But he let her be adopted into a family he admits could care less about the Root, and that interview from that French con had Urobuchi revealing he knew all about the stuff Sakura would go through and bought that it would make her stronger as a magus. From a guy whose bloodline was damn near dead.
The best part? He thought that if Zouken was outed as a heretic, that a four year old girl with no magecraft training could stop him.
You don't get more naive in parenting than this guy.
>>135882464 >People will hate on Tokiomi for giving Sakura up for rape and love Kariya for being an edgy cuck but then shit on Sakura for being a slut who loves being raped I don't understand the logic behind this.
>>135887676 Not really, though. Take Rin for example, she's widely accepted to be a pretty good magus, but she's still surprised by how good he is. It's stated that projection is mostly used to substitute for sacrificial items in magic rites, due to the fact they only last seconds or minutes at most. Some of the shit Shirou keeps in the shed have been there for hours, if not more. It's an uncommon specialization, but Rin herself agrees that what he's doing is pretty impressive for an untrained magus.
>>135888034 Sakura gets the hate for two reasons. One: Sakura gave up hope of being saved/helping herself (for some reason NOBODY remembers or cares about Zouken's ability to kill her at any given time). Two: waifufaggotry
>>135887894 >You don't get more naive in parenting than this guy. Well you see there's this guy called Ashton Lhant. He may have taken his youngest of two sons, who care about each other deeply and respect each other, and shipped him away to a completely different and sand filled country. Not explaining why he did so to either the son he kept OR the son he shipped away and going 'you'll understand one day'. His reasons for doing so is the two sons don't fight over a spit of land the size of your average street and when both already had a better plan to not fight over it. This plan failed when the younger brother came back to save the town from invaders only to take it over himself as part of his foster father starting a coup. The only reason this plan worked out was because of Alien Parasites taking over a Prince and draining all energy for the planet and that they are mutual friends with a robot girl made of Moon/Mars magic. He also died before anyone could call his shit out like Tokiami
Sakura mentions him being impressive when it's apparent he doesn't have the talent, but it's still an ironclad thing that he is only a mediocre magus who has his RM by a freak accident and reinforcement, maybe a spell or two. For magus society that prides itself on bloodline, special talent, and usefulness, he is bottom of the barrel. But then again the Association is full of contradictions.
The thing is that it's the special over specialized people who do the big things in that universe, not just being a genius or gifted.
That was only because she was hooked to something she had no knowledge of previously thanks to him doing 10 years of torturous experiments that, if she hadn't had strong blood and will, would have killed her.
It doesn't change that without the freak occurrence of AM, he would have just destroyed her internal organs from the inside and eaten her brain had she disobeyed. The fact she saw Kariya get eaten alive at five years old was a factor too, not many kids are gonna try to fight back when they know the same familiars who turned a person they cared about into chunks of meat on the basement floor populate the entirety of their body current. That isn't cowardice, it's common sense.
>>135889769 >he doesn't have the talent I disagree. Disregarding weapons, as they come from UBW/his origin, he manages to make long lasting projection without any kind of formal training, given that he doesn't even know how to activate his natural circuits. I agree that he (probably) has nothing in the matter of bloodlines given that we don't know his parents and inherited nothing from Kiri, but he is talented in his magecraft. How useful it is is debatable. His abilities are good for fighting, he'd make a good rogue mage hunter.
As for overspecialization, he definitely fits. All he can do is conjure and enhance things. Possibly some kind of affinity for detecting magic given how he finds the sigil for bloodfort, but then again he can't sense that Rin or Sakura are magi.
>>135888296 >Sakura gets the hate for two reasons. One: Sakura gave up hope of being saved/helping herself
It's not that she gave up hope on it, she just knows how the society she was brought up in operates, she is kind of under the thrall of a wicked magus. The most help she would get from anyone in the know is a "so?" or "there is nothing I can do" followed by torture from Zouken since he knows where she is and what is going on with her all the time. If there was any time she should have been looked at, it was before the experiments began and Zouken's familiars started fusing with her vital organs. Now it's much harder, and there aren't many that would go out on a limb to help her.
There is Rin, but Rin is unreliable on that front, all someone would have to do is trick her into thinking she couldn't be saved and her rationale would turn into putting the girl down "for her own good", which is pretty much giving up.
It only makes it more miraculous that a magic experiment like her ends up getting a bishop of the church as a father figure and mentor, working to regain some semblance of something out of years of being a lab rat.
