[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Home]
4Archive logo
You're telling me all the character...
If images are not shown try to refresh the page. If you like this website, please disable any AdBlock software!

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 114
Thread images: 17
You're telling me all the character development Okazaki underwent as a young widower was all for nothing? What the fuck is this shit?
>>
Yup. Shitty ending.

It had been set up for something so much more too. Too bad Maeda pussied out. I guess Air's beautiful ending really did break him.
>>
The ending doesn't work in the anime medium, go read the VN.
>>
>>120445837
>go read the VN

>>120445623
I can think of at least 3 different endings that can happen in the episode after that one one and be much better than whatever the hell that was. Is there a job description for someone who goes and fixes shitty endings?
>>
>>120445623
>Goal!
>>
>>120446036
>Is there a job description for someone who goes and fixes shitty endings?
The job title is "Faggot who writes shitty fanfiction"
>>
>>120446085
If the endings are fixed before they air and approved by the folks who wrote the rest of the story, it isn't really shitty fanfiction, is it?
>>
Unexpected revivals can happen without it being a terrible asspull.
>>
>>120446467
It is, because it's rewriting the ending.
>>
>>120446688
Yeah, Ushio reviving due to the light orbs would have been expected, after all it would mirror what happened between Akio and Nagisa many years earlier.

Nagisa coming back was just fucking stupid.
>>
>>120446990
>Nagisa coming back
She didn't come back.
>>
>>120447076
This. What the fuck are people talking about? Did we watch the same fucking show?
>>
File: 1422250290005.jpg (8 KB, 259x194) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1422250290005.jpg
8 KB, 259x194
>>120447159
I don't think they did. And why no love for Nagisa?
>>
Fine. Bizarre fucking time warp ending that resulted in Nagisa alive, if you're gonna be a pedantic dumbfuck.
>>
>>120447254
Love? Is that what it means when thinking about someone makes you cry like a little bitch?
>>
>>120447283
Nope. Try again.
>>
Stop acting like you gave a shit about Nagisa in the first place. The show was about clannadman getting what clannadman earned with blood and tears.
>>
>>120447342
Ushio was sick of her father's muh Nagisa shit and used her god powers to do a Haruhi Disappearance?
>>
>>120447393
4 years of parental negligence after being one of the worst sons imaginable and not ever coming to understand his father's feelings until he lost the woman he loved.

He didn't earn shit. He was an awful son and an awful father.
>>
Kyon is the only reason to care about this franchise.
>>
File: Clannad Time Line.png (509 KB, 1262x1068) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Clannad Time Line.png
509 KB, 1262x1068
>>120447551
He earned it in S1.
>>
>>120445623
>>120445464

The development wasn't for nothing... holy shit.
>>
>>120447653
Kyou* fuck.
>>
>>120447393
Okazaki doesn't meet Nagisa. He skips the encounter with Fuko and goes straight to the helping out Kotomi. He realizes how much he really loved the strange girl with the teddy bear and the violin. The show progresses smoothly and Ushio is born, only now instead of sickly she is retarded. Well done, the Girl from the Hidden World is autistic and it's all your fault.
>>
>>120447655
>sends him back in time

So I was spot on here >>120447283
>>
Keyshit. Not even once.
>>
>>120445464
Did you even watch until the end you dumbfuck? How was his character development all for nothing?
>>
>>120447872
Air doesn't have any of the bullshit that plagues Key nowadays.
>>
>>120447924
Wrong.
>>
>>120447655
So according to that chart, Tomoya never makes up with his father in Timeline 2? He stays a constant ass to him and never appreciates the hardship and struggle that his father did for him?

