fan of this kind of parody myself aqnd do they really have to repeat these kinds of bad executed jokes over and over? Well I guess that's pretty usual, to base jokes repeatedly on one character traits.
Well it's not repeated that much that it really annoys me, I still enjoy the show.
I watched this show because it was kyoani, and I was expecting something at least above average. What I didn't account for was the harem genre. I never really watch harem shit (though I did just watch monmusu which was definitely more interesting than Phantom World). But really this is all just standard for a harem show, including the terrible writing and the cliches packed like sardines in a crushed tin box. I'm not familiar with the harem genre so I didn't expect something quite so unremarkable. It's basically just a showcase for character design and ecchi shit. And that's what harem fans want.
So, this is just a quick cash-in on the harem genre. Unlike all of kyoani's other shows, no real thought went into the development. Nobody bothered to write any clever dialog. Nobody ever tried to make the characters feel real. They just packaged up the tits and asses and shipped them out.
Also I suspect we'll look back on episode two as specifically bad. After the first ep I was unenthusiastic but ready to continue, but the second ep I was aggravated and oppressively bored. I doubt they can consistently maintain that level of shitty.
>>136165217 >watching capeshit for the plot and not the visuals >bitching about a lack of depth in a super-hero show >thinking you're too cultured for simple entertainment isn't demonstrating a total lack of refinement
I really hate this false-patrician culture that's sprung up over the last decade.
>>136164989 >What I didn't account for was the harem genre I have yet to see any romantic interest towards the OP by any of the girls yet so how do you figure it's a harem?
>Unlike all of kyoani's other shows, no real thought went into the development. Nobody bothered to write any clever dialog. It's a fucking LN adaption what are you expecting? KyoAni have already taken liberties with the source material. There's only so much you can do when the source material is trash.
>>136166555 >how do you figure it's a harem? because every single female character introduced is a harem stereotype Even when you don't have actual romance, it's still haremshit. A poor excuse of a plot to show off a collection of fanservice characters.
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the shown content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows their content, archived. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content, then use the post's [Report] link! If a post is not removed within 24h contact me at email@example.com with the post's information.