>>135887676 >Being good at tracing is like being good at breathing. Is breathing rare and broken as fuck? because Tracing is. Shirou's projection (called Tracing) is not your average magus' projection, it's pretty much unique to him and it's effects violate the laws of physics and magic alike. Normal projection can't make permanent objects out of thin air, cant create bullshit OP weapons like NPs, and can't reproduce the history of the weapon or it's owner's skills.
I know Shirou is special, but this is from a magus perspective, who are elitist assholes only out to further their research.
I mean, look at Sakura, her own father adopted her out because he feared that she would end up in a test tube by some kidnapper because she didn't have a crest. The world of magi is that wasteful that they would kidnap toddlers and put them in preservation yanks for spare parts rather than train them.
Point is, even with Shirou's powers, he doesn't have notable talent. He has one strong specialty centers on close combat weaponry, only because he had an artifact of great power stored inside him. He won't be the leading researcher or contribute toward research into the Root, so he useless except for stripping his circuits and studying why he has a reality marble. He is no more than a tasty bit of meat.
>>135889252 >people who cause it directly and indirectly are bad If you and your family are held at gunpoint and you're told to rape an educated prostitute or else you all die, including the prostitute, would raping her still be bad? >people who try to stop it are good What about a man who stops another from trying to rape a girl because he wants to forcefully take her virginity himself? What about a person who embarks on a crusade to stop worldwide rape by torturing and killing every person that has raped, tried to rape or indirectly caused another person to get raped? >people who enjoy it are bad What about Sakura? she clearly enjoyed rape, at least her body did. Does that make her a bad person?
>>135888296 Maybe because she is shit. I am tired of explaining it to you shitters and then get ignored the very next thread as you shitters spout your opinions on why you think people dislike that cunt.
>>135891235 Nasu begs to disagree. As a theoretical formal magus, he doesn't have much future but >as a spell-user, he'll be among one of the big specialists. Ultimately, he'll receive an evaluation on the same level as "Magus Killer" Emiya Kiritsugu had in his peak That's pretty good if you ask me.
>>135891235 >adopted her out No. He did that because that's what magi do. One child receives magecraft training, the other live as normal people. Plus, one of the three founding families needed a heir. >only because an artifact Also wrong. That changed his origin to sword and that's the reason he can project swords with little difficulty, but the other things he creates are unrelated to swords or combat in general and are just as resilient as combat equipment.
>Iskandar probably wins Medusa is a better melee fighter, IH can't do shit against Bellerophon (airborne and anti-army GG), and on top of it, Iskandar has no counter for Medusa's Cybele, neither does his army. This battle is so one-sided it's not even funny.
>Cu Chulainn beats Deermud Only in Ireland. Anywhere else Diarmuid has the edge due to his much better master support. This was stated by Nasu, btw.
>Probably matched Medea wrecks Gilles' ass in a normal fight with no prep. With prep and at peak level, Gilles gets Ctulhu but Medea gets slave Saber, Archer and Assassin. Not to mention that Rule Breaker can pull the same shit Lancer did with Gae Drearg to finish Gilles off.
Yes, but Kerry was feared, not highly regarded. My point was about value here. His value as a magus (a researcher under his own merit) is low, but it doesn't take away that he has something special. If you compared a 'magus' and a 'spell user' it would go like this, a spell user practices magic for his own sake, not seeking to further his practice or pass on his work, it's a tool to be used. A magus is opposite, where developing their craft is their lifestyle and profession. Sakura would probably skirt the line between them, but Shirou is a spell user and Rin/Luvia are magi.
It's the difference between objective value and subjective value. Shirou's value in the magus community is minimal.
>>135892588 >Only in Ireland. Anywhere else Diarmuid has the edge due to his much better master support. This was stated by Nasu, btw. >having more fire power=/= stronger Cu has the bigger legend, better fighter, better NP, better skills.
>Lancer did with Gae Drearg to finish Gilles off. What?
>>135892237 >No. He did that because that's what magi do. One child receives magecraft training, the other live as normal people. Plus, one of the three founding families needed a heir.
Tokiomi wanted her to be an heiress. But it was nonsensical because she would literally have had to rebuild the Matou on her own, and Tokiomi knew Zouken had fucked up the family for generations and the foundation of tue family's magecraft is unsuited to Japan. So it was a stupid idea he took up due to a pact that was long past expired. It was him being overly conservative again because he didn't bother actively looking for a better home. So he risked ruining her body and potential for political mumbo jumbo. Luckily, she survived all those years and ended up finding another mentor down the line, but it's no thanks to her father.
And second children are not always adopted out. Kayneth's little sister knows magecraft. Also see Sola's family. Her brother got the crest, but she was still taught magecraft and then married off later. Toujo was taught magecraft while Aoko learned later, but neither example were adopted out.