Well that's just fucking peachy.
>>
>>120447971
Nope, fairly certain I'm correct. There is no bullshit, it's all explained quite in depth by the plot.
>>
File: kanna1.jpg (26 KB, 800x433) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
kanna1.jpg
26 KB, 800x433
>>120447895
>ever not watching to the end
>>
>>120447551
didn't his father hit him?
>>
>>120447655
That makes more sense, but it seems excruciating to sit through.
>>
>>120448003
>Tomoya never makes up with his father in Timeline 2?
It's implied they make up, since he, Nagisa, and Ushio go on the trip to meet his grandmother.
>>
Can we all agree that Uguu is best.
>>
>>120448003
they do make up in the VN at least, I honestly wanted another OVA showing a bit more of his relationships even after all the shit that happened
>>
Really wish someone had told me to stop at episode 18. I can't unsee that travesty of an ending.
>>
The ending was fine. It's implied that he received the ball of light that grants wishes (which was mentioned as being a 'legend of the city' in season 1 I think), and that he uses it after Ushio dies.

It's been a while since I watched Clannad but I think he first contemplates wishing he had never met Nagisa so he would never have had to suffer but then realizes that he had a lot of good times with her too, and wishes her back to life or some shit. But they don't do a good job of explaining it.

There were those stupid robot sequences too; I don't really remember how they fit in. Man, I really need to rewatch Clannad.

>>120448003
That chart is bullshit though. It's pretty clear that Tomoya knows Kyou and Kotomi in "Timeline 1," and not just as random fucks he happened to go to school with.
>>
>>120448264
Just pretend that blinding light near the end was Kotomi pulling up in a Ford Mustang and blasting the snow away with some American freedom.
>>
>>120448156
Akiko is better at j-j-jamming
>>
>>120448110
He fucked up his arm which made him unable to play basketball. He also brought dishonor on entire family, so now clannadman can never get a good job.
>>
Although the anime is still good, alot of the shit isn't explained. The ending was a total deus ex machina but in the VN it fits because its foreshadowed in all the routes as you learn about The Hidden World and the myths about the town "where wishes come true". The reason the anime ending feels stupid is just because they were trying to cram all the plot development from the different routes into Nagisa's romance so you didn't get the idea of the Hidden World existing outside of time.
>>
Is wish granting other worlds a generic concept? Because it feels kind of specific, but this isn't the only place I've seen it.
>>
>>120448783
It's foreshadowed in almost every start of the episodes. "The world where wishes comes true" also stated in Nagisa's drama script (and when she trained under the street lamp). When she tells the story about a girl in an unknown world people would have understand that she's referencing the mysterious girl and the robot. Hell, I haven't picked up the VN yet even I can understand that.
>>
>>120445464
I would of liked if it was about sanae San and Okazaki.
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=csBZLd66Bow
>>
No good doujins including Ushio
feels bad, man
>>
>>120445464
Still better protagonist than Angel Beats.
>>
>>120449946
>sexualizing dying child
I hope you enjoy your new life in the deepest hell, anon.
>>
>>120450003
>Not liking loli
What a fucking loser.
>>
>>120449946
I second that.
>>
File: 1422162499559.jpg (24 KB, 308x273) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1422162499559.jpg
24 KB, 308x273
>>120449946
I know right it sucks.
>>
>>120450048
It's only proper to nurse her, not for sexualizing!
>>
>>120449948
>mfw Angel Beats outsold clannaids without having an existing fanbase prior airing