>>135893150 >Tokiomi Never said he was a sane or logical man. My point was that he did that because muh traditions, something you seem to agree on. >second children That's the general rule though, and most magi part of the Association adhere to it. Given that the Tohsaka bloodline was one of three that founded the HGW, they're pretty much expected to follow traditions.
>>135892761 >Cu has the bigger legend, better fighter, better NP, better skills. Q: Cu Chulainn and Diarmuid are both Lancers, but who will win in an honourble battle? In their first engagement with Saber, Cu Chulainn was being pressed hard, but Diarmuid was able to pressure Saber. So... Diarmuid is stronger
A: Diarmuid received more backup from his Master (magical energy supply), thus in terms of pure firepower, Diarmuid was stronger. In Japan, both of them received 0 geographical boost (from the cultural sphere), but if the stage was in Ireland --- Cu Chulainn would have an edge.
>>135892588 >>135892588 >Anywhere else Diarmuid has the edge due to his much better master support Only in a battle of pure technique. Diarmud get completely fucked by Gae Bolg with his E rank luck. Cu's also the faster of the two, and he can 1v1 Rune so Diarmud doesn't try hit and run tactics with Gae Buidhe
>>135893150 >>135894969 >>135898880 Did you guys forget that Tokiomi was also concerned how the Association would try to make Sakura a lab rat because she would not be under the protection of the heiress title?
This was even talked about in the narration monologue in the book.
>>135898722 >Tokiomi cannot be blamed for Kirei, he was vetted well
Not really, Tokiomi and Rise were framed as woefully ignorant of Kirei's personality. Risei in particular was noted to have been ignorant and almost avoiding personally trying to understand his son beyond his accomplishments as man of the Church.
I mean even Kiritsugu, who only knew the man for a week could tell the guy was screwed up by the fact he made so many accomplishments and yet treated it all like it was worthless. Moreover, the listlessness he had about EVERYTHING was as plain as day.
This was because he didn't take it into account before she was born. He counted on her being mediocre enough he could raise her as a normie, which was a stupid bet.
Then he decided to wait 4 years without doing much of anything until some old vampire he described to Kirei as a filthy heretic comes knocking at his door to bail him out of being a father, in his own words.
Her being taken by the Association doesn't excuse the rest of his poor decision making.
>>135899672 All servants are Madara Uchiha Pasta tier to some degree. Just imagine for the sake of argument that Servants get summoned by a Master who can just make them EX in all stats. That's already in the ballpark of Nappa and introduction Vegeta or higher just on pure fighting ability alone.
>>135899843 But all Servants so far had weaknesses or could be defeated if the conditions were right. Wasn't this Solomon just pure bullshit OP with a asslong list of stupidily broken powers as if some 8 yo said "Lets make the strongest Servant ever"?
Tensions were running high there, if you wanted to peg Aoi for something, it would be the conversation she had with him at the park after he saved Rin. She didn't report his declaration to Tokiomi about trying to free Sakura from Zouken.
>>135899843 >Master who can just make them EX in all stats That's not how it works. Servants with shitty masters get their abilities limited by it, but it's not like any old Assassin will ever have full EX stats just because he has a godly master. The heroes themselves still have rough base stats based on their specialties, weaknesses and lives in general.
>>135900021 >She didn't report his declaration to Tokiomi about trying to free Sakura from Zouken Considering we've already established he knows what Zouken is doing to their daughter I'm pretty sure that would have been pointless.
Probably, but maybe it might get him to understand Kariya's position later on and maybe have the common sense to ask why he was so angry.
Regardless, even if Tokiomi was incensed that she was just bring made into a lab rat anyway, he would ultimately go for the euthanasia route if Zouken used her as a hostage. I don't hold out much hope for him as a dad.
>>135898341 The art style.... Is this related to that doujin where Shiroj qnd Sakura fucked all the time around the whole house while the rest was out, and Sakura got (supposedly) pregnant? I liked that one
>>135900090 >Servants with shitty masters get their abilities limited by it or in Saber's case fucking Kneecapped by it. Seriously with Shirou none of her stats reach above B, but Rin even still untrained can make Saber A in almost everything.
>>135888034 Tokiomi gave up on his daughter and his wife didnt do anything to stop him.
Kariya decided to go into a battle he had no chance of winning for the sole reason of looking good in front of a girl. The only reason he acted so edgy was because Kirei and Zouken dedicated themselves to making him suffer.
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the shown content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows their content, archived. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content, then use the post's [Report] link! If a post is not removed within 24h contact me at firstname.lastname@example.org with the post's information.