The m/a/d from hipster f/a/ggots will last forever
>>
>>120450135
We all know your still going to buy the Clannad VN on steam anyways.
>>
>>120450135
That 12 episodes and their minimum-scripted Tenshi are honestly too overrated.
>>
>>120450135
And it did so without Jun Maedo even going out of his usual highschool VN style. Has he even done anything else?
>>
>>120450221
Nope, not even pirate. clannad is shit compared to Rewrite, Little Busters and soon the Angel Beats VN.
>>
>>120449786
How is Sanae-san's breads taste like?
>>
File: image.jpg (128 KB, 449x640) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
image.jpg
128 KB, 449x640
>>120450339
I don't know m8 we should read to find out.
>>
>>120450336
>Angel beats VN
See you in 2026
>>
>>120450482
>he is not up to date with the news
http://key.visualarts.gr.jp/angelbeats/
>>
File: 1365909828888.png (2 KB, 142x138) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1365909828888.png
2 KB, 142x138
I liked where it was going until Ushio died for no reason. If it was just Okazaki getting over Nagisa's death and successfully raising Ushio it would of been 10/10. I guess it's a happier ending and all but it felt better that he fixed everything even after losing Nagisa.
>>
File: 1384737888979.png (298 KB, 730x716) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1384737888979.png
298 KB, 730x716
>>120450336
>clannad is shit compared to Rewrite
I don't know about you, but Rewrite routes are fucking shit, it's unbelievable.
>>
>>120450587
That I don't know what the fuck is happing moment but I'm cool with it lol.
>>
>>120450336
>Shittier than Rewrite
My brother once recommend me to read the black-ribboned girl's route and saying that it's the best route. But I find it's shit and predictable. Also 2chuuni4me.
>>
>>120450587
People often died with no reason in real world, anon.
>>
>>120450587
Not 10/10 for Tomoya hooking up with Tomoyo years after Nagisa's death and them raising Ushio together along with having another kid.
>>
>>120450336
>Little Busters
>muh fucking more girls to get more courage and mental strength to face real life
>>
>>120450800
Nigga that's called going hard in the paint boy he smashed a hoe to do it to another one.
>>
File: 1358398284066.jpg (103 KB, 800x1261) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1358398284066.jpg
103 KB, 800x1261
>>120450800
A rather weird way of spelling Kyou but I can see it happening
>>
>>120450800
>Tomoyo
I believe you mean Kyou. Though I guess Tomoyo could get on on a threesome on occasion, I hear Kyou is bi, so she'd probably be okay with it.
>>
>>120450800
Considering how the anime really didn't handle the orb situation well at all, that might have just been a better idea to go with. You meant Kyou i hope?
>>
File: Untitled.jpg (544 KB, 1332x1598) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Untitled.jpg
544 KB, 1332x1598
The ending is fine you fucking retards, and all the development he went through on a personal level is still there because he vaguely remembers it all, and most importantly plans to seriously reconcile with his father instead of putting it off indefinitely like before
>>
>>120450860
>wired way of spelling kyou
In your dreams loser.
>>
>>120450800
>Tomoyo
>relevant at all after her arc
Despite how much of a shit she is, five years after the death of Nagisa the most likely to receive the Okazaki would be Kyou.
>>
>>120450800
>Tomoyo
I have a feeling it would be Fuko instead. Remember, in the anime she even almost became the first one to talk to Tomoya when he's doing the love charm.
>>
>>120450834
At least Rin route and Refrain definitely makes the whole thing worthwhile.
>>
Breaking news, Clannad is shit. More at 11:00!
>>
>>120450990
Kek'd
>>
>>120447655

Bullshit chart because you need 7 orbs just to unlock After Story to begin with so there is no timeline 1.
>>
>>120447655
so episodes are out of order and confusing, that's fucking great
>>
>>120450237
This.

>>120450339
They're so bad that when combined with Akiko's jam they can make people faint.

>>120450800
My waifu is Tomoyo and even I think that if Tomoya had to remarry most likely it would be Kyou. Kotomi would be too busy with her studies, Fuko would still be asleep, Tomoyo is a possibility but only if you follow the Tomoyo After timeline.
>>
>>120451094
No, you never see timeline 1 in the anime. Timeline 3 just animates Tomoyo's route as a separate OVA.
>>
>>120450929
I laughed in that scene. Really, I didn't expect Fuko would appear in that situation and almost made Tomoya fall into her route if only he didn't immediately shut her.
>>
File: 1422238137566.png (2 MB, 1920x1080) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1422238137566.png
2 MB, 1920x1080
>>120450800
Dear god it was a joke. At this point Kyou is best girl.
>>
>>120445464
The ending was beautiful and all that shit, but I really thing it would have been a better ending, if Nagisa stayed dead, and Tomoya moving on taking care of Ushio, it would have send a more real message.
>>
>>120451174
Yes, but that won't explain the girl from the hidden world story, and it could feel quite generic.
>>
>>120450929
>>120451153
I kek'd. Fucking Fuko.
>>
The ending is nothing. What really bugs me is the lack of aftermath in Nagisa's death. No funeral, no scuffle between the husband and the daughter, no grieving at all. She just faded out of existence and was replaced immediately by Ushio. Kotomi's character got reduced to Captain Obvious and her violin once an outward expression of the screams of her inner soul now a mere angle for a joke, but at least someone was sad to see her go.
>>
>>120451404
>Lack aftermath of Nagisa's death
It's obvious when you're seeing how Tomoya has changed from a guy who teases people all of the time but can be nice and responsible when it comes to the people he knows turn, into that bitter and smileless guy even when he meet Ushio. No, him refusing to take care of Ushio should have been obvious that it's that hard of blow for him.
>>
>>120451622
Yes, everything's implied, and it might even be an attempt to portray how lost Okazaki was during this time, but it's still a dick move for the studio to not pay respect where respect is due.
>>
If the revival didn't happen, Nagisa and Ushio stayed dead, then Tomoya accept that they're already memories and move on, I would totally rate Clannad 10/10.
If Tomoya decided to move on with Kyou it would be 12/10.
Too bad they had to make a "happy" end, so it's 8/10 at best.
>>
One of the few cases where anime > VN

I gotta rewatch it sometime
>>
>>120451925
>few
>>
>>120451925
>anime > VN
>when people still think the ending was an asspull
>>
>>120451925
>few
LEL
>>
>>120451942
Well honestly I haven't read many VNs that also have an anime adaptation that I watched. Can you think of any others anon?

>>120451992
Ending aside, many of the very emotional scenes were done much better in the anime because of the animation and the music being significantly better. The pacing was also much better in the show.
>>
>>120451925
The fact that all these people are complaining about the ending proves that isn't the case. I love the anime but the VN is still a better experience just because it's longer and goes into more detail about stuff.
>>
>>120451992
The ending they used was rushed and they really should have not used that ending, yes, asspull, no.
>>
anyone got that picture edit of ushio enjoying the pleasure of being cummed inside, it always cracks me up
>>
>>120452017
I haven't heard of a VN that wasn't otaku-pandering waifu trash, and that sort of stuff works ten times better as anime. All the decent story-type stories are manga adaptions.
>>
>>120452057
If i was home i would post it.
>>
>>120452072
>I haven't heard of a VN that wasn't otaku-pandering waifu trash
Maybe because you're retarded. There's also fujoshi pandering trash.
>>
>>120448156
Yes she is, but I do like Nagisa
>>
File: smug anime girl 5.png (747 KB, 800x600) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
smug anime girl 5.png
747 KB, 800x600
>>120452024
Clannad's highlights wasn't really the ending, it was the journey, which the show did better in most aspects.

>>120452072
You're a silly man
>>
>>120452072
Well yeah, it's hard when they hardly get translated.
>>
>>120452024
>goes into more detail about stuff
>ever a good thing
>>
>>120452113
god, I fucking hate that aspect in japanese story narrative, the journey the journey. Fucking garbage if the end ruins all of it. A story is only as good as the final destination as the entire trip is ruined by a poor resolution
>>
>>120450800
You do realize that will kill Tomoya, If he skips Nagisa the dreaded japanese truck finds him
>>
>>120452113
>>120452148
I guess we just have different opinions on what we like in a story. I would prefer the journey to feel more natural (which usually means its longer) rather than just skipping between major plot points. That being said i don't disagree that the anime had better pacing. I just think that when weighing my experiences of both, the VN came out on top.
>>
>Ushio doesn't die
>Tomoya gets close to Kyou by picking up Ushio everyday
>best girl wins
Would've been a much better ending.
>>
>>120452211
Please don't remind me. The pain is too real.
Thread replies: 114
Thread images: 17
Thread DB ID: 34829



[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Home]

[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vip /vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the shown content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows their content, archived. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content, then use the post's [Report] link! If a post is not removed within 24h contact me at [email protected] with the post's